Preview

Hotspur's Virtue

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1347 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hotspur's Virtue
When you think of honor, you might think of a strong and bold war hero jumping in front of his fellow soldiers, taking a hit to save them, or a brave man in a valiant fight against a dragon to save a beautiful princess. I, Sir John Falstaff, say that’s stupid. Honor is a pointless virtue; it shouldn't be sought after by anyone that is halfway intelligent. I know you must be thinking, ‘that man is a fat old drunk! He’s not intelligent!’, but if it weren’t for my understanding of the pointlessness of honor, I wouldn’t be where I am today. Honor is also a powerful virtue that can change the outcomes of men's lives. Many men stupidly strive for honor, which is a complete waste of time. Hotspur ventured for honor by fighting bravely in war. Hal …show more content…
In his last moments, Hotspur said,“O Harry, thou hast robbed me of my youth,”(5.4.78). Even Hotspur knows that he died too young and that it wasn’t at all necessary. He died in battle because he believed that fighting was the only way to obtain more honor. He equated honor with glory on the battlefield and thought it was important to defend his reputation and family name. Hotspur waged war on the King because he had a false sense of honor. He thought that he must protect his family’s honor. Hotspur also believed he was entitled to respect because he was born a Percy. Honestly, I was really surprised when I saw that Hotspur had not faked his own death just like I had, questioning, “Why may not he rise as well as I?” (5.4.128). If Hotspur was truly an intelligent man, he would have faked his death long before he got into that battle with Prince Hal. Since he did not, he died in an “honorable” way; he went down swinging. After his defeat, he attempted for even more honor by sneaking in a quick death speech saying, “But thoughts, the slaves of life, and life, time’s fool,”(5.4.82). When he said this, he couldn’t have been referring to anything besides the honor that caused his downfall. His thoughts of honor have been the slaves of his life, causing him to waste his time and die such a young death. Honor didn’t help Hotspur, but rather it caused him to die a tragic and early …show more content…
Prince Hal became stressed about becoming a son that his father could be proud of, so he took after Hotspur, and tried to achieve honor through fighting as well. When he was speaking to his father, he spoke of Hotspur very highly when he said, “I do not think a braver gentleman, / More active-valiant, or more valiant-young, / More daring or more bold, is now alive,”(5.1.90-92). The tone that he took when referring to his supposed enemy was full of pure lust. Hal knew that Hotspur, although the enemy, had the exact drive that his father wanted him to have as the prince, so Hal took Hotspur’s hunger for honor and strived for it as well. Not only did Hal want to be as honorable as Hotspur in order to make his father proud, but he also wanted to kill Hotspur, to in some twisted way make Hotspur’s honor his own. I was lurking just outside, in hopes to not face any battle, before Hal and Hotspur faced off in their fight. Just before entering I heard Hal say to Hotspur, “To share with me in glory any more. / Two stars keep not their motion in one sphere,”(5.4.65). Hal was referring to the two stars as him and Hotspur, declaring that they couldn’t keep sharing their glory. This meant that either must’ve died at the hand of the other, for neither could live while the other survived. Hotspur was too hungry for honor, but Hal wanted that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Legitimacy is the key to a successful kingship. If you can be perceived as an effective and legitimate ruler by the nobility, you will remain in power. This was especially important in the early period of the reign of Edward IV because the son of Henry VI, Edward of Westminster, was still alive until he was killed at the Battle of Tewkesbury on 4th May 1471. If Edward IV not establish the legitimacy in the minds of the nobles, then they could easily justify overthrowing the usurper because the son of the rightful king, Edward of Westminster, was still alive. Our extract shows us this attempt to legitimise Edward IV by delegitimising the overthrow of Richard II by saying that Henry IV took the throne through illegal…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor Definition Essay

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In a book written by Samuel Johnson in 1755 he defines honor as "nobility of soul, magnanimity, and a scorn of meanness” (Johnson). People may say that this still applies today in the modern world because honor could be staying the same while the people are what is changing. Conversely, this isn’t true because honor has just changed through time, but it has also changed between cultures. With this in mind honor has never been one definition. In an article written by a journalist from New York The Sun, Shalin Punn about James Bowman and his book Honor: A History, he states “honor still exists in more developed forms, in "honor groups," like the "family or the military," where we do have a "code" of honor which creates a "mini-honor culture”(Bowman). In other words he says that honor exists in a more developed form, changing over time. Furthermore honor may be based off of an idea, but it has been developing over time into something…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    * The officer believes that honour is about doing what you think is right, an individualist perspective, where as Rubashov contends that to uphold the honour of the regime/revolution is more honourable.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hotspur's Views On Honor

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In this comparison, Hotspur is the too hot porridge, Falstaff is the too cold porridge, and lastly Hal is just right. Hal is the perfect in between of Hotspur and Falstaff. Hal understands honor to be noble behavior, not noble actions. He shows us at the beginning of the play that he’s a ruffian, but lets us in on his plan to regain the honor later. These actions of hanging out with criminals and hoodlums didn’t earn him favor with his father or with England for that matter. His plan to earn the honor later was to lower the views of him now, so that when it is time to be the hero everyone will love him even more instead of just expecting it from the get-go. His longing for honor is in moderation and he achieved honor in a suitable way. When Hal fought Hotspur it wasn’t so that he could earn honor but so he could save the thrown and his father, it was essential. Hal’s plan was effective, removing himself from his previous lifestyle just in time to be the hero his father needed him to…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hal and falstaff

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In act IV, prince Hal and Falstaff develop unusual relations. The two characters frequently exchange good-natured insult towards each other. The reader comes to see this as a reality as they are unfit to have a good relationship with each other. Though they are related through blood, they hate each other with the spontaneous insult they have in this act. Prince Hal is the surrogate son of Falstaff. He is the factious son. Falstaff is said to be the second father. He is like a parent who does not care about their son’s wellbeing. He has no respect at prince Hal. On the hand, prince Hal is the one who persuades him to emulate him to take his parental role. Their relationship with each other leads to the development of a character similar to King Henry. They all want to impress their audience. Falstaff seems to influence Hal into developing character of King Henry. He wants him to like a leader. He teaches him to learning the art of appreciating every small gift the society has to offer. Though Hal relationship is completely different from his relationship with…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hal was always fair which made his subjects admire him. Hal is a prince, which makes it easy for him to care only about himself; however, he takes care of his friends. Hal tells Falstaff “I’ll procure this fat rogue a charge of foot” (2.4.528). Hal not only wants honor for himself, but he also wants his friends to be honorable. Hal does not have to worry about anyone other than himself, however, the fact that he worries about his friends shows his true character. Hal tries to stop unnecessary bloodshed when he says to Hotspur “And will, to save the blood on either side, try fortune with him in a single fight” (5.1.99-100). Hal not only cares about his friends, but also all of the people that will be his subjects. Hal does not want to see his people slaughtered if he can help it. Hal is a fair man who thinks before he acts which makes him seem…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Richard iii

    • 1757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Though still sick, King Edward IV brokers a reconciliation between Queen Elizabeth, Dorset, and Rivers and Hastings and Buckingham. Anon, Richard appears to reconcile with everyone else when Queen Elizabeth mentions her wish to have Clarence pardoned. To the shock of everyone, most especially to King Edward IV himself who claims that he had issued an order reversing Clarence’s condemnation, Richard informs the gathered assembly that Clarence is dead and buried, adding that the King’s countermand must have been too late to reverse the original edict and insinuating that the Queen is responsible; at this point, Stanley comes to beg the King to have a servant of his pardoned for killing a man. The request spurs the King to chide his subjects for their collective failure to plead on behalf of Clarence, arguing that it’s a crying shame that no one thought it his duty to stand up for a King’s brother when at this very moment a noble is standing up on behalf of a slave. Distressed, the King goes back to his room. The children of Clarence, question their grandmother, the Duchess, as to why she’s often so sad of late if not for the fact of their father‘s death. The Duchess replies that she’s sad because of her son’s Edward’s illness and that their father Clarence hasn’t died. The latter of the Duchess’ assertion, however, contradicts what the Boy knows to be truth as he has been told by his uncle, Richard, that the King has had their father killed and at the behest of the Queen. The Duchess assures the boy that his uncle has lied and wonders how she could have ever given birth to such a disgrace Richard. The Queen, accompanied by Rivers and Dorset, appears in a state of dishevelment. King Edward IV has died. She appears to be inconsolable, but Dorset and Rivers manage to calm her, arguing that she cannot begrudge God his payment and that she has yet her son, the Prince of Wales, from her marriage to King Edward IV, who will no doubt be King, on whom she may rely.…

    • 1757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Suicide, at this time, was considered a cowardly move, something a Prince or a hero should never consider. We relate to the dark heart, sense of loss, and pain experienced by Hamlet. He is trapped in an unsettled mind with no escape. He is a Prince, but he feels pain like every other man.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlet Yorck S Skull

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, the returning prince finds that his scene of sanity is gone in picking up the broken pieces of his life. He tries to coup with it all, facing the reality of his father being dead, dethroned by his uncle, and losing the love of his life Ophelia. What more could a man take in staring death in the face and questioning it. As human beings we all have a purpose on this earth, to find what we are destine to do. Hamlet reaches acceptance of his situation. Wondering if he will be known for being a great avenger, or the son who didn’t avenge his father’s death.…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It's ironic that the thing that ‘rouses him from his state of crime' (Pojman, Vaughn 358) is the horse that his father is on. He hesitates to shoot the enemy soldier because of the beauty of the scene; the horse, the valley, and the sky. Carter Druse ponders if it is so terrible to kill the enemy during war. (Pojman, Vaughn 358) Kant felt that it was duty to the…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rhetorical analysis

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages

    By knowing he faces extreme opposition of wanting to fight, Patrick Henry makes it evident that the war against Britain is completely inevitable. Because the people had such a narrow mindset, Henry knew it highly important to first gain respect from the people, if he wanted even the slightest chance of them listening to him. “No man thinks more highly than I do of the patriotism, as well as the abilities, of the very worthy gentlemen who have just addressed the House.” This beginning sentence establishes his credability rather quickly, and makes him a more worthy contender to listen to. Henry begins the second paragraph of his speech discussing the illusions of hope. He is trying to act as a teacher of truth, but also a bearer of bad news. He recognizes that man dreams of freedom without fighting, but then refutes this idea. The word, “illusion” proves that it cannot be a reality. Patrick Henry also quotes, “…and listen to the song of the sirens that transforms us into beasts,” making an allusion a highly popular book of the time, The Odyssey. By making the reference, it reminds the people that he really is just another…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However honor has evolved over time, but like a sequel to a movie, it just isn't as good as the original. In the not so distant past honor insights humility, but today honor insights…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor has always been a central aspect of one’s identity. People go great lengths to keep and prove their honor. Honor is a popular topic that is regularly seen throughout literature, but what exactly is honor? Honor today is seen as one’s integrity and protecting one’s values and beliefs. But it has not always been that way.…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many concepts, that Americans are exposed to- and even use- in their regular day to day lives, that are not very clearly defined. Maybe these concepts are too confusing. Or too broad to clearly understand. Or they’re just vague. Or, perhaps, maybe these concepts simply are not valued enough within that American “go-go-go” mindset to have time taken to really think about and understand what they mean. One of these cheapened, romanticized concepts, is honor. Honor always has, and always will, exist in some way or form in every single society, including America, however morphed and faded it might be.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor to different people can mean completely different things, so it’s almost impossible to come up with one solid definition of what honor is. To some people being a brave soldier and dying for your country is honorable. For others, it’s being a missionary in a poor African country. While the deeds that are considered honorable may be different, I think it all goes back to my point of being an individual and doing what you think is right. Those missionaries don’t go to Africa for a vacation. They go there to bring the word of God. Those soldiers, sailors, marines and airmen aren’t out there dying for no reason, they are risking their lives to ensure America stays free. While those instances maybe different, they have one thing in common, and that is that in both instances the actions are done because of some moral conviction to do what is right. These people are few and far between these days, and it’s really a breath of fresh air to see people with some kind of morality these days.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays