Preview

Comparing Song Of Solomon And Such A Long Journey

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1257 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Song Of Solomon And Such A Long Journey
Literature is an art form unlike any other, with a special ability to allow us to peer into the lives of others. In turn, we then are able to peer into the lives of these characters, revealing a more nuanced, complex portrait of human nature. The two books, Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison and Such a Long Journey by Rohinton Mistry both allow the reader to experience this complexity, by contrasting the characters reactions to the extraordinary and mundane events in their lives. By doing so, they both provide the same insight into human nature: the key to achieving one’s dreams is balance, and it is only by accepting the complexity of one’s own life, that one truly gets what they desire. In Such a Long Journey, an uneventful, quiet life seems …show more content…
Milkman’s life is the one Gustad strives for: while they are both minorities in their respective countries, Milkman’s family has accumulated and maintained their wealth, and Milkman has a clear path and role within that. He has a secure position within his father’s business, but the simplicity of that existence seems to dull him. In his childhood, his sisters and mother did everything for him, and he was loved and revered by his mother (it is also worth noting that although she breastfed him well into his childhood, this was yet another thing Milkman regarded with boredom.) As an adult, he is the object of Hagar’s obsession, and yet he does not seem to feel strongly one way or the other about any of them. His dullness is also demonstrated on page 211, when he asserts that “The alcohol didn’t change him at all but it had a tremendous effect on whomever he saw while he was under its influence.” This solidifies the idea that Milkman has spent his whole life in a stupor, as the effects of alcohol are indistinguishable from his normal state of being. We also see how discontent he is with the comfort of his existence in his interest in flight in various forms. In the episode with the Sunday drive, the narrator states that he sat backwards because he felt like he was flying, and more symbolically, he is restless and desperate to “fly” in a sense from the town. …show more content…
Song of Solomon describes the importance of one’s identity, and demonstrates that as being central to ones happiness. At the same time, Such a Long Journey advocates for trust, in the people around you, but also in the universe at large, illustrating the importance that plays in life. However, their methods belie a very similar idea about human nature as a whole. Both of them deliver their messages by allowing the reader to witness the protagonists navigate both the daily and extraordinary events that befall them. It is only by accepting both aspects of the human experience that the characters are able to achieve what they really want. And so, it is clear that Such a Long Journey and Song of Solomon both argue that acceptance of the complexity of life is a necessary aspect of human

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Introduction: the similarities and differences in Song of Solomon and Gloria Naylor's Mama Day discover the ways in which to theorize the ''politics of identity, race, and class'' By relating the chracters such as Pilate and Naylor's Miranda to real-life stories of Black, Southern midwives (called granny midwives)…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the novels, Song of Solomon, by Toni Morrison, and As I Lay Dying, by William Faulkner the constitution of Darl and Milkman’s identity transform along the way of an ongoing journey in, which they carry the burdens of their families while struggling to gain complete independence and their indifference to the world surrounding them.…

    • 55 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Eng 125 Final

    • 2722 Words
    • 11 Pages

    A short story and poem, no matter how structurally different, are two literary pieces where a rich story is embedded. Readers are drawn towards these scripts by means of rhythm (poem), characterization, or a fictional setting in their respective narratives. However, the mere script would not make it entertaining enough to hold the reader’s attention. It would depend on the imagination of the readers as they are reading the story as to what they take from it. Every reader has their own way of visualizing the descriptions and symbolism used by the author. It is through imagination that the readers are able to interpret what the author is trying to depict within the symbolism and other descriptive languages. The beauty of stories and poems is that they are generated and created through the readers own imagination which consequently allows each individual reader to build their own personal connection with the literary piece. The two literary pieces “The Road Not Taken” (poem) and the short story “A Worn Path” are different in terms of actual writing styles, however they both share the same theme which is every person’s journey is greatly governed by their decisions and no matter how many paths there may be, it is still the choices that the person makes that determine the ending of his or her journey. Each one conveys a theme of life journeys and the challenges and struggles that go along with those journeys. In “The Road Not Taken” it is the journey one must make while trying to choose the right path in life. One path seemingly offers a more familiar road and perhaps the easier of the two. The other path is clearly been less traveled upon, yet yearns to be. In “A Worn Path” the journey that one woman takes on in order to care for her sick grandchild is unfolded. It is…

    • 2722 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    World renowned author, Toni Morrison, is known for her mystical references and interpretations. This is seen constantly in her 1977 novel, Song of Solomon. It is an eccentric story, one like no other, and any reader will see that from the first few pages. Morrison depicts eccentric characters and an African folktale to challenge readers into understanding the story’s deeper meaning. Song of Solomon focuses on the life of the protagonist Milkman Dead and his lifelong quest dedicated to discovering both his roots and purpose in life. Milkman has always been dependent and influenced by others; not once did he ever have to rely on himself for anything and being raised by his protective mother and sisters did little to help that. He has survived an unusual life, constantly having to endure strange and conflicting relationships between either his family, his best friend, or his lover. Everyone in the story contributes immensely to Milkman’s flight. Some help Milkman realize who he truly is and others help him see who they truly are.…

    • 2655 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Where as others see her relationship as inappropriate, Ruth views the ritual of breastfeeding as comparable to the “gold thread spun by the miller’s daughter in Rumpelstiltskin, the milk from her breast nourishes her son as “golden thread stream from her very shuttle” long past the age when a child would nurse” (Bloom 56). Ruth was seen by the janitor Freddie, who for years will keep this secret but marked the child with the nickname Milkman. Ruth breastfed him till age four. Macon Sr. blames Ruth for the nickname and the repetition given to the family causing a disconnect in relationship from Macon. Macon abandons Ruth throughout the relationship due to the hate he feels of her. The event also causes the nickname Milkman to follow him into adulthood causing him to also despise and disrespects Ruth for most of his life. This reflects in him developing odd relationships towards with women such as his cousin Hagar. Growing up, Hagar and Milkman develop an intimate relationship. The relationship is seen as peculiar due to their bloodline relation of Hagar and Milkman. Hagar falls deeply in love with Milkman. The relationship goes on for twelve years until Milkman reaches age thirty-one. Milkman tries to abandon the relationship breaking due to the fact that they are cousins and “she needed a steady man who she could marry her” (Morrison 98), breaking Hagar’s heart. As a result, Hagar attempts multiple times to kill Milkman. The abandonment of the relationship caused a dramatic toll on Hagar’s emotions. Milkman’s abandonment towards Hagar is an example of the burden his mother has a left on him reflecting, somewhat influenced by his father, on Hagar. Also, Milkman abandons the relationships and drama with Ruth and Hagar by taking a trip to Shalimar to fall…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The New York Times article I read titled “ President Obama on What Books Mean to Him.” In this article I learned that Toni Morrison's writings have a great influence on people. She had great significance on President Barack Obama. “Toni Morrison's writings, [ he says,] particularly “Song of Solomon” is a book I think of when I imagine people going through hardship. That it’s not just pain, but there’s joy and glory and mystery.” Morrison meant so much to Obama, in 2012 Morrison was presented with the Presidential Medal of Freedom by Obama. I also learned that Obama made his daughters actually read Morrison books so they two could feel inspired by her books. When awarded with this medal this means that you have made a great contribution…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Themes In Pleasantville

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Any Journey includes both realities and possibilities”, the three texts that we have studied in class, the film 'Pleasantville' by Gary Ross and the poems 'Road Not Taken' by Robert Frost and 'Journey to the Interior' by Margaret Atwood, support this idea as these texts include the protagonist having embarked on not only physical and interior journeys in reality but also imaginary. The journey is known to be imaginary for the audience, but for the characters of the text these journeys have led them to be in a different stage in life, not only physical but internally, evolving into different people or having what become completely different people due to these journeys.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Salj Symbolism

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Such a Long Journey (SaLJ) by Rohinton Mistry and Song of Solomon (SoS) by Toni Morrison are novels that both showcases the lives of their male protagonist, Gustad and Milkman respectively. In both novels, symbols are used to represent different meanings, and both novels have successfully used them to do so. Even though the symbols from the two books represents different things, they are also both used to show change, which can be seen in the symbols of the black wall and black paper on the windows in SaLJ, and, the symbol of the roses and flight in SoS. This further shows that there are similarities and differences between the symbols in the two books.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, I'm going to elaborate some on the first, second, and fourth prompts... My opinions developed of Milkman and his sisters throughout the text. My angle on Milkman shifts from noncommittal, to disliking him. He's too apathetic and abuses his social status, which I specifically dislike. Arrogance and apathy aren't all that bad in my book, but under his circumstances it is, he has no accomplishments of his own to lead to his attitude. On the other hand i grow to like him as the text develops. He becomes a sort of survivor. Or rather a man…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In "Song of Solomon" the women take somewhat of a backseat compared to the men. There are plenty of strong and important female characters in this work but they become disposable to the men. For example Macon Dead II loved the thrill of taking off Ruth's shoes and stocking but as time passed he simply hated her and wasn't afraid to hit her either. From Ruth's perspective she just craved loved and wanted someone to fill her void since he husband would no longer show her an ounce of appreciation. Ruth then decided that Milkman would be her champion and she would love him and hopefully that love would be reciprocated and this relationship would eventually lead her to breastfeeding Milkman even when he was too old for it and thus him receiving…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When one writes a piece of literature with the ability of choosing what to write, one is unable to prevent putting their own self into it. Depending on how well the person knows he or herself, with experiences that are unique or even relatable will determine how well their piece will impact the world. One does not want to read textbooks that are all factual, unless forced too, they want to read stories within a event. The interest goes deeper than just the surface, we may not realize it, but we crave for information. We tend to want to know more than we need or should, but that curiosity drives us to places we wouldn’t expect to find ourselves. Whether the place is good or bad, we are to deal with it the best we can. John Steinbeck capitalizes…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As children soar their way into adulthood every experiences they will go through will play an important part in their journey.We will all experience joy, love, hatred, and pain in our individuals lives that make us become the person who we are today and the future. Our character can only be created by our individual life experiences that will create those bonds, life skills, and memories. We will want to share our “findings” with others so they can understand a piece of ourselves. Our most explicit experiences is created by a trail we go through to show us how we learned and grown . In Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison, the time of the youngest Dead, Milkman (Macon Dead III) as he transition from a black man into a benevolent adult…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adapted from The Hero’s Journey: a Guide to Literature and Life by Reg Harris and Susan Thompson…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the novel, the author emphasizes life is a journey, not a destination, and that the real treasure is in the journey itself. “There is only one way to learn. It’s through action. Everything you need to know you have learned through your journey.” The same could be said for success or happiness. It is in the journey where you will find your true self.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Adversities are all around us. In any particular place, there are challenges that one must face, challenges that come one after another. It could be an abstract obstacle such as time, fear, despair, or frustration. It could also be a physical entity that one must face before they can overcome a problem. In Song of Solomon (1977), by Toni Morrison, the characters in this book are constantly reminded of the adversities around them, by a color that appears again and again. Living as blacks in 20th century America, racism exists and surrounds their daily lives. The two characters, Guitar and Milkman, face many hardships; one tries to fight back by resorting to violence, the other tries to resist by finding his identity as a Black American. Throughout…

    • 1569 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays