It is not easy for a person who considers himself a full-blooded American to relate to a Native American who lives in a country that is full of people who's ancestors basically wiped out your entire civilization. I can understand what he is going through somewhat. He is stuck in this country, this is his "home" weather he likes it or not. Obviously, things will never be like they were before the first settlers landed. The setting of the poem, an Amtrak train for Boston to New York, I believe is very significant. The New England Area, especially by Walden Pond in Massachusetts is near where the firsts settlers land. It is the site of our civilizations beginning and the Native American civilizations end. It was the site of the beginning of the end for the natives of what today is the Untied States of America. Its one of the biggest tragedy's the world has ever seen. Some their traditions however, are still possessed by today's Native Americans. They are however being threatened by today's culture which is dominated by material items. Many Native Americans are leaving the reservations and some of their traditions behind in search of jobs to support themselves and family. The main character of the poem seems to be sick of attitude. He is sick of Americans who ignore the history of those who were there before them. This is evident throughout the poem. They main character is very influenced by his heritage. He would not have such strong thoughts on the train about the American historical objects being pointed out by the woman. It seems to me that this man wants nothing to do with America and its history. However, he can't get away it. American culture consumes his everyday life. He has to not be himself very often. He has to act fake to appease those around him. I like many others in this world have been guilty of this same act. This character is perfectly politically correct. He tries not to confront anyone, which is not a bad trait. Unfortunately, that is not who he really is. However, his Native American upbringing has instilled in him a deep respect for elders. A characteristic that our culture lacks teaching to its young sometimes. He, like many of his kind, is very honorable and respectful of those who deserve respect.
"On the Amtrak from Boston to New York City" was honestly one of the best poems I have ever read. It is about a subject that I have not put much thought about. However, after reading this piece I will put a little more thought into the subject to try to put myself into the shoes of a Native American trying to live in America. This is their "home" but it's not really their home. That is the way I see it. Many are forced to live lives they are not supposed to live. Many struggle everyday to survive to keep their culture alive. This is a struggle they are losing. Many Native Americans are forced to leave the reservation in search of better education and a better life.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the short story “Indian Education” by Sherman Alexie, the narrator’s life parallels Alexie’s in many ways. The narrator of this story is a boy named Victor who lives on a reservation with his two parents. Like Victor, Alexie grew up on a reservation in the state of Washington. Both boys were teased and bullied by their fellow classmates and initially decided to go to school outside of their reservation for greater educational opportunities.…
- 332 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Before the advent of the transcontinental railroad, a journey across the continent to the western states meant a dangerous six month trek over rivers, deserts, and mountains. Alternatively, a traveler could hazard a six week sea voyage around Cape Horn, or sail to Central America and cross the Isthmus of Panama by rail, risking exposure to any number of deadly diseases in the crossing. Interest in building a railroad uniting the continent began soon after the advent of the locomotive.…
- 305 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Between 1915 and 1970, six million African Americans left their homes in the South and moved to the states in the North and West (Layson and Warren 1). This movement is called the great migration and is explained in The Newberry, Chicago and the Great Migration article. Some of the main reasons that African Americans traveled from the north to the south is because of racism reconstruction and a chance to get more opportunities as equals. In the book native son the main character Bigger Thomas goes through discrimination because of his actions based off of his race. In this paper what bigger went through will be compared to the great migration article. Bigger experiences racism, segregation, and poverty throughout the book native…
- 124 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
“The Contested Plains: Indians, Goldseekers, and the Rush to Colorado” Written by Elliott West. I chose to write about this book because of the large range of events and transitions that occurred throughout the American West that the author includes in the text. Elliot West highlights the struggles that many endured while trying to create better circumstances for not only themselves but also their families by moving to the west. He chronicles the adaptations that many white settlers arriving in the west faced in order to be able to make a living for themselves. But another reason why I found the book interesting was because of the way Elliot West provided perspective for each side of the struggle over the American West. He gives us the Native American view of what was happening at the time, which I found valuable because a lot of the time the Native American perspective is not heard.…
- 1065 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Analysis of Sherman Alexie's novel. Centers on character of John Smith, a man caught between two worlds: the Indian and the White and not at home in either world. Issue of John's intolerance; his suffering, alientation and violence. Negative impact of intolerance of white society and co-workers. Author's message.…
- 1305 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
A similar vein of thought exists within the piece, “Proceedings of the Lake Mohonk Conference,” in which speakers push the idea that assimilationist narratives are generous toward indigenous people and helpful for society. Speakers deemed assimilation necessary, not only for the United States as a whole, but for the indigenous population as well, who were not regarded as full persons until they became “civilized” (“Proceedings of the Lake Mohonk Conference” 11). People with indigenous identities were not only treated poorly, but their identities were also mocked and considered unimportant and primitive, and one speaker within the conference claimed that giving up one’s indigenous culture may be necessary if it “will buy them life, manhood, civilization, and Christianity” (“Proceedings of the Lake Mohonk Conference” 11). The loss of one's culture in this context was seen as a slight, unfortunate price to pay for citizenship and civilization, and an assumption existed that indigenous people would want to give up their culture in exchange for a place in white…
- 1391 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In Sherman Alexie’s short story, “What You Pawn I Redeem,” Jackson, the protagonist, must figure out how he can merge his Native American culture into modern day Seattle. The characters in this story have similar characteristics of real life Native Americans. According to The main character, Jackson Jackson, is part of the Spokane Indian Tribe but he has moved to a larger metropolitan area in Seattle, which is much different from the cultured-based Spokane Reservation. Most people move to a new area and have to deal with finding new friends and finding their way around town, but Jackson has bigger problem. He is caught up in his Native American culture and has not quite learned how to live the modern day lifestyle. The story shows that it is important that he keeps his culture alive without becoming separated from the modern world. Jackson is put to the test each and every day to find new ways to interact in the big city and figure out how he can mix his historic traditions with the contemporary civilization that is set in Seattle, Washington. He must adapt to a new culture without losing his own. The struggle to balance modern day living and the Native American culture in Seattle is revealed through the setting.…
- 1464 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Similarly to how Reynolds exposes the marginalisation of indigenous Australians, Ginsberg describes the alienation of many Americans due to Cold War politics. He immediately expresses his dissatisfaction with the state of the US, using sequences of apostrophes to address ‘America’ directly and turning the poem into a kind of argument with the personified country. Like Reynolds, he has an intensely personal focus, using the first-person and drawing on his own experiences to show ‘America’ his disillusionment. He reveals in the first stanza how the country used to inspire him – ‘you made me want to be a saint’- juxtaposing this with the disenchantment he feels now – ‘I sit in my house for days on end and stare at the roses in the closet’. The use of free verse with minimal punctuation and broken grammar gives the poem a deranged quality, suggesting that America is driving him mad. This is reinforced by line 7 where he almost sulks, ‘I don’t feel good don’t bother me’. Ginsberg reveals the source of his consternation as the militaristic and fanatically anti-Communist political atmosphere of the 1950s, and uses satire to mock those he sees as conforming to blind nationalism. He writes in the third stanza, ‘America it’s them bad Russians…the Russia want to eat us alive’. The childish grammar and hyperbole ridicules the widespread…
- 1083 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The quality of life on some reservations can be comparable to that of life in countries like Mexico with issues of poverty and alcohol and drug abuse. Starting at a very young age Alexie had overcome many obstacles as does his characters in his stories. In the short story, “This is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,” the author Sherman Alexie shows the struggles of Native Americans in a white man’s world. To help us better understand these struggles, this paper will analyze the characters, theme and setting of this story.…
- 477 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The narrator is a small, disfigured, and disproportionate child who is nicknamed Junior. The book’s main theme is about education in Native American youth. Aside from the page by page cartoons and the enthusiasm on adolescent youth humor, the book is essentially about the transformation that Junior undergoes by switching from a Spokane Native American Reservational school to a private caucasian “White” school. There is a particular chapter where Junior is still at the Indian public school, Wellpinit. Junior is given a textbook in class and his jaw drops at the name he finds in it. His mother’s first and maiden last name are Sharpied on the front inside of the cover. In short, Junior goes balistic and throws the book at the teacher, thus creating a series of events that inspire Junior to reach the decision that he must change schools to survive. Before he transfers schools though, the teacher he threw the book at comes to meet Junior on his front porch. He and Junior have a long discussion, but in the end “Mr. P” tells junior “Son…You’re going to find more and more hope the farther and farther you walk away from this sad, sad, sad reservation” (Alexie, 2007). Junior should not have to transfer schools and go through hell for being Indian. Throughout “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian” (Alexie, 2007), Junior is ridiculed and neglected for being Native American not only by his peers, but his teachers as well. There is a quote that makes one quiver and is much too vulgar to state in an educational composition, which happens to be a true statement that was said to the…
- 2008 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The rituals were reviewed as an important significance in facilitating interactions with the sacred. In other words, it can mean communing with deities, and honoring ancestors. This underscores the connection of Native American’s relationship with their spirits and ancestors. However, the Native Americans are having to fight a major battle in maintaining tradition yet allowing for the influence of contemporary values they face every day. It proves to be challenging because the beliefs that make contemporary society are drastically different from their traditional customs. In addition, being a Native American had a stereotype associated to being drug addicts and alcoholics. This meant no jobs, and no housing. Due to the lack of respect for the way these people pray, and live to understand their relationship of the world around them the biggest problem, Annika explains, for the Native American people today is invisibility. She explains throughout the film how the American people forgot about the natives, where they made treaties with them and yet failed to uphold their part of the treaty, by stealing lands. One of the many ways these Native Americans have been countering these issues have been where one out of four tribes in the US have casinos and use that money to fund education, housing and have control over their own finances and resources. This creates freedom for the community while at the same time holding on to their identity. Vic Camp, one of several interviewees of the film beautifully summarizes the reflection of the Native American’s struggles by stating, “[w]e live in America, but we are not Americans. But we are the first nation here, protectors of this land. So we are going to be here on the July 4th to celebrate our independence…
- 929 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“ The native americans had to face poverty and climate” (Dudley, 4). The native americans had to also face drunk tribesmen who committed murder and robbery. The native americans were frustrated because of how they were forced out of their land. “ the native american tribes didn’t have many resources so they journeyed with little food or supplies”. The battles waged by the native americans had man of their food supplies trashed and disposed of with the battles. “ some native americans suffered because of the treaties”. With some native americans suffering from the treaties The native americans had to move west with no food or supplies from the government to help them. The journey to the east lands was a tough one and the native americans had to fight just to make it their.…
- 717 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Sherman Alexie applies hyperbole strategy. “Our house was filled with books. They were stacked in crazy piles in the bathroom, bedrooms, and living room.” Using his exaggerated speech it shows the reader how much Alexie read growing up. The stacked up books all over the house shows what a tremendous role books had on his life. “We lived on a combination of irregular paychecks, hope, fear, and government surplus food.” For Alexie growing up was not easy living on a reservation and desperately wanted to escape. This hyperbole emphasizes how hard life is for most Indian children, ultimately wanting all children to leave the reservation and not be a stereotypical Indian.…
- 474 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The history of Native Americans has been a long and grueling one. Most of which has been plagued with pain, degradation, struggle, and horror. Even to this day, they are still trying to recover all that was taken from them. They struggle to regain and preserve their culture and lands that was ripped from them so long ago. Although there have been many events that have impacted Native Americans since 1877, the assimilation into non-reservation boarding schools, the Meriam Report, the American Indian Movement (AIM), and the American Indian Religious Freedom Act are among some of the more significant.…
- 1484 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Sherman Alexie was born in 1966 and raised on the Spokane Indian Reservation in Washington. Although born with a severe case of hydrocephalus, he astonishingly recovered and learned to read at an early age. Alexie used his social rejection to concentrate on his studies. In 1985, he was awarded a scholarship to Gonzaga University where he regrettably began abusing alcohol. His college years can be described as depressing and inspiring. His alcoholism compelled him to convey his feelings on paper. Prompted by Alex Kuo, his poetry professor, Alexie engage in writing using his somber encounters as subject matter. Since his years at Gonzaga, he has published several stories and poems pertaining to Indian culture and life on the reservation. He has been presented with prestigious awards for his screenplays and novels and was named one of the twenty best young American novelists by The New Yorker. Using melancholy tones and woeful themes, Alexie broadcasts his people’s despair and brings light to the ignored feelings of a lost generation. Perpetual alcoholism, fragmented families, and racial alienation are major issues present in Sherman Alexie’s three short stories.…
- 1084 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays