Miss Narwin's Homeroom

Question:“If this case were taken to court, who would win?”

Answer: I assume that the school would win the case because

The students in Miss Narwin’s homeroom saw what Philip was doing during the morning announcements. This AVI pg. 146 “Dr.Doane:How close to Philip do you sit. Ken Barchet:Cross the room. Dr.Doane:So loudly enough for you to hear.”The student sat across the room from Philip nevertheless the student could still hear Philip singing which means that Philip was singing loudly.(AVI pg. 149) “Cynthia Gambia:Well, I heard him. Sort of. I mean, it wasn’t loud or anything. Not like the paper said. But he wouldn’t stop. And she did ask him. I guess that was the disturbance.”This student also heard Philip singing during the morning announcements, which is against the rule of respectful silence during the national anthem.(AVI pg. 153) “(Conversation between Dr.Doane and Allison Dorsett)Dr.Doane:I’m glad. Your telling the truth can only help her.”This student was telling what actually happened in the three days that Philip was singing the
(AVI pg.154) “(Memo)by singing the national anthem in a loud, raucous, disrespectful fashion, thereby drawing attention to himself.”Philip was singing the national anthem in many rude and disrespectful ways that drew attention to himself which is against a school rule.(AVI pg. 206) “Miss Narwin:And- that boy- Philip Malloy- for reasons I’ll never learn-decided to insult me, me his classmates, and, as far as that goes the National Anthem.”According to Miss Narwin Philip Malloy insulted Miss Narwin, his classmates, plus the national anthem which seems extremely disrespectful.(AVI pg. 150) “Cynthia Gambia:No. I guess not. I mean, he was being sort of rude”Cynthia Gambia said what Philip did was rude plus Philip broke the rule of respectful silent,