Preview

Case Study Of It's Your Gavel: Chance Of Survival Diminished

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1345 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Case Study Of It's Your Gavel: Chance Of Survival Diminished
Jennifer Aguirre-Post
January 22, 2014
Health Care Ethics & Law
Robert Smiles

It’s Your Gavel…..Chance of Survival Diminished

In the case of its Your Gavel, Chance of Survival Diminished, is about Mrs. Ard’s views of what she went through the night of May 20th, in regards to her husband, Mr. Ard’s care. The story states Mrs. Ard account of the night, and the documentation that supports her story as well. Mr. Ard did not survive from the experience at the hospital, and Mrs. Ard believes the hospital is at fault. According to the Standard of care provided by the nurse standards, the care Mr. Ard was given was below standard (2012).
Mrs. Ard’s Case In the case of its Your Gavel, Chance of Survival Diminished,
…show more content…
The care for MR. Ard was below standard of care. Mrs. Ard’s testimony of what happened the night of the 20th collaborates with the nurses logs of when Mr. Ard was checked on. The nurses brought in to speak as expert witness both agree that the care was below standard of care and steps were skipped in assessing Mr. Ard’s care. The nurse was contributory negligent. “A person who is negligent when that person does not exercise reasonable care for his or her safety, thus contributing to any injury sufferer” (Pozgar, 2012, pg. 125). The nurse was aware of Mr. Ard’s issues in the doctor’s notes, she was also made aware through constant calling from the wife of Mr. Ard, and not responding in a timely manner. According to Pozgar, the nurse did not have to be directly aware of the issues that may happen, but aware that something might happen and to keep an eye on the patient in case it did (2012). The Judgment by the court was granted towards Mrs. Ard in wrongful death, and I agree.
Conclusion
The negligence produced by the nurse in the care of Mr. Ard was below standard of care, which resulted in the loss of a life. There’s no evidence of what stresses the nurse might have been going through with the shortages of nurses and extra duties that may have been a part of nurses jobs currently. The lack of care Mr. Ard was given without proper protocol could have been prevented if proper steps were taken with his care, and proper attention was

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Although happened 2 years ago, the case remained controversial till today. People argue whether the nurse is liable for the patient’s death, what should have been done in the future and etc.…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    B) was brought into the emergency room for pain to left leg and left hip. The injury occurred when the patient had a fall due to him losing his balance after tripping over his dog. The hospital is a 60 bed rural hospital located in Mr. B’s hometown. Mr. B was brought in by his son and neighbor. Upon triage Mr. B was complaining of pain 10/10 on the numerical pain scale and his vitals were found to be stable. Mr. B has a history of impaired glucose tolerance, prostate cancer, and chronic pain which he is on oxycodone. The Patient states he had no known allergies or previous falls. Upon the nursing assessment Nurse J. has noticed that the patient has limited range in motion, his left leg has swelling and appears shortened in comparison to the right. Nurse J. has informed the ED physician which he came to his bedside for…

    • 2877 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A patient came into the hospital after suffering a head injury. While receiving care, the patient was misdiagnosed with a concussion, but admitted for observation. The Duty of Care would fall on the attending physician who was responsible for providing an appropriate diagnosis for the patient. Throughout the night, the patient was not routinely monitored and because of this, the hospital staff failed to acknowledge signs that his condition was deteriorating. The patient was found in a coma when the next shift came in. The Breach of Duty would have to be the staff that failed to monitor the patient during his stay as his conditioned worsened. The injury that was sustained by the patient was irreversible brain damage. Causation is present…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    RTT Role of Organizations

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The problem statement is that Mr. B was overmedicated , and went into respiratory arrest which lead to brain death and his eventual death. The key people involved in this event were the Emergency Department Doctor, Dr. T., the ER nurse J., and the LPN. A thorough assessment was neglected to have been performed in triage. They failed to ask Mr. B. if he had taken any medications prior to this arrival, and they did not question his reactions to medications, especially to his home pain medication Oxycodone. After the initial administration of the I.V. diazepam with the hydromorphone, the ER doctor should have waited an additional 10 to 15 minutes before administrating another dose since Mr. B. has built up a tolerance to opiod medications from taking Oxycodone for his chronic back pain. The the nurse and the ER doctor both failed to take into consideration the half life and the duration of the drug, which can take up to three hours. When Mr. B's oxygen saturation went down to 92 the nurse failed to monitor his…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Patient X walked into the ER, dressed himself in a hospital gown, and became suddenly unresponsive. After regaining consciousness, he was admitted to the intensive care unit. Nurse A noticed that patient X’s temporal artery was in a rapid spasm, presented with right sided weakness, poor muscle control, and was bradycardic. Nurse A notified Nurse B of the symptoms, concerned that this was an acute, high stakes situation indicating neurological involvement. The physician began an assessment and asked Nurse A what she witnessed. Nurse A presented the patient’s symptoms and stated a concern with the neurological presentation of patient X. The physician turned to the patient care assistant (PCA) and stated he did not see anything wrong and asked…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jones is a 87 year old male who arrived to the emergency department via ambulance. Mr. Jones neighbor called the ambulance after he fell and hit his head. Mr. Jones had a small laceration to his head that the neighbor felt might need stitches. Mr. Jones is the primary care giver of his 84 year old wife who suffers from dementia. On arrival to the emergency room Mr. Jones is agitated and insistent that he is discharged. Mr. Jones stated that he needed to be home with his wife and he did not need to see a doctor. The nurse was able to settle Mr. Jones down by talking about his wife and their relationship. She proceeded to clean up his head laceration and it was determined that he did not need sutures. The nurse learned that Mr. Jones had two children and was able to contact his daughter. Mr. Jones daughter arrived at the hospital to take her father…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many of the civil cases against these nurses are connected to issues of neglect and are settled out of court without having to go to trial, making it hard to find documented details of the case later on. The finding of liability in a civil case does not demand evidence of meaning to do harm, but rather, failure to meet the measure of care of another levelheaded school nurse in the same situation. Of cases decided in court, common causes of liability include failures to (1) complete a sufficient evaluation, (2) get involved professionally in crisis and (3) record data of proper nursing care. Added causes of liability include failures to keep the clinical records current, follow the school district guidelines, appoint carefully and make sure the communication with parents is always there(sunrise river press,…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The nurses mistreatment was brought upon the fact the patient had seen an image of her husband. Seeing her husband was most likely brought upon by the patient’s disability. Unfortunately, the nurses had no compassion. The…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Patient A is a female white 38 year old G1P0 with Type I diabetes since the age of 9. Due to her high risk pregnancy and history of non compliance with medical therapy she had been coming in since 28 weeks gestation for twice weekly non stress tests. One Saturday as patient A was at the hospital for her non stress test she was found to have elevated blood pressure and proteinuria. Dr. A, an obstetrician (OB), who was on call for the weekend decided to send the patient home on bed rest and to follow up with her primary OB physician, Dr. B on Monday. At her follow up appointment with her primary OB, she was found to still have elevated blood pressures, blood sugars in 200 's, 2+ protein in her urine and had some elevated blood work. Primary OB decided Patient A needed to be induced due to patient A’s unstable condition. Primary OB is not on call this particular Monday and asked Dr. C to induce her patient. Dr. C was not happy about inducing her because of her high risk status but agreed to do so. Dr. D, a laborist and pediatrician, wanted the patient transferred to a higher level of care facility because he felt due to patient A’s history best care for the newborn would be at another facility. Dr. D and Dr. C argued about patient A’s care and disposition at the nurses’ station which was in close proximity to patient A’s room. The nurses who were without a manager at the time were unable to control the altercation between Dr. C and Dr. D. Patient A who overheard the discussion eventually asked to be transfer to another hospital to seek care elsewhere.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Croke, E.M. (2006). Nursing Malpractice: Determining Liability Elements for Negligent Acts. Journal of Legal Nurse Consulting, 3-24.…

    • 2093 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Please dont let me die

    • 559 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Situations can change very quickly, especially within a healthcare facility. The nursing staff within a nursing home carries the responsibility of always watching and monitoring the environment to assure the residents are comfortable and cared for in the home. The ethical problem in “Please Don’t Let Me Die” case is malpractice. The nursing staff neglected to care for a patient noticeably in need and continually asking for help. Additionally, the three registered nursed were negligent. The two nurses found culpable in Loren Richard’s death had not successfully overseen the nursing staff to assure the team was following the standard of care. Regardless to the state of the floor prior to the three nurses taking a break, the registered nurses are responsible for the coverage of the floor and care for the patients for the duration of their break. If I had been one of the three registered nurses I would have been mindful of my responsibility and would have scheduled the breaks at different times to assure at least one registered nurse was present on the floor at all times. Additionally, I would have responded to Loren Richard’s cries for help and helped him get the necessary treatment.…

    • 559 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    After reviewing the case study of Nursing Malpractice in a Mental Health Setting. There are many different factors that had led to the unfortunate death of this child. I would begin with inaccurate documentation of this child severe airway disease, as being listed as mild reactive airway disease. Later, after developing symptoms of an increased cough and wheezing without the presents of a fever, the nursing staff dismissed it as his attempt to avoid group therapy. The next situation that is concerning is that he had requested to be taken to the emergency room for treatment and made a statement of “You’re going to kill me” and was told by the nurse “that he doesn’t need further treatment” and had referred to his outburst as attention seeking…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    A 55 year old patient admitted for chest pain and on telemetry monitoring. This patient requested for shower, a nurse removed his telemetry and was ask to assist the patient during shower, but the patient insisted to shower on his own. Then the nurse left the patient alone without instructing him to call for help if he felt any discomfort. After a while, the nurse went back to check, patient was…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are two defendants in this case are the family practice physician and the nurse practitioner. Both healthcare professionals impacted the outcome of this case through an act of omission; therefore, the healthcare professionals failed to act when there was a duty to act as a reasonable and prudent person (Law.com, n.d.). According to Pozar (2016), failure to act when there is a duty to act in a similar circumstance is considered nonfeasance which is a form of negligence.…

    • 79 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Four Patterns of Knowing

    • 260 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mr. John was a 70 year old male, 170 lbs, 5'4" with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). He had a smoking history. He was transferred from the hospital to the Nursing home before six months. He had a history of congestive heart disease and osteoarthritis. When I assessed him, he had a weak but persistent cough, and midsternal chest pain from coughing. He had an elevated temperature and Oxygen saturation was 89%. Other vital signs were stable. He had a dry skin, redness, and irritation of nose, and throat. He did not want to wear his breathing mask, and refused to get out of bed from the last two days. I was called to the nursing station by one of the social workers working that morning. When I arrived to the nursing station, Social worker voiced her concern that patient family wanted to transfer him to the home. Before I discussed with family, I decided to check the Physician Order Sheet (POS) so I could understand this case better and try to solve the situation in the best way possible. After checking the documentation, I decided to schedule a meeting with his wife, and she expressed a concern that she is not able to provide enough time. The John was independent before the situation. John was very active. He was involved in different activities conducted by activity members. When I was making a final round before my end of the shift, I felt, John was very frustrated because he wasn’t able to get out of bed due to…

    • 260 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays