Preview

Depicting Characterization And Heredity In David Auburn's Proof

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
485 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Depicting Characterization And Heredity In David Auburn's Proof
Depicting Characterization and Heredity in Proof David Auburn’s Proof, tells of the struggle of a young Catherine who is the daughter of a mathematician, Robert, and although she inherited some of his genius she also believes she inherited his mental disorders. The play throws in a couple twists: tricking the reader into thinking Robert is alive when he is actually dead and finding out that Catherine wrote the proof. There are three themes that overrides the play: that is insanity, heredity, and family. Although Catherine and Claire are sisters, they are far from the same spectrum; however, Catherine and Robert are precisely what a father-daughter combination looks like. Catherine is more like her father than her sister. During the time of Robert’s sickness, Catherine was the only one to take care of him. This act of kindness shows how loving and caring Catherine is towards her father. In the play, Robert is portrayed as a figment of Catherine’s imagination. Auburn writes, “Robert: Well Because I’m also dead. Aren’t I? / Catherine: You died a week ago” (1887). This quote not only shows the death of Robert, but also shows, in a way, the mental instability of Catherine. Although Catherine and Claire share similar genes, they are different in more ways than one. Claire is a stand alone in …show more content…
We understand that the theorem is called the proof but it is also ironic that Catherine can provide no proof whatsoever as to her writing it. Catherine also demands proof of Hal’s love for her when he does not believe she wrote the theorem. Auburn writes, “Hal: Your dad might have written it and explained it to you later…I’m just saying there’s no proof that you wrote this” (1218) and again, “I should have known she [Claire] wouldn’t believe me but why don’t you?” (1219). The inability to provide proof for the authorship of the theorem, delivers classes between the two main

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Statistics, “show that most people receive up to 80 percent of their intelligence from their parents”. However, is this really true? Catherine the protagonist, was born from a father who was a remarkable genius. When her father got sick, she dropped out of school to take care of him; nevertheless, he died. In the play, “Proof” written by David Auburn, Catherine inherits plenty of her father’s extraordinary talent, as well as his super genius capabilities. Catherine is a genius and she is not insane. She is an expert at memorizing books as well as proofs, she understands all of her father’s complicated mathematical proofs without having prior background knowledge, and she was able to write a very extraordinary and complicated…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    "The Widow Douglas she took me for her son, and allowed she would sivilize me; but it was rough living in the house all…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Catherine is Introduces to Eleanor Tilney, Henry’s sister and the two become quick friends. Henry captivates Catherine with his knowledge and understanding of history and the world as well as his love for books. Henry and Eleanor’s father General Tilney, invite Catherine to stay with them at their home in Northanger Abbey. As she accepts and leaves Bath for Northanger, Catherine has many preconceptions about the Abbey. After reading The Mysteries of Udolpho, a gothic novel, she thinks the abbey to be dark, scary and full with mystery and secrets. Upon arriving at the abbey, Catherine is disappointed that the abbey is more renovated and modern than she had anticipated. After hearing murmurs about the mysterious circumstances surrounding the death of Mrs. Tilney, Catherine is determined to find out what really happened to her. Catherine eventually came to the conclusion that General Tilney killed Mrs. Tilney and tells Henry. He is enraged, tells her that it was ridiculous and Catherine leaves crying. Abruptly, Catherine received the news that she must leave the abbey immediately under the General’s…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ii. Anna contemplates what life would be like when Kate dies. The quote illustrates that death is merely physical. It can take away Kate in this world, but it can never take away the bond that the two shared. Anna is able to realize that even when Kate is dead she is still a sister due to the past experiences she was able to have with Kate.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Play Vs Movie Proof Essay

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages

    From the beginning of the play when we see Catherine in a bike riding around the neighborhood, to scenes like her in the bedroom with Hal. The movie creates suspense when Hal is figuring out if Catherine truly wrote the proof, it drags on the scenes and flashing back to the pass a couple times to confuse the readers. Throughout the scenes the viewers could possibly be thinking was Catherine really lying? Could she be really capable of writing this proof? The movie flashes back to when her father, Robert is eagerly telling her about a proof he has been working on, but the viewers don’t end up seeing it. The movie tries so hard to characterize Catherine as a crazy and emotional woman who might be capable of stealing a brilliant work from her own father, but then in the end it reveals that Catherine was truly the person who wrote the proof. It makes the viewers guilty for even thinking that she couldn’t be as intelligent as her father.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    poetry

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This Victorian poem is about the narrator (a fallen woman), the Lord and Kate. It is a ballad which tells the story from the narrator’s perspective about being shunned by society after her ‘experiences’ with the lord. The poem’s female speaker recalls her contentment in her humble surroundings until the local ‘Lord of the Manor’ took her to be his lover. He discarded her when she became pregnant and his affections turned to another village girl, Kate, whom he then married. Although the speaker’s community condemned the speaker as a ‘fallen’ woman, she reflects that her love for the lord was more faithful than Kate’s. She is proud of the son she bore him and is sure that the man is unhappy that he and Kate remain childless. Some readers think that she feels more betrayed by her cousin than the lord. This poem is a dramatic monologue written in the Victorian era.…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    cathedral questions

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages

    5. Robert lost his wife a few years back. The narrator’s wife and Robert were also very close. The narrator never met Robert and when he came over their house for the first time, he didn’t accept Robert. He had no sympathy for Robert because he was blind. Whenever the wife went to bed, he took over hosting to Robert and tried to give Robert descriptions of the Cathedrals.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henry first talks of having no affection towards her, only bothering because it’s easier than going to a brothel (Hemingway 30). He eventually falls in love with her however, and they wind up spending his entire hospital stay together. In The Role of Catherine Barkley, the author reports that Jackson Benson describes Catherine as heroic in the way that she “is the one who taught Henry to love.” This might be the case as Henry never discusses past lovers or even much of his family. Catherine and Henry become so much in love her having a child accidently doesn’t even phase him, as long as it doesn’t get in the way of their love of course (Hemingway 138). While in Switzerland, they would rarely go out of their house, and almost never left each other (Hemingway 290). The book ends with the loss of Catherine and their stillborn baby (Hemingway 331). Henry is terrified of this happening and prays that it doesn’t. When it does he leave the hospital and the book is over. This is the final scene of the book and perhaps the most important, as it is the most life…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She also is successful in proving that her prime number proof is her work, rather than her dads. At first, Dobbs and Catherine’s sister didn’t believe that the work was hers because the handwriting was very similar. I believe this is a fair assumption, but at the same time Catherine has a valid point being upset, since her two closest acquaintances don’t believe…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within the essay "The Not So Deadly Sin" written by Barbara Kingsolver, the use of literary proofs help support her ideas. The first literary proof she uses is personal anecdotes. When she says, "My sister and parents are alive and well, thanks. I don't have an adopted child." (Kingsolver, 274). Barbara is referring back to her own life in order to fully get her point across in her essay. She is telling the readers the real facts about her family so that they understand that her stories are just stories. By using a personal anecdote she proves to the readers that not all pieces of writing are written from experience but rather creativity. In addition, Kingsolver appeals to personal beliefs and values within her writing. She writes, "And secondarily, because I believe the purpose of art is not to photocopy life but to distill it…" (Kingsolver, 274). Through sharing this personal belief, Barbara is able to communicate the reasons behind her essay. Again, she is able to clearly communicate the purpose of her essay to prove that not all authors stories are written based on experience. Indeed, the proofs that Barbara Kingsolver uses for her essay are very effective in supporting her…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Owen Meany

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The mother he thinks he knows is actually a completely different person and the man he dreams his father is ends up being false hope as his real father’s identity disappoints him. As a little boy, John is alright with not knowing his father’s identity because his mother will tell him when he is older. However, when his mother dies, he feels cheated out of information he has a right to know. John thinks he knows his mother, but she is not who he thinks she is. She sings under the name “The lady in red” and dresses quite differently from the way she does in Gravesend. Owen accompanies John to Boston to help him discover the truth about Tabitha, John’s mother. The two visit the store where Tabitha purchased her red dress. Jerrold, the owner says, “Sure I know her! It was the dress she always sung in!” (7.347). Jerrold’s reaction to Tabitha’s picture shows John that his mother is not someone he knows and that she lived a completely different life. While Owen is alive to help discover the truth about Tabitha, he helps John discover who his father is after he dies. John is talking to Reverend Merrill when Owen’s voice tells him to “LOOK IN THE THIRD DRAWER, RIGHT-HAND SIDE” (9.542). Reverend Merrill yanks the drawer open, which causes the baseball that killed Tabitha to roll across the floor. The Reverend then turns to John and says, “Forgive me, my s-s-s-son!” (9.542). John feels disappointment when Reverend Merrill admits…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Tennessee William’s play, The Glass Menagerie there are many ways that show how Laura is stronger than her mother. First, Laura endures more obstacles than Amanda. In scene two, Amanda is talking to Laura about her disability pleurosis. Amanda says, “Why you’re not crippled, you just have a little defect,” (Williams 17). In this quote Amanda is indirectly giving one of the reasons as to why Laura is stronger. This reason is, she endures more obstacles such as a disability or a defect. This specific quote is important to not only the story but also this essay because it completely supports the first reason of why Laura is the stronger one between Amanda and Laura.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blanches downfall

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages

    way of Blanche coping with her guilt over the death of her late husband as she is symbolically…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Louise’s entire character is powerfully ironic in that she is the furthest thing from a mother. Mothers are expected to be of caring and affectionate nature. However, Louise neglects Isabelle-Marie and treats her like an outsider since she is physically unattractive. Louise only favors her son Patrice because he reflects her outer beauty and she feels the necessity to sustain it by only nurturing him. Since Isabelle-Marie is physically unappealing, Louise does not love or treat her in the same fashion as Patrice. Isabelle Marie finally gains the courage to express how Louise has mistreated her. She exclaims, “[m]other, ever since I was a child you adored Patrice because he was beautiful and hated me, the ugly one. Patrice always Patrice! You never realized that your son was stupid, that he was an idiot…nothing but a beautiful body” (104). Isabelle-Marie’s tone is filled with contempt and jealousy while she spills out all the emotions that she had been bottling up for years. Louise always favoring Patrice due to his beautiful face even if he was just an “idiot” exasperates Isabelle-Marie. Moreover, Isabelle-Marie’s ill thoughts towards her own daughter and disfiguring her brother’s face can be seen as the result of her mother’s intolerance and lack of love towards her. Louise’s superficiality and favoritism towards Patrice transforms Isabelle-Marie to turn into a self-loathing and destructive character. Hence, Louise can be held responsible for creating this dysfunctional family. Rather than loving her children unconditionally as a mother should, she loves them based upon their looks. Therefore, ironically, even though Louise is their real mother, she fits the archetypal character of an evil stepmother due to her discriminate, mean and evil behavior.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1) One of the main, most interesting characters in the play is Sophie. She was brought to Mama Nadi by Christopher as a bar girl. Sophie is Christopher’s Niece. Christopher wants to protect her and knows that Mama Nadi will take care of her. At this point in the play Sophie is extremely shy. It is understandable because she is being brought to some she has never met. Mama and Sophie end up becoming really close and Mama takes great care of Sophie. Later in the story mam even sells her really expensive diamond for Sophie to live.…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays