Preview

Disparities In Pygmalion And The Makeover

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1012 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Disparities In Pygmalion And The Makeover
In the stories Pygmalion and The Makeover, a lower class individual who aspires to have a higher position in his or her career prompts two upper-class citizens for their assistance. Even though the Pygmalion and The Makeover display numerous similarities, the two have apparent disparities. In Pygmalion, the story began with a rainy day, and Eliza was trying to sell flowers on the street when Freddy bumped into her from behind. Eliza then began to shout at Freddy in her unorthodox dialect, and he went on his way. Soon thereafter, Eliza witnessed Colonel Pickering and Henry Higgins, both of whom were very knowledgeable men, conversing in the garden. Knowing they were strong speakers and knowledgeable in dialect, she showed up at Higgins` laboratory …show more content…
At first, Higgins was hesitant that he would be able to help Eliza, and he scoffed at her multiple times. Nevertheless, Pickering remained very polite to Eliza throughout the discussion, and he later took on a bet with Higgins. The bet at hand was if Higgins could turn Eliza into a Duchess, then Pickering would buy Eliza all the materials and clothing she needed for her makeover. Soon thereafter, Eliza`s father appeared on the doorstep of Higgins` home requesting money, but not too much because he didn’t want the responsibility that would come with it. Higgins gave him the money and he didn`t surface again until the ending, but when he did come back into context, he had obtained a large sum of money. At the party, the two men presented Eliza as a duchess and Henry won the bet. Afterwards, Pickering and Higgins were talking about Eliza as if she weren`t there, and she quickly …show more content…
Meanwhile, on her way to the congressional speech for Hannah Higgins, Colleen Pickering accidently bumped into him. Afterwards, when Pickering and Higgins were eating their dinner, they met Elliot Doolittle, and he introduced himself as a beer vendor. Though Pickering shook his hand was very polite to him, Higgins ridiculed his grammar and education. Nonetheless, the next day Elliot (like Eliza) surfaced at Higgins` Office, and he asked for lessons about how to speak properly so he could acquire a job as a sales representative for the beverage company where he worked. But like Henry Higgins, Hannah was weary of teaching Elliot; however, she quickly realized that she could use Elliot for the new election because he had plain folk appeal- something that she lacked. Therefore, Higgins bet Pickering that if she could turn Elliot into a congressman and win the race, then she would be able to keep her parking spot and office. Similarly, Elliot`s mother appeared at Higgins` office one day, also asking for some cash, but just enough to have a good time. However, Allie Doolittle kept resurfacing throughout the course of the film, and unlike Alfred Doolittle from Pygmalion, she remained poor. Additionally, following Elliot and Hannah`s fight soon after the election, which he went down in defeat, Elliot told Hannah to thank Pickering for always treating him like a gentleman, even before

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Later in the letters we learn that Eliza was at Colonel Farrington’s when she met a man named Mr. Boyer, who is a minister, and how they spent a nice evening together. Mr. Boyer then writes to Mr. selby, Describing how he was met…

    • 322 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Act2Pygmalionquestions

    • 724 Words
    • 1 Page

    Higgins recognizes Eliza with disappointment and his reacts as if he will refuse to spend…

    • 724 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Satisfied” Eliza says “I’m a girl in a world in which/ My only job is to marry rich/ My father has no sons so I’m the one/ Who has to social climb for one..” This proves that she gave up Hamilton for Eliza but it wasn't accurate.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though he and his wife, Emily, are kind to their slaves, they still had to sell two of them in order to earn money. However, earlier, Millie promised Eliza that she wouldn’t sell her, but then, Eliza overhears Mr. and Mrs. Shelby discussing about selling Eliza and her Uncle Tom. She then decided to runaway with her child. After Uncle Tom was sold, he was placed on a riverboat where he eventually saved and met a girl named Eva. She then told her father, Augustine St. Clare, about Tom and he purchased him from a slave trader. St. Clare promised to free Tom, but before he did, he got murdered; someone stabbed him to death when he was entering a tavern in New Orleans. Uncle Tom and another slave, Emmeline, was later sold to a very vicious slave owner, Legree, at an auction and brought them to Louisiana. Legree hated Tom because he believed in God and confronted slaves kindly. Tom also met another slave named Cassy, who killed her son because he was going to be sold. Afterwards, Eliza and her two sons, Harry and George, gained their freedom when they escaped to Canada. Uncle Tom then tries to convince Cassy, to escape, who eventually took Emmeline with her. When Tom refused to tell Legree where both girls went, he orders someone to execute Tom. Shortly before his death, George arrives to buy Tom’s freedom, but discovers that he’s too late. Cassy and Emmeline later meets George sister and Cassy also discovers that Eliza was her long lost…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the begging Eliza tells Lucy that even if she behaves coquettishly, “they proceed from and innocent heart” (Foster 844). We can see that Eliza knows about her coquettish tendencies and even Sanford immediately identifies her as a coquette (Foster 851). Her justification of such behaviors shows that she doesn’t see the harm in it even though she is warned many times by Lucy and Mrs. Richman. Mrs. Richman tells her that Sanford is a libertine who destroys families (Foster 852). “Beware of the delusions of fancy!” says Mrs. Richman (Foster 852). “Their evil propensities of their minds will invariably dominate.” Says Lucy (Foster 858). The warnings somewhat affects Eliza’s behavior but she keeps being a coquette even though Mrs. Richman warned her about exercising too much freedom will lead to bad things. “Though strowed with flowers… it is, after all, a slippery, thorny path.” Says Mrs. Richman (Foster 848). After losing Boyer for good, Eliza doesn’t follow Lucy’s advice of forgetting all former connections but instead starts seeing Sanford again (Foster 904). Second, it is Major Sanford’s fault for seducing Eliza even though he has no intention in marrying her (Foster 854). He wants to keep her around for his own satisfaction and he doesn’t want to see her with another man (Foster 861). He reminds Eliza how marrying Boyer will subject her to restrained and confined life (Foster 861). This made Eliza entertains the thought of finding…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Haley searches for Eliza hopelessly, as she is drove on by fear of losing her child and reaches the river swiftly. Remarkably, Eliza crosses the river by jumping from one ice flow to the next. After reaching the shore in Ohio, Mr. Symmes, a man who has witnessed her brave act, listens to her story. Luckily, Symmes hates slave traders and accordingly takes Eliza and Harry to the house of Senator Bird, where they receive food and lodging. Ironically, Bird has just voted for a bill barring aid to runaway slaves, but the Senator is rather inspired by Eliza's story. He therefore changes his opinions and takes the fugitives to a Quaker settlement, where they stay with the Halliday family. As luck would have it, Eliza's husband has sought refuge in this same community, and the young family is reunited. The Quakers assist the family in boarding a ship for Canada before Haley's hired slave hunters, Loker and Marks, can apprehend them.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eliza, Mrs. Shelby's personal maid servant is married to George Harris, a slave from the next plantation over. Together they have a son named Harry. On the Shelby plantation Eliza has always been…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    EVID: In “Pygmalion,” upper class people were supposed to only talk about the weather and their health at parties.…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the end of the letter, Walter writes what will turn out to be the most famous quote of the book: "There was your photo, in a magazine. Of course, you are older now. Still, I'd know you anywhere." By now Walter was on death row, scheduled to be executed on November 25. Eliza, of course, was not his only victim. She was just the only one to survive, not be murdered like the others. Eventually Walter requests that Eliza have more contact with him, starting off with phone calls. Soon he promises to tell her about the other murders, the ones no one was able to prove. The catch? Eliza has to visit…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Uncle Tom's Cabin Thesis

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages

    However Eliza escapes with Harry after hearing that her son will be sold. They certainly obtain obstacles but overcome them. Uncle Tom being a middle aged man with a wife and children, is taken away by Mr. Haley to a slave market where he was sold to a man very grateful of him.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Victorian England, especially London had a severe problem with poverty. Many people in London lived in poverty. Eliza is one of these many people that lived in poverty during the Victorian era in London. In the play Pygmalion and musical My Fair Lady, the main character, Eliza, is shown to be poor and living in poverty. Both the play and musical show how she lived in poverty and how her poorness hindered her from attaining a job. Since she cannot speak well she can’t get a job as a lady in a flower shop. Because she could not get a job she had to resort to selling flowers on the street. Seeking help to learn how to speak properly, she goes to Henry Higgins, a phonetics professor. He teaches Eliza how to speak properly and how to act like a lady over the course of six months. After learning how to speak and act properly, this raises Eliza’s status because she no longer appears to be poor. Poverty during…

    • 1752 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pygmalion Act 4

    • 382 Words
    • 1 Page

    and mad. Higgins and Pickering shouldn't be thinking that they are better than Eliza. They…

    • 382 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    and Mrs. Shelby. Mr. Shelby had made a decision to sell Tom and Harry as a result of outstanding debt. When he discovered that Eliza fled with her son, he exclaimed, “…he’ll [Haley] think I connived at it, to get him out of the way. It touches my honour!”…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Fair Lady

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Higgins then makes a bet with Colonel Pickering that he will pass Eliza off as a lady at a party after 6 months of lessons. Higgins tries to correct Eliza phonetically as she pronounces some vowels, diphthong and consonants of the English Language incorrectly. Eliza goes through many forms of speech training in order to get her pronunciation right.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Eliza first goes to Higgins, it is the first sign of her ambition and aspirations to be a better person. She knows she is a common person, in a much lower class than Higgins and Pickering, but…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays