Preview

Haimon's Decision-Making In Sophocles Antigone

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
682 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Haimon's Decision-Making In Sophocles Antigone
Haimon delivers a successful argument urging his father to reconsider his decision to kill Antigone.

When he first approaches his father, Haemon appeals to his father’s sense of morals and values by cautioning him to use reason in his decision-making. He does this by explaining to Creon how he is not capable of ¨knowing everything¨(Sophocles). He says this to try to knock some sense into Creon that no one can make these huge decisions without a little help and advice. It is important to Haimon that he tries his hardest to prove to his father that it is okay to take some advice, and it will not make him out to be a week king. Haimon also tells his father that the only reason his people will agree with him and take his side was because “his temper terrifies everyone¨(Sophocles). This is an attempt to prove that listening to the people and caring for their best interests is his most important job as a king. This was meant to appeal to his
…show more content…
The analogy he used was comparing trees to his being stubborn. He explained that in a storm, some trees bend and are loose and because of this “even their twigs are safe”(Sophocles). Then he explains how the stubborn trees “are torn up, roots and all”(Sophocles). The reason he used this analogy was to express to his father that allowing yourself to be moved is a good thing and is a much better way to go about things. This is just another way Haimon backed up his opinion that the better way to go about things is to not be so stubborn, and learn to forgive. This analogy shows that a leader's strength is not determined by how stubborn and stiff he or she is. It shows that being able to go with the flow of things is one of the most important qualities in a leader. This is why Haimon thought it was so important for his father to hear it before making his final

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    1. What are the beliefs of Creon, Antigone, and Haimon about laws? Compare and contrast.…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Haimon is supportive of his father’s idea at first, but as he begins to think it through, he begins to question it. He eventually agrees with it and begs his father to forgive Antigone for her actions.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Haemon is Antigone’s fiance and also the son of Creon. His father asks of his…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Antigone by Sophocles, Haemon's sound, and strongest argument for a change in Creon’s policy is that Creon is too self righteous and has not been listening to what his community thinks is best for Thebes. Haemon proves that Creon has not been listening to the community because of stubbornness when he said, “So the report spreads in darkness. When you do well, father, I have no more honored possession than that, for what prize is greater for children than that...Don’t be so stubborn that you say you and you alone are right”(712-16). Haemon’s argument proves that Creon should consider changing his policy because the people of Thebes are talking about who they believe is right in secrecy. The people do not think that Creon's policy is just.…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As Creon made decisions and orders towards the body, Antigone also stood for herself and made here own decisions. First, at those times it was very rare that a woman would speak out, because they didn’t have the chance to say what was in their minds and express themselves. In other words, it was very rare that a woman was caught in some type of trouble. Also, woman had any importance or value in the ancient Greek society. At those times men were superior to the woman. Therefore, they were the only ones that had the last word and the ones that mattered. In those times it was thought that women were unable to make important decisions. Men had every importance in Greek society, they were the ones who made every single decision and were the ones who had the voice, the woman had to remain submissive and obey even though she would disagree.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Publilius Syrus once said,(12c) “Man’s life is short; and therefore an honorable death is his immortality,(12c)” that is also the main idea in the play Antigone by Sophocles. After studying “If we must Die” by Jamaican author Claude McKay and “Invictus”by William Ernest Henley then comparing them to Antigone,(12c) it is effortless to decide which one is more related. “If we must Die” is more similar to Antigone seeing that they share the same views of dying an honorable death and making something of life and not just wasting it.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After King Creon honors Polyneices's body, he arrives at the vault of Antigone and his son, Haimon. Creon immediately discovers that Antigone has committed suicide like she said she would while Haimon is right by her side, devastated. In a dazed rage, Haimon takes his own life right in front of his father. "And suddenly drew his sword and lunged. Creon shrank back, the blade missed; and the boy, desperate against himself, drove it half its length into his own side and fell(969-970)." At this point, the king is unimaginably depressed but his morale decreases even more when he comes home to find his wife is also dead after she stabbed herself. Sadly, Creon's change of heart did not reach out to his loved ones, which left him alone and…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He is trying to set an example of what he feels a good man does. No matter his feelings for Antigone or his father, he still listens to what others have to say. By listening, he learns what they think about Antigone’s charges. The people believe she should should receive all the honor they can give her and that no women has ever died so shamefully for such a generous act. After learning all this, he feels that his conscious is clearer, which when he goes to talk to his father, he tries to show him not only a different perspective but so maybe he can see it the way others see it also. When Haemon talks to his father, he cannot accuse him of being a hypocrite, which Creon himself is afraid of being. Haemon sets a stellar example of what a good man does, showing his father living proof of what listening and learning can do. He tries to show Creon how greatly he has benefited from the new knowledge, which changed his thoughts about the…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Creon is a stubborn man and a stubborn king, but it is the king who bears the responsibility for his state. It is the king alone who will be blamed if his city falls while under his rule. If he cannot trust his own judgment and stick by his decisions, does he deserve to be king? In Sophocles’ play Antigone, Creon steadfastly believes that the king must be obeyed and must rule by example to keep the laws of their land without exception.…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Throughout the story of Antigone, he spills his flaw all over the pages. Such acts are committed when Antigone confesses to burying her brother and argues with Creon that she had done no wrong. Similar to Creon, she was only trying to do the right moral thing, yet his pride holds him from sympathizing with her. Haimon, Creon’s son tries to be reasonable and tries talking him out of making the wrong decision. Even though Haimon is in love with Antigone, Creon refuses to back down on his decision to execute Antigone because then the people will look down upon him. Another example of his arrogant pride is when the prophet, Teiresias, comes to Creon to advise him and to consult about his decision and that it is going to bring about troubles. Teiresias tells Creon, “These are not trifles! Think: all men make mistakes, but a good man yields when he knows his course is wrong, and repairs the evil. The only crime is pride” (232), but Teiresias words doesn’t change Creon’s mind and refuses to yield and accuses him of selling him out and being paid to tell Creon his wrong…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his famed work Antigone, Sophocles does what most authors fail to do. Unlike the general crowd, Sophocles uses positive personality traits to bring conflict to his characters. He breaks normal organization of works and pushes the use of character flaws out of view. With this, persuading irony is formed—an irony which immortalizes the play just as a proper burial would immortalize Polyneices. Standard positive traits result in Creon and Antigone’s disgraces.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    – Haimon says: “Do not be unchangeable: do not believe that you alone can be right … the man who maintains that only he has the power … a man like that … turns out empty” (Scene 3, line 76). Haimon wants his father to know that is he does not change his ways in the end he will be alone. This is foreshadowing the end of the story where he will “turn out empty”. This is because Creon was stubborn in his way, and was “unchangeable.” And though he had good advice Creon would not take them and put them into action, and because of his non action it makes him unsympathetic. – Creon says: “I swear you’ll regret this superior tone of yours! – you are the empty one”: – you girlstruck fool … I swear, by all the god’s in heaven above us, you’ll watch it, I swear you shell” (Scene 3, line 129). This would suggest that Creon is going insane, and that something is going to happen his son by his own hand. Creon is getting on to his son, but really he is getting on to himself. He is the one that will regret what he has done, it is he that is the empty, and it was he that went against the gods. He threatens the life of his own son just because he took a stand and told his father what he needed to hear. This suggests that he was stubborn in that he would not listen to others good…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle once said, “A man doesn’t become a hero until he can see the root of his own downfall.” Sophocles’s Antigone was written in 440 B.C. which was the time when plays were written based on ancient Greece culture. The idea of a tragic hero was established in Ancient Greece, tragic heroes are in ancient Greek plays. A tragic hero is a character who is inherently good, has a fatal flaw and loses everything in the end. Creon is Antigone’s tragic hero because his loyalty and obsessive pride influence the conflicts that led to his family’s demise.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violence, greed, and suffering are all great examples of power being abused negatively. When someone has power, they have the decision to either use that power in a positive or negative way. Sadly, some people decide to use their power in a negative way that affects others. Power can have a negative effect on others by using fear and manipulation.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ethos pathos

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Although Creon uses ethos to convey his feelings towards his laws, Haemon uses rhetorical appeal within pathos to support Antigone. Creon expresses his belief that the law is law, and no one should break it, “I’ll have no dealings with lawbreaks, critics of the government: whoever is chosen to govern should be obeyed” (iii.34-35). Within this, Creon believes that no matter how strict the rules are, they are rules, and they must be obeyed. This way of approach seems right to Creon, because he believes that he is above everyone else, and that his rules are for the benefit of the citizens. Haemon however, questions his belief of his father Haemon exclaims, “You are not in a position to know everything that people say or do, or what they feel” (iii.58-59). Haemon appeals his position with the backings of the citizens. He believes that the citizens come before the rules, and whatever suits them the best should be the law, not whatever a king says is. Haemon creates a brash response to Creon by telling him he doesn’t know what the people want and essentially jeopardizes his relationship with his father. Furthermore, Haemon goes on by questioning his father, “She covered her brother’s body, is this indecent? She kept him from dogs and vultures, is this a crime?” (iii. 65-66). Using a rhetorical appeal, Haemon questions the doing of Creon. He creates an ethical approach to his belief in what’s right by acknowledging the problems with Creon’s law, yet not straight forward telling him he is wrong. Overall, Ultimately Haemons rhetorical questions and overall ethical response shows the underlying stupidity of Creon’s law.…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays