Preview

'Has Africa Got Anything To Say' By Karen Smith

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
839 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
'Has Africa Got Anything To Say' By Karen Smith
SUMMARY
Karen Smith in her article “Has Africa got anything to say” wanted to basically address the rising criticism of how the developing world and in particular Africa has been neglected in International Relations theory. She attempts to go beyond the criticism by addressing concerns of how the developing world can make contributions which are potentially vital in enriching people’s understanding of IR. She highlights how the existent Western knowledge is seen in many parts of the globe in a superior manner. The article also speaks of how the interest of enriching the western knowledge by the indigenous knowledge has not extended to the field of International Relations.
The author goes on to explain in detail the meaning of African knowledge
…show more content…
It is made clear in the text that the colonial period provided a platform of widespread western influence. Commentators in the field have argued that the western knowledge was imposed on Africans via the colonial era and that all African knowledge has since then become a reflection of it.
The author when talking about what stories Africa can contribute cites a renowned scholar by stating that the current IR theories which are American and British have dominated the field of IR that they can no longer be thought of as just stories. The objective according to the author is to now challenge the dominance of these stories and reclaim space for other stories, which in this case includes African stories. In the test there are ways highlighted of how to tell the stories and how they can be of a great deal to the IR fraternity.
In conclusion the text talks of how the contribution from the lived experience of Africa is important to provide a view of international relations and international politics from bottoms up. There is emphasis put on the need to acknowledge Africa’s contribution in IR theory because it can provide a different perspective. The most important position set out in the article therefore is that Africa has a lot to contribute and IR scholars should take it into account so as to enhance their understanding of international
…show more content…
When one examines the existing IR theories, it becomes quite evident that Africa is rarely given accreditation. For example when you look at the foundations to international relations the founding fathers all hail from Europe e.g. Karl Marx, Maxx Webber, Hans Morgenthau, Thomas Hobbes etc. What I found interesting in the article is the way the author strongly believes that knowledge from the non western world can influence the West. This when one goes back to the colonial period and remembers how the Africans fought for their independence; there is a high chance that Africa can make a huge contribution in the current global system.
The author however did not highlight the hindrances as to why Africa is still lagging behind. For example poor leadership, civil wars, underdevelopment, poverty, overpopulation etc are some among the many problems that Africa faces. The findings from the author are presented clearly but she omitted the facts behind the whole question as to whether Africa has a say in the international system. However the results presented in the article are convincing in that there is evidence of examples of Africa’s potential in terms of resources and knowledge

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    HIST 325: Colonial Africa

    • 3255 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Winter 2013 – TR 6:00-7:20pm, McKenzie 214 – CRN 23274 Version 1.00, 7 Jan 2013 Professor: Dr. L. F. Braun Office: 311 McKenzie Hall Telephone: x6-4838 on-campus. Email: lfbraun@uoregon.edu Office hours: T 2:00-4:00pm & by appt. Overview and Objectives Africa is central to human history. It is the continent where our species arose, where some of the greatest ancient civilizations throve, and where dynamic, complex, and innovative cultures confronted a variety of social, political, and environmental challenges. Many African states and societies were materially wealthier than their European counterparts until the 1700s, and Africa has always been connected— however tenuously at times—to the wider world. Yet in the popular, Eurocentric historical imagination in the U.S. and Europe, there is sparse knowledge of Africa’s history, and it was rarely even considered a subject for historical study until the 1950s. For the period before European political dominion in Africa (c.1880-1960), this lack is even more pronounced. In this course we will explore the history of Africa between the 800s and the late 1800s, while at the same time discovering the…

    • 3255 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    2009 Dbq Ap World

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For years after the Berlin Conference, various European powers raced to occupy and colonize land in Africa. It was a time of growth for Europe, but what was it for Africa? Africa’s fate was being decided for it by the European invaders. Not all AFricans just stood by and watcher, however. There was a wide range of actions and reactions to the Scramble for Africa from the Africans themselves, from giving in peacefully to attempting to fighting back with all of their might.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Presently, Africa has become a developed continent with the Western system of governments and religions; but despite Africa’s significant transformation like other continents of the world, the media, through documentaries and stories portray Africa in a way that people still have a widely held and an oversimplified image of Africa, and…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Where the writer supports the best the thesis of his book, is with the idea that globalization is great for most of the countries of the world, at least from an economic standpoint, but as stated:” […] in the less privileged parts of the world, where participation in the process is not easily achieved, globalization is seen by many as a threat, not as an opportunity” (De Blij, 2012), and thus, it is not always the case. This example perfectly depicts how a nation’s geographical location can change the way it sees what the West is doing and how globalization affects that country. Also, understanding that globalization can be a challenge for Africa puts in perspective all the problems that the United States also faces with Islam. De Blij makes a great case, saying that the greatest danger to Africa’s stability is its “Islamic Front”, and as we saw during the last decade, most terrorists and enemies of the West are coming from afar. Then, understanding and being able to predict what is happening in Africa by example, might relate directly to the way the United States deals with Islamic countries all over the world, and could help them develop better internal policies as well as improve the safety on U.S. soil. I understand that as of today, the American government does not see Africa as big of a threat, or at least not as threatening as some of the middle eastern countries. But ideas are spreading extremely fast, and events that were thought impossible, such as the Arab spring, happened and took the world by surprise. Additionally, Africa’s infrastructures will certainly improve to reach a level of organization that could potentially threaten the US security as much as Afghanistan, Syria or Iran do today. We all know that Africa is one of the poorest parts of the…

    • 1767 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Benefits to Africa as a result of imperialism were plentiful. A primary document, “Does Colonization Pay”, details the many improvements made to the continent; Africa was home to innumerable, rich resources. As a result, Europe was able to utilize these as raw materials, and return the money to Africa. The money was also used to bring the people of Africa food supply, as well as other supplies that were much needed. Besides this, these nations created “roads, canals, railways, and telegraphs”, along with “schools and newspapers” (Document 1). As displayed by the information, imperialism was seen to have profound effects on Africa. Not only did they utilize the rich resources to supply economic gain to the continent, but also significantly developed the continent by providing means of transportation, education, and a source of news. Unfortunately, these benefits were not of significant value due to the immense oppression experienced by the people of Africa during the age of imperialism.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The purpose of this essay is to talk about the connections between the USA and Africa...…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is Africa an important part of world history? George Hegel, a German philosopher, stated in one of his quotes that “Africa has no historical part of the world, and has no movement to exhibit.” This report will discuss the importance of Africa, and why Greg Hegel was incorrect through the development of major cities, huge empires, and a few dynasties.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking back in history, countries around the world go through tremendous changes that influence the future. Change is inevitable and countries have the ability to transform in order to stay competitive. Countries have the power to change for their own self benefit, and on the other hand, countries can change due to other dominating regions. Africa is a country that has fallen victim to both instances. Early on, Africa was a country that had new technology for farming and overall viewed as a powerful country. It is easy to say things can turn out different in any given situation, but at the same time, change is necessary for progress. In the past, Africa has been shaped by various countries in Europe which forever altered their outcome. Through stories like Things Fall Apart and other countries’ actions and involvement, Africa ended up with an outcome that most likely could not be changed.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    By attributing less agency to poor African countries than other poor countries, it ignores those communities’ political and economic success stories. When a country in the West believes they know what is best for a country outside of their own, it is not only not true usually, but it diminishes the assistance that they are trying to offer. The interference of paternalism is justified by saying that the group will be better off because of it, but as we can see from the past, it is rarely true and an idea that those in the West must work hard to re-contextualize their understanding of countries outside of the West to fit with their true…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Africa is more undeveloped than any other country today because of the problems that were rooted from the past. The trading system, having their history denied, and the inequality had a major negative effect on Africa’s development. Africa's history has been denied and it's resources have been taken advantage which has taken an effect to their…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When defining any discipline that the world offers, it is important to discuss its origin, pre-disciplinary history, and its formation as an actual academic study. According to Professor Robert Lee Harris Jr., “African studies is the multidisciplinary analysis of the lives and thought of people of African ancestry on the African continent and throughout the world” (Harris 321). While analyzing Harris’s definition of African Studies, one must focus greatly on the fact that ancestry has an immense impact on creating a disciplinary study. Disregarding the history of the African people before establishing a study about them only hinders the opportunity a student has to fully understand what they learn about. “For some four hundred years, Europeans conquered and divided the whole of the African continent among themselves. The dark cloud of colonialism descended over Africans, whose land, labor, and economical wealth were methodically and thoroughly exploited and stripped by colonial powers” (Martin and Young 4). Anthropologists studied African people during the time of colonization and therefore, started the African Studies. Although the anthropologists had the opportunity to study the culture, language, and lifestyle of the Africans, they unfortunately developed a colonial-based view.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    African American Culture

    • 4492 Words
    • 18 Pages

    As we begin to think about Africa and its, we must also consider how Western perceptions of "race" and "racial" difference have influenced our notions about the history of Africa. These ideas, which have usually stood out against the presumed inferiority of black peoples with the superiority of whites, arose in Western societies as Europeans sought…

    • 4492 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    -What organizations, ideologies and leaders did Africans create and engage in the 20th century to promote and advance their liberation?…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Hall, R. & Peyman, H (1976). The Great Uhuru Railway: China’s Showpiece in Africa. New York: Gollacz Salvaterra, N. (2012), « U.S. Aims to Lift Investment in Africa », The Wall Street Journal [Online], Available: http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/ SB10000872396390443517104577573152210348294 Nunn, A. & Price, S. (2004) « Managing Development: EU and African Relations through the Evolution of the Lome and Cotonou Agreements », Historical Materialism 12. Nyere, J. (1974), Freedom and Development. Dar Es Salaam: Oxford University Press.…

    • 2246 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Colonialism In Africa

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The continent of Africa has faced and continues to deal with many problems due to its geography, colonialism, and economic exploitation. Africa contains roughly 1/3 of the primary commodities in the world, yet it is one of the poorest regions. Geography on the African continent is diverse from deserts to rain forests and beaches to mountain ranges. The pure size of the continent and some extreme environments has made it challenging to develop infrastructure and regional international trade. Ethnic conflict on the continent, primarily due to colonialism and arbitrary boundaries, has also hindered the development of the region. Africans often have a stronger allegiance to their ethnic group than their…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays