Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Comparison and Contrast of 1984 and the Hunger Games

Good Essays
410 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison and Contrast of 1984 and the Hunger Games
Comparison and Contrast of 1984 and The Hunger Games The two stories 1984 and The Hunger Games both have characters that show briefly, but affect the actions of the main character. These characters have many similarities and differences, although they are in different stories. An example character that appears briefly in 1984 is Julia. Similarly, in The Hunger Games, an example would be Prim. In 1984, Julia is very important to the action of Winston Smith. She is a rebel of the Party and also Winston’s lover in the story. This affects Winston in many ways. Julia acts as an encouragement for Winston to rebel even more. Additionally, Julia assures Winston that there are definitely some people that hates the party or at least betrayed the party, like him. Furthermore, Julia makes Winston feel a little more secure and stronger. In contrast to 1984, The Hunger Games’ character, Prim, has a much stronger influence on Katniss’s actions than Julia’s on Winston. For example, Prim is the reason why Katniss was in the Hunger Games. Her love for Prim caused her to volunteer for the games. She is also one of the many reasons why Katniss tries so hard to win the games. Katniss knows that if she doesn’t win the games and go back home, Prim and her mother wouldn’t be able to live because of the poverty and lack of food that face them. These two characters also have similarities among them. Specifically, they are somewhat opposites of their main character. Julia’s rebelling of the Party is more personal; however Winston has this bigger picture of rebelling. Prim doesn’t like hunting; while on the other hand, it is one of Katniss’s strongest skills. These characters are also very dear to the main characters’ hearts. Katniss loves Prim so much that she wouldn’t want her to get hurt anyway, which is shown in Katniss’s decision to volunteer as a tribute and to not allow Prim to take any tesseraes. Winston loves Julia enough to relocate to a new home with her, and to sleep with her even though it did started out as just an act of rebellion. Prim and Julia have very important roles in the action of the main characters, Katniss and Winston. They both show that the main characters’ have a quality of love and loyalty. In addition, they are both opposites of their main characters and they increase their main characters’ hate of their superiors.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    1984 Julia Quotes

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Within the novel 1984 lie multiple characters, some more complex than others, but one character truly stands out above the rest, Julia. Julia is quite young and mostly obeys the Party’s rules, she usually defies the little rules but claims to be breaking the “big” ones. Julia makes it clear that she hates the Party, yet does not want them to be eradicated? Surely Julia keeps heads spinning, this is certainly true in Winston's case. Winston is quite special himself, at the beginning of 1984, the feelings he felt towards Julia were more or less violent.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the whole book Winston and Julia were against the party and they would rebel. Winston hides from the telescreen and writes. He writes about the party and things that happened that he remembers (not actually remembers but gets flashbacks). Julia on the other hand has sexual intercourse with many men and she steals from the party. Both of them are serious crimes during the entire book, and it's kind of like today except you don't get punished as bad. People just tend to look at you bad and call you things like if a boy has sexual intercourse with many women then he's a player and if a girl does it she is a hoe. Stealing on the other hand can lead to serious punishment like going to jail for a couple of years but it's not much to die for…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through the use of language techniques and character manipulation she portrays this contriving conviction to the reader. Katniss uses an imperative "Okay, I figured out what I'm asking," I say. "If it is Peeta and me in the Games, this time we try to keep him alive." To convey her wishes to save Peeta and the addition of the italics of the word “him” enhances the depth of her feelings. “And one of us is going to be victor again whether you two like it or not!” through the use of his indifferent tone Peeta conveys his courage to Katniss which also acts to empower her. He shows his courage, as he knows that he may not survive, as it is his plan to do anything possible to save Katniss just as she plans to do for him. This is where the major conflicting perspective lies between the two as they are both attempting to save the others life because of their resonating love. This is similar to the conflict between Brutus and Cassius where Brutus kills Caesar for the good of Rome “not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more” the use of juxtaposition accentuates the love that Brutus has for Rome just like the love Peeta and Katniss have for each other and how powerful a motivator this can be in any situation. Cassius on the other hand is motivated by his greed and jealousy “this man is now become a god, and Cassius is a wretched creature, and must bend his body if Caesar carelessly but nod on him” The use of hyperbole and metaphor emphasizes this and resonates the conflicting motives between Cassius and Brutus. The Quarter Quell of the Hunger games sets the perfect background for Collins to shape the characters in a way that reflects her perceived viewpoint of conflicting perspectives which is also presented to the audience by Shakespeare in the events…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She takes risks only to gain pleasure from breaking the small rules, like having relations with Winston, who thinks she is a serious follower of the government. “'It's this bloody thing that does it,' she said, ripping off the scarlet sash of the Junior Anti-Sex League and flinging it onto a bough.” (127). This shows how effortlessly she can rebel against the Party whose routine she pretends to religiously follow. Secondly, she enjoys stealing food from members of 'The Inner Party', like real chocolate, and coffee, which leaves Winston in awe. “'How did you manage to get hold of all these things?' 'It's all Inner Party stuff. There's nothing those swine don't have, nothing.'” (147). This proves how Julia enjoys being rebellious towards the party when it comes to breaking the small rules. Lastly, Julia pretends to enjoy Big Brothers rules of living, but really, she tries to hide her laughter while they do their routine 'Two Minute Hate' which proves your patriotism towards The Party. “She also stirred a sort of heavy envy in him by telling him that during the Two Minutes Hate her great difficulty was to avoid bursting out laughing.” (160). This final act of rebellion shows that Julia is careless and wants the freedom of having no government ruling her life. Julia is rebelling solely for the purpose of having the freedom of living without the power of the government watching over her every move, every…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Julia offers Winston something outside of this. She gives him physical and emotional comfort, contrasting what the Party offers. However, their beliefs in the opposition to the Party differ greatly, Winston rebels in hope that future generations will be free of the Party. Julia, being younger has no memories of a time before the Party and therefore can't imagine a time without them in control, she rebels more for simply the sake of doing so. Julia believes that the only way of opposing the party is with secret acts of disobedience or at the most isolated acts of violence because she doesn't believe that anyone or anything can defeat…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Different but are still similar. In George Orwell's 1984, Winston and Julia are two people who meet each other and think that they can relate to each other in a society where nobody can freely express themselves. They both try to fit into society but think about society differently.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Primrose Everdeen

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are many characters in the book The Hunger Games the main character is Katniss Everdeen she’s sixteen and her family relies on her because they no longer have a father figure, Katniss has a talent in archery because she hunts for deer in the forest where everyone is forbidden to go by order of the Capitol. Primrose Everdeen or Prim for short is Katniss’s younger sister, they're four years apart and hardly fight. Katniss would do anything for her which she proves by volunteering for her in the reaping. Peeta Mellark is the baker’s son who…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Poodicks

    • 9888 Words
    • 24 Pages

    Julia: The girl that Winston eventually falls in love with. I find Julia to be a burden for Winston because I feel like she’s constantly holding him back. When Winston gets captured into Room 101, he eventually falls into acceptance of The Big Brother because he loves Julia.…

    • 9888 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The protagonists also face difference difficulties in their stories. Tris mainly struggles to find her place in her new faction, while Katniss has more day-to-day problems, such as finding food for her family. Also, Tris and Katniss play different roles in their nation’s war. Tris is more of soldier, involved in the combat itself, whereas Katniss is portrayed rather as an icon of hope for the rebels. Furthermore, Tris and Katniss both engage in romance in their stories. Tris always shows affection towards only Four, but Katniss is involved in a romance triangle with two boys and struggles to decide between them. The final contrast between Divergent and the Hunger Games is that in the Hunger Games, the Capitol is more clearly defined as the…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The characters, Julia and Parsons, are very different.While Parsons is an unattractive man who supports the Party, Julia is a young, attractive woman who despises the Party very much. These depictions are what make Winston like Julia, and hate Parsons as much as he does. A similarity between characters has to do with O’Brien and Julia. They both plan a secret meeting with Winston, and both have watched Winston without him knowing anything. O’Brien’s plan to meet Winston is by walking with Winston and telling him to stop by his place to grab something. He gives Winston his address, and Winston gives O’Brien his attention. Julia takes a different approach, but it is still as effective. She knocks into Winston on the street, and in the process of him helping her up, she gives Winston a note. After Winston reads the note, he knows that the two need to meet. No matter the differences, these characters all played roles that shaped Winston’s life and perspective of…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Katniss Adversity

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Her mother falls into a heavy depression, and she is forced to take care of her six year old sister. . Katniss and her sister are starving, but she learns archery, and hunting in the woods in order to feed her family. Through the hardships of losing emotional contact with her mother, losing her father, and her family being on the brink of starvation, Katniss learns to be caring, yet tries to hide emotions from the ones closest to her. Katniss' mother falling into depression teaches her how to take care of her her little sister, Prim. This illustrates that any hardship can be a tremendous opportunity to learn from. Due to a tragic accident, one can acquire skills as an effect of it. For example, Katniss becomes capable of being responsible for more than just herself, and caring for others. Furthermore, due to heavy oppression from the Capitol, which is the government of Panem, Katniss learns the concept of justice. Katniss developed the skill of rebelling, and rallying others, and she becomes the face of rebellion for the districts of Panem. Katniss becomes a true inspiration for many people, and if Katniss hadn't felt the affects of oppression from the Capitol so personally because of her rebellious act in the 74th Hunger Games, Katniss learns to fight for her family, fight for her life, and fight for what is…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Saranell tries time after time to grow and be apart of her mother's life but all that her mother does is turn her head. "Maybe Renny's right. Maybe Mama will like some flowers," she murmured as she stooped for the yellow blooms. "But I'd like them better if they were pokeweed we could eat."She tucked the stems into the mouth of the pitcher, and when she couldn't crowd any more in, she took it back inside.Geneva didn't acknowledge the bouquet, however, and she ate the third of tasteless pancake without a comment"(Carr 116). Regardless of how thoughtful Saranell may be towards her mother, all she receives in return is a cold shoulder. Geneva, upon being gifted with the flowers, should be overcome with joy and delight instead of scoffing and looking the other way. In the book The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins the reader is able to see similarities between Saranell being emotionally abandoned and Primrosee Everdeen being physically abandoned by her sister and mentally abandoned by her mother. As Katniss waits to board the train to the Capitol, she tells her mom to stay strong, if not for herself then for Prim. "You can't clock out and leave prim on her own. There's no me now to keep both of you alive"(Collins 35). Prim solely relies on Katniss for support because of her mother being absent minded after her husband's death. Now that Katniss has been selected to participate in the Games, Prim is left to fend for herself because her mother doesn't take care of her. Even though Katniss has the possibility to become the victor in the Games, it is almost better for her to just die instead of abandon Prim who clings to the possibility of seeing her sister again. Children look towards their parents for guidance and comfort, if their parent is not emotionally their for them they become lost and feel…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Towards the middle of Lord of the Flies, the young group of boys split into two different groups. Ralph, Piggy, Simon, and SamnEric were allies throughout the story until Simon passed away and SamnEric were kidnapped. That left Ralph and piggy to fend for themselves while Jack, Roger, the hunters, and a few little ones began taking over the island. Jack Stole SamnEric, torturing them to find information about Ralph and Piggy. This created a very different feeling than The Hunger Games. While Katniss was camping in the trees, waiting for people to pass by she spotted a young girl, Rue, who reminds her very much of her sister. They became partners after Katniss was stung by a Tracker Jacker and fell from the tree. Rue covered her in leaves and created a remedy to help Katniss heal. They were planning to kill Cato and his group but was unable to proceed because Rue was shot by one of the tributes in his group. Katniss killed him using the bow and arrow she collected and sung to Rue as she died. This shows a bond between them that was very strong in a big sister, little sister way. This is the first time people see Katniss cry and show remorse for the killings. She then tries to find Peeta and stumbled across his camouflaged body. He is hurt so she helps him to a nearby cave that was high enough to not be noticed. They…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, they are both heroines. Saint Joan of Arc saved the french from the English and Katniss saved her sister from the games and her family from starving. They both sacrificed their lives for the lives of others. Saint Joan of Arc almost got killed for the French, and Katniss sacrificed her life so that way her sister could live. They both grew up poor. When she was young, Saint Joan of Arc was a peasant and Katniss was very poor and struggled to find food for her family. They were both very young when they made these life changing decisions. Saint Joan of Arc was 18 when she lead the French into battle against the English. Katniss was 16 when she volunteered to take her sister’s place in the Hunger Games. Saint Joan of Arc and Katniss Everdeen are very alike.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To conclude, The Hunger Games is a dystopian novel acting like a utopian society, which would lead you to think it was a perfect place, yet in the end it is either kill or be killed, so it is far from the perfect place. Katniss sees the games simply as a death…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays