My partners and I firmly negate the resolution that corporal punishment should be reintroduced in schools.
We cite, one, ineffectiveness of corporal punishment, two, physical and mental damage done to students, and three, fostering violence in society as major reasons why corporal punishment in schools are rightly banned in Korea and many other countries. Contention 1, Corporal punishment is ineffective for behavioral education for students. According to Alan Kazdin, professor of psychology and child psychiatry at Yale University, punishment doesn't do much to improve children behavior. (Evidence) He states, "Research shows that even if punishment temporarily stops unwanted behavior, it will return at the same rate, or worse, in the hours or days to come. Your child’s resistance to punishment escalates as fast as the severity of the punishment does, or even faster, so you have to get harsher and harsher to achieve the same result". (Warrant) Professor Kazdin's statement proves that although corporal punishment might seem a way to teach students discipline, like my opponents argue, it is only a temporarily act and bad behavior will come back even stronger. This explains why corporal punishment is ineffective and why corporal punishment in Korea was so severe: in order to regulate stronger growing bad behavior. Contention 2,Teachers punishing students show bad examples to students and foster violence in society.According to bangkokpost.com,three student try to burn school because of teacher's punishment. And that three student maybe get punishment again. Alan Kazdin, professor of psychology and child psychiatry at Yale University, he says "Hitting teaches hitting as the way to respond to life’s problems; yelling teaches yelling; becoming angry teaches anger, and so on." So Teachers punishing students show bad examples to students and foster violence in society. Then we have to dis agree that reintroduced. Also according to, a research by Human Rights Watch, it states, ‘Corporal punishment teaches both boys and girls that violence is acceptable when used against a weaker person. Psychologists argue there is a connection between corporal punishment and accepting or perpetrating domestic violence later in life.’
Contention 3, Severe corporal punishment can cause extreme physical and mental damage to students. This has been evident in numerous cases including suicide case in 2009 where a student in Gwangju committed suicide after being struck 110 times on the foot with a rod by a female teacher. Such cases suggest that corporal punishment not only inflicts physical harm but also give mental damage. This is true according to a position statement from National Association of School Psychologists(NASP) which states, 'Corporal punishment is a technique that is easily abused, leads to physical injuries, and can cause serious mental harm.'
In conclusion, we must realize that there is reason why most countries ban corporal punishment. Even if there are problems in public education such as drop in teacher authority, reintroducing corporal punishment should never be the solution. Therefore we once again negate the resolution.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
"The fundamental need of American education is to find ways of engaging today's children in the thrill of learning. Fear of pain has no place in that process." - The Christian Science Monitor. Because Ms. Peña and I are in compliance with this statement, we have decided to bring to the attention of the community, the corporal punishment of Sinton High School. There are many effective ways of properly punishing a disobedient student, but there are also limits to certain disciplinary measures. Grant it that a student from Sinton High School may now choose their own punishment, with consent from the parents, it is up to the administrator to keep in compliance, and with in the limits. Bruises, cuts, and/or broken skin should not occur in the process of administering corporal punishment. The eight constitutional amendment clearly states that "no cruel or unusual punishment should be inflicted." If markings are found on a student, the boundaries and law have been broken. Rupturing these boundaries surfaces the question, "Just exactly WHY are we administering the corporal punishment to students, to hurt them?" "...the use of corporal punishment in schools is intrinsically related to child maltreatment. It contributes to a climate of violence, it implies that society approves of the physical violation of children, it establishes an unhealthy norm...Its outright abolition throughout the nation must occur immediately." - U.S. Advisory Board on Child Abuse and Neglect.…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Corporal punishment is used as a discipline method for children. One of the most commonly used discipline methods in America is corporal punishment [ (Gershoff & Larzelere, 2002) ]. Is corporal punishment considered to be an effective form of discipline for children? Many parents’ opinions are different on how to properly discipline a misbehaving child. It has been proven children who receive corporal punishment as a form of discipline face several challenges. Due to the affect of corporal punishment other discipline methods are available and will be discussed more in details.…
- 2711 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays -
“Discipline and Punishment: Emerging Theories” is a summary of contemporary views on punishment in public education. The article suggests that teachable moments are more impactful than corporal punishment. Teachable moments are defined as taking the moment to communicate to the child or adolescent that the behavior they exhibited was inappropriate. Additionally, the article notes the ineffectiveness of the no tolerance policy on the grounds of it does not fix the problem.Suspending kids from school,in the articles opinion defeats the purpose because it does…
- 224 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Definitely, violence is not the way to discipline or educate kids, UNICEF (United Nations International Children´s Emergency Fund) reports on violence against children clearly states “ violence in all forms can rob children´s dignity, diminish their self-worth, and threaten their optimal development. Children not only suffer its immediate physical and emotional effects; the violence they see and experience is likely to impact on the type of adult they become and the future society of which they will be part”. Thirty-five years ago, Sweden was the first country to prohibit the corporal punishment of children in all setting, now it is banned in thirty-nine countries and in is in process in other 46 countries. Germany, Sweden, and Denmark are some of the countries that prohibit this behavior. These countries are within the most developed countries in the world and their education systems are used as an example for many countries around the world. This is a perfect example to show how violence is not needed at all to educate and discipline…
- 727 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The theory of discipline has been debated for decades. Arguments over how it should be carried out and how harsh it should be has been discussed. One aspect of discipline has been shoved into the dark, the effect on the child. No matter how much it is spoken of children remember what happened to them in their childhood. Whether they were pleasant or not can lead to problems later in life. One debate that shall soon be settled deals with the spanking of children.…
- 1006 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Greydanus, Donald E., Dr. "Corporal Punishment in Schools and Its Effect on Academic Success." N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Apr. 2013. .…
- 2453 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
“Corporal punishment remains a widely used discipline technique in most American families, but it has also been a subject of controversy within the child development and psychological communities.” (Gershoff) Corporal punishment is not only spanking your child but it is the effects that hitting your child can have. Studies have shown multiple outcomes of corporal punishment, some which have not resulted to be positive. There is so much behind disciplining a child stemming from emotions, force, and frequency. A child should not be disciplined to the severity where it will in turn affect them for the rest of their lives. Corporal punishment is severely damaging physically, mentally, emotionally, and socially to children and should not be allowed in any home.…
- 1712 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Over fifty yeas ago, Dr. Benjamin Spock,a prominent child pediatrician, suggested that all forms of corporal punishment traumatize children, trigger more aggressive behavior in the future, and is entirely ineffective in discipline (Costello). Since then, modern child psychology has been under that assumption. I believe this assumption is based on the fact that criminals of physical abuse were often abused as children, thus turning all corporal punishment into abuse.…
- 1412 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
• Corporal punishment sends a message to the child that violence is a viable option for solving problems (Straus, Gelles, & Steinmetz, 1980; Straus, Sugarman, & Giles-Sims, 1997).…
- 838 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Your 8-year-old refuses to put away her toys. Your 11-year-old isn 't turning in his homework on time. Your 16-year-old has come home late for the third time in a row. One of the biggest challenges in raising children is providing proper discipline. Punishment sometimes comes in the form of name calling, isolating a child, or using physical force, may or may not give you immediate results. There has been increasing debate about how we can effectively discipline children - and the rights and wrongs of corporal punishment. This paper will look at (1) the change in societal views of corporal punishment of children (2) the effects of corporal punishment on children, and (3) alternatives to the use of corporal punishment on…
- 2682 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Over thirty states worldwide have banned corporal punishment in the home. There are many people who are trying to get corporal punishment outlaws in Canada, the United States, and many other places. People believe that if they make spanking your child illegal, it will solve many problems. Twenty-two countries in Europe have banned this particular practice beginning with Sweden thirty-four years ago. “Since then, child abuse rates exploded over five…
- 631 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
According to his article Stratus discusses the extent to which parents in the United States use corporal punishment (such as spanking and slapping) and its consequences on their children. The question of whether corporal punishment is an effective technique of discipline is fervently deliberated. In his article, Murray Stratus discussed ten myths that perpetuate corporal punishment, in this essay I will be discussing three of them, starting with: Myth 2: Spanking is needed as last resort. Straus stated that this myth consisting on physical and corporal castigation as last resort it is a myth that becomes out of our social and mental duty to beating, Straus stated that spanking as a last resort is not necessary and does not work. Straus gave us some examples on why he think is a myth and that using spanking or physical punishment is not the best option, in fact he think using physical punishment as a last resort is a release of the parents own stress and anger, because the kids does not listen and obey at first. As evidence he wrote “You can prove this to yourself by a simple exercise with two other people. Each of the three should, in turn, think of the…
- 812 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Corporal punishment is just one of the wrong ways to discipline a child. The aim is not to…
- 41662 Words
- 167 Pages
Good Essays -
On the other hand, many countries banned spanking because they believe it to be a form of physical abuse that could lead the child to develop psychological problems. In fact, Sweden was the first country to banish such act in 1979, and the European Committee has been trying to encourage the countries of the European Union to do the same. In 2007, New Zealand, Netherlands, Portugal, Uruguay, Venezuela, Spain and Chile approved laws that prohibit parents from punishing their children with spanking (Research Paper n. pag.). Moreover, it looks like many other countries are considering banning spanking as an educational practice.…
- 1174 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
However, the pro-corporal punishment perspective is largely unrepresented in the empirical literature, so the research that was done excluded the majority of the public opinion and the positive effects (Fréchette et al. 135). Discipline is an inherent part of parenting that targets children’s socialization that trains them to obey rules or a code of behavior through punishment to correct unacceptable behaviors. After many studies and observing all the perspectives of corporal punishment Blum et al. concluded, “Although parental use of verbal instructions and reasoning with young children may be associated with an increase in some prosocial behaviors, it generally has not been shown to be a reliable intervention for changing problem behaviors in young children” (337). Blum et al. tests this by examining the change in toddler and preschool children’s behavior after using reasoning to try and control their behaviors. As a result, Blum et al.…
- 701 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays