Preview

Rhetorical Analysis Of My Summer At An Indian Call Center By Andrew Maranz

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1042 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rhetorical Analysis Of My Summer At An Indian Call Center By Andrew Maranz
Is it easy to change the culture of a person? Andrew Marantz touches on the issue of cultural change in his article, “My Summer at an Indian Call Center.” Andrew Marantz is an American author, who publishes articles for a magazine called Mother Jones. In his article, describes his experiences in Delhi at an Indian Call Center, where he was an employee and observed cultures being taught to him in an inappropriate manner. The author uses a list of rhetorical strategies in his article, but the one that stood out was, irony. Andrew Marantz uses the rhetorical strategy, irony, effectively in his argument that Indian Call Centers ruin the identity of their workers by forcing other cultures upon them. That is due to the reason that the use of irony highlights important events and it persuades the reader that his argument is trustworthy.
The author, Andrew Marantz, uses irony effectively to persuade the reader that Indian Call Centers are ruining the identity of their employees by trying to force another culture upon them. In the article, Marantz describes an incident, which draws a connection between two boys cleaning a window to the trainers of Indian Call Centers indirectly. Marantz’s states: “Behind the showroom
…show more content…
The article discusses the issue of cultural change throughout his article and it brings up the question again, is it easy to change the culture of someone? The answer is no, it is not easy to change the cultural background of a person because it requires a lot of practice and time to do this. In “My Summer at an Indian Call Center,” there was not much time given to the workers at the Call Centers, which could be another reason why they are confused about their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The documentary movie “Cold Water”, produced by Noriko Ogami in 1986, demonstrates how different people feel and what kind of experiences they have when they first come to live in the U.S. All of those people have something in common about their experiences in a new culture; all of them experiences culture shock in some ways. Dr. Robert Kohls, the Executive Director of Washington International Center, describes a state of being in a culture shock as “when you realize by living in a new culture that your own values are being brought into question.” He farther states that when individuals step into another culture, they begin to doubt their own values. Values, which they were taught about by their relatives and environment. Immigrants begin to question those values because they see that values of people from different culture are different and work well for those people. Due to this, immigrants realize that they have to adjust to new values and even act as they are their own. However, it is hard to be themselves if they have to change their perspective. This is what happens when individuals experience culture shock.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The speaker of the film “Amistad” is David Franzoni. Since this fact was not identified verbally during any part of the movie, and I was not able to view the credits, I went to the World Wide Web to find the author for the movie.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Jasmine Lopez’s persuasive essay video, the speaker was very well-spoken and kept her speech at a steady pace. I also liked how she would enunciate every word she spoke to make sure the audience was engaged and understood. Furthermore, the speaker’s opening line was relatable and provided a nice hook to start her speech. The speaker backed up her statements with factual data, which showed the audience that she was credible and passionate about her topic. As the speaker was saying agricultural terms, she made sure to define those terms.…

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Speech Critique

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This paper will critique the speech Questions of Culture delivered by a graduate of Richmond University in 1996. The speakers name is Sajjid Zahir Chinoy. This critique will focus on the organization, content and delivery of the speech.…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When racism was a huge issue there were two main leaders that decided to take action and find control. Booker T. Washington wanted to focus on improving relationships with whites, Du Bois wanted to focus on blacks getting education. Rhetorical styles are used in both “The Atlanta Compromise” and “Souls of Black Folk”. Washington uses styles like imagery, metaphors, similes and he appeals to logos While Du Bois communicates his message by using strategies like parallel structure, allusion and imagery. Although both leaders had opposite beliefs they both made huge changes in segregation for the…

    • 96 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every human being will face personal challenges and what makes it different is, how we accept those obstacles and how we make decision to overcome those challenges in our life. The absolutely true dairy of part time Indian by Sherman Alexie clearly shows how a typical Native American faces challenges in his life. In order to become a better version of ourselves, Arnold and myself had to overcome challenges like getting better education, adapting to new life style and believing ourselves and we both experienced racism. Arnold Sprit and I have to face obstacles to get a better education.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sometimes a stern warning is just what you need in order to push you to take a step back and evaluate your next move, especially when it could be a life changing one. In “Alumnus Welcomes New UC Berkeley Students with Stern Warning,” Shouak Bagchi, an alumnus of UC Berkeley, addresses the Berkeley freshmen class of 2017 with appraisal and advice for the future. Bagchi writes to the new students about what attending one of the most prestigious public universities entails. This article is rhetorically persuasive due to the fact that Bagchi is an alumnus of UC Berkeley. He references topics that the students can relate to and he mentions many of the successful alumni of the university.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Everybody can have limits in anything. Sometimes the limitations comes in the shape of not being able to talk the right way, not being able to keep up with other children in the same age and lots more. All of that is explained in one sentence Amy Tan wrote. The title of her article is '' Mother Tongue'' and it was in 1990. The main purpose of her article is to show that there are a lot of people that want to learn a new language but face difficulties with their families as the family don't talk that language very well. As Tan said, she describe the language that parents speak as broken. Putting yourself in other people's shoes or difficulties is consider the main idea. Judging people from one thing that they can't do is something that…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vine Deloria has a very poor opinion of American anthropologists who come to the reservations. His tone in the writing is far beyond annoyance or anger and is somewhat sarcastic. He also used harsh vocabularies and connotations such as saying the Indians are a “chessman” or a “game” for the anthropologists to play with. I was unsure if he is purposely doing it just to get the public's attention. He stated that American anthropologists only came to the reservations, not to learn about the Indians and their culture. They, however, solely come to look for proofs that support what they thought the Indian lives should be like which is why the anthropologists, as mentioned in the article, never have to rely on any instrument to record their observations. Deloria also believed that American anthropologists are responsible for many problems that occur to the Indians because the government and the outsiders only get a chance learn about the Indians through the anthropologists' writing. They are representing “the ultimate truth” to others. He stated that not only…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short story “Dave Barry Does Japan” by Dave Barry, Barry describes his experience as an American in Japan, how unprepared he was for the culture shock specifically talking about the difficulties of communicating, describing how in Japan they, “...tend to communicate via nuance and euphemism, often leaving important things unsaid; whereas Americans tend to think they are being subtle when the refrain from grabbing the listener by the shirt” (118). The experience in a foreign country is made more difficult due to the inadequate education of other cultures. As a result, Barry is unprepared when encountering this culture and ignorant. Similarly, in “An Indian Father’s Plea” by Robert Lake, his son is moved to a school not on the Native American reservation where he is labeled as a “slow learner”. Lake argues that the teacher did not do a good job in accommodating for his heritage and different background saying, “All you have to do is take advantage of [“Indian Education”] and encourage your school to make an effort to use it in the name of “equal…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I do believe that Black Power rhetoric is an useful organizing tool, with in reason. I also believe that confrontational rhetoric should not be relied on to help create a movement. The Black Panther Party for Self-Defense is prime example of how using black rhetoric can help spread awareness of your cause. However, black rhetoric causes those you are criticizing to become alert and may even cause them to retaliate. Just like what was brought up during the lecture, the Black Panther Party didn't necessarily plot to kill policemen. Yet, they commonly referred to themselves as want to kill the "pigs" and even made cartoons depicting it. The fact that they were not actually randomly killing police men is completely overlooked by the fact they…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The analysis I made was based on Douglas McGray’s article “Lost in America”. You did a great job mentioning where the article can be found and giving a brief summary of the article at the beginning. It helps the reader understand the main points of the article. However, you started your introduction with “Douglas McGray, in Lost in America”, which is a very common attention-grabber. Unfortunately, because of its frequent usage, it becomes boring or less interesting to readers. You should try to start in a more creative way like a statement meant to surprise or amuse readers. The strategies you used to address the thesis statement was not very effective since your paper lack’s a purpose and you did not specify the audience. Also, it would be…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How can some people live in endless misery and not have any hope for the future and the good things to come? In America, Claud McKay describes America as a woman who is treacherous and someone who continually puts him down. America does many terrible things to the narrator, but he still loves her and the goodness she can bring. America is his home no matter what she does. By showing how the narrator perseveres through all the awful things that America throws at him, I can infer that the message the narrator is trying to put out is that if we fight for the good things in life, we can achieve anything. America is personified as someone who treats the narrator as if he is nothing, expendable, and only worth the punishment she gives him. She makes everything harder for the narrator and constantly gives him reasons to give up, but he still fights on and keeps hoping to receive the reward of the American Dream. If no one ever looked on the bright side of things and persevered through the bad, no one would ever achieve the American Dream. Because the narrator is still persistent, and keeps hoping, he will soon be rewarded with the beautiful things about America and not…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Native Americans were the first people to have arrived in America, and to have built an establishment in America. Many people have a stereotype on how they lived and still live currently, and many Native Americans don’t consent to that at all. The way many people believe that the Native Americans lived a nomadic type of lifestyle, such as hunting large animals for food, using animal parts to create clothing, and many other actions. This article that the author has wrote is very convincing on how a Native American feels about how people are stereotyping him and his type of people. It gives a perspective from a Native American’s point of view of what they deal with on a daily basis, and throughout their entire life. The main reason that is convincing…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The message of the story, CONFORM PEOPLE, CONFORM! Get used to living with nothing because that's all you're going to get. We're the wealthiest nation in the world but that wealth is only for some people, not you huddled masses, working stiffs. $30K a year breaks down to about $15 an hour and change, pathetically something like 47% of our working population in the U.S.A. earns less than that. In some parts of the country $30K would be an okay income, but in any of the major cities and that is a joke, unless like here, you have plenty of helpful perks. People giving or leaving you money when they die (which is a sad way to get it). Or you're living like a poor migrant worker, six people to a room, sharing one bathroom, living on crackers and…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays