Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

How succesful was the weimar republic?

Good Essays
770 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How succesful was the weimar republic?
How successful was the Weimar Republic (1919-1923)?
As First World War end Germany had to face different problems. One of these problems was the fact that as the Kaiser abdicated, a new government was created. This new government was The Weimar Republic and the First President of the Republic was Friedrich Ebert.
On the one hand, the Weimar republic brought many improvements to Germany and learned to cope with the problems the country was facing at the time. As soon as Friedrich Ebert became the new leader he helped deciding what the constitution should be like. Ebert believed the Allies would treat Germany better if they had a democratic government so the new constitution gave Germans many new rights. This new constitution allowed men aged 21 and over to vote in elections for deputies to the Reichstag. Germans have rights to free speech, freedom of newspapers, freedom to set up trade unions, and anyone could form a political party. All of these were completely new freedoms for Germany, and very modern for the time. German people weren’t used to this new constitution but many of them were interested in learning more about it and supported it. When elections came Friedrich Ebert won them. The new president had to face different problems. One of these problems was the opposition from both the right and the left. On the left wing there were the spartacists who were communists who felt that Germany was ready to follow Russia’s example of making communist revolution. Furthermore, on the left wing there were the Freikorps, a group made up mostly by ex-service men who disliked the new government but specially were totally opposed to communism. Ebert managed to stop both sides by making an agreement with the Freikorps who crush the communist revolves. This tactic was supported by people from the right wing and by judges and democratics who opposed communism. In addition, the new government had to decide whether to sign or not the Treaty of Versailles. Ebert felt he had no choice as the army wouldn’t be able to stop an invasion so he signed it. Although most people felt betrayed by him and the new government there was no other way of making peace. The Treaty of Versailles was also blamed by Germans for economic chaos as it forced Germany to pay high reparations to the allies. Germans protested but their protests were ignored. They didn’t have enough money to pay the reparations and the Allies, specially the French ran out of patience as they also had debts to pay to USA so they entered the Ruhr and took was owed to them in the form of raw materials and goods. The government told the workers to make passive resistance so that the French have nothing to take away but this brings even bigger problems. The production decrease and there were no goods to trade so government simply started printing money. For them this seemed a good solution as they were able to pay its debts. The great industrialists were able to pay off all their debts as well.
On the other hand, the Weimar Republic was a weak government with many opposition and made wrong decisions that bring lot of problems to the country. The truth is the new constitution was very critized as most people were divided between those who wanted a communist government and those who wanted to stay as they used but only a few liked this new government. Moreover, as Ebert send the Freikorps to crush the communists revolves it was as if they had the permission to kill communists. This means that the punishment for those who killed was least or didn’t even exist. Besides, the fact Ebert signed the Treaty of Versailles made German population felt betrayed by the new government as they didn’t believed they had lose. The Kaiser and the army never told bad news to the people and many believed that Germany could still win the war. What is more, as the government started printing money the prizes raised high faster than ever. Hyperinflation wasn’t a minor problem. Poor people were suffering and the prosperous middle class who had savings in the bank noticed that that money now had no value. The situation needed urgent actions.
In conclusion, although the Weimar republic had many conflicts it found the way of staying in power what shows it wasn’t that weak. It was very critized but the new constitution laws were quiet fair and decisions like signing the Treaty of Versailles were decisions that have to be taken.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A major flaw in the Weimar constitution was the proportional representation electoral system, which was an attempt to become more democratic. Democracy comes at the price of a strong government as it is usually difficult to form a stable government in a democracy. This can be manifested by the fact that in the mere period of 14 years, there were 21 different governments and 13 chancellors. This shows that the Weimar government lacked stability and strength which would make it almost impossible for the government to be effective and tackle the problems. How could the government solve the difficult troubles that Germany was facing, when they could not even manage to cooperate and unite? Since, proportional representation is one of the fairest electoral systems, it was impossible to form a strong single party government who had a good hold in the Reichstag and only weak coalitions which could not agree upon a decision was formed. Weak coalitions meant ineffective and incompetent governments. On the other hand, it could be said that the Weimar governments were not as unstable as it is claimed to be. The Weimar constitution has produced effective and stable governments such as the grand coalition which was seen as a strong government and it stood for the longest amount of time. Also, despite the numerous changes in government, the base parties of…

    • 999 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Weimar Republic faced several problems during the years 1919-24, one being the Spartacist uprising. The Spartacists, a very communist party, were a threat to the Weimar, and became troublesome, making retaliation inevitable. The Weimar government however could not defend themselves in any physical way, so had to depend on the Freikorp, a more right wing group, to defend them and fight off the Spartacists. This proved instability through the government, as they had to rely on someone else to fight their battle.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the years following World War I, Germany had suddenly became a democratic state. The Weimar Republic created a divided situation in Germany, one that led to its downfall. The weak leadership of those at the head of government, the apathy of the German population towards democracy and the outright rejection of democracy by the communists were all factors that led to the instability and downfall of the Weimar Republic.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The new Weimer Republic lacked support from to run a proper democracy, they relied heavily on the Reichswehr and the Freikorps. Although the Reichswehr fought against the communists, they were not loyal to the democratic republic. They believed that they were “Stabbed in the back”, when Ebert’s government (November Criminals) signed the Treaty of Versailles. The population did not recognise the fact that they would not have lasted the end of the war without being entirely crushed. The Reichswehr supported the right, so during the beer hall putsch they refused to defend the new government, they stated “Reichswehr does not fire on Reichswehr. The new government was in between the left and right, however after the war the working class (the majority of the population) tended to support the two extremes, conservative and communist. The new government forced a new constitution to be drawn up, this included article 48- which could suspend the fundamental rights of the citizens if public order and security were seriously disturbed. The new government was due to the treaty of Versailles and the revolution.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As World War I came to a conclusion, the German people faced an inherent complication: what was to be the future of Germany? Democracy was a paltry response to such a climactic part of history. The Weimar Republic not only deteriorated the already feeble nation, but became a mixing pot for the future of the Third Reich. Once the previous leaders of the Weimar Republic conceded defeat, Adolf Hitler rose in his ranks until he accepted his position as Führer on August 1st, 1921 for the National Socialist German Workers’ Party. They pushed through many different trials and victories, and finally became chancellor on January 30th, 1933.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Democracy was a foreign concept to the German people, whose authoritarian tradition had deep psychological and social roots. On 9 November 1918, when the Kaiser’s abdication was announced, and Friedrich Ebert the leader of the Social Democratic Party was entrusted with the German Empire, “The old and rotten – the monarchy – has broken down. Long live the new! Long live the German Republic!” was shouted towards the public. However, familiarity of authoritarian rule and therefore the traditional expectation for the government to take control, make strong decisive decisions and stand as a unified front, was not a feature replicated in the new republican government. One of the problems lay in the new republican constitution of 1919, which guaranteed the basic rights of the German people but also contained weaknesses that undermined its functionality as a democratic constitution. The voting system based on proportional representation was one such weakness. With a…

    • 2088 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early 1920's, hyperinflation and £6600m worth of war reparation payments sent Weimar Germany into deep finiancial decline and a economic slump. It was in 1924, shortly after Gustav Stresemann introduced the Rentenmark when the situation started to improve, started by implementation of the American 'Dawes plan' in August. The key factors of this plan were the agreement that the reparations should paid over a lengthened period of time, and the £100m worth of gold given to Germany to strengthen the currency. Passive resistance in the Ruhr was no longer supported by the Weimar government. Employment rose to healthier levels, and reparation payments began at their new rate.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To be able to answer this question you would first have to ask yourself what problems Germany faced before this time. Between the years 1919 and 1923 Germany had a lot of problems to deal with: hyperinflation, violent uprisings and the French occupying the Ruhr made it very hard to govern Germany.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Imperial Germany was replaced by the Weimar Republic on the 9th of November 1918 opening the door for the democracy which subsequently lead to political instability and a contrastingly new liberal society. This new republic adopted the Weimar constitution which created the first parliamentary democracy in Germany. The change in society from a previously autocratic society is highlighted by a passage in the Constitution saying “The German Commonwealth is a Republic. Political authority is derived from the People”. Electors were now all men and women above the age of 20 compared to before where it was men only above the age of 25. It also guaranteed personal freedoms such as religious freedom and freedom of speech. This new highly liberal and democratic society highlighted a change in society from the previous autocratic one controlled by the Kaiser. However the Weimar constitution had flaws in it which were used ultimately in its fall such as Article 48 and proportional representation in the Reichstag. Historian Eric Weitz said “The flaws…were to do [more] with…the fact that German society was so fragmented” highlighting that although there were flaws, they could have worked under a society more committed to democratic…

    • 1649 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    A Republic was declared and an interim government set up under Friedrich Ebert, leader of the largest political party, the Social Democrats, whilst plans were drawn up for a new constitution and political system. With Berlin in turmoil, a small town in the centre of Germany called Weimar was initially made the centre of the new government.…

    • 3108 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Firstly, the role that Hindenburg played was the most significant factor in helping create the Weimar Republic. This is because after the sudden announcement that World War one was lost, he and Erich Ludendorff went to Kaiser Wilhelm II and informed him that they wanted to create a new government. This new government would be made up of representatives from the biggest parties that were in the Reichstag. Although the Kaiser was, at first, tentative whether or not to do this, he eventually agreed and Germany became a democratic country. The creation of this democratic country meant that the country was now being run in a way that Hindenburg went against. The reason he wanted to make Germany a democratic country was that, by doing this, he hoped that he would be able to make the Treaty of Versailles have better terms. Another reason that he wanted to become a democratic country is that he hoped that the blame for the loss of the war would be diverted to Prince Max’s government ministers.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    World War I left Germany vulnerable and leaderless. Germany struggled economically, like any other country in the world, especially hard. They did not just lose the war; they lost territory, military, money, and hope. Paul von Hindenburg, president of Germany appointed Adolf Hitler Chancellor on January 30, 1933 along with the National Socialist German Workers Party, or Nazis. Germany did not stay a democracy for long. The Enabling Act permitted one cabinet, the Nazi Party, to be in place for four years, giving Hitler full dictatorship.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Weimer Republic was unpopular between the years 1919 + 1923 because of their democratic approach to government. They were not liked by the Germans because they were thought to have been ‘stabbed in the back´ after they agreed to sign the Treaty of Versailles.…

    • 518 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The “old” German empire reached to an end when its significant personalities agreed on “a revolution from above” 1, as the Foreign Minister of Germany Paul von Hintze was convinced to try to prevent a revolution in Russian manner. It is essential to take a closer look at the constitution of 1919 while analyzing why the Weimar Republic failed and why Adolf Hitler became the chancellor. The position of the “Reichspräsident” that was created had way too much power. This leader position could break down the Reichstag with Article 25 that says, “the president of the Reich may dissolve the Reichstag, but only once for the same cause”(wiki). Furthermore he had the authority to suspend some basic rights in order to create his “personal” vision of the public order and security.…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hitler’s outstanding oratory skills and modern propaganda raised the face of the Nazi Party. On the other hand, the Weimar Government had suffered many disasters such as the occupation of the Ruhr and hyperinflation. This also enticed people to support the Nazis who felt that they had been ‘stabbed in the back’ after the politicians who went on to serve in the Weimar Government signed the Treaty of Versailles. Furthermore the political situation in Germany was highly fragmented with many political parties with extreme ideological divisions meaning they did not work together and this…

    • 1999 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays