Preview

Nectar In A Sieve

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
818 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nectar In A Sieve
Nectar in a Sieve shows the impact of modernization on rural India through the story of Rukmani and her husband Nathan, and their struggle with the change that happened all around them, yet seemed to leave them behind. The book shows the effect that change had on their family, their village, and how it shaped their lives. Modernization played a significant role and had a big impact on family life, social and class division, and the land in rural India.
Once the tannery moved into their small Indian village, everything began to change for the families of rural farmers including their son’s views on working the land like the generations of men before them had. They no longer wanted to be poor lowly farmers who couldn’t afford the land they cared
…show more content…
While the rich were getting richer off of the tannery and new shops, the poor were uneducated and left behind. Once the tannery came into a village prices for everything went up, so while a farmer could sell their goods for more money, they also had to spend more money on their basic needs which made it practically impossible for them to get ahead or even catch up. The modernization led to families having to take drastic measures just to be able to provide for their families, which caused them to sell their possessions and what little they had just to keep their homes from being taken from them. “Rather these should go, said Nathan, that that the land should be taken from us; we can do without these, but if the land is gone our livelihood is gone” (78); those that had so little would sell or do whatever it took to keep their land and families alive. Some women went to extreme measures to help provide for their families by selling their bodies and making little money through prostitution, “but the man who finds a woman in the street…throws her a few coins that he might possess her, holds her unresisting to whatever he does to her” (118). Some women had no other option other than prostitution, and although they were only trying to provide for their families, the people in their communities shamed them for their desperate actions. The modernization and change of rural India led to the oppression of the poor, shaming of poor women, and left many hungry and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    One issue that came from this was the desperate lack of labor, because there were so few settlers and each seemed to want land for himself and his family. On land, the farming way of life that New England settlers left behind in Europe saw the most basic place of production was the individual household. This, combined with the labor shortage in Essex County during the first decades of settlement there, meant that the people who ended up helping to clear forests, building barns and other farm buildings, as well as tending to the fields were the sons of farm owners, if they had any. The “productive relations” between fathers and sons in New England families, Vickers argues, has never received extended study, and his depiction of how boys, teenagers, and young men fulfilled their roles at home convincingly illustrates that “the two were interdependent on each…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Loss was a major part of the book Nectar in a Sieve, by Kamala Markandaya, and was highly influenced by the Europeans bringing it into India. First, the tannery caused many problems for the Indian culture. Many people diffused to India and around the tannery. With so many cultures diffusing into the country, it caused the Indian culture to start to decay and for cultural appropriation to occur. Not only did the culture slowly go away, but people were killed or died from the tannery. Next, because of inflammation, prices started to rise. The land was in high demand. Everyone wanted to live there because of the job opportunities and because of the cultural landscape. Prices of items, especially food, were greatly increased. Lastly, many people lost their land. Because of inflammation from the Europeans bringing the tannery to India, the price of land went…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tilly, Joan W. Scott and Miriam Cohen, who are disagree with Shorter’s points, and they are stating that his claims have no supportive evidence. They argue that no evidence found to support the point Shorter made about women that they were powerless in traditional families. Instead, there are some evidence that showed the women had power within a family because importance of their roles. They point out that vast majority women did not work in the factories, but in customary women’s jobs. Women did not work because of rebalance or to seek for independence, but to add to the family finances. Woman who worked they add only small amount to the family finances they did not make much money. Tilly, Cohen, and Scott proving different point as to why women sought work. Unlikely Shorter, the explanation they offer why women were employed was because the problem generated from industrialization. Industrialization gave new opportunities for women, it also contribute for young girls were sent out to the cities for work. Even though, young women were sent far from home their independence was very limited. Some countries had nuns, who were placed watching and restraining young women behavior and social lives. Women did not make much money and very poor, female got paid significantly less than male did, and female work was seasonal and irregular. Authors point out that young women were deficient income with unstable jobs…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Behind Mud Walls Paper

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In order to understand India, one needs to understand its villages. Behind Mud Walls does a great job in providing a detailed background of an ordinary village life in India. Since seventy percent of Indians live in villages, it is important to learn about village lifestyle and the changes that take place in it. Only then one can learn about the cities because one needs to understand the relationship between the two in India. Behind Mud Walls provides the opportunity to examine a north Indian village from a non-Indian point of view; in other words, a non-biased point of view. Since the book is broken up into parts by years, it gives the reader a great way to examine the changes that take place in this village; it shows how it was then and how it is now. Karimpur in 1930 was very different from Karimpur in the 80’s and 90’s. Many changes were observed by Wisers and Susan Wadley, who writes the later chapters in the book. These changes were social, economic, educational, technological, political and cultural but most significant of these were social, and educational. The social changes with an emphasis on role of women, the slowing down of the Jajmani system and the rise in education will be the focus of this paper.…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rural poverty for peasants in the British Isles was key in them hoping for a new start in the New World. In early England, more than half of the population were in poverty. The increase in inflation proposed new issues for these people that they were not dealing with before. The prices of goods were continuously rising, making it more difficult for peasants to live in their daily lives. During the 17th century, there was a rise in peasants settling in American colonies because of the weak economy during this time. It is understandable that these peasants would risk their lives to hope for better economic opportunity in the American colonies.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The farmers' hands, stained with dirt, grease, oil, and toil, illustrate the long hours, boundless passion, and devoted determination exerted to provide for families while sacrificing time with their own. These crop cultivators brim with knowledge, share the same obsession about weather and time, and walk on a tightrope during the long, scorching summer. The agricultural world never provides any guarantees for these preserving laborers; therefore, some may ask, "Why be a farmer?" The passion, desire, and expression across all farming families convey a response where no words need to be spoken - a family…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Nectar in a Sieve many motifs are revealed, but the central most valuable theme in the story is that in order to survive you must be willing to transform and change. People struggle to understand that adapting and change is what helps them overcome their obstacles. It is the key to their growth and survival.…

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    <br>Poor women did not go to school or have an education, they just looked after their home, and span cotton or worked in fields.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hilary Clinton's Heroine

    • 4666 Words
    • 19 Pages

    It soon became apparent that women workers had a serious problem with money and banking. Even though many of the women worked twelve hours a day or more, they made little money, had no savings, and never had enough capital to improve their conditions. For example, a home- based textile assembler might have to pay high rent on the sewing machine she used. She never had enough money at one time to buy the machine. Even if a woman was able to get a little money together, the money often was not safe at home, where men felt entitled to whatever was in the…

    • 4666 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Industrial Revolution led to the creation of the middle class, a social group between wealthy land-owning farmers and poor farmers who lost money through the “enclosure movement.” This led to four distinct social classes: the peasants, working class, middle class, and aristocrats. In The Communist Manifesto, it is believed that the “The modern bourgeois society... has not done away with class antagonisms... new conditions of oppression… but created new forms of struggle in place of the old ones” (Marx and Friederich 14). The rise of the middle class, new factory owners, lead to the control and exploiting of the working class. This new class has emerged and made immense profits through unfair treatment of workers because of demands for cheap labor. This division further enhances a social gap between the wealthy and destitute and creates social systems that can be noted in modern day societies as well. In addition to a class divide, family life was severely changed during the Industrial Revolution. As women began working and child labor became more prevalent, the traditional family model was disturbed. For instance, in Cornish mines, about 19,000 men, and 11,000 women and children are employed, in part above and in part below ground (Engels 200). Women and children began to work within factories and sometimes acted as the primary breadwinners of the household. Furthermore, women in the United States and other areas were earning less money than men; about $3.00 to $3.50, 70-75% less than men (Dublin). This gender inequity was the underlying problem for many households. As more women were hired (because they could be paid less), men were forced to stay at home in many families. This led to increased alcoholism and crime within cities as men spent more time in pubs and other similar…

    • 1855 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Legacy of Malthus

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This movie looks into the issue of poverty prevalent in rural India. Deepa Dhanraj takes us from one corner of rural India where poverty persists to the Scottish highs which witnessed highland clearances in the 19th century. Scottish high landlords had legal claim over the common land on which shared croppers survived. Landlords rented the land to tenants who further let it to sub tenants. At the end of 18th century, volume sheep farming for wool and meat became immensely profitable than renting it to shared croppers in Scottish highs. The landlords claimed that due to increased unchecked population growth the produce from the land was insufficient to sustain the population. Shared croppers were legally and forcefully evicted from the land. There was misery, starvation and cycle of poverty amongst the evicted people by the more powerful who had law and authorities on their side. Many died, thousands migrated outside England, and some were allotted land along the shores which was uncultivable while others were displaced internally to big cities in England as cheap labor.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Black Death

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Agricultural prices dropped significantly, making times hard for those who made their living on the land. Fewer people to work the lands meant fewer crops to sell and less money to be made. To make things worse, there were less people to do the work in the fields so they demanded higher wages, less work, and better living conditions. The better wages for the peasants, who were once “poor”, made things more equal between the “rich” and the “poor”(Knox, n.d.).…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Working in the factories was all too often unfair for the women. Women’s earnings were about one fifth of the of a man’s earnings for doing the same job for the same amount of time. The wages that women received were not only extremely unjust but the money they did receive was not nearly enough to live off of.…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Operation Reaserch

    • 1299 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Ploughman family farm owns and operates a 640-acre farm that has been in the family for several generations. The Ploughman always have had to work hard to make a decent living from the farm and have had to endure some occasional difficult years. Stories about earlier generations overcoming hardships due to droughts, floods, etc., are an important part of the family history. However, the Ploughman enjoy their self-reliant lifestyle and gain considerable satisfaction from continuing the family tradition of successfully living off the land during an era when many family farms are being abandoned or taken over by large agricultural corporations.…

    • 1299 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Caste System

    • 1770 Words
    • 5 Pages

    by speeches. The caste system affected the status of people, meaning who you can talk…

    • 1770 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays