Preview

Compare And Contrast Karl Marx And Adam Smith

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2300 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Karl Marx And Adam Smith
When people think of economics, they initially think about the common ideas or relationships behind supply and demand, GDP or goods and services. However, going back to the history, there is much more philosophy involved that is unthought-of. I believe it is incredible to think how we live personally, socially, politically can be determined by beliefs or theories formulated by many others before our time that influence those amongst us. These theories or ideas may or may not be correct but have thought out logic, have various studies conducted and to ultimately determine the best way of life or common good. Adam Smith and Karl Marx, like many others before and after them, dedicated a majority of their life to understanding and discussing their rationales behind how countries should function in respect to their nation’s economic stability and structure. I think that although both Adam …show more content…
Prodigality means the wastefulness or indulgence of the unnecessary, and so he aims to have people remain abstinent from being prodigal. In order to advocate for limits on interest rates, Adam Smith urged usury laws when it came to market loans because this would result in profitable investments, which means productive accumulation. In addition, Smith was in favor of free trade when international trade was not subsidized because the preference would remain in domestic trade for the betterment of the economy.
Karl Marx was born in 1818, so that is definitely post Adam Smith’s take on Capitalism and his ideas of economic laws. Karl Marx has an interesting background in which he was dismissed from Germany due his political views not pertaining to that of Germany’s, even though he professionally got a Ph.D. in philosophy. Marx studies many others that provoked many of his ideas such as the French socialists, the work of a German philosophers known as G.W.F. Hegel, Smith, Ricardo, and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Adam Smith, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels were three of the most profound economic philosophers in history. They lived in the midst of a society that was incredibly capitalistic. In 1776 Scotland, Adam Smith published the book, The Wealth of Nations. It was his take on how the capitalist society was something that could flourish over time if it were to operate in a highly functioning manner. Merely 72 years later in 1848, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, both of German decent, published a pamphlet entitled The Communist Manifesto.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    adam smith

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Smiths baptism was on June 16, 1723 in Scotland. Smith attended the University of Glasgow at age 14, later on transferring to Balliol College in Oxford, England. He also spent time tutoring and teaching. Smith is culpable for promoting many of the ideas that built the school of thought that became known as Classical Economics. Laissez Faire philosophies like reducing the role of government intervention and taxation in the free markets and the idea that an invisible hand models supply and demand are key concepts Smiths writing is responsible for advocating. Adam Smith believed if the customer was satisfied and their needs were meet if would be good for both parties. This type of system would be beneficial for a country as a whole because the producer would continue to earn profits and the customers would keep coming back because they are satisfied. This is good for a country because it keeps it thriving.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    <br>Socialism is one of the roles of government in the economy. Adam Smith, who is the father of capitalism, believes in laissez-faire, "hands off" the government. He believes all production should be sale at the best possible lowest price. (Doc 5) While Adam Smith believes in capitalism, Engel is criticizing it. Engel believes the capitalism seizes everything for themselves but not the poor, they remain nothing. (Doc 7) Karl Marx, the author of a 23 page pamphlet, "The…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early in Marx’s career and writings he is dominated by a heavy Hegelian influence, particularly by the Young Hegelians who were radical liberals. In particular Ludwig Feuerbach had a profound effect on Marx’s early works. In contrast Adam Smith’s early life and works were strongly influenced by the literati who were a tight, close-knit group that met at pubs and social clubs to discuss, critique and debate each other’s work. While they both had early influences that would later drastically affect their views and works, Adam Smith was clearly the most influential of the two based on the changes to the Western world and culture. When you look at the political effects of both Smith and Marx’s philosophies you see a world dominated by a capitalist economy and society.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Adam Smith was a moral philosopher who established a baseline for all contemporary discussions on how wealth is amassed and what the effects are on society. Adam Smith knew that in the late eighteenth century for many people, they worked for wages that would barely enable them to survive. Since his focus was on the economics of the city in relation to that of the countryside, Mr. Smith did not make any comments on international trade. Smith went as far to say that people would do more good if they were not set out to do so. On another hand, Mr. Smith made an observation that when a political system was dominated by business interests the needs of the public may be ignored in the rush to use the political system to make money other than better…

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Enlightenment was a time period which featured a new generation of intellectuals who formed new political, educational, philosophical and economical ideas which used reason instead of religion and changed history. Adam Smith, the father of modern economics and the father of capitalism, was the most influential Enlightenment thinker as his book “The Wealth of Nations” made a substantial impact on the modern day economy. Adam Smith focused on economics and He established economics to be its very own important topic and he was the first philosopher to focus on economics in society. Smith also argued that people working to earn money not only benefited themselves, but also the society as a whole. Furthermore, charity was an important act but that a society should not depend on it.…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Modern political economic theory and philosophy can be greatly attributed to the works of two men who seemingly held polar opposite views on the subject. Adam Smith, a Scottish philosopher, published his most well known work An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations in 1776 and is most often associated with the ideas and principles of the political economic system known as Capitalism. At the other end of the spectrum is Karl Marx; the German philosopher most often associated with Communism and the author (or co-author) of The Communist Manifesto. This paper seeks to discuss the core differences in their respective political economic philosophies with regards to what economic value is and what the role of government should be in their versions of political economy. This will conclude with the argument that while Smith's work had laid the foundation for modern economic philosophy, it was Marx who would ultimately leave the most significant impression upon the world with his revolutionary ideas.…

    • 2054 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the feudal system in Europe began crumbling with the dawn of the Industrial Revolution a void was created in the European social and economic structure, Scottish philosopher Adam Smith took it upon himself to fill this void and in 1776 published The Wealth of Nations; just as Newtons Principia Mathematica laid the foundation for modern physics so to did Adams work lay the foundation for modern economics. For the next 70 years Adams doctrine went unchallenged until Karl Marx presented his rebuttal in the Communist Manifesto.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. What did Adam Smith believe serves to curb self-interest in an economy? “People care what others think of them and it is this desire for the good opinion of others that constrains people in their pursuit of self-interest” (41). Adam goes on to say, “this constraint is reinforced by competition and by the jurisprudence system” (41). Smith believes that others opinions shape what they pursue. Smith…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For a free market to operate well, one must think about what others want. The invisible hand, Smith’s theory, is the power that guides capitalism through competition for scant resources. This theory states that individuals will try to maximize self-interest, leading to the exchange of goods and services, allowing individuals to be wealthier than before. He said, “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we can expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest” (The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics). Smith is stating that everyone wants to be successful, and in order to gain prosperity one must exchange what he owns or produces with others who value what he has; thus, public interest is advanced and competition increases which in return stimulates the free market.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Karl Marx is regarded by many as the first social scientist ever. Although it is argued that Adam Smith was the first great economist, and David Ricardo the first great modern economist, Marx is undoubtedly the economist that has had the biggest impact on economic history. It was he that masterminded the concept of a socialist utopia, which ultimately led to over a third of the world been ruled under the communist regime , a model that Marx concocted. Born on 5 May 1818, in Trier, one of Germany's oldest cities, Marx was the first economist who infused history, philosophy, economics, sociology and political theory all into his work. Marx was ahead of his time, his theories were ground breaking, only time would tell whether his predictions would come to fruition. Marx's main claim was that capitalism would eventually fall due to its own internal contradictions and faults, to be replaced by a socialist utopia, so to speak. Marx had many complex motives behind the eventual fall of capitalism, he delves in to great detail about these reasons in his masterpiece Capital (1867), in this text Marx writes about how the capitalist system will falter over time due to the way it operates. It is these faults of the capitalist system that are brought in to question when analysing an issue of this nature, what weaknesses did Marx identify in his writings and were these weaknesses evident in the capitalist system come the end of the twentieth century?…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Two of the most noted and influential modern political thinkers are John Locke and Karl Marx. John Locke was an English philosopher who was famous for his use of empiricism and his social contract theories. After graduating from Christ Church College in Oxford, he worked there as a philosophy lecturer. He also studied medicine and various fields of science. In 1675, John Locke traveled to France, where he met with French scientists and philosophers. He spent four years in France before returning to Oxford. In 1683, he was nearly arrested on charges of radicalism. Locke fled to Holland, and stayed there for several years. While in Holland, Locke wrote his Essay Concerning Human Understanding. When William and Mary took the English throne, Locke returned to England and published his essay there. He also published his Two Treatises on Civil Government, which argued in support of the Glorious Revolution, in which the government of Great Britain was reformed without bloodshed. The writings of John Locke soon became famous in England and throughout Europe. Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding argued that all knowledge the human mind possesses is a result of observations made through the five senses. Locke argued that when a person is first born, his mind is a blank slate, which accumulates knowledge through the senses. Locke argued that science is the method of understanding reality based on observations made through the senses. Although contested by later philosophers, this understanding of the human mind was essential in the development of empiricism, and the scientific method.…

    • 2445 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the first chapter of Culture and Anarchy, "Sweetness and Light", Arnold describes culture as being responsible for the progress of politics and society and as "the best knowledge and thought of the time" (19). Matthew Arnold's culture is based on two main aspects, religion and education.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    We social beings, naturally look after ourselves as well as giving sympathy to other people. We also have our own interest. We want to pursue our goals and achieve our personal gain. Our self-interest drives us to form the free market. We buy things we want likewise produce and sell goods to have money to buy. We benefit each other in the means of economic activities making the public interest to promote yet we do not intend to. Adam Smith coined the term “Invisible Hands” to this. Moreover, we have the freedom to choose and reject the things we want. We are free or less ruled by the government and free from externalities like taxation. Nevertheless, minorities like the poor are left behind for they have no or insufficient money to buy their necessities and wants especially if there is competition or high equilibrium price. Hence, the more you work, the more you will have. Vices like dishonesty, selfishness, greed, violence, etc. must be considered in one’s motive.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Adam Smith

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Also, Adam Smith is famous for his classic book “The Wealth of Nation”, in which he was against the view that a free-market economy where everyone pursue his or her self-interest with no government direction at all would be inefficient. Smith said that individuals pursuing their self-interests would be led, “as if by invisible hand” to do things that are in the interests of others and of society as a whole.…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays