Preview

History and Films Black Robe

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
430 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
History and Films Black Robe
In the films Black Robe, The Crucible, The Patriot, The Alamo, and Cold Mountain, the authors created historical inaccuracies for the audience of the generation they were made for. This means they would change some details to fit their idea of what the people felt in that time in history, to grip the audience and give some insight to the characters. These inaccuracies also helped to develop a point, even though a few minor details were changed, the audience eventually saw the whole picture and knew the story. In The Crucible, the director would have been hesitant to address the actual age of Abigail, 11, and John, 60, because the age difference of these two people being involved in a sexual relationship would have been so unacceptable. While the author certainly knew this was going on, it wouldn’t have been talked about in his day. This is why the director chose characters closer in age, to develop a point and show that those type of scandals had been occurring between younger women and older men since Puritan times, making the film also more realistic to its viewers. One major example of these historical inaccuracies, which is also found in Re-Viewing the Past: The Crucible, is that he took the language taken directly from trial records, but would sometimes alter the lines, leaving the movie with a historical feel and providing proof of the satanic possession. For example, he changed the words in the Lord’s Prayer from “hollowed by the name” to “hallowed be thy name.” These differences of the text and the movie aren’t negative, but just present more of an understanding of these historic events for the audience.
The inaccuracies of these films do not harm my understanding of past events because they didn’t change the huge event in history that they were trying to give a picture of, they just altered minor details. If anything, the changes made by the directors helped me appreciate and get to know these historical figures even more. While using the text to make

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The movie “Black Robe” was very realistic in portraying themes that paralleled with the lives of the aboriginal people living in North America at that time. Some of the themes that were similar in both portrayals of aboriginal life the primary document “The French Presence in Huronia: the structure of Franco-Huron relations in the first half of the 17th century” by Bruce G. Trigger and another primary document called “The Meeting of Two Worlds - Who Benefited from Indian-French Contact?" by Paul Bennett and Jaenen Cornelius were sickness, violence and the culture differences between the Huron and the Jesuits. The movie “Black Robe was very good at describing the aboriginal life through related themes…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Gallagher, Edward J. “Synopsis.” Reel American History: Black Robe (1991). Accessed October 4, 2011 http://digital.lib.lehigh.edu/trial/reels/films/list/1_4_6…

    • 2135 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Movies make a huge impact on how we view history. Even though a movie says it is based on a true event, it is not always historically accurate. The movie 300 is based on a true story. The movie portrays how the boys grew up. How the Spartans fought is also historically accurate. There is also some material in there that is not historically accurate or we don’t know if it happened.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In reality Elizabeth Proctor was some 20 years younger than her husband, John Proctor, which wasn’t stated in “The Crucible”. Also, Arthur Miller never declared in his play that Elizabeth was already in worry of being accused as having dealings with witchcraft due to her grandmother, some 30 years earlier, being tried as a witch but truly only had a skill in healing people. In the website “legendsofamerica.com” Kathy Weiser includes that, “She grew up to marry John Proctor, who was some 20 years older than her, on April 1, 1674.” Also, “Elizabeth was at risk of being targeted because her grandmother was Ann Holland Basset Burt, a Quaker and a midwife, who was brought up on charges of witchcraft in 1669.” These two pieces of evidence shows a dramatic difference between Elizabeth Proctor I reality and the Elizabeth Proctor in “The Crucible”. I believe the author left out the fact that Goody Proctor was 20 years younger than John because majority of todays people see the huge age gap in relationships as bad or immoral. As in the fact that Elizabeth’s grandmother was accused of witchcraft 30 years earlier and was also a Quaker, which were felt to be “witchlike”, I believe Miller left tis out of the play for simple reasons as in suspense and it wouldn’t really give the play much creativity. If he would have included this then the…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Robe

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Robert Kilker concludes that though Black Robe “may at times pretend to equalize its perspectives of the French and Algonquins . . . it always recovers that balance, replacing it with a Eurocentric hierarchy.” I felt just the opposite. For me, Black Robe was based around Chomina, a true hero. Chomina is a strong character who stands firm in his beliefs but respects the beliefs of others, which is why he is the essence of the movie. As the movie progresses, the characters change, especially Laforgue, who comes to question his very identity as a Christian. Chomina changes the least, however, and emerges as the film’s most powerful character. His key trait is his ability to establish relationships that are founded on respect. Chomina accepts outsiders, while staying true to his own culture. He demonstrates how two cultures can co-exist, but not assimilate into one culture or the other. The basis for this co-existence is respect – a respect that begins in respect for himself and spreads to respect for his tribe and respect for other cultures.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One thing the people in the crucible were afraid of was witches. If anyone was accused of being a witch, they had to tell on other people or they would be killed. To prove if someone was a witch they would hold them under water and if they survived they were a witch. They soon realized that they were killing tons of innocent people that were not witches. The people were also afraid that Abigail would accuse them of being a witch.…

    • 184 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    1.) How historically accurate was the movie you watched? How do you know? Did any inaccuracies affect your perception of history?…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The older generation has always feared and suspects the younger generation. In Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible, the knowledge of the older people has always suspected the younger people and most of the time they are right. In the Puritan New England town of Salem, Massachusetts in 1692. A married man(John Proctor) have an affair with a young girl named Abigail Williams. Abigail still desires John but he doesn’t want anything to do with her anymore. Elizabeth Proctor wants John to denounce that Abigail’s a fraud. Mary Warren, the Proctor’s servant and one of Abigail’s circles, returns from Salem with news that Elizabeth has been accused of witchcraft but the court did not pursue the accusation. Proctor later confesses his affair with Abigail…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most common characteristic societies throughout history is the fear of unknown things. Natures of human are weary of thing which is different, and the Puritans’ actions during the events that appeared in The Crucible have no difference. Many characters in the Crucible were forced into horrible situations where their beliefs, morals, and overall faith were put into the trial. The reputation, intolerance and hysteria are the main themes surround in the novel, and through those phenomena that show clearly of struggles of human nature. This is what happened to John Proctor, Elizabeth and Abigail when they were in the trial of Salem.…

    • 157 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Crucible” everyone was to dress and act a certain way. They believed that if you didn’t follow the bible and did one thing wrong you were headed for hell. In that Society that Church was in charge and, secretes got around quickly. In this time society believed that it made more sense to believe Abigail Williams over Tituba. This happens because Tituba is a slave and Abigail’s uncle is a big…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play, The Crucible by Arthur Miller, the Puritans take part of a government that is based solely on the Bible. The good faith of the townspeople is quickly changed as many of the town’s high-standing citizens are accused of witchcraft, tried, and even hanged. In The Crucible, fear and faith relate very closely with the decisions that are made throughout the course of the trials and hangings of the Salem Witch Trials.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crucible Movie

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The 1996 film version of “The Crucible”, portrays the infamous Salem witch trials that took place in Massachusetts during the 1600’s. Author Arthur Miller portrays many events and characthers true to that of what happened in salem in 1692. However, many of the historical events are concentrated around the movies non-fictional relationship that Abigail Williams and John Proctor have. The movie is have many inaccurate elements that are not true to what really happened.The fictional romantic affair along with the overall exaggeration that Miller’s incoperates, was necessary to follow the Relationship of Abigail and Proctor. The most significant ways is through the innacurate historical events that are added to the movie, that ties…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nearly everyone can agree that the Puritans had some issues. They killed countless innocent people for ridiculous reasons, accused anybody different from them of being a witch, and were extremely strict about religion. Some Puritans even accused people they didn’t like of witchcraft just to get them executed. The Puritans that saw problems with this system were accused of being witches and hanged as well. These actions are shown very clearly in Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible. In this play, several teenage girls begin to accuse people they don’t like of witchcraft and pretend that they are being afflicted by them. The people of Salem all believe them and almost every person the “afflicted” girls accuse…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miller uses diction, all through The Crucible, to show that the story being told is taking place in the past and to make the story have a biblical effect to it. In Act three, John Proctor begs for his name to not be blotted out and says, “Tell them I confessed myself; say proctor broke his knees and wept like a woman”. Through, using the word woman instead of baby, which most of people would use in this time period, he uses the word woman, which gives the reader a feeling of being in the past, because in that time woman were looked upon as second class citizens. When Proctor and Abigail speak with each other in Act one, Abigail explains to Proctor that Elizabeth is talking bad about her and that she is ruining her name in the community. She explains this to him by saying, “She is blackening my name in the village”. From, the diction that Miller uses by using the word blackening, it puts an old feeling to the story and it also puts a biblical feel to the story, which enhances the story by making you feel like you are in the 1690’s. Another great example of Miller using diction to make the story feel old and biblical is in Act two when, Elizabeth explains to Proctor that it is not her that judges him, but he judges…

    • 846 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arthur Miller’s, The Crucible, is full of dishonesty and pain. It’s set during the Salem witch trials, where “witches” were hanged for associating with the devil. Many people can be blinded by the truth without knowing. Some tell a convincing lie and we believe it because we sometimes have no reason to question it. In The Crucible, some characters blind to the truth are Judge Danforth, Reverend Parris, and Thomas Putnam. These people were well respected and smart, but were still blinded by the lies.…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics