By Daniel L. McGivern
There are four main philosophical reasons surrounding the purpose of sentencing criminals. Retribution is of the main reasons and is the philosophy that is the criminal’s punishment that shall be determined on the severity of the crime that has been committed. The retribution philosophy goes by the Old Testament which states “eye for an eye.” Deterrence is also another reason. The basis of deterrence is its effectiveness that a criminal will realize their punishment from the crime actually outweighs the crime itself. The philosophy goes to say that the criminal prevents the return of the criminal. The specific deterrence basis theory is that once a criminal is punished and released that they will be less likely to commit any more crimes. The incapacitation philosophy is the philosophy that believes by incarnating criminals will effectively keep these criminals from committing further crimes. One of the more important philosophies is rehabilitation. This is a means of trying to teach a criminal not to commit furthers acts of crime. This philosophy firmly believes that the public is better serviced when a criminal is given certain resources that will help them be done with any criminal behavior they may have.
There are six main forces of punishment used to punish criminals for their crimes. Capital punishment or also widely known as the death penalty is the legal process where a criminal is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime they have committed. This punishment uses the incapacitating philosophy and most definitely the retribution philosophy. Imprisonment is another form of punishment. Imprisonment refers to the restraint of a criminal’s liberty. Imprisonment is when a criminal is incarcerated for a crime they have committed. This also uses the incapacitating philosophy and also hopes of rehabilitation. Probation is used as an alternative to incarcerating a criminal for a crime they have committed. Probation is an order by court to be under certain supervision and follow certain rules and guidelines. This is a way for them to deter a criminal from becoming a repeat offender.
Paying fines another way to punish a criminal. Ordering a criminal by court to pay fines for a crime they have committed is on the lesser scale of a punishment. However failure to do so may result in a higher punishment. This is a deterrent in hopes they learn by not wanting to pay anymore of their earned money to the system. Restorative justice uses the retribution by makings others replace or fix what they have broken or destroyed. Restorative justice uses an approach to justice that focuses on the needs of the victims. Victims take an active role in the punishment. For example if a criminal were to have vandalized a store the store owner may take part in the punishment and demand the criminal help clean up and restore the store the criminal damaged. Community service is another way to punish a criminal. This punishment too is on a lower scale of punishment but failure to do so may result in fines and even jail time. This is a way to give them a chance and also a way to attempt to rehabilitate the criminals. Community service is a donated service or an activity that is performed to benefit the public or communities. It is not the same as volunteering, since it is not always done voluntarily by people.
Sentencing is an important aspect in the criminal justice system. It is punishment that defendants receive when they become convicted of a crime they have committed. The punishment spectrum has a vast range of punishment from community service and fines to incarceration and being sentenced to death. Punishment and sentencing present some of the most complex issues. According to the text it reads in one scholar is that there is no such thing as an accruable sentence and there are only sentences that are more or less effective. Nothing in the recent or past history of sentencing that suggests there is anything that approaches perfection. A sentence forms a final and explicit act of a ruling made by a judge. The act may generally involve a decree of imprisonment and/or a fine and other punishments. Punishment is an authoritative imposition of something negative or unpleasant of a person in response to a behavior deemed wrong by the law.
I have a few recommendations for how to modify the sentencing process to decrease recidivism rates. Clearance rates are calculation by dividing the number of crimes that are cleared from a record by the total number of crimes recorded. These are used by different criminal justice systems as a measure of crimes solved by the law. Clearance rates can tend to be very problematic for measuring the performance of the law. I believe this is because a police force may employ a different way of measuring clearance rates. Each police force has a different method of measuring this rate. Further focus on clearance rates may result in effort being expended to attribute crimes more correctly for a criminal that may actually result in retribution, compensation, rehabilitation, and even deterrence. This would greatly benefit our justice system.
References
http://bethyada.blogspot.com/2009/06/reasons-for-sentencing-criminals.html
http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=18
http://www.uplink.com.au/lawlibrary/Documents/Docs/Doc82.html
http://www.alternativesyouth.org/restorative_justice
http://conspiracy.uslegal.com/punishment-and-sentencing/
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Punishment:When a crime is committed many may wonder why it happened, but most everyone believes that the person that committed the crime should be punished. The concept of justification for punishment is to deter deviant behavior. Retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation and societal protection are the four justifications for punishment currently used in today 's society. These four forms of punishment are used in today 's society in an attempt deter criminal activity and to lower crime rates. Research of the four justifications of punishment will reveal which type of punishment deters crime most effectively as well as if the consequences of punishment provide any benefit for criminals and society.…
- 1618 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Sentences are based on the severity of the offenses being committed. Punishment can be based on certain factors of the crime. Violent offenders can be sentenced to death or incarceration of life. Using general deterrence it supposed to stop others from committing similar crimes. Specific deterrence is a way to avoid offenders from repeating their crimes. Keeping criminals incarcerated & away from society, is the practice of keeping criminal of the street. Retribution punishes the criminal based on their action from the crime committed.…
- 470 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
There are various forms of sentencing that are used in the criminal justice system and each has its’ own rationale. These include but are not limited to the death penalty, incarceration, suspended sentence, probation, and restitution. The death penalty must be requested by the prosecutor and in some rare cases the defense. The death penalty can also be recommended by a jury, however only specific crimes are eligible for the death penalty. Most states require a certain number of witnesses in order to qualify the defendant for the death penalty. These crimes vary from state to state and include aggravated rape of a victim under 14 (including repeat offenses), espionage, piracy, ransom kidnapping, treason, and most commonly aggravated first degree murder. Incarceration is another popular form of sentencing. Although jail and prison are often used interchangeably, they differ. A prison sentence is typically longer and for those who commit felonies. A jail sentence is shorter and for those who commit misdemeanors, who are awaiting trial, or waiting to be transferred to a state facility. The ideology behind prisons is easy to recognize. We follow prisons in every…
- 2161 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Another type of sentence given to a criminal is deterrence and in lamens terms it is the use of punishment as a threat to deter people from offending. Deterrence can be divided into three separate categories. “Specific deterrence, as used in criminal justice, refers to crime prevention achieved through instilling fear in the specific individual being punished such that they refrain from future violation of the law; also referred to as individual deterrence. General deterrence, as used in criminal justice, refers to crime prevention achieved through instilling fear in the general population through the punishment of offenders. Incapacitation is considered by some to be a subset of specific deterrence. Incapacitation aims to prevent future crimes not by rehabilitating…
- 1042 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The four fundamental philosophies surrounding the purpose of sentencing are retribution, deterrence, Incapacitation, and Rehabilitation. Retribution is the belief that those who commit criminal acts should be punished according to the seriousness of the crime and that no other circumstances are considered. It relies on the principle of just deserts, which holds that the severity of the punishment must be in proportion of the severity of the crime. Deterrence is the thought that if the punishment given is severe enough that it will stop the potential criminal from committing the crime or to be a repeat offender, so rather than seeking only to punish the offender this strategy is to try to sentence to prevent future crimes along with incapacitation and rehabilitation. Incapacitation is the third philosophy that is a belief that if the criminal is detained for a crime, thereby being separated from the community reduces the criminal activity and once released will not be as likely to be a repeat offender. Rehabilitation is the fourth and final philosophy that surrounds the purpose of sentencing, some believe that society is best served when those who break the law are not simply punished but are provided with resources needed to eliminate the need or want to engage in criminal behavior activity. There are three steps to help determining sentencing. When public opinions move toward more severe strategies of retribution, deterrence, and incapacitation, legislatures have responded by asserting their power of over determining sentencing guidelines. The Legislature passes sentencing Laws; this specifies the terms of indeterminate sentencing. An Indeterminate term of incarceration is in which a judge determines the minimum and maximum terms of imprisonment. Only a jury can hand down the decision of the death penalty. When the minimum term is reached the prisoner becomes eligible to be paroled. Then there is determinate sentencing, this is a period of incarceration that is…
- 360 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In a contemporary society where crime takes place we expect the state authority to dispense justice in the form of punishment to maintain social solidarity. There are many forms of punishment that can be given to an offender, each with their own functions for the offender and society itself.…
- 1349 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Limits of Criminal Sanction, Herbert Packer said that criminal punishment should serve two purposes; “deserved infliction of suffering on evil doers” and “the prevention of crime” (Packer, 1968, pp. 36-37). Punishment of offenders in the United States is delivered through criminal sentencing. Sentencing is defined as “the imposition of a criminal sanction by a judicial authority” (Seiter, 2008, p. 40) When examining criminal sentencing, one must first understand the basic theories associated with the punishments given to criminals. There are five main goals/theories behind criminal sentencing; punishment, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and restitution.…
- 3708 Words
- 15 Pages
Best Essays -
Sentencing is very important and usually the last stage of the criminal process. The purpose of sentencing is to punish the criminals while at the same time stopping crime from continuing. The five philosophical reasons for sentencing are retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation and restoration. Retribution is the philosophy that those who commit criminal acts should be punished based on the severity of the crime and that no other factors need be considered. Deterrence is the strategy of preventing crime through the threat of punishment. It assumes that potential criminals will weigh the costs of punishments versus the benefits of the criminal act so then the punishments will more then likely be more severe. Incapacitation is a strategy for preventing crime by detaining wrongdoers in prison, separating them from the community and reducing criminal opportunities. Then there is rehabilitation, which is the philosophy that society is best served when wrongdoers are not simply punished, but provided the resources needed to eliminate criminality from their behavioral patterns. Restoration is a sentencing goal that seeks to address the damage by making the community and the victim “whole again”.…
- 437 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Deterrence is the first punishment philosophy. Deterrence is the philosophy that if fear of punishment for committing crimes is present, then crimes are less likely to be committed. Deterrence in today's society is more for police and their presence in the community to prevent or slow down crime. The idea of deterrence also can be helped through punishment of crimes to be carried out swiftly and being a punishment that will make others think twice before committing the same crime. With the philosophy of deterrence, people are going to be less likely to commit a crime if they are more than likely going to be caught committing the crime, and they will be punished for committing the crime. The adult court systems rely on deterrence to come from punishments people found guilty are sentenced to. Punishments should fit the crime and when punishments are severe, most people will reconsider committing the same crime in fear that incarceration will result. Juvenile courts use the threat of punishment as a deterrent for minors that commit crimes.…
- 1267 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Sentencing is an important aspect in the criminal justice process. It is the punishment defendants receive when they are convicted of a crime. The punishment spectrum is wide and vast, ranging from probation to death. Punishment and sentencing present some of the most complex issues of the criminal justice system. There are four main philosophical reasons surrounding the purpose of sentencing; they are retribution, deterrence, incapacitation and rehabilitation. Retribution is the philosophy that a criminal's punishment shall be determined on the severity of the crime he or she committed. It should be noted that retribution is not the same thing as revenge and that the punishment does not satisfy the revenge theory to anyone who may have been a victim. The retribution philosophy also is inspired by the Old Testament, where it states "an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth." Deterrence philosophy has two parts to it, which are the general and specific deterrence. The Deterrence philosophy is based on the fact that a criminal will realize the punishment outweighs the crime that he or she is going to commit. This philosophy hopes to prevent the criminal from going through with the criminal act. The general deterrence works this way, if the punishment is seen to outweigh the crime then others will be deterred from committing the same crime. The specific deterrence is based on the theory that a criminal, once punished and released, will not want to commit another crime and receive the same punishment. The Incapacitation philosophy believes by incarcerating criminals, this takes away the criminals liberty by placing them in jail or prison; this will ultimately keep the criminal from committing further crimes among society and reduce further criminal opportunity. Rehabilitation is another means of trying to reduce criminal activity. Rehabilitation will teach a person not to commit further criminal acts. This philosophy believes that the public is better…
- 728 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
A punishment is the negative consequence forced upon someone by a group or person. Normally a punishment is a consequence of a rule being broken. A rule is any type of vehicle, or guide to ensure certain actions or behavior. Rules are often just written or spoken, and provide guidelines for human activity. A rule is made by higher authority, like a Parent, King, Minister, Dictator, or a Teacher. Rules are enforced with punishments, to deter people from breaking them. Besides punishments being used to deter people; they could also be used to isolate, retribution, and rehabilitate criminals. The question that is related to this essay is; what was the goal of older punishment and what is the goal of modern punishment?…
- 379 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
On the other hand punishment is used in order to reprimand a prisoner, this can be used simultaneously with rehabilitation because if one is imprisoned he has the ability to make his stay there as pleasant as given. Then you have inmates who have nothing to lose and act out while in prison, those who do this are punished in ways such as solitary confinement in which…
- 212 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
There are three theories or models of criminal justice. The first is the retributive theory, the second is the rehabilitative theory, and the last is the restorative theory. The first basically concerns itself with the punishment of people by putting them in boot camps/prisons or away from people, in order to deter their ways. Such acts instill discipline and fear, which in turn reduces crime. The second one believes that working with these people change their ways reduce crime (The U .S. Penal System: Restorative and /or Retributive Justice).The third restorative theory aims to reintroduce and re-incorporate the persons back into the community after retribution or rehabilitation.…
- 1929 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
The four fundamental philosophies surrounding the purpose of sentencing are; retribution, this philosophy is the belief that those who commit criminal acts should be punished according to the seriousness of the crime and that no other circumstances are considered, deterrence, this strategy is the thought that if the punishment given is severe enough that it will stop the potential criminal from committing the crime or to be a repeat offender. Incapacitate is the third philosophy that is a belief that if the criminal is detained for a crime, thereby being separated from the community reduces the criminal activity and once released will not be as likely to be a repeat offender. Rehabilitation is the fourth and final philosophy that surrounds the purpose of sentencing, some believe that society is best served when those who break the law are not simply punished but are provided with resources needed to eliminate the need or want to engage in criminal…
- 353 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
According to the book, Criminal Law and Punishment, written by Joel Samaha, the characteristics of punishment include pain or unpleasant consequences, punishment prescribed by the law, punishment administered intentionally and punishment administered by the state (Samaha 22). The two sole purposes of punishment are prevention and retribution. The five philosophies of punishment include retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and restitution. Retribution is the best at exemplifying the philosophy of punishment.…
- 798 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays