Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

English as Official Language Debate

Satisfactory Essays
461 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
English as Official Language Debate
English should not be the official language of the US
The United States is a nation founded by immigrants. Throughout the years the US has struggled with discrimination and close-mindedness. But, when we put our differences aside we can achieve the impossible. We are a country united by our differences. We celebrate our diversity, independence and individuality. We are a country that believes in choice, and one of those choices should be the option to speak the language which we relate to and understand. It was our forefather’s ambition that got us to the Land of The Free and our determination that made us successful.
So how can we say we stand for freedom if we don’t give our people, immigrants (illegal or not), the right to speak their language? We are a country for the people, but not all of our people speak English. Many Americans argue that those who live in America should speak English but think about this: English is the sum of many other languages. The British brought English to America and forced the Native Americans to convert to their language and their ways.
In modern society, we cringe at the idea of oppression and encourage those who are oppressed to speak out for themselves, yet turn a blind eye when we are the oppressors. A parallel can be drawn with bullying. It is an issue that many children, teens, and adults experience. Bullying has been an active topic in the media in recent years. Teachers, parents and authoritative figures continue to urge those who are bullied or have witnessed an act of bullying to stand up for themselves and get help. Thus, America is not only being hypocritical and ignorant, but it is also being a bully by forcing other’s to speak “our” language. We are oppressing their beliefs. We are telling them that they must speak our language if they want to be American; they must speak our language if they want to be successful. Understandingly, those who come to America should be educated in our history and be required to pass a citizenship test. But speaking English does not make one an American. A citizen is not inferior because he/she cannot speak English. Americans today are born with this innate sense of superiority. Yet, over the years we have overcome most of our selfish and antiquated ways and this is just another obstacle which we must surmount. We cannot force a diverse group of people to speak one language when our nation consists of so many. We cannot force a language upon our people without oppressing those people. Making English the official language would make us hypocrites and bullies. Therefore, English should not be the official language of the United States.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    For two centuries, the U.S has the greatest success because of “the acquisition of English” (Krauthammer 112). Before the great immigration (many different type of races immigrated to the U.S), English had been a dominating language, but since the great immigration, it was no longer the dominating language. The Senate could not declare English as an official language. They only passed an amendment declaring English as the national language. (Krauthammer 112). Even the Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid called that action “racist” (Krauthammer 112). His second argument is it is fine generally if only a small group of people speak their own language but when this group expands, the problem appears. The U.S has been accepting immigrants who speak their mother languages since the great immigration. For example, Brooklyn has different kinds of people speaking varieties of languages; it is still fine when they are only small groups. People can speak their own language in the street and “proudly teach it to [their] kids” (Krauthammer 112). However, all of that will change when the groups expand, more people speak their own languages and they may want the official recognition similarly to French people in Canada. Therefore, the U.S. probably has the same problems as…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States of America originally a nation of immigrants is rapidly becoming a nation of native born citizens. We have by now had an opportunity to produce the native-born individual someone we might label as an “American”. Today, the number of foreign-born persons in the United States is about 3,000,000 of the population, and about 5,000,000 of Americans are the children of immigrants. Due to the new Immigration Reform and Control Act the days of mass immigration are over, but the influence of the movement will never be eased. (Arun and Daniel p.1)…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With a high likelihood of growing immigrant numbers in the U.S. it stands paramount to have a healthy debate on what is best for the society – to mitigate the formation of deeper fissures on the sensitive topic. “Language, as one linguist has said, is ‘not primarily a means of communication but a means of communion,’” (King, 1997/2013, p. 492). Michael Schwalbe (2008) further expresses the importance of language when he states: “Knowledge itself is the past living in our minds and habits. Our language – each word, each grammatical rule – connects us, not only to each other, but also to a common human past,” (pg. 46).…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Anzaldua Metaphors

    • 100 Words
    • 1 Page

    In this essay, Anzaldua reveals her thoughts about the issues of racism, identity, and low self-esteem faced by Mexican immigrants living in the United States. Anzaldua states that a person’s identity is linked to the way they speak. Anzaldua begins her essay with a metaphor demonstrating how immigrants are suppressed in society. She uses ethos to establish her credibility throughout this essay such as in paragraph 35 (“Until I can take pride in my language…”). Today there are still issues where immigrants are judged by the way they speak and made to feel ashamed of their own language and culture.…

    • 100 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every day, Americans of all races encounter the problem of walking into a store and hearing people of other ethnicities speaking other languages. It is frustrating to have to interrelate with other individuals and not be able to connect fully with them because of a linguistic barrier. In the articles, The F Word by Dumas, Mother Tongue by Tan and Aria by Rodriguez, the difficulties of being an immigrant are stated. Many immigrants have problems adapting to a new society and sometimes society does not understand. Every day, they endure many problems such as not being understood, having to learn a new language, and discrimination.…

    • 893 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Living with Mexican or American people would be perfect if both of them knew one another’s language. School, jobs, and traveling are a big part in why people should know how to speak and understand more than one language. These three topics go well together because your start off with school to get a good job and then having money to travel to places you always dreamed of going to. The interesting thing about this paper is the fact that knowing more than one language has more advantages than disadvantages. Although some people would not be interested to learn, they should recognize the fact that when they do learn to speak a different language more opportunities come their way and they will feel proud for what they accomplish. To this end, hopefully if people read this essay it will convince them on why it is important to speak and understand different people from all races speaking another language when they are around them. They might be talking trash about them and they would not have a clue in how to respond back. Although, it is like learning anything new because it will take time and reflection until people master…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    American values are frequently forced upon students or workers. There are few times, where people look down on people who do not accept the American Way of Life. In “How to Tame a Wild Tongue,” Anzaldúa wrote, “So if you really want to hurt me, talk badly about my language. Ethnic identity is twin skin to linguistic identity – I am my language” (Anzaldúa 445). Linguistic identity can be difficult for a bilingual person, being somewhere in-between two different culture is confusing and sometimes uncomfortable. A person can’t simply identify with one or the other because each culture has impacted an individual’s life. Being a bilingual also creates boundaries and limitations because the feeling of being disconnected from the language and culture a person is…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Currently, and surprisingly, there is no official language designated for the United States of America. Should English be that official language for our nation? The United States is usually thought of an English speaking country and the Official Language needs to be representative of the same for many reasons. The voting public is extremely divided; with some stating that the United States should remain language-less, others claim it should be Spanish, while another viewpoint is to choose multilingualism, and even some claim an unrecognized language of “American” should become the new official language. There are many views on this topic, heated debates, and political upheavals by both citizens and illegal immigrants of various backgrounds, not only the English and non-English speaking. This topic is extremely controversial among many groups; both political and non-political. The underlying ramifications of a decision; or lack thereof, many may not realize but will be presented thoroughly in addition to the mere implications of a decision finally being made on the topic on a nationwide basis and statewide level, will be weighed against each other. The results of the research efforts shall present several aspects concerning English as the official language of the United States including, but not limited to; language choices aside from English that are being presented as the official language, the financial ramifications between having and not having an official language, a brief history on the nature of English as the official language of the nation, a brief overview of the legal actions related to the same; and any incidental information that is deemed relevant pursuant to the nature of the research intentions.…

    • 2747 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Back then, it wasn’t uncommon to hear up to 20 different languages spoken in daily life. Today, those numbers are more staggering. According to U.S. English Inc., an advocacy group that supports declaring English as our official language, 322 languages are spoken in the country, with 24 of those spoken in every state and the District of Columbia. California has the most languages, with 207, while Wyoming has the fewest with 56. So why won’t Congress declare an official language? Because we are a nation of immigrants and these numbers prove it. Because declaring an official language would abridge the rights of individuals with limited English proficiency, individuals who are paying taxes and who are entitled to the same rights as those who speak…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What makes America great is the goals it has placed for our people; for example, my mother came to this country in search of the, “American Dream.” She did not have any money, and she did not speak or understand English at all, but she had a goal to accomplish. America allows citizens to pursue their goals and dreams through hard work and determination. No other country has such standards for their people. America’s strength is found in the diversity of its people. America symbolizes acceptance; therefore, we must protect our diversity in order to continue moving forward together, as a nation. This diversity makes our country a more interesting place to live, as people from different countries contribute to an array of languages, new ways of thinking, knowledge perspectives, and different…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “America is a country of immigrants, but also a country that sometimes hates immigrants”. One would find it rather odd how everyone can trace their family heritage to somewhere over seas, yet most Americans today frown upon immigrants from other countries. Studies have shown that students at large schools and even at some small high schools segregate themselves from other minorities without even noticing. It could be because their comfort zones are only within their own personal races. Also, their cultures and traditions are more alike to people within their own race and it is easier to adapt and be accepted. Even though, discrimination has been looming in America’s school system for years it is slowly beginning to…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    English as a common ground is so that Americans can understand what is being spoken to each other. Americans should be able to communicate and read any material out in this country without wondering what is being said. Foreigners or non-English speaking citizens are increasingly becoming more segregated, creating poverty- stricken areas. The creation of these areas is due to the language barrier (US-English, 2012). Americans who speak English can find it insulting when other begins to speak to them in another language. Majority of the states have English as their official language. So when a foreigner begins to speak another language or attempt to communicate in English, it could be found offensive because if the same person were to go to their country, it would offensive if you did not speak their language. When living or visiting the United States, it would be safe to assume that everyone spoke English if it were the official language. No one would be insulted, nor would an individual find it hard to communicate with another. Making English the official language of the United States means that the government will be conducting everything solely in English. This includes all public documents, records, legislation and regulations, as well as hearings, official ceremonies and public meetings (US-English, 2012). “This means that everything will be conducted in the English language and that no one will have the right to demand government services in any other language” (ProEnglish, 1994). The government cost of multilingualism is in the hundreds of million dollars. Companies have to spend about 15 to 20 percent of production cost to use in translation services (CalRecycle, 1995). For example, Hospitals have to pay for translators to those who do not speak English. Translators in California are paid $45 to $50 an hour! While…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    America is our country and English is our language, I believe that if foreigners want to move to our land then they should be the ones to learn our language. For example, our country is becoming extremely populated with Hispanics and now because of that kids have to take Spanish classes in school. Kids in school should be learning about history and math and things of that nature, not try to learn another language. Although, it's not bad learning another language so you'll be able to communicate with different types of people. I think that a law should be passed that anyone moving into the United Sates be permitted to be able to speak English. I also think that our driver's licenses should be printed in English along with our ballots. It's not that I am a racist, it's just that I am a firm believer that if you plan on moving somewhere with a new language and culture, I think that you should give them the respect and learn their language. Also, I don't think that it's fair for minorities such as Hispanics to get a minority scholarship to some colleges. For some reason, I don't find that fair at all, it's hard enough for Americans to get scholarship, and minorities get one because they are a minority.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Living in Texas most of my life I was no stranger to Americans who either didn’t speak English at all or whose first language wasn’t English. As I interacted with people, mostly from Mexico, I had a hard time understanding why they didn’t want to speak English . Although I’m ashamed to say it, I often viewed these people as less educated and meek. A statement that Ive heard all to often is that people who don’t speak English should learn our language or leave America. However, I’ve never considered myself racist or close minded, despite the fact that I often felt frustrated and uncomfortable while trying to interact with people whose first language wasn’t English. Being on the other side of this situation forever changed…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    English speakers in the world including those who are in the inner circle, outer circle and expanding circle had reached to 380 millions of people since 2001. The finding shows how influential English Language is. Gradually, English become the international lingua franca, “utilized outside of the country or countries of its origin.”( Subject Area - English Language Essays) The Lingua Franca There are both pros and cons of English becoming the international lingua franca.…

    • 775 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays