Preview

Qualia In The Joy Luck Club

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
595 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Qualia In The Joy Luck Club
The philosopher and cognitive scientist Daniel Dennett has done numerous researches on the concept of Qualia: a gap in language. Qualia are the subjective experiences that cannot be described by words, such as describing color to a blind person, or the blind describing the lack thereof to a seeing person. In the novel "The Joy Luck Club," the mothers and the daughters have somewhat of a communication gap: one is centered on the Chinese language and the other American English. In communication between the mothers and daughters, there is a large amount of misunderstanding that can be seen due to the mother’s insistence on speaking Chinese and the daughter’s habit of speaking English.
The novel illustrates the relationships between Chinese Society
…show more content…
I talked to her in English, she answered back in Chinese” (Tan 33-34). The difference of languages is a synecdoche of the difference of the culture as a whole, with the daughter being strongly connected to the American world and the mother being strongly connected to the traditional Chinese world. Because of this barrier, neither side can completely be adapted to the other; similar to how a perfect translation cannot exist from the Indo-European language family to the Sinto-Tibetian language family. A transition from the main language in a family is a “growing pain” of immigration. The communication between them, or lack thereof, makes them seem unrelated and certainly not close due to their reactions, their communications, and their ideas. This event has happened all over the world, from the Hellenistic Era in Greece to the Pax Sinica in China, where new cultures were accepted throughout the entirety of the ancient world. Another place where a difference of culture and beliefs are seen is when Jing-Mei was thinking through her argument

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The essay “Mother Tongue” describes a writer who grew up with a mother of Asian origin and the limitations created by her mother’s speech. The author, Amy Tan, defines her mother’s English as “broken” and that it created communication barriers. For example, when Tan’s mother would need to call her boss about work, she would rely on her daughter to make the phone call and use proper english. When Tan decided to go into English in college, it seemed foolish since she was more skilled in math and science. The author also mentions how not everyone’s speech is the same, but that is not a bad thing. Tan decided to start writing fiction, and write a book in a way her mother would comprehend. Though the writing was harshly critiqued, Tan knew she…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Death of Woman Wang, by Jonathan Spence is a historical novel pertaining to average people living in northeastern China. Spence’s book is unlike the “typical” social Confucian society China was thought to resemble during the seventeenth century. In this book, ideas of a Confucian family are challenged and can be seen as alternative but non-the-less, Confucian throughout human interaction and specifically in individual behavior. The Confucian ideas of filial piety, suicide, and being subservient are present, yet not as prominent as historians might think in a small town known as T’an-ch’eng.…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel gives insight as to what was happening in the war between the Chinese and the Japanese. For example on page 21, it is revealed that Shanghai was repeatedly bombed and was purposefully set on fire in certain locations that were not destroyed by the bombs. Aside from the World War being described, the novel does a good job of teaching about the Chinese and Japanese culture. Throughout the novel, hobbies such as gardening and painting are often brought up. The mentioning of such simple hobbies helps the reader comprehend what the common citizens saw as an escape to get their minds off of the war. Ultimately, the book’s combination of both personal information used with the actual historical events of the war help the reader have a better understanding of what was truly occurring during this time, making it an interesting book that is a good source of learning general historical information about World War…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jan Wong starts out as a naïve, nineteen year old, Canadian student who is displeased with the capitalistic nature of her surroundings. It was the early seventies and to the author, she was experiencing a cultural revolution all her own. Opposition to the Vietnam War was strongly prevalent, the notion of feminism was beginning to arise, and there was a strong desire against conformity of any nature. The author grew up middle class to second generation Chinese citizens and was fueled by bourgeois guilt, and by a feeling of separation from her roots. “Curiosity about my ancestry made me feel ashamed that I couldn’t speak Chinese and knew so little about China” (14). After devouring every morsel of information that she could, she firmly believed Mao and his “comrades” were the only people who had a legit shot at establishing a utopic society. It was official. Jan Wong was going to Beijing.…

    • 1587 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    she grew up with exposure to both English and Mandarin in her household. She embraced…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    China Coin Belonging

    • 5163 Words
    • 21 Pages

    The narrative focuses on a Eurasian teenager named Leah, who travels t o China with her…

    • 5163 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One tragic event in China, which was the Tiananmen square massacre sparked the curiosity of Grace specially for the safety of Chun-mei during that event. For the first time in her life she asked a question to Kevin her adoptive dad about Chun-mei. An example is a scene that happened in the book, ”What about Chun-mei?” I asked. “I’m sure she’s alright,too.” our eyes met briefly. I look away. It was the first time I had said the name Chun-mei without anger. Because of this tragic event, it was the very first time Grace thought about the safety of her mother Chun-mei. It also sparked her interest on what is happening in China even though she hated her cultural heritage when she was a child. A few years have passed, Grace started to learn how to speak and write Mandarin with the help of Mr. Frank. After years of learning she started to appreciate the idea of being able to speak in another language Grace quoted that “Many times, I basked in the sense of superiority it gave me.” (Ting Xing Ye 121). Grace starts to appreciate the beauty and benefit of speaking Mandarin even though she abominated her culture when she was a child. She starts to feel superior of being able to speak Chinese since she is the only person in Milford that can speak it. Grace hated the idea of stereotyping other Asians saying they're all the same and she classifies all of them are different,…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    joy luck club

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Throughout The Joy Luck Club Amy Tan inserts various conflicts betweens mothers and daughters. Most of these relationships, already very fragile, become distanced through heritage, history and expectations. These differences cause reoccurring clashes between two specific mother-daughter bonds. The first relationship exists between Waverly Jong and her mother, Lindo. Lindo tries to instill Chinese qualities in her daughter while Waverly refuses to recognize her heritage and concentrates on American culture. The second bond is that of Jing-Mei Woo and her mother, Suyuan. In the beginning of the book Jing-Mei speaks of confusion in her recently deceased mother's actions. The language and cultural barrier presented between Jing-Mei and Suyuan is strong enough to cause constant separation and misunderstanding.…

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A child, who grew up only knowing America, will definitely struggle in communicating with a mother who was fully immersed in Chinese culture back when she lived in China. Although age does make it difficult, these cultural differences will hinder their communication even more than age as they have different perspectives, ideologies and thoughts because of their different upbringing.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tan spoke chinese, and her mom's original language, chinese. But, also when Tans mom spoke english, she wouldn’t be able to use big words, they had to be short and simple sentences. I have been reading the way she would speak to her mom. Her story is a good example of code-switching and how it can make big changes in someones life. Tan makes a clear description about the way she grew up with two different languages, and helping her mom. Her mom had gone to the hospital for her result of the cat scan, and the people from the hospital barely paid attention to her or give her a good explanation about the results since they didn’t want to bother wasting their time trying to explain to someone who didn’t know the language correctly. She told the doctor to stay there and wait for her daughter who spoke perfect english. In my opinion, I believe that a very high percent of the second generation has problems with code-switching in this country because most of the times the parents don’t speak good english and they have to combine two or more languages at…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Joy Luck Club Identity

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Suyuan had to make the hard decision to leave her twin babies on the side of the road in hopes some kind stranger would take them in, that way she would not have to see them die. Suyuan searches for her babies all through her life in America, sending multitudes of letters; they finally get in touch with her two months after she has died. Because her mother is not alive to meet her children, Jing Mei takes her place and the trip enables her to finally recognize her Chinese ancestry. The minute she enters China she "feels different" and can realize that she is "becoming Chinese" (306). At fifteen Jing Mei believed she was only as Chinese as her "Caucasian friends" (306). Yet her mother counters thoughts, telling her: "Once you are born Chinese, you cannot help but feel and think Chinese" (306). Once in China Jing Mei decides her mother was right and she "has never really known what it meant to be Chinese" (307). She has never understood her mother or her heritage. This trip is the connecting link to understanding her life. She begins to feel natural in China, thinking to herself on the train: "I am in China… It feels right" (312). Jing Mei sees the landscape, the people, the histories, and the families in China and sees where her mother was speaking from all of those years. She knows a "little percent" of her mother know (15). It becomes "obvious" to Jing Mei to see what "part of [her] is Chinese"; it is "in her family, in her blood"…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Pair Of Tickets Analysis

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the story, there are many situations which show that Jing Mei has a bad impression of China and does not want to admit her heritage of being Chinese. For example, she hates certain behavior of her mother, such as haggling with storeowner, picking her teeth with a toothpick in public, and combining odd colors for winter clothes (Par4). Her mother's behavior embarrasses her and makes her think that she herself is nothing like a Chinese woman. In addition, what she sees during her trip to China also gives her a bad impression of China, but she begins to change her view gradually. When she is in a taxi in Guangzhou, the taxi driver dodges between trucks and buses, honking his horn constantly (Par59), and she sees workers work on scaffolding without safety straps or helmets. Also, when she arrives in Guangzhou, the station is so crowded that she and her father are constantly being pushed and shoved; however, when she reminds herself that she is in China, she feels right and starts pushing, too (Par33). The reader can see that she is a little accustomed to China and its environment. Later, when she stands in the shower in the hotel, she feels forlorn instead of relieved, since she would like to be a member of Chinese people and to get along with people. Later on, what she experiences changes her mind about her heritage more thoroughly. Before she arrives in Shanghai, she often images that her two sisters will be disappointed when they see she comes along without their mother; and they will not accept her or like her. She thinks so because she does not regard her two sisters as her family members at the beginning, but when she finally meets them, she almost mistakes them for her mother and they warmly and amicably…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    June was born and raised in San Francisco California, United States. June’s language,country setting, friends, way of living and thinking were all fragments of her American life. She rather to be called June May instead of Jing Mei. She only spoke a little bit of Chinese. Even though June looked Chinese she did not feel like one. “ All my Caucasian friend agreed: I was about as Chinese as they were” (Tan 145). She felts like a normal American woman and thought she had no Chinese in her. Her mother told her “Once you are born Chinese, you cannot help but feel and think Chinese” (Tan 145). However it wasn't until she went to China that she discovered that her mother’s words were true. “I saw myself transformation like a werewolf, a mutant tag of DNA suddenly triggered, replicating itself insidiously into a syndrome, a cluster of telltale Chinese behaviors…”(Tan 145). June experienced a self transformation during her trip to China that changed her perspective and rapidly made her understand what was Chinese about her.” I look at their faces again and I see no trace of my mother in therm. Yet they still look familiar. And now I also see what part of me is Chinese. It is obvious. It is my family. It is in our blood. After all this years it can finally be let go” (Tan 157). This quote emphasize that June finally has overcome her internal conflict and now she recognized the Chinese behaviors as her…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joy Luck Club

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “The Joy Luck Club” by Amy Tan was four stories about four Asian-American women and their families. These women where all independent and adapting to their life in the United States of America. The excerpt was from the first section of the book, “Feathers from a Thousand Li Away,” where a daughter loses her mother and is mourning her loss. Tan has an interesting way of making the characters seem believable.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    mother tongue

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Tan herself speak two kinds of English, standard English and broken English. She realizes that she always speak in perfect English, the standard English, when she gives a speech, when she is giving a speech which her mother attends. However, when she talks to her mother, she changes her language into a limited English, broken English, without any transfer. This is because the language people speak is based on how language can help us understand each other. Her mother only needs a limited English to be able to understand newspapers and radios. Thus, her English is just a transferred Chinese.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays