Preview

Regeneration: World War I

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1246 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Regeneration: World War I
Paper 2
‘Regeneration ' by Pat Barker is a novel focusing on Craiglockhart War Hospital in Scotland in 1917. The novel shows the physical and mental traumas inflicted by the war on the soldiers. Apart from the main war, the novel also addresses the internal 'wars ' in Britain, based on class, gender, father and son relationships, the 'sane ' and the 'insane ', the soldiers and the civilians. While men aspired to gain glory from war and become heroes, Regeneration effectively conveys that not all of war was glorious .The horrible mental and physical sicknesses, which plagued a number of soldiers, caused many men to withdraw from the battlefield. Feelings of guilt and shame haunted many of these soldiers as they found themselves removed from the heat of war. Barker discusses many issues plaguing the soldiers at the front, which gives insight into the reasons why many soldiers were getting disillusioned and turning against the war.
The war is brought to life by the flashbacks the soldiers experience in their nightmares as well as in their interaction with Dr. Rivers. Barker offers realistic details of many horrible war scenes, dwelling upon the destruction that war wreaks upon men 's minds. Throughout the novel, there is an insistence on physical suffering as well as on mental suffering.
Barker also delves into the class distinctions at the front, within the ranks of the British military. This issue is brought to light through a conversation between Billy Prior and Dr. Rivers. The characters ' discussion explores the injustice of these class distinctions and the harm they produce on the war front. Prior 's discussion with Rivers highlights specific examples of "snobbery" and degree of class bias and prejudices at the war front. According to Prior
"It 's perfectly made clear when you arrive that some people are more welcome than others. It helps if you 've been to the right school. It helps if you hunt, it helps if your shirts are the right color " .



Bibliography: 1. Fussell paul, from The Great War and Modern Memory, ch. 2 2. Professor Kali Israel, The home front: liberation and loss, liberation and control 3. Professor Kali Israel, The front 4. Professor Kali Israel, Bodies and memory (with in-class video) 5. Brittain, Vera , Testament of Youth, 1933 6. Barker, Pat , Regeneration,1993 7. Roberts, Robert, The Classic Slum, !971

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mr. Meyers shows in this book how soldiers can grow brotherhood with other soldiers. He is very descriptive so it’s like you’re watching a movie. Meyers shows how gruesome war could really be. He also shows that the war could effect everyone including children.…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Regeneration focuses on troubled soldiers ' mental states during WW1. The Craiglockhart setting allows Barker to explore the psychological effects of warfare on men who went to fight and also their feelings about the war and the military 's involvement in it. While the focus of the novel is firmly on the male perspective (indeed Barker claimed she had partly chosen this novel to prove she could 'do men as well as women '), there is a small but important female presence.…

    • 1234 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Regeneration is deliberately set in a psychiatric hospital, Craiglockhart, and this location highlights some of the major issues of war. Pat Barkers intention in terms of location is obviously because this emphasises some of the key elements of WW1 she wishes to explore, such as the mental trauma that the trenches caused, the often suicidal battle plans of those in charge of the conflict, plus other issues of hierarchical command. From the very beginning the experiences of the patients provide a disturbing insight into the effects of war on the soldiers. Within this hospital, which should be the soldiers sanctuary, their haven we are shocked and moved by Barkers portrayal of events as we realise that the men are seen as unmanly and degenerate for being in hospital. Barker uses the central character of senior psychiatrist Rivers through his therapy with the patients to highlight their war experiences and the horrific effects of those on them.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “We are all affected by war in some way, however slight” Scott Anderson’s Triage reveals the affects war has on people by linking the characters through war and parallel stories. From a pressured Dr. Talzani operating in a cave in Kurdistan to Mark and Colin who are war photographers and Elena and Diane their partners .As well as a ‘specialist’ war psychiatrist, Joaquin Morales. Anderson uses various techniques and symbols to communicate these ideas and writes in a conversational format to incorporate the reader into the journey.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    War creates many different versions of a person after being a soldier. A person can become stronger and more focused on the important things in his or her life. Most people come back changed more for the worse though. War can make a person paranoid, cold and withdrawn. The Vietnam War is the most well known for this fact. The war also can make a person learn about life. Thus in Daly Walker’s “I Am the Grass,” the narrator deals with the struggles of life from coming home after the war in Vietnam, finding something to do with his time and life, and returning to Vietnam.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    War, in the novel, is presented as a thing only masculine male could participate in. “They’d been trained to identify emotional repression as the essence of manliness. Men who broke down, or cried, or admitted fear, were sissies, weaklings, failures. Not men’. The significant word Rivers, uses in the quote, is ‘trained’. This is because it indicates that the men have been given specific orders to stop themselves from being demasculinised which would lead them to being unfit to take the proper role in the war, as only men could be involved in it. The quote uses asyndetic listing, this can show that the list could have been broken up with a conjunction however it didn’t due to it being the concrete definition of masculinity, this reflects back on the quote where it said “broke down”. Barker’s intentions…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many soldiers after World War I suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. War veterans with PTSD faced flashbacks, nightmares, and fight-or-flight response. These war veterans must find "a good place" (184) in life to help calm and relax them, so they can be in a healthy state, like before the war. Nick, who was in war, relaxes himself by fishing for trout in a river, something he did before the war. Additionally, many veterans strive to find the "live feeling" (197) they experienced before the war, after they have had their life returned to them. Soldiers must emerge from a terrifying past, to a hopeful future.…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Slaughter house 5

    • 1144 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Witnessing a traumatic event can be devastating, and the impact of that experience can result in the destruction of one’s peace of mind. Billy’s intense experiences throughout the war have a profound effect on his mental state. After escaping the fire bombing of Dresden, Billy experiences several signs of post-traumatic stress disorder including erratic sleep patterns and irrepressible sobbing. Because of his extreme anxiety, he checks himself into a mental hospital for veterans in the hopes of calming his mind and helping himself return to normalcy. Inside the hospital, the horrifying effects of war on one’s mental state is obvious, and it is very…

    • 1144 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sassoon and Owen as poets and Barker as a novelist, explore through their works of literature the changing and challenging notions of masculinity experienced as a result of The Great War. Furthermore, all three writers suggest that the often overlooked reality of the conflict was the creation of a subversion of the stereotypical ‘heroic soldier’. Replacing this image through their work, with that of the truth, we see an exploration of the emasculated and dehumanised shell that many men truly became as a result of what they experienced in service. This extends throughout their texts, to explore the paradoxical nature of war itself largely causing more harm to its soldiers than it gains in military desires, and a practice that reshaped an entire generation of British men into no more than physical and psychological carcasses of their former selves.…

    • 2204 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With little in the way of power, the men in power knew the army could not win or even stand a fighter’s chance without more tried a far subtler and ingenious way and tactic for calling on the masses for ‘their’ war. Using a carefully planned campaign of propaganda (most famous of which was the ‘your country needs you’) with this the men flocked to the recruiting stands unbeknownst to them the horrors that waited on the other side of the channel. For some this was a godsend to go from the squalor they knew to the life of a hero they had been promised with 3 meals a day. ‘At the start of the 20th century, malnutrition was widespread. Although the importance of clean water and good drainage was recognized, little was known about the dangers of a bad diet. During the First World War it was found that almost half the men called up to enlist were not in good enough health to serve. Efforts were made in the 1930s to improve the situation and the nation's health became a government priority.’ (Eating In 1900-1950) this fact shocked Britain and its opinion on how it would treat or continue to treat these men upon their return from the fields of red. There was little evidence to the opinions in Britain at the time on mental health prior to the war as people had little concept as to the meanings and uses of science of emotion due to it’s at the time near mythical standing, unlike physical medicine that could be seen and treated, problems of the brain were harder to diagnose and more of a problem of the upper classes. Such an illness in a family could bring much shame and social stigma, where as in the lower classes, mental illness is less documented but more visible in the works of predominant writers where suicide along with many other forms of mental illness are seen but used as a crutch to portray how hard the lower classes have the simple…

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Regeneration focuses on troubled soldiers' mental states during WW1. The Craiglockhart setting allows Barker to explore the psychological effects of warfare on men who went to fight and also their feelings about the war and the military's involvement in it. While the focus of the novel is firmly on the male perspective (indeed Barker claimed she had partly chosen this novel to prove she could 'do men as well as women'), there is a small but important female presence.…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The trenches on the Western Front are the setting for this story, which the trenches alone present the brutality of war as they seem to be a doorway to death. There was rat infestation, frogs, lice, and worms which would spread infections and contaminate the only food they had. Therefore even the environments which they had to face reflects the horrors that they had to endure being in the war, and this realism is certainly one of Hill's devices which has an effect on a reader. This lyrical beauty of Hill's narrative draws the reader in and doesn't let go.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pat Barker illustrates, through her novel, the difficulty of giving treatments to war trauma patients due to the narrow-minded view of what a soldier, and furthermore what a man, should be. Masculinity was so important in the eyes of the military and in the general society that it even affected the ill patients and their family’s view of mental issues. Even as of now, mental issues are treated as minor by many people, and the concept of men as stronger and more resilient than women, and thus able to get through anything without help, is still very much engrained in…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Accounting for the soldiers is only done on a minimal fatigue based resting period that has yet to account for trauma. War is the aggregate of those that fight it. The novel does a good job at depicting this as the reality of the situation, despite its best effort. The only real mistake made was in giving war a factor beyond that. It is very understandable for someone in the point of view of the soldier to believe that war was an entity in and of itself, however in that case there are further problems with the story that are unrelated to the portrayal of war.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Regeneration

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Regeneration, we follow the work of William Rivers, an army psychiatrist, as he tries to mend the minds of broken men. His talking therapy with various patients highlights the issues of the emotional and physical trauma caused by war, but especially the flawed philosophy behind the war. One patient in particular, Siegfried Sassoon, causes Rivers to delve introspectively so as to carefully consider and question his own beliefs and attitudes towards the war. It is also during this inner search that he finds his subconscious speaking to him through the medium of dreams as though they are “the voice of the protopathic heard at last” (Barker 239). Through his treatment of Sassoon and the contemplation of his own dreams, Rivers reaches the conclusion that the war can no longer be completely justified.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays