Preview

Colapinto Nature Vs Nurture

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1136 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Colapinto Nature Vs Nurture
Jacey S. Washington
Brierly
AP English Lang Comp
1 October 2013

Nature vs. Nurture: Where Do We Draw the Line? The argument over nature vs. nurture has continued to torture society by presenting cases in which we simply don’t know which rules to apply. One of these cases is sex change. Sex change is a very big step to take in a person’s life and it involves the careful consideration of many factors; but it is not a simple answer to a complex problem such as hermaphroditism or even blotched circumcisions. These choices can be difficult because we don’t quite understand which factors to consider given that we haven’t determined whether it is nature or nurture that determines a child’s sexual identity. Until we solve this riddle, people …show more content…
Colapinto describes in great detail all aspects of the case and how horribly wrong it went. He does elaborate research and uses interviews from direct sources in order to explain the case coherently for readers. This book is the main source for this essay as it describes so vehemently the case from all angles. It argues mainly how nature over nurture is the main factor in determining sexual identity.

"Jonisportfolio - Sexual Reassignment and Gender Roles Nature VS Nurture." Jonisportfolio - Sexual Reassignment and Gender Roles Nature VS Nurture. N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Oct. 2013. . This portfolio was published online by Jonis Portfolio to recognize and argue the issue of nature vs. nurture and its concern with sexual identity. It describes many cases where biologically born males who were raised as females so vehemently were determined to be males. It describes nature as a leading factor over nurture for determining sexual identity. It’s helpful to this essay because it presents some major arguments concerning the matter of nature vs. nurture. It even describes the John/Joan case and what happened there.

YouTube. Prod. Allan Gregg. Perf. Allan Gregg and John Colapinto. YouTube. YouTube, 04 June 2012. Web. 01 Oct. 2013.
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    rose for emily thesis essay
    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages

    rose for emily thesis essay

    1) Bruce Reimer, who lost his penis as the result of a botched circumcision in 1996 and was raised by his parents as a girl. As Bruce grew up he knew something was wrong in his life, and he later reclaimed his male identity. Reimer’s story is often cited in nature – versus – nature debates as evidence that people are shaped more by their biology than by their environment.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Chemical Influences and Gender Identity
    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Chemical Influences and Gender Identity

    In this paper will be discussing how biological factors such as nature, i.e. genetics and other environmental influences factor in to our sexual orientation and gender identity. Next I will focus the discussion based upon my evaluation of the nature versus nurture agreement, and decide which one has a larger influence over gender identity be it nature or nurture. Lastly, the paper will talk about current arguments in biopsychology might be able to help with bringing about a resolution to this debate.…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Evaluate The Biological Approach To Psychology Essay
    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Evaluate The Biological Approach To Psychology Essay

    This study looked at the gender development of an individual who was born a boy but was subsequently brought up as a girl after having his penis accidentally removed. Although Money reported that this change in gender behaviour had been successful indicating that gender identity was to a great extent socially and thus environmentally driven, it finally transpired that this was not the case. As a young adult the individual (David Reimer) felt compelled to reverse his gender change to become a male again. This gives very strong evidence that our gender behaviours are biologically driven and that although the environment might play some part in this respect, it is minimal.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Biological Genitals vs. Cultural Genitals
    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Biological Genitals vs. Cultural Genitals

    When considering the ideas of both sex and gender, it is universally understood, by most, that they are both intertwined; that is to say that gender cannot be discussed without bringing sex into the conversation, and vice versa. Here it is understood that the term “sex” is being used to signify the existing genitalia on an individual’s material body, and that the term “gender” is relating to markers of social difference between men and women (Halberstam 118). However, many scholars have attempted to create a distinction between sex and gender, which now many socialization scholars speak of as a body/consciousness distinction (Gatens 144). Both sex and gender, in theory, can be thought of as two separate entities, but it is important to keep in mind that an individual’s genitalia and material body are instant sources of proof when questioning one’s biological sex for gender to fall back on, when needed. The declaration of an individual’s biological sex (i.e. It’s a boy/It’s a girl) must first take place, and, once it does, their gender begins to slowly map itself out on the body, and essentially helps the individual create their own set of ‘cultural genitals’ that will be used to express their gender within society.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Alcoholism Nature vs Nurture
    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Alcoholism Nature vs Nurture

    References: Nature vs. Nurture: A Continuing Debate | Serendip 's Exchange. (n.d.).Serendip Home | Serendip 's Exchange. Retrieved July 16, 2012, from http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    David Reimer
    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages

    David Reimer

    The age old question of what influences humans more, with regards to biology or environment, has been under investigation for decades. Current scientific evidence acknowledges the notion that biology and environment work together to influence various aspects of human development and behavior. It is now believed that understanding a person’s biology and the environment in which one develops is key to studying and comprehending humans overall. However, the notion of biology and environment intertwining isn’t always exemplified clearly in various aspects of people’s lives. This was shown in the case of David Reimer, the boy who was raised as a girl. In Reimer’s case, he was born biologically male, but due to an unfortunate circumstance involving…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Gender Blur Deborah Blur Analysis
    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Gender Blur Deborah Blur Analysis

    It has always been said that both nature and nurture are the main ingredients in shaping a person’s behavior for the rest of their lives, like the meats and the cheeses to your favorite sub sandwich. Deborah Blum seems to think that not only do these things greatly effect human behavior but also gender identities. She gives the reader a new perspective on nature and nurture, arguing that it is way more than just nurture that paves the path of gender roles. Blum’s essay “The Gender Blur: Where Does Biology End and Society Take Over?” does a great job convincing the reader with it’s incredible use ethos, slight use of pathos, and so-so use of logos allowing it to be determined as a successful essay.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    As Nature Made Him
    • 3020 Words
    • 13 Pages

    As Nature Made Him

    Ronna Pearson Sociology 3337-70 July 12, 2012 As Nature Made Him The boy who was raised as a girl John Colapinto In 1967, after a baby boy -- one of a set of identical twins -- suffered a botched circumcision, a radical treatment option was agreed to by his desperate and grieving family. Encouraged by renowned medical psychologist Dr. John Money, an expert in the field of gender identity and sexual reassignment, the anonymous child was surgically altered to live life as a girl. The case would prove to be precedent-setting, becoming "proof" for the feminist movement that gender gap was purely a result of cultural conditioning. But all was not as it seemed. Initially proclaimed a resounding success, the devastating psychological cost of the procedure has only recently become known. Now living as an adult male, married and with a family of his own, this patient has granted John Colapinto unprecedented access to his story. As Nature Made Him is at once a fascinating exploration of the elusive nature of sexual identity and an examination of the ever-intensifying struggle between what medical science can do and what doctors should do. It is also a story of courage and survival that sheds light on the murkiest areas human sexuality. (Amazon.com)…

    • 3020 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Changing Trends in Sexual Orientation
    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Changing Trends in Sexual Orientation

    Homosexuality is commonly attributed to 3 major causes: gene, hormone and social influences. The notion of “born-that-way” was first supported by discovery of “gay gene” on 1993. (Appendix 2) This discovery has spearheaded the search for similar gene and other gay genes were reported to be found at chromosomes 7, 8, and 10 on 2005. Prenatal hormonal theory suggests that testosterone exposure during fetal life ‘masculinized’ the developing brain while lack of testosterone during early life ‘feminized’ the brain. In short, mismatched level of sex hormones in mothers during pregnancies were said to render a child more predisposed to homosexuality. These arguments support the advocates that sexual orientation is innate and “biologically fated”.…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Nature Nurture Debate in Gender Development
    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Nature Nurture Debate in Gender Development

    If a person displays masculine, feminine or androgynous behavior, then what determines this? The two main arguments are either gender is innate or it has been learnt. These two different perspectives represent a famous debate that occurs throughout psychology: the nature-nurture debate.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Psychology Term Paper: The transgender mind
    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Psychology Term Paper: The transgender mind

    levels, a case is made against being born with a sexuality and gender identity, that…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Growing Up Gay
    • 2664 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Growing Up Gay

    The debate over homosexuality as nature or nurture dominates most topics about homosexuality. People often confuse the nature/nurture issue with the development of gay identity. In fact, the nature/nurture argument plays a small, insignificant role concerning gay youths (Walling 11). Homosexual identity is the view of the self as…

    • 2664 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Nature vs. Nurture: Homosexuality
    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Nature vs. Nurture: Homosexuality

    'We do not even in the least know the final cause of sexuality. The whole subject is hidden in darkness’; this is a quote by Charles Darwin which illustrates the fact that your sexual orientation is unknown- this suggests that homosexuality is evolved through the upbringing and personal experiences. Many Social Theorists agree with this and they argue that Nurture is the main factor when considering the reasons behind human sexuality. They also suspect that upbringing and parental and family dynamics has a direct effect on a child 's sexuality. However, Biological theorists disagree and say that humans are born with a 'gay gene ', meaning that genetics are the reasoning behind sexual orientation meaning that we are born with our sexual preference. In this essay, I will discuss the main factors when considering what causes sexual orientation, this essay will however not debate whether homosexuality is right or wrong but rather to establish an understanding of the biological and social theories surrounding the cause of homosexuality.…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    War Against Boys
    • 2915 Words
    • 12 Pages

    War Against Boys

    One of the oldest debates in psychology is the nature versus nurture debate. Its roots extend far beyond the nineteenth century psychologists such as Freud and Skinner into the beginnings of scientific thought. Even Greek philosophers such as Aristotle and Plato addressed the issue of how personality is formed. Today, a relative consensus has been reached that nature and nurture work in tangent with one another; one can have many biological possibilities of which the environment determines the development. In any area involving gender however, this debate is still strong.…

    • 2915 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Gender Differences In Intersex
    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gender Differences In Intersex

    Even though Money’s theory has no substantial scientific or case study evidence, intersex children are still handled in the manner that if they are surgically assigned a sex and raised as that sex, that they will identify with that sex and live happily. Hospitals still follow this policy and have been slow to change otherwise. This is because Money’s theory provided an answer, even though it is not a good one, and a policy for handling an anatomical condition that previously did not have one. These power structures should be addressed because this “solution” has caused all damage and no good; not one person who was the victim of Money’s theory was thankful that their parents took this route to handle their intersex. The best way to do this we think is to educate the public more on intersex, and that it is not a deformity but simply an aspect of an individual. Also, educating medical students and current medical practitioners that surgical assignment of sex does more harm than good, and letting the child grow and decide on their own what they want is what is truly best fort the…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics