Preview

Cashmore's Argument Against Doping Be Legalized?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
982 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cashmore's Argument Against Doping Be Legalized?
To begin with, Cashmore asserts that permitting the use of doping would make competitive sporting activities safer and help in the research process investigating the substances’ properties. In essence, he argues that by eliminating the use of unknown substances from the unchecked sources it would be easier to regulate sports as there would be no covert doping activities. He further adds that “permitting the use of doping would rescue sports from this clandestine state, creating an environment that would be not only safer, but more congruent” (Cashmore). To some degree, this argument is correct. Even so, it is important to realize that athletes will always find ways to outperform their peers by taking the ‘next best alternative.’ To clarify, …show more content…
Marveling in the death-defying stunts and record-breaking feats, the audience does not bother how the performers got there. Cashmore insists, “Sports starts are not models. Possibly. But they are not paragons of virtue.” Anyone who does not wish to enhance their performance artificially is simply making a personal choice according to the author. There are a number of reasons why this argument is inappropriate. First, it is evident that allowing doping eliminates any sense of fairness in sport. Apparently, competitors who use the banned substances have an unfair advantage over their ‘clean’ peers. There would be very few, if any, instances where clean athletes emerge victorious in sport. Thus, almost immediately, doping would become as important as taking breakfast. Secondly, fans want to see their favorite athletes compete in their full natural form. If athletes were allowed to use drugs, any stunning achievement would be dismissed as a result of using performance-enhancing substances, not natural ability. Evidently, young athletes idolize sportspersons and follow their footsteps as they mature, dreaming of playing in major leagues when they grow up. Consequently, if the culture of doping is made lawful, the young ones would be exposed to the vice at a young …show more content…
Doping undermines sportsmanship, which is the act of engaging in sporting activities in a fair, generous, and polite manner. The real spirit of sports is the perfection of talents. Even if doping was allowed under other circumstances, some athletes and the countries that they represent would not afford to fund costly doping programs. Indeed, sports has its own unique character; fans are interested not only in the results of the game, but also in the entire process that has led to the impressive results. For this reason, the competitive sports is based on a set of rules that promote equity, transparency, and integrity. Certainly, cheating compromises the admiration that fans have for their athletes for having reached their peak performance through hard work and relentless training. Should competitive sports lose its value, events such as the Olympics and the Tour de France would attract fewer fans with time and eventually face the possibility of dying out. It is important to realize that sporting is inherently a healthy pursuit and an inspirational activity, and allowing doping would simply be akin to commercializing athletic

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Varda Burstyn provides great insight on hypermasculinity and modern sport in her book, The Rites of Men: Manhood, Politics and the Culture of Sports. In this book, Burstyn asserts that performance enhancing drugs have become institutionalized as part of the “hypermasculinization” in sports and society. Athletes use performance-enhancing drugs to receive an energy boost as a means of playing through the pain endured during a sporting event. Especially in modern sports, competition has increased dramatically and athletes are willing to do anything they can to gain a competitive advantage. Monetary and materialistic incentives that are attached to winning in modern sports have catalyzed a need to attain even the smallest advantage. The source of athletes’ mentality of gaining a smallest advantage over competitors can be traced back from the time they were young to the time they reach the professional stage. The pressure to perform at a high-level consistently throughout his life has influenced the athlete to rely on drugs and has normalized the use of drugs in modern sports. However, using performance enhancing drugs comes with its fair share of disadvantages as well. Athletes who use steroids tend to have mood swings,…

    • 2609 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In “We, the Public, Place the Best Athletes on Pedestals,” author William Moller presents his explanation for the widespread use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs). Moller begins by telling a story about his past experience with PEDs. During his sophomore year of high school, Moller was under immense pressure from himself and others to achieve a standard of excellence and secure the top spot in his class. After pulling three all-nighters in a row and forcing himself to stay awake for more studying, he willingly took a PED to improve his focus. It was easy for Moller to make the decision of being rewarded with a good test grade and risking the consequences of getting caught, instead of doing the right thing and falling to his competition.…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through the history of sports there has always been cheating. Cheating in sports has always been a topic for conversations, controversy and debates. It seems that cheating currently is at the highest point, and will not go down anytime soon. With the fast development of technology and medical science it seems that drug use in sports will increase. The line between acceptable and unacceptable will be harder to determine as it takes time to make proper tests. There are various different motives for someone to cheat. Some sportsmen cheated because of the pressure to be the best. Some cheated for money and some of them cheat because they simply want to have fun. Regardless of the reasons, it seems that the cheating has only increased and will continue to increase even more as…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In “The Doping Dilemma”, Michael Shermer writes about the consequences and the ethics behind performance enhancing substances in professional sports. He begins with an anecdote, which describes the feeling of getting “dropped by your competitors on a climb” (420:2). As described by the author in the development of the story, every athlete has a genetic limitation that regular training cannot exceed (421:4). According to Shermer, the only thing to be done is to dope. Arguing that, in order for an individual to stay competitive nowadays, he needs to make use of performance enhancing substances. Shermer concludes that today’s drugs are better, harder to test, and the incentives usually favor them (421:8/422:9). The author effectively argues that there should be a direct shift on the incentives regarding sports doping. His experience read as a reflective narrative to young competitors who are now starting,…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Long before Cal scored the touchdown in the 1982 “Big Game” against Stanford, and before Stephen Curry made a record-breaking number of three pointers in one basketball game, sports was primarily based on natural abilities. Today, sports has evolved to elevate the level of play and performance. Major competitions such as the Olympics manifest the most dominant world athletes. The winners are deemed the best in their sport for their abilities to be biologically and physically gifted and to harness that potentiality. These athletes train strenuously, often ingesting synthetic or natural additives to increase performance. To remain competitive in increasingly higher levels of play, athletes should have the choice of using their natural gifts and/or using performance enhancing drugs. Neither an athlete who has a gene that prompts a superior physique nor an athlete who uses steroids should be deemed cheaters, for they are pushing sports to a new level and creating an equal level of play.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It is estimated that around forty-two percent of professional athletes use steroids. Any athlete who uses steroids goes against the “spirit of sport”, which is based on honesty, fair play, ethics, health, the respect for game rules and the respect for yourself and other participants. Steroid use shows bad sportsmanship and lack of respect, and is fundamentally a contrary to the “spirit of sport”. Steroid use then makes for tainted glory, and questions of whether the win or trophy was actually deserved are quick to…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Some people say that the only way that athletes will stop using the drugs is if they get a lifetime ban from the sport they love playing. The complicity of medical professionals and shadowy labs are often involved. Corruption in general has and also doping are ubiquitous in both amauter and professional sports. It has taken the character of a symmetric threat. A lot of athletes that are serious about the sport is that you will do anything to win and the competitive sport can be fierce.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Drug Testing in Athletes

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many people do not see the severity of drug use in professional and High School athletics. Drug use in professional athletics is looked upon as somewhat of a serious problem, but also very discrete and low key. Every once in a while and individual might see a prominent figure in a certain sport being reprimanded for the use of an outlawed drug. However , that athlete may just be one of the many who happened to get caught. Athletes today seem to find no moral problem with using performance-enhancing drugs, or in other words, cheating. Athletes feel that because they are "stars" there should be no repercussions for their illegal activity. Today, drug use in sports has reached enormous proportions in society and destroying athletics from the ground up. The use of steroids and other performance enhancement drugs also effects athletes at the high school level. It does not matter how good the athlete is, a zero-tolerance policy should be in place at all levels of competition.…

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sport is a major global industry generating billions of dollars in sponsorship, media rights and gambling funds. In recent times, a number of sports have been tarnished by doping scandals. These incidents pose threats to the integrity of sport both nationally and on a global scale. In response, sporting organisations and governments have introduced legislation and accompanying punishments to deter the use of both performance enhancing and recreational drugs. However, it could be argued that effective strategies for combating doping in sport are hindered by a lack of organisational commitment, varying opinions on how the problem should be managed and a lack of reliable information and empirical data to formulate and implement appropriate doping policy. It is timely for sport managers to focus on the topic of doping, as public concerns over the use of drugs in sport cause significant damage to the sports industry, with consequences such as reduced attendance at sporting events, reduced sponsorship and possible impacts on broadcasting rights amongst some of the most pressing concerns.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The use of performance-enhancing drugs in sport has become a huge issue in all modern codes of sport. In the recent 2012 Olympic games in London, it was suggested that as many as 60% of the athletes were taking illegal drugs. You only have to open the newspaper or turn on the television to discover a new batch of professional athletes that have been caught ‘doping’. Although athletes are regularly drug tested, there have been multiple cases where athletes have been able to cheat the system and return negative results. Australia has been a front-runner in the fight against sports doping, and has even established a…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Drug use among athletes has become a common action. Many athletes have or still use performance-enhancing drugs. Not all of these drugs are illegal. In fact, many of these products are available at nutrition stores or on the Internet. Performance-enhancing drugs are used to give athletes an edge. Whether this edge is in competition or in self-esteem, consequences play no part. Why would any athlete disregard consequences and consider using performance-enhancing drugs? For many, the possibility of unlimited gains is enough reason to justify disregard to consequences and use of drugs.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Doping In Sports

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Baseball is the first sport that comes to one’s mind when doping in sports is brought up. Doping is also common in cycling, wrestling, bodybuilding, swimming, and running. These sports take an immense amount of strength and stamina. On top of that, athletes are pushed over the edge to exceed greatness in the competitive world. The average amateur player does not feel the need to enhance their abilities because they play for the love of the game. On the other hand, competitive athletes want to be noticed. They want to be the best they can be, along with the best on their…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As children, many people are introduced to the famous quote by late National Football League coach, Vince Lombardi, which is "winning isn 't everything; it 's the only thing" (Voy 204). Sports have always been about winning; however, some professional and amateur athletes take this simple saying too literally and it changes their outlook on their profession. As high school and even middle school athletes, they start to take drugs in order to be accepted, or to better their performance on the playing field (Louria n.pag). Once theses athletes reach the college level; they experiment, and are surrounded by even more drugs in order to get any advantage. It is not fair that one athlete can work hard in order to improve his performance, but then have another athlete improve more than him due to being wired on cocaine or bulked up on steroids. Also, Robert Voy states that drug use today is the biggest threat to the Olympics ideal, thus the Olympics and many other professional organizations are turning to drug testing. Testing is a huge controversy today because many believe that it violates one 's right of privacy; however, if there is no testing, many athletes will continue to have an unfair advantage to non drug users (180). Furthermore, it injures the user because it will result in mood changes, and it will hurt their health, if not immediately, then it will later on in their life. The chance of being caught using drugs is so small compared to the achievements one will have while using drugs which is so vast. No athlete should have an unfair advantage, these advantages only promote drug use, which many athletes believe it is a necessary means in today 's time. The only way to have the use of drugs decrease is to have mandatory drug testing across the board for all athletes.…

    • 2701 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It always raises an eye when an average athlete suddenly becomes the fastest or the strongest in their sport; in many cases they have stopped depending on talent and now rely on a performance- enhancing drug for success. Substance abuse in sports is shown to be common because of their benefits, various scandals in the media, and new polices companies have now had to implement. The act of "doping" or the use of an enhancing-drug has become a social norm though out all sports.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr. Smith states “The primary reason why performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) are outlawed in professional sports is that they give users an unfair advantage over the rest of the field” and that “legalizing PEDs would make life much easier for professional sports organizations currently tasked with managing convoluted anti-doping policies.” The sheer consideration that allowing dangerous drugs or supplements such as human growth hormones, steroids, stimulants or creatine to the already sensationalized world of professional sports would be a travesty of epic proportions for the health and viability of both the athletes and competitions themselves.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays