Preview

First Nations Negotiations Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
859 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
First Nations Negotiations Analysis
During the times when the Europeans were colonizing throughout Canada, they were looking to co-exist with First Nations people. After treaties were made in Eastern Canada, treaties between the Crown and Aboriginal people were beginning to be negotiated from 1871 to 1921 throughout western Canada. The treaties were solemn agreements that would benefit both parties. Many First Nation leaders agreed to the treaties because times were changing and so in order to adapt, they negotiated what they thought were reasonable aspects while others opposed the treaties because they did not agree with the whole “surrendering” their rights to the land over to the Crown. Eventually agreeing to negotiate treaties, some of the Chiefs and headmen made sure their people would be taken care of and the future generations to come. Some of the main aspects that were common amongst the numbered treaties were free education, health care, housing, and proper rights to the land. Many First Nations saw this as a footstep into a peaceful co-existence with the British Crown. To this day, First Nations people are at a continuous struggle with the Canadian Government over the land that is supposedly protected. Looking at the different treaties in western Canada, I can only agree on some of the overall intensions because I feel like the First Nations people were taken advantage of during the times of the signings due to them being “robbed” of their proper …show more content…
The Crown wanted to use the land for agricultural purposes but needed to negotiate treaties with the First Nations people because they dominated most of the area. Today the numbered treaties span across Canada covering parts of the Yukon, The Northwest Territories, and British Columbia as well as Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and Northern

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “If you sign this treaty, you’re not going to ever have to work or hunt again; we’ll take care of you.' Everything will be provided. Every year you’ll get so much money to buy your needs, your pots and pans, but we’ll also have food coming in every month, or once a year for you. The other alternative is: 'We’re going to drive you all the way to the Rocky Mountains where you’re going to starve to death and we’ll never have to worry about you again.” Those were exactly the conditions Indians have to agree with by signing the…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the 1990 Meech Lake Accord resulting in failure, succeeding it was the Charlottetown Accord in 1992. While primarily focusing on the Issues of Quebec at the time it did also address “the issue of Aboriginal self-government but provided for a waiting period of three years before the concept would be recognized in law. It also dealt with aboriginal representation in Parliament (Gall).” Through a total of five rounds of constitutional politics, the First Nations peoples were managing to achieve some recognition of their right to govern by consent (Russell 169, “Constitutional Odyssey”). However, the process was far from easy, it has been thus far, far from easy. During the Charlotte Accords was no exception, “reaching an accord with [First…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The report outlines the extensive issues that existed prior to the modern land claim negotiations processes, and some of the more recent efforts that the federal government has made in order to regain the trust of Aboriginal communities. This report is authorized by the Canadian government, who holds a wealth of specific details regarding land claim negotiations. In this respect, this source is about as reliable as it gets. The report fully outlines the specific and comprehensive land claim negotiations processes. This source will be instrumental to my understanding of the dialogue that occurs between the government and Aboriginal groups in land claim negotiations. As well, when working on my policy paper, I can refer to some of the legal literature referenced in this report, such as for example, The Indian Act. This can help me to obtain a firm grasp on the ways in which First Nations people have been marginalized in the past, and possible ways that the government can achieve reconciliation with…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Land was purchased off the Métis people and treaties negotiated with the people of the First Nations, after which they were moved to reserves, and immigrants were enticed to Western Canada in a bid to create large nation stretching ‘from sea to sea,’ this vision however failed to include the interests of the Métis people and First Nations, also with the influx of immigrants the Francophones also felt their needs were ignored.…

    • 945 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    History Study Notes

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Although Royal Proclamation of 1763 gave some protection for First Nations, British govt. wanted to gain control of their land through treaties…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    According to Robert Bone, The term treaty generally included cash gratuities, and presents during the signing. Treaties between the two groups promised education, agricultural assistance, Rights to hunt and fish on crown land until such land was required for other purposes and land reserves to be held by the crown and entrusted to the Indian (Bone, 2011).Conflicts between the two signing parties of the treaties has arose during Canada in the 20th century as each group had different perceptions of the treaty agreements . This issue has caused a divide and has contributed tot the fault line between the two groups. The Crowns understanding of the treaties were that they would diminish aboriginal rights and their title to lands in hopes of having available land for agricultural advancements. As for the aboriginals, they understood it as an agreement to share the land and resources. With the two different perceptions of the treaties between the groups, conflict was bound to happen. An example of where conflict would occur was when government would sell crown land to corporations for extraction resources with out compensating the aboriginals. Many aboriginals lived on Crown land and the large corporations would destroy their natural way of life as they would interfere with hunting, trapping, fishing, and any many other resources needed to…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The government needs to help repair these reserves to create better living conditions as well as create programs to assist the survivors of residential schools with their emotional and psychological issues that were created from the human rights abuses they faced. The aboriginal people of Canada are owed more than an apology for what was done to them for generations. A number of broken families and lost lives cannot be fixed from the monetary compensation they received. The Canadian government has not done enough to ensure the rights of aboriginals are protected. With the signing of the Declaration of Rights of Indigenous, there is hope for the future improvement and protection of these rights. Allowing for the past and current issues to be corrected and never repeated. It is the responsibility of Canada to recognize the abuses and create changes to protect these rights. It is up to future generations to understand the human rights abuses of the past and ensure that the future will never hold similar conditions for any group of people. The Indian Residential Schools Truth and Reconciliation Commission set forth by Harpers government will provide this opportunity as it seeks to educate all Canadians of the Human…

    • 2396 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Canada Expropriation

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages

    All land in Canada started off belonging to the Crown. The government did not need all the land and could not possibly have managed all of it. Large tracts were surveyed and then sold to private parties to live on, building structures on and otherwise turn into productive uses. Sometimes,…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Oka Crisis

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Prior to the Oka Crisis, land disputes between Natives and other citizens of the country had been widely ignored by the government. Since the Oka Crisis was so large scale it attracted a lot of attention. The Natives could not be marginalized by the government because of the Canada wide reaction drawn by the shocking events. This meant that the Mohawk nation was given a full and most importantly fair trail, over the land dispute. The reaction to the proposal was extreme, but is an almost inevitable outcome after hundreds of years of inequality. The Canadian government was forced to listen to the Natives side, which improved relations because it is one of the first times that there was equal treatment of FNMI and whites. Though the crisis brought about an equal treatment, it is important to acknowledge that there is still much room for improvement between relations, treatment and reconciliation given. The Oka Crisis was necessary for FNMI rights to be recognized, and for the improvement and development of their government…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These lands have been tampered with by the government, reducing them throughout history separating these lands into six different sections. The government has not enforced these treaties such as the Executive Order of March 16 ,1875, giving the native Indians the right to keep their lands but only to reduce them. Acts by our government have caused deprivations and great losses to our native Indians. The past shouldn’t repeat itself these natives have suffered time and time again but the government continues to industrialize these reserved lands instead of respecting them.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Firstly, the Canadian government's intention of the treaty was quite well-known. Obviously, they wanted to take the land which belongs to the natives'. In order to achieve their ambitious goal, they took advantage of the decay of the bison. Clearly, the Canadian government knew what the natives thought: they were losing their main source of food and they were willing to negotiate with the Canadian government. The Canadian government could just give the natives a small amount of land and suggested them to be farmers. They verbally promised that they would give them the equipment, supplies, and instructions they need for farming.…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time, the relationship of indigenous and French people was informal. There was no evidence regarding how the French were going to use the native land or the resources that they found there. In 1756 the New France and British were at war. The British won. As part of their peace treaty new France was transferred to British. They named it Quebec. When British took over they made a more formal relationship with the indigenous people with regards to the use of their land. In 1763 they signed the first treaty with the indigenous and it was known as royal proclamation of 1763. There are numerous of treaties created by the British government; however these treaties can be misinterpreted. The British and Canadian government had a misinterpretation of the treaty. The British thought that the native lands would be transferred over to them while the indigenous government did not believe in the concept of land ownership, for the treaties were an agreement to share their land to the British government. Another political impact was the 1969 white paper. The white paper is a law or act of parliament takes years to develop. Plenty of people in government must work for many years to get all their ideas together. During this time of information gathering a document of ideas emerges. The idea of white paper came from the Liberal Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau. He believes in a just society and democracy, where all of Canada’s citizens could participate equally. The aim or goal of the white paper was “to enable the aboriginal people to be free to develop Indian culture in an environment of legal, social and economic equality with other Canadians.” Although the indigenous saw this to assimilate them and that if this happens they will lose their right for the land. Harold Cardinal was a native leader that wrote the book unjust society to contradict Pierre Trudeau’s white paper. Another political impact is the Indian act. When…

    • 2296 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The native people constantly experience neglect from the government, it was recorded that the mortality rate of the natives were higher compare to other Canadians. Nobody care that their babies were dying, water the primary source of livelihood were often poisoned with chemicals and yet no provision was made…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indian Removal Act

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Native Americans were treated horribly, when they trusted the Americans. The U.S., stole their horses and many died from diseases. This information was gotten from the article called “Allow the Cherokee to Stay,” it stated “Their horses were stolen and hundreds died from disease and malnutrition on the journey.” This quote means that they agreed to move nicely and calmly, but the U.S., still did not treat them fair. That’s not all, when one tribe called the Lakota Nation agreed to move westward because there would be food, water, and land. The U.S., tricked them and they went to imprisonment camps. This was in the article called “ The Betrayal of Native Americans”, it said, “Instead, many Lakota live on reservations (or prisoner of war camps, as they might be called) like Pine Ridge, which is annually one of the most impoverished places in the United States.” This states that Native Americans agree to move where it would be better, but the U.S. still treated them horribly. It was not only the U.S., it was also Canda. The Canadians agreed to help the native groups with money because the U.S. and Canada were the richest nations back then. Instead, the Canadians poisoned their water, soil, and air. Some of the native groups were from the first nations. They were the Inuit, Métis tribe, and others . This was in the article called, “The Betrayal of Native Americans”. The quote stated, “Instead of honoring its…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Aboriginal Inequality

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Aboriginals, which include first nations people, were the first people of Canada however, the treatment they receive today shows otherwise. Aboriginal treaties, Westphalia Treaty of 1648, that were established in Canada in the mid-seventeenth century were used to “harmonize discovery and conquest principles” (Frideres, 2000). The land that Aboriginals occupied was more than just land to them, they felt a connection with Mother Nature and they established roles in their families that helped them create a working community. Without even trying to understand how Aboriginals felt about their treaties and their land the British Common Law abolished Aboriginal…

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics