ELI 73(001)
Paper 2 – Academic Writing(draft 1) Grouping the Gifted Children The articles talk about grouping gifted children. In his article entitled “Grouping the Gifted: pro” Kenneth Mott claims that we should do grouping gifted children. Second article “Grouping the Gifted: con” Bruno Bettelheim claims that Grouping the gifted children has some cons.
According to Kenneth Mott ‘Gifted’ means that pupils of average intelligence who have exceptional ability in art or music, or it may refer to the child with an IQ of 135 who excels in everything. The author of “Grouping the Gifted: con” claims that we should group them as nearly as possible according to interest and ability and challenge them with a type of program that will help them to grow to the fullest extent of their abilities and capacities. One of the basic arguments against grouping the gifted is the fear of creating a caste of intellectual snobs. Similarly, some educators fear that the average and slow students would come to regard themselves as inferior. But Kenneth Mott said that these” fears are groundless because encouraging gifted debaters, musicians, artists, and writers to develop their special talents dose not create envy or feelings of inferiority among less talented students.” Also many educators believe that grouping does not affect achievement significantly. They believe the pilot studies which indicate that no significant change in achievement results when children are separated into slow and accelerated classes. However the author do not believe the studies because it was just based on IQ scores. In my opinion we should do grouping gifted children for students’ development.
I agree with
In conclusion,
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Albert Einstein once said “Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will spend its whole life thinking it 's stupid”. As stated by one of the greatest minds of all time, every individual has the capacity to be an intellectual, but the way society currently measures intellect purely based off of one’s “book smarts” not everyone’s genius is fully realized. As stated by Gerald Graff In his essay “Hidden Intellectualism” Graff states that our current system of teaching does by no means try to foster the intelligence of street smart people who account for many in our society. In Graff’s experience he thinks that a style of teaching incorporating street smarts would have benefitted him and would benefit people today. If we tried to teach street smart people using topics they are interested they would be able to understand…
- 1529 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
“The Downside of Being a Child Prodigy” is an article written by Andrea Sachs published in Time Magazine on September 6, 2006. The article starts with a reference to a short story about Alissa Quart who had skills since she was a child. She was able to read and teach her peers at elementary school how to read. She got awards for her writings. One of her good skills is that she was able to edit her father’s writing by the age of 13. Then the writer refers to Quart’s book entitled “The Dilemma of the Gifted Child”. The book talks about the pressures that a talented child encounters in life. Some parents try to enforce their kids to learn at early stage. Some of the materials that they learn are difficult to learn. This step might put a pressure…
- 265 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Dr. Carol Dweck researches environmental factors and how we view our intelligence. Her theory proposes we take either an entity view or an incremental view of ourselves (Niehart, Reis, Robinson & Moon, 2002). People with an entity view see their intelligence as fixed. Intelligence does not change. Entity view individuals want to appear smart and want learning to seem effortless. When working in a classroom, these students will not take risks unless they are sure the end will result in success. These students will become upset when given challenges, take a stance of helplessness, and not attempt the work (Niehart, Reis, Robinson & Moon, 2002). Students with and entity view expect praise for work, not for effort. Dr. Dweck believes that this view is cultivated in the early days at school and at homes. These gifted children often sit unchallenged, spend time working only on self-select work where success is assured, or through adults who praise the child’s success not the process (Fenstermaker, 2014). Conversely to the entity view is the incremental view. These people believe that intelligence continues to grow (Niehart, Reis, Robinson & Moon, 2002). As students, these people are willing to take learning risk and do not care if others perceive them as smart. They will set…
- 349 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There are a lot of different factors that can affect a child’s educational achievement; their social background has a strong influence on the achievement and success that they may get during their lives. For example a child from a middle class background is on average more likely to attain a higher success than one from a working class background, and the class gap between the achievement levels gets wider and wider the older that the children get.…
- 1097 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Giftedness: Some children are seen as ‘bright’ very early on. Adults may notice how quickly they remember things and how fast they are to learn new skills. For these children, it would seem that they are able to process information more quickly and effectively that other children of the same age.…
- 1275 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Q8. Describe some of the assumptions of currently popular gifted children's programs Q9. Describe the self-fulfilling prophecy when students are labeled "ungifted" Q10. What do critics and proponents of gifted education agree on? HW #67:…
- 1729 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
This paper focuses on the overrepresentation or over-identification of minority students found in special education in our schools. I chose to research this topic because being an immigrant myself, I can relate to the education experience of a student who is new to the American school system.…
- 3089 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Gifted students are often well beyond their years when it comes to their ability, however they are not always mature enough to handle the assignments that go along with that ability. This brings about a problem of accommodating these students with sufficient enrichment or acceleration without using subjects that are too mature for their mental age. Gifted students can learn the same standards, themes, units and concepts as the rest of the class. They will just be allowed regular opportunities to become engaged with learning activities that require more depth and complexity. One way to accommodate a gifted learner in a chronological age-based assignment organization is through the use of extension activities that will provide more challenge. Extension activities can be created and used in a variety of ways. Curriculum Differentiation Charts can be made to address the different learning styles of the students while addressing the key concepts of the unit or theme being studied. Extension Menus can be made that offer different activities through the different levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Thinking. Students can also be provided with the opportunity to create a learning center. This would involve giving the students some parameters and guidelines for how to create the center and what needs to be included. When grading these activities and assignments it would be helpful to create a rubric that would be shown to the students before they begin the assignment so that they understand the criteria for which they are being assessed.…
- 1300 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Since both gifted and with disabilities individuals need special needs, corresponding modifications, strategies and adjustments should be done accordingly to be able to suit to their needs thus learning process can occur. Both classroom set up should be designed in accordance to provide optimum conduciveness in learning. Both have its own sets of teaching strategies that would be best effective in each set of exceptionalities.…
- 671 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Streaming is the action of separating children into different groups based on their abilities. This means that children are taught differently depending on their ability. As Becker shows teachers do not see working-class children as ideal pupils which results in lower-class children finding themselves in lower sets. Middle-class children often benefit from streaming because they’re likely to be placed in the higher streams. The streaming enables the pupil to gain self-confidence and work harder to improve their grades. It could also give them a false ego and make the pupil think they don’t need to work to get the grades they have been predicted so streaming can have both positive and negative effects but both lead to social class differences. As Douglas found, a child placed in a higher stream at the age of 8 improved their IQ score by the time they were 11. This shows that factors such as labelling and streaming have an effect of ability within…
- 768 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Not all students reach the same level of achievement and not all of their minds develop…
- 523 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In 1983 a professor of education at Harvard University, Dr. Howard Gardner, developed the theory of multiple intelligences. This theory states that there are eight different ways in which a person is intelligent. These different forms of intelligence are as follows: linguistic, or word smart; logical-mathematic, or reasoning/numbers smart; spatial, or picture smart; bodily-kinesthetic, or body smart; musical, or music smart; intrapersonal, or self-smart; and naturalist, or nature smart (“Multiple Intelligences” para. 1-2). It is not difficult to pinpoint which of these intelligences standardized testing primarily measures. For students who are not linguistically or mathematically gifted, the tests do not accurately show the students’…
- 581 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
And really the worst part about all of that is that intelligence isn’t some blanket term, applicable to all areas of education. There are so many different types of intelligence that really even tests, as black and white and emotionless as they are, cannot determine how smart someone is.…
- 678 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The hottest thing in education theory is something called "multiple intelligence," which holds that every kid is smart in his or her own way if only you can find out what it is. Developed by a Harvard psychologist named Howard Gardner, the theory of multiple intelligences has taken its place alongside such concepts as critical-thinking skills and higher-order thinking as a cornerstone of enlightened education. It's not hard to see why. In an egalitarian age, it is anti-elitist. And by redefining intelligence, it seems to topple the cruel tyranny of IQ. "It appeals to the benign belief that all our children must be good at something," says Mr. Lambersky.…
- 813 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Isaac Asimov wrote an article titled, “ What is Intelligence, Anyway”. In this article Asimov begins the endless endeavor of defining intelligence. Asimov believes there are two types of intelligence. He begins to explain how some people have the talent of memorization and critical thinking. Others have minds that can imagine something and create or repair it to its magnificent structure. Asimov’s theory is proven to be true, for there are two different sides of the brain. Each side controls two different types of thinking. The first is the right side, which is used for creative thinking. The second is the left this is used for logical thinking. It has been proven that young children harness more power from the creative side. Since schools generally teach towards logical thinking as children grow older more than half of the population use logical thinking. This has a tremendous impact on human intelligence. This shows that people can be equally intelligent but their intelligence can lay in different areas along with the idea that intelligence is something that is not fixed but can be increased. Many would argue that talents and intelligence are not the same thing. However, talent is just a predisposition to be successful in a certain venture. This…
- 438 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays