Preview

Bystander Effect and High Density Cities

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2528 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Bystander Effect and High Density Cities
As you wait to cross the street, a blind man is standing in front of you. Without warning, he begins to cross the street even though the light has not changed in his favor. He seems to be in no danger until you see a car about a half mile away speeding towards him. Totally unaware of the situation, the man continues walking across the street. As you and many others watch in horror he is struck by the car. Although every single one of you had plenty of time to rescue him, you just watched, hoping that someone else would do it. After all, you don't know him so it's really none of your business. This is what is referred to as "bystander apathy". People close enough to see, hear and possibly touch one another are socially distant and totally indifferent to the fact that another human being may be dying, in immediate danger, or asking for help. This extremely sad urban problem is just that- a problem of cities. The likelihood of this occurring increases with the number of people present and it is probable that there will be many people to witness an event when it happens in high density cities. Urban sociologists, social psychologists, and criminologists have argued for years that the size of cities is directly related to the amount of "social pathology" they contain. The legal consequences are not severe. Unless an individual is a certified medical doctor, they have no obligation in Alberta to help anyone in need. So generally, they don't. The personal consequences may be more severe. Feelings of guilt and regret may follow an event, especially if it ends fatally or if the individual feels that they could have done something significant. Because of this, people attempt to convince themselves and others that they were justified in their inaction because "it wasn't their place", "I didn't want to do it alone", or "I didn't want to get involved." Excuses like this often stem from fears of being seen as abnormal, possible physical harm, public embarrassment, possible

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    understand the failure of bystanders to intervene. The chapter also touches the effect on front…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Levitt and Dubner begin an argument with a murder crime of a woman called Kitty Genovese. Genovese was attacked by a man in a residential area and died because of the bystander effect. As New York newspaper reported, 38 people saw the murder but no one called the police or stop the assailant. This murder case astonished so many people and some people blamed the 38 residents, thought they're indifferent. Then, writers mention the rise of crime in the USA and analyze three reasons of this situation: the policy of releasing prisoners, post-war baby boom and violent TV show. (98-99) When I read this case, I feel angry about the 38 residents and think they're indifferent. At the same time, I also wonder why the residents are so apathetic. Maybe they thought other people will help Genovese; maybe they didn't…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short stories “The Pedestrian” and “The Whole Towns Sleeping” by Ray Bradbury the idea of conformity is shown with the usage of characterisation in the short story “The Whole Town’s sleeping” with the characterisation of Lavinia Nebss. Similarly in the short story “The Pedestrian” the usage of imagery is portrayed through the description of the deserted town and the enslavement of people due to the introduction of television to present the idea of conformity.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    people’s cars if they parked on the side streets….” This shows the lack of safety present…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Seattle Windshield Epidemic reflects the collective delusion that can exist in society. In reality, approximately 4,000 cars had their windshields pitted. The media influenced everyone to believe that it was an issue, by drawing their attention towards it. Pitting of windshields is common, therefore should be expected. The questions arises as to how one can know, without looking. By drawing attention to the already pitted windshields, people witnessed damages they’ve never seen before. Seattle citizens misconstrued the new found information with an existing problem that they were facing. Considering how many people had their windows pitted, you begin to notice how blown out of proposition this is. The media quantified the situation…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Glasgow 5th March Analysis

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is noted that it is a 'sharp clear night' and a street as big as Sauchiehall Street should be well lit but still the drivers pass by and ignore what they see. It has been said that 'there's no such thing as an innocent bystander'; I think that this is what Edwin Morgan is trying to point out to us. He is reflecting on how more people in this 'high-tech' age are forgetting that there are people around them that feel the same things that they do. A lot of people live one-track lives and do not look to either side to help others; just like the drivers who 'keep their eyes on the road' and refuse to look to the pavement and help the young people who are so obviously in trouble. I feel sorry for the couple, anger towards the youths and annoyance with the two drivers.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    While reading “Thirty-Eight Who Saw Murder Didn't Call the police”, I knew that the people did not bother on calling the police. Honestly, I was impressed by this story because now and days people still do this. I started to pretend I was in this story because the author wanted his audience to have a click while reading. While I was imagining to be a character in this story, I wanted to be that person were to call the police right away and help that victim. This story have caught my attention throughout the story. I really wanted to add details to this because it was interesting to know that people around us won't step up for help for other. When the victim was getting attack by the stalker, this guy came out of his window saying “Let the girl alone” (128) to the stalker and the person who call out to that stalker just went back to sleep. I wanted to scream at that person because he told the stalker to let her go but he did not bother calling the police because he was tried. I wanted to asked that person if he was the victim and his neighbor tried helping him by saying “let him go'', would you be so angry that no one bother to call the cops on you. I would rather help the victim by calling the cops , instead of tons of guilt when I don't save that person. Thirty-Eight who saw the crime should have helped her by calling the cops because it is much better to feel care to other. If they care, the next something goes wrong they can be heroes like the same way they did to that victim. This people that called the police at the last minute felt like they were in a movie were their role was to be silent when a stranger tries to attack a victim and they will pretend that they did not know it was a bad situation. The author, Martin Gansberg wants to make a point were we help others and they can do the same actions as we did. He wanted us to know that stepping…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, people should be required by law to offer assistance to victims in need. Assisting people is part of human nature, and our laws should reflect on our human character. Human beings have a duty to assist people in need, but they must remember to put their needs above the needs of others. Albeit the arguments of many people in need, Good Samaritans were present from the beginning of mankind, continued until the Bibilical times, and still continue to this…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The routine and everyday problems and needs make people go around without noticing what they are surrounded by, simply seeing it as obstacles on the way to their destinations or just a means to get there. While analyzing how people see their surroundings de Botton on his essay states that, " A bus, which we might at first have viewed as aesthetically or mechanically or as a springboard to thoughts about communities within cities, becomes simply a box to move us as rapidly as possible across an area which might as well not exist, so unconnected is it to our primary goal, outside of which all is darkness, all is invisible" (63). There are a lot of things to be noticed around a city or just a street, but people often just focus on their objective and forget about anything that will not be part of that goal so they just do not see anything else. Things like a bus or a train are seen as nothing else than a tool to reach the a certain destination when it could represent a lot more if seen for another point of view like for example the opportunity of meeting the members of the neighborhood. The “primary goal” or what people are trying to accomplish makes them blind of simple things like their community or just how the bus or the street looks like. De Botton gives another example of how people ignore what is around them when he says “The power of my…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    On a humid summer day in Chicago, my family and I decided to take a long journey to visit my distant family/friend in the Upper East Side of Chicago. Although, the car ride seemed peaceful and smooth, little did I know this was a journey to the most horrific town I’ve ever seen.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What gives a bully power? What allows a murder to take place in broad daylight without any intervention from those looking on? What makes a country silent as millions of its citizens are sent to their death under the command of a tyrant? The answer to all these questions is a phenomenon known as the Bystander Effect, in which people are less likely to come to the aid of someone in distress when there are others present. This attitude is born when one believes that other passersby will provide help to the victim, and therefore he or she has less responsibility to intervene. While already unethical when practiced by an individual, it is when this passivity is adopted by an…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    All across the world, there are many events that get overlooked by thousands of people. Most people believe that being the bystander of something is okay. Being in between the wrong and the Wright (indifference) is still wrong because not doing something makes things worse and just standing there watching what is going on creates more problems.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The bystander effect or Genovese syndrome denotes a scenario where a victim in an emergency situation is not offered any help by the surrounding individuals, even though they are aware that the victim needs help. The presence of other bystanders greatly reduces the likelihood of intervention. The more bystanders present, the less likely any one of them will assume responsibility for taking action to help the victim. The bystander effect happens quite often independently of culture, gender or age and it is very unfortunate as if it didn’t happen, lives could be saved, and crimes could be avoided. The bystander effect could happen for three main reasons which are the pluralistic ignorance, the social inhibition, and the diffusion of responsibility.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Individual in Groups

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I think Travris hits the nail on the head when she states that people, “if they are in a group observing the same danger, they hold back.” It reminds me of an article I read in the “New York Times” a couple of months ago. It reported that a Chinese girl was found raped and brain dead on the main street in Flushing. It was 2:30pm. What shocked me was that the surveillance tape which was taken by the supermarket nearby showed that there were several witnesses who saw the tragedy as it was happening. However, no one intervened or even called the police until the criminal ran away. In fact, they “hold back”. Later on, when a reporter interviewed one of those witnesses, he claimed that he thought there must have been someone who had already called for help and he felt terrible that he did not call the police at that time. After I read “Individuals in Groups,” I could not help wondering whether the tragedy would have happened at all if there was only one person who had witnessed the accident.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Trolley Problem

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Supposing I observed a runaway train at the rail-yard and if it continues hurtling in the direction it is going, it will kill five people. Luckily for me, I’m standing next to a power switch and if I pull the lever of the switch, the train will divert into a different track. However, there is one person working on this track and if I pull the switch, that rail worker will die. Here’s what I would do. I would in fact pull the lever of the switch to spare the lives of the five people working in the rail-yard. The reason to that is even though it is not my obligation and my right to be a “hero” and the fact that I wasn’t given permission to do what I just did, the fact is five lives are greater than one. There are a lot of scenario’s that could happen if I did or didn’t pull the switch. One of the scenario’s is that I could ask myself “How would I warn the six workers that a runaway train has escaped and is in full pursuit of damaging property or damaging the lives of the six workers all together working”? “Would yelling from the top of my lungs be as effective as going into a building owned by the rail yard hysterically yelling out for help that I spotted a runaway train in full speed? The logic may be the person I’m yelling out for help to may think I’m crazy and delusional or he may follow me out to the rail yard to physically show him what I saw. Regardless of the logic and scenario, had I not pulled the switch to divert the train, I probably would have lived with guilt and regret not saving anyone’s lives that was at stake, especially the one person that was working on the track of where I diverted the train to go to after I pulled the switch.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays