Preview

How Did Truman Progress Towards Equality For African-American

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1033 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Did Truman Progress Towards Equality For African-American
“To what extent was progress towards equality for African-Americans made under President Truman?”
President Truman adopted a Civil Rights Activist label during his presidency and is widely known for his efforts in fighting for equality and eliminating segregation. This essay will examine the depths of whether Truman’s actions were really as progressive as they seem.
Socially, Truman became increasingly involved in the rights of African-Americans as time went by. From Truman’s private life, it is insinuated that the progress made towards equality for African-Americans under Truman’s presidency would have been minimal: The fact that he originated from a pro-slavery town (Missouri), where most of black people over 40 had been born into slavery
…show more content…
This confirms that Truman’s attitudes were shaped by his youth, as reinforced by the historic fact that he developed an ‘abiding belief for white supremacy’. This demonstrates the assumed lack of progress in Truman’s potential to change the lives of black people. In contrast, it could be argued that his personal, instinctive views towards black people did not hinder his intentions to achieve equality in general. For example, Truman’s involvement in the armed forced illustrates a progression in seeking and implementing equality. Although he was privately racist, he tried to be fair – He said that equality for black people was a black man’s ‘basic right because he is human’. In addition to this, the destruction that World War Two inflicted upon black people’s lives affected Truman massively. He was horrified by attacks on black service men returning from WW2. This emotional attachment led to a legalised progress when Truman sparked the Desegregation of the …show more content…
The President seemed hesitant to make a speech to the Society for the Advancement of Coloured People as he quotes, “Mama won’t like what I say” in a letter to his sister. However, Truman seems to dismiss this view, as backed up with his direct quote, “I believe what I say and I am hopeful we may implement it”. Progress was sparked further through his speeches as public views were altered, creating a slight political shift. Truman gave the first presidential speech to the NAACP saying that all Americans were entitled to full civil rights and freedom. Furthermore, his urge to end lynching, the poll tax and inequality in educational employment implies that he was sympathetic for black people, indicating a progress in terms of human rights for African-Americans. This is emphasised in Truman’s quote, “Our first goal must be to secure fully the essential human rights of our citizens” which shows that Truman’s personal motivational drive to achieve general equality was progressive and influential. However, it could be argued that his intentions were not progressive as he claimed that it was important to set a good example during the Cold War against Communist Russia. This implies that he may have only supported Civil Rights for his own reputation and benefit. As historians, one must consider the context of his intentions, and although the implementation was active and thus progressive,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Truman in the aftermath of World War II, though ideally a positive historical move towards equality, the actualization of the orders instatement legitimized the increasing opposition by the general public (Levy, NP). Truman’s decision to issue the order undoubtedly paints a picture of true leadership and fortitude in the fact that the order was faced with strong opposition from the masses; especially those most affected by the order, service members. The idea of ceasing racial segregation in the military, at face value, seems to be another necessary and overdue step to be taken towards racial equality in the 1940’s (Dalfiume, NP). My initial position, naturally, was that of confusion. I found it difficult to believe that those fighting for equality would be in opposition to an order put in place to help achieve this goal. However, after digging in a little deeper I was able to not only understand, but agree with the oppositions; knowing that disagreeing with the execution and timing of an Executive Order does not necessarily mean that you disagree with the fundamental concepts and beliefs the order was set to carry…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The years 1945-55 could be seen as a time of significant change for black African Americans. Such as segregated schools abolished. Truman also fuelled some positive changes. However equally these changes might not be as big compared to the negative events that happened. Such as the attack on Emmet Till and returning black service men.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In assessing the important role of Lyndon Baines Johnson in the battle for civil rights, the opinions of scholars and politicians differ enormously. Among his advocates he is viewed as “the foremost practitioner of civil rights to ever occupy the White House.” (“Civil Rights 116) Their appraisal is reasonably based on the legislative victories accomplished during his five-year presidency. His opponents on the other hand tend to question…

    • 68 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The introduction of The Progressive Era and Race: Reaction and Reform, by David W. Southern, opens with his representation of the Progressive Era and the subsequent American shift from emancipation to segregation that occurred during it. The author uses social history to examine and demonstrate his subject. He argues that “the nation was in fact caught up in a powerful tide of white supremacy at home and imperialism against people of color abroad.” Southern discusses the hopes and expectations of the emancipated and subsequent generations alongside the failures of the Progressive movement. Chapter titles provide a glimpse of his discussion into the restructuring of the American social hierarchy.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of his political beliefs was that if blacks were educated and trained industrially it could reduce the hostility from…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    President Truman as a young man was undoubtedly a racist. But after hearing about stories of black men fighting in the Second World War his attitude towards African Americans did change. It was because of this change in opinion and the importance of the black vote Truman established the president’s committee on civil rights to produce a report on experiences of African Americans in 1947. This report was important as it was one of the first steps in establishing what the actual problems were for African Americans and what needed to be done to change it. In the report it talked about many things including lynching, police brutality, voting rights and much more. But what could be gathered from the report was that segregation was the main source for much of the African Americans problems. So this was something that the federal government could be blamed for as much of the south had free reign over black people and the federal government done nothing to change this. Instead they focussed their attentions on keeping the news of African Americans treatment in the south out of the media and not actually helping the cause. So although the “secure these rights” was important in identifying the problems of African Americans it didn’t actually help the position of…

    • 1598 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A. Phillip Randolph was known as a radical journalist, a labor leader, and a pioneer of civil rights. His mission was to unite blacks against the discrimination which shut them out of well paying jobs in the factories. Many whites and blacks knocked his efforts in the beginning but as time went by people started supporting his message. All over the United States committees of black people were forming to protest in the march on Washington. A lot of people tried to persuade Randolph not to do it but he insisted that it needed to be done. Finally recognizing that he could not be swayed, President Roosevelt signed an order to end the discrimination on plant jobs. This was the beginning of fair employment. Randolph started getting recognized as the most dangerous black man in America because he made someone so powerful do something he really did not want to along with another President by the name of Harry Truman. Randolph’s persuasiveness allowed Truman to sign an order commanding that there will be an end to…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American civil rights movement succeed in integrating society by breaking segregation in education and evolving legislature to not only prohibit but to demonize open racial discrimination and bigotry. If Eisenhower never did what he did, then I assure that ethnic relations today would be very different. We would have never have gotten this far if that man hadn't stepped up in spite of being a white man and them being black; If he hadn't done what no one thought a white man like himself would have ever done. Society today would not be the same, and I genuinely believe that the real Cecil knows that too.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During World War II many African-Americans moved North to take advantage of the many jobs. This migration continued throughout the 50s and 60s. In the North African-Americans increased their voting strength. When African-American soldiers returned home they also wanted to end racial discrimination. Their fight would have a small victory because in 1948 Harry S. Truman ordered the desegregation of the armed forces and called for federal laws to advance civil rights. Even though Congress rejected his appeals for legislation, this was the first time since Reconstruction that a president had made a move towards desegregation. In the 1940s many were ready for an end to school segregation. These people had their homes and churches burned and many…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Men Analysis

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Furthermore, as he chooses to present a White-centered narrative that pays little attention to both the ideas and the methods of the civil rights activist, he diminishes the historical importance of African American activists in transforming the United States by making it both politically and socially more inclusive. The “Great Men” narrative that Lawson utilizes fails to present the complexity of the civil rights movement and the resilience of the activist, who, despite the numerous setbacks they suffered, continued to fight for their rights. By not paying any attention to the grassroots, Lawson creates a false picture of racial and social progress. He implicitly suggests that having a more or less amicable administration in place would be sufficient to maintain or advance the interests of historically marginalized groups. That is unfortunate, particularly because the article was published at the turn of the century, long after conservative forces had begun to dismantle some of the hard-won reforms. Consequently, a more inclusive approach that depicts the essential groundwork before and after the national leaders of the movement negotiated legislative reforms with the national government, would have been warranted.…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    African Americans have always struggled throughout history, and th1930s was no exception. During this period they were victims of hate crimes, racism, discrimination, segregation, and lynching, had unfair employment and had very bad access to education and other resources. The great depression was felt throughout the entire country but was obvious that African Americans were getting the worse end of the stick. Roosevelt’s new deal helped many people in America also, yet again it seemed that African Americans were often left behind, or more their needs were dealt with second to whites. Although Roosevelt had little interest in race relations and civil rights, his wife Eleanor realised the crisis black people faced in America, and did much to aid them throughout the 30s. African Americans were still affected by the Jim Crow laws, which saw the segregated in many areas such as schools, public transport, and drinking fountains, in restaurants and even in the military. Even in times of war America could not bring itself together to fight alongside people who were fellow countrymen, regardless of the colour of their skin to fight what they all believed to be a greater evil. So yes, the 1930s were a turbulent time for race relations in America, despite the decline of organisations like the Ku Klux Klan, which received renewed support during the 10s and 20s in America tensions were still high in America between blacks and whites[1].…

    • 2117 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    By the second half of the twentieth century there were essential indications that the government would soon act to improve the status of African Americans. President Eisenhower presented a four point proposal for civil rights in 1957. When the Congress passed the civil rights bill, Clarence Mitchell Jr. was appointed to fight the legislation. Clarence Mitchell Jr. was the director of the Washington Bureau of the NAACP.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In post-reconstruction America, many Black writers, ministers, teachers and others eloquently argued on behalf of freedom and justice for Black Americans, advocating various strategies for achieving racial and economic equality. Two such leaders who helped shape the political discourse were Ida B. Wells and Booker T. Washington. Urging politically divergent approaches, they both wanted African American people and men in particular, to be valued and respected by the white south. However, they differed significantly in the means by which they believed such change would come about. Ida B. Wells told the truth in a way that made many whites uncomfortable, addressing lynching and other racially motivated atrocities directly and proposing that African Americans collectively leverage economic power through strikes and boycotts, and individually protect themselves from lynches with weapons. In contrast, Washington was more conciliatory, appealing to whites to give African Americans the opportunity to prove their technical capacity and participate alongside whites as legitimate economic partners. While the “gradualist” gained unprecedented access to formal political power through his white benefactors, I believe Ida B. Wells’ argument that African Americans stop conceding power to whites was more persuasive in advancing racial equality for African Americans in post-reconstruction America.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    • The Committee of Civil Rights was set up by President Truman inn 1947 and a program of reforms was devised.…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Berman, William C. The Politics of Civil Rights in the Truman Administration. N.p.: Ohio State…

    • 3715 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays