Preview

Compare And Contrast The Three Plans At The Constitutional Convention Of 1787

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
487 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast The Three Plans At The Constitutional Convention Of 1787
On May 25 1787, the most powerful men in our history met in Philadelphia to create a guide for the Democracy that we enjoy today. There were three plans at the Constitutional Convention in 1787.
The Virginia Plan was drafted by James Madison, from Virginia, and presented to the delegates by Edmund Randolph on May 29th, 1787 who was also from Virginia.
The hope behind this plan was to create a central government that could collect taxes, regulate foreign and interstate trade, and also be able to replace state laws with federal laws. This proposal would create central government with a powerful bicameral congress. It would consist of the Senate and the House of Representatives. Their members would be chosen by their state legislatures. The Congress would be controlled by the three largest population states, Virginia, Massachusetts and Pennsylvania. The national legislature seats would be filled based on the state’s population size. This branch would also have the power to appoint executive and judiciary branches that could veto state laws.
…show more content…
The Great Compromise/Connecticut Plan had a vision of a two house legislature. The House of Representatives and the Senate. The selection process for the House of Representatives would be based on a state’s population, and the Senate selection process would be the similar for all states. Roger Sherman, a politician from Connecticut, suggested this plan and based its framework on both the New Jersey Plan and the Virginia Plan. It created a process with the desire for a fair, balanced, and practical plan of action to appoint a State legislature which took into account the population size, and to eliminate any potential favoritism that could be gained by states based on their respective sizes. The importance of this plan was after its ratification the delegates were able to move on to deal with other future

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As you know, we are going through the Great Compromise. Congress cannot decide whether or not it is fair to adopt the New Jersey Plan, or the Virginia Plan. This compromise (An agreement with two sides or more, where every side gives up some of what they may want.) is one that potentially will shape the future government. You might be in between the two plans, but after you read this, you’ll know why you should choose the New Jersey Plan. This plan is about having an organized government, and the ideas on what the Congress should have the power to do.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book “A Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution” by Carol Berkin she explains the constitution from start to finish from how it all began, to the debates inside the convention and finally the end product. Berkin takes the reader and puts him directly in the middle of the convention of 1786; throughout the book you can feel the excitement, the frustration, the tensions between delegates and the overall commitment to making a new government work for all.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His proposition with the plan was to expand the government power over states, representation for states to be based on their populations and overall called for excessive change to the Articles of Confederation.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Describe the structure of government as proposed in the “Virginia Plan” and “New Jersey Plan” of the Constitutional Convention.…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Constitutional Convention delegates were from a variety of different backgrounds and different political views. They held a debate about how many representatives would be acceptable for each state to have. The states with a large population preferred the Virginia Plan. This plan allows for each state to have a different number of representatives based on the population. The states with a smaller population preferred the New Jersey Plan. The New Jersey Plan states that each state would have the same number of representatives. A delegate from Connecticut proposed a two-house legislature as a compromise. This compromise set the foundation for the Senate and a House of Representatives. The states with a smaller population favored the Senate…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    May 25, 1787, the day where the framers met in secret for a period of 4 months, with george washington presiding. by the end of their deliberations, the delegates had created a constitutional framework that has served as one of the most structural…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Constitution. Paterson delivered the New Jersey Plan with his concern of the voices of smaller states would be drawn out of larger states if the Virginia Plan been approved (Abraham Messler, 1954). His plan was particularly in response to the Virginia Plan, which in favor of proportional representation and a bicameral legislature( Leonard Williams Levy, 2000). The New Jersey Plan supported each state has one vote regardless of their population and the unicameral legislature. The with the final decision had come after their intense debate, that was the rejection of the New Jersey Plan, and the main reason was because it was too concentrated on gain more power to small states rather than the…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles were written during the early part of the American Revolution by a committee of the Second Continental Congress of the now independent thirteen sovereign states. The head of the committee, John Dickinson, who had refused to sign the Declaration of Independence, nevertheless adhering to the will of the majority of the members of the Continental Congress, presented a report on the proposed articles to the Congress on July…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the middle of 1700’s, Americans were unhappy with British rule, to show their unhappiness they established the Declaration of Independence. The Declaration of Independence was ratified on July 4, 1776. After the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation were passed but had a weak central government because congress could not levy taxes. Therefore, the government did not have any money to help improve the new nation. This weakness led to the Constitution and the Federalist papers. The Constitution was signed by 55 men meeting in secret in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania to establish a new political system. The Federalist papers were created to convince at least nine of the 13 states to ratify the…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States of America was going through a time of great debates and dilemma’s. It became obvious that a better more powerful national government was necessary. The Articles of Confederation was weak and needed to be replaced. While this was occurring a major problem developed. This was between large states, which vied for legislature segmented by population, and smaller states which wanted the system to have equal portioned votes everywhere. The larger states suggested the Virginia Plan, and the small states proposed the New Jersey Plan. At first, this issue was at a stalemate and both sides refused to give up ground. Eventually, Oliver Ellsworth offered The Great Compromise. This called for a bicameral Legislature with proportional…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Was the United States in a crisis under the Articles of Confederation, or was the “crisis” exaggerated by the Federalists to justify their movement?…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution were both recognized and followed by the same group of people. Even though the same group of people followed these two documents, these documents are very different. One example is the writing style of each document. The Articles of Confederation were repetitive, less direct and less certified for quoting than the Constitution. The two documents have a different approach towards the type of government and its control over the matters.…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the issues that the delegates argued over was representation. They had a disagreement on how representation would work—either equal (small states) or proportional (large states). The large states, mostly from the South, wanted proportional representation, in which they will earn seats in Congress by the amount of their population. They thought that the more populous states should have more seats in the Congress than the less populous states. Thus, Edmund Randolph proposed a plan, with the large states’ support, called the Virginia Plan. This proposed a bicameral legislature and three separate branches of government. Representation will be based upon states population or money contributions. The large states supported this because it promoted their…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The draft of the Constitution was submitted to the states by congress in September of 1787. For the first time, the people were able to peacefully vote and discuss how their nation would be governed. Among the people, there were mainly two groups: The federalists and the anti-federalists.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    U.S. Government

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Constitution was completed and adopted in Philadelphia on September 17, 1987. One of its main functions was to ensure the thirteen states became worked as one rather than following separate laws. Before the Constitution there was a weaker government that encompassed many problems and holes that needed ratification. This lead to a convention in order to create a stronger central government that would fix the issues the current government was facing.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays