Preview

Compare and Contrast "Rose for Emily" and "Story of an Hour"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
540 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast "Rose for Emily" and "Story of an Hour"
William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” are both stories about women that struggle with love. In a Rose for Emily, Emily Grierson is in the need to get married, while in The Story of an Hour, Louise Mallard is convinced that her husband is dead and we she finds out that he isn’t, it saddens Louise and ultimately kills her. The characters, the setting, and the idea of repression in both stories are three topics that can be compared in these two selections. Louise Mallard and Emily Grierson are two women that are in search of love but cannot truly find it. Louise is content with the liberty she receives from her husband’s apparent death, while Emily is not able to marry due to her father’s strictness. Louise is married to Brently Mallard. At the beginning of the story Louise finds out that Brently is apparently dead. This brings out some sadness from Louise, but overcomes that feeling fairly quickly. Emily was never allowed to marry. After Emily father dies, she dates Homer Barron, but she ends up killing Homer because he tries to leave Emily. The setting has in impact in both selections. Both stories take place in a time where it was socially unacceptable for woman to be free and do whatever they please. They had to have a man as a backbone. They both lived in male dominated societies, and at times, fathers were very strict in allowing their daughters to date. This impacted Louise because she wasn’t allowed to be free and divorce her husband. By the end of the story you can easily perceive that Louise was happy with the thought of being single. Emily was affected by the setting because her father was very strict and didn’t believe there was a man good enough for her. So when Emily finally got a man she killed him because she was scared of getting left. Repression is seen in both Emily and Louise. Emily is being repressed from men by her father. In a time period were women were supposed to be married to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although, Louise Mallard and Emily Grierson have many similarities they also had their differences. Louise Mallard wanted to find a way to accept the fact that her husband has just died and she would get to have the freedom she has always wanted. However, Emily’s goal was to make her father happy and she wanted to make sure she respected him like all women should, and in the story she respected her father.…

    • 73 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miss Emily is first explained as a nice, sweet, and normal woman, though that all changed as her life went on. The death of her father was the flame that ignited all of this weirdness of Emily. After her father died, Miss Emily did not go out much probably because of grief over the loss of her father. “Because her father is the only man with whom she has had a close relationship, she denies his death and keeps his corpse in her house until she breaks down three days later when the doctors insist she let them take the body” (A1). This statement demonstrates her inability to let go of lost ones.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story, Emily is cut off from social contact and courtship because her father has driven away any man trying to approach her. Therefore, when her father…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, Emily Grierson and Louise Mallard both shared a common shackle, the society in which they lived. Both Emily and Louise were women, and they both lived in times where society defined them by their male counterparts. The expectations of women in those days were cooking, cleaning, dining, other household chores. Women were also expected to be married in their middle ages. In a Rose for Emily, the narrator says that the town was not pleased when Emily turned thirty and she still wasn’t married. Louise was bonded in marriage, and Emile was bonded in solitude. Louise felt that her husband’s powerful will was bending her own. A man was seen traditionally as the provider of a household, and a woman was to be the housekeeper. This is evident in A Rose for Emily wherein a group of women who were observing the fact that Tobe was keeping the Grierson house made the comment “Just as if a man—any man—could keep a kitchen properly.” The comment was directed at men in general and it reinforced the idea that men had their place in society and women had theirs.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To me when Emily was a young girl she had so many suitors that her father had to scared them away which kept her from meeting potential suitors and getting married “…all the young men…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since the beginning of time, women have been treated as second class citizens. Therefore, women were forced to face many problems. Because of this women were repressed. At that time, the Napoleonic Code stated that women were controlled by their husbands and cannot freely do their own will without the authority of their husband. This paper shows how this is evident in the "Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin and " A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner. In both stories, the use of literary elements such as foreshadowing, symbolism, and significant meaning of the titles are essential in bringing the reader to an unexpected and ironic conclusion.…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Southern Patriarchy

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The feminist theory can be shown through Emily’s dependence on her father both economically and psychologically in every aspect of her life…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparisons Between Two Woman In the stories “A Rose for Emily”, and “The story of an hour”, there are two woman who many can say they go through similar phases in their life that restrain them from being free. As if happiness was ungraspable for both Emily Grierson, and Louise Mallard.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emily Grierson is a mentally incapable woman who has abandonment issues. She killed the man so he could they could be with each other for all time. The entire time that Homer Barron was dead on Miss Emily’s bed she slept next to him. This shows that she is crazy and will do anything to preserve the ones that she lover because she cannot let go of the past and accept that Homer will leave…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This quote emphasizes her early isolation with the opposite sex and shows how her relations with her father played an early factor in her loneliness. This is vital since her relations with any other male besides her father are non-existent in which will play a significant role in the way she conducts her self when finding a lover. According to a study conducted on adolescent girls, it suggests that fathers’ over-protective relationships had significant negative correlation with daughters’ self-esteem that later effect them during their transition to adulthood. (Mori 46). This is important because it gives context about her damaged sexual self-esteem from her over-protective father and how it later effects her in a negative way. Until Miss Emily’s father’s death, she had never explored her sexuality due to her fathers governing influence. When Miss Emily’s father’s death occurred she refused to accept the facts, in the story it was said, “She told them that her father was not dead. She did that for three days, with the ministers calling on her, and…

    • 1905 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first sentence of the story sets the tone of how the citizens of the town felt about Emily: “When Miss Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to the funeral: the men thought a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument, the women mostly out of curiosity to see inside of her house, which no one save an old manservant-a combined gardener and cook-had seen in at least ten years” (Kincaid, 1984). Significance of the story based on love. Her father was very controlling man, who thought that “None of the young men were quite good enough for Miss Emily” (Kincaid, 1984). After her father died she kept him the house and told everybody that her father is not dead. From my point of view this way Miss Emily shows a lot of respect and love for the father. Emily wants to be love again, that’s why when she felt in love with Hommer Barron she killed him, because he did not want to get married and was trying to leave…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    <b><i>The desire for freedom is a similar aspect of the female protagonists Louise Mallard, Mathilde Loisel, and Emily Grierson.</b></i><br><br>In Kate Chopin's, "The Story of an Hour," Guy DE Maupassant's, "The Necklace," and William Faulkner's, "A Rose for Emily," the female protagonist's have a desire for freedom. The stories are about three women living in patriarchal societies. Each character longs for freedom in a different way, but because of the men in their lives they are unable to make their own life decisions.<br><br><br>In "The Story of an Hour," Louise Mallard is a repressed married woman that has a heart condition. The reaction to her husbands presumed death is a sign that she is unhappy. After hearing the tragic news she goes up stairs to her room and looks out an open window and notices "new spring life", "the delicious breath of rain", and "countless sparrows twittering in the eaves." As she looks out the window among the storm clouds, she stares at patches of blue sky. "It was not a glance of reflection, but rather indicated a suspension of intelligent thought." Louise is not grieving over her dead husband or having negative thoughts about her future. She realizes that she will have freedom through her husbands death and whispers over and over, "free, free free!" Her unhappiness is not with her husband, it is with her ranking in society because she is a married woman. Becoming a widow is the only chance she has to gain the power, money, respect, and most importantly freedom.<br><br><br>Mathilde Loisel's chances for freedom are decreased because she comes from a middle-class family of clerks. "She had no dowry, no expectations, no means of being known, understood, loved, wedded by any rich and distinguished man; and she let herself be married to a little clerk at the Ministry of Public Instructions." Mathilde feels her marriage is beneath her and that she is worthy of a richer more powerful man. Because Mathilde is of a middle class family, she…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Emily throughout the story is perceived as an object to the reader rather than a character because her side of the story is not personally expressed by her. This type of narration grasps the readers’ level of curiosity as they are not given access into her perception about her life.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    a Rose for emily

    • 1641 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Actions of Emily’s father and his negative influence on her cause her to be isolated and separated from her society. Emily’s father has a high social rank in the society due to him been a Grierson. Her father does not give Emily the independence and sense of self that she needs; therefore, affecting her mental ability to take responsibility and sense of decision. For example he was the one that provides money for the house as the narrator hints “Now she too would know the old thrill and old despair of a penny more or less” (909). As you can see after her father’s death, she needs to provide money because her father was the one providing the family income. Mr. Grierson isolates Emily from her relatives as she has relatives in Alabama but due to her father’s problems with them, all connections are cut this is implied…

    • 1641 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The protagonists of “The Story of an Hour,” by Kate Chopin and “A Rose for Emily,” by William Faulkner long for a freedom withheld by the heavy hand of their surroundings. At the presentation of both these stories, it is easy to see how this could become a classic telling of the Southern condition but the skillful use of foreshadowing and symbolism creates irony in a series of seemingly ordinary events. Both women in these stories were bound by the strict expectations of their society. Louise and Emily not only feel but also live by the demands that society and their families have placed on them. When they finally realize their sovereignty, they attempt to maintain it in the most unconventional manner.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays