Judicial Precedent

Topics: Stare decisis, Precedent, Supreme Court of the United States Pages: 2 (533 words) Published: April 30, 2013
Judicial Precedent

Judicial precedent means the decisions of the higher courts automatically binds the lower courts according to the hierarchy of the courts. This refers to the doctrine of stare decisis. For example, the Supreme Court decision binds the Court of Appeal, Divisional Courts, High Court and County Court. Ratio decidendi is the principle of the case or reasons for the decision and it is binding.

In London Street Tramways v. London County Council, it said that certainty in the law was more important than individual hardship. From 1898 to 1966, previous decision was bound to follow unless the decision was made 'per incuriam' or the Parliament has introduced a new act. In 1966, a Practice Statement was issued by the House of Lords. It states that they can depart from previous decision when it is right to do so. The first major case was Conway v. Rimmer but it only involved a technical point on discovery of documents.

The first major use of Practice Statement in civil law was in British Railways Board v. Herrington. In Schorsch Meier GmbH v. Hennin and Miliangos v. George Frank (Textiles) Ltd, the Court of Appeal refused to follow a decision of the House of Lords in Havana Railways which said that damages could only be claimed in sterling. House of Lords attacked Lord Denning by saying that the Court of Appeal had no right to overrule the decisions of House of Lords. Then, House of Lords used the Pratice Statement to overrule its own decision in Havana Railways. Practice Statement was used in criminal law for the first time in R v. Shivpuri.

Court of Appeal is bound by its own previous decisions. However, in Young v. Bristol Aeroplane Co. there are some exceptions. Firstly, Court of Appeal can refuse to follow its previous decisions if there are two conflicting decisions. Court of Appeal must choose between the two decisions, the rejected decision will lose its binding force. Secondly, Court of Appeal must follow the Supreme Court if a...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Judicial Precedent Essay
  • Essay about Judicial Precedent
  • Judicial Precedent in the United Kingdom Essay
  • Doctrine of Judicial Binding Precedent Essay
  • precedent Essay
  • Essay about judicial precedent
  • Judicial Precedent Essay
  • Judicial Precedent Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free