Bpo Philippines
Philippine Management Review 2006, Vol. 13, pp. 1-20.
INDUSTRY REPORT: THE PROBLEM OF SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE IN PHILIPPINE CALL CENTERS Aileen S. Alava*
Facing high expectations as the newest “sunshine industry”, the call center industry in the Philippines appears to have dimmer prospects in the coming years. Having experienced rapid growth from 2000 to 2003, the industry experienced a slowdown in growth from 2004 to 2006, raising the question of how sustainable the country’s competitive advantage is against neighboring competitors such as India and China. This paper uses Porter’s Diamond Model to analyze the factors resulting in competitive advantage between nations, and provides industry player and market information on the Philippine call center industry, as well as updates on how the industry’s participants are seeking to address the industry’s challenges.
I. INTRODUCTION The call center industry is heralded as the newest sunshine industry in the country, earning around US$1.8 billion in 2005 alone, with revenues forecasted to reach US$5.3 billion by year 2010. Employment for this sector has more than doubled every year, from 2,400 agents in 2000 to 150,000 in 2006, and is expected to reach 300,000 full-time employed agents in 2010. The Philippines is among the top locations in the world for outsourced call centers. An SGV industry report states that in 2005, the Philippines’ share of the global call center market is 3% and 31% for the Asia Pacific market. By 2010, industry leaders target 6% global market share and 51% Asia Pacific market share.
II. FRAMEWORK AND METHODOLOGY
What will give Philippine call centers an advantage over call centers in other countries, such as those in India, China, Malaysia, Singapore? Michael Porter‘s Diamond Model defines competitive advantage between nations as the outcome of four interlinked factors: 1) firm strategy, structure and rivalry; 2) demand conditions; 3) related supporting industries; and 4)
INDUSTRY REPORT: THE PROBLEM OF SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE IN PHILIPPINE CALL CENTERS Aileen S. Alava*
Facing high expectations as the newest “sunshine industry”, the call center industry in the Philippines appears to have dimmer prospects in the coming years. Having experienced rapid growth from 2000 to 2003, the industry experienced a slowdown in growth from 2004 to 2006, raising the question of how sustainable the country’s competitive advantage is against neighboring competitors such as India and China. This paper uses Porter’s Diamond Model to analyze the factors resulting in competitive advantage between nations, and provides industry player and market information on the Philippine call center industry, as well as updates on how the industry’s participants are seeking to address the industry’s challenges.
I. INTRODUCTION The call center industry is heralded as the newest sunshine industry in the country, earning around US$1.8 billion in 2005 alone, with revenues forecasted to reach US$5.3 billion by year 2010. Employment for this sector has more than doubled every year, from 2,400 agents in 2000 to 150,000 in 2006, and is expected to reach 300,000 full-time employed agents in 2010. The Philippines is among the top locations in the world for outsourced call centers. An SGV industry report states that in 2005, the Philippines’ share of the global call center market is 3% and 31% for the Asia Pacific market. By 2010, industry leaders target 6% global market share and 51% Asia Pacific market share.
II. FRAMEWORK AND METHODOLOGY
What will give Philippine call centers an advantage over call centers in other countries, such as those in India, China, Malaysia, Singapore? Michael Porter‘s Diamond Model defines competitive advantage between nations as the outcome of four interlinked factors: 1) firm strategy, structure and rivalry; 2) demand conditions; 3) related supporting industries; and 4)
References: A. T. Kearney (2007 & 2005). Global services location index. Balfour, F. (2003, February 3). The way,way back office. Business Week. Bharadwaj, G., Varadarajan, P. & Fahy, J. (1993). Sustainable competitive advantage in service industries: a conceptual model and research propositions. Journal of Marketing, 57(4), p. 83. Business Process Association of the Philippines, http://bpap.com.ph Board of Investments, http://boi.gov.ph Call Center Directory, http://callcenterdirectory.net Callcentres.net. 2006 Asian contact center industry benchmarking report. Contact Center World. http://contactcenterworld.com Cruz, Dennis H. (1981, October) A review of international subcontracting arrangements in the Philippine electronics (semiconductor) industry, October 1981. Department of Trade and Industry. http://dti.gov.pg Domingo, G. (2005, April 11). BOI, BPAP, CICT: What roles they play. Computer World. Domingo, G. (2005, March 7). Why we rate poorly in technology in global competitive surveys. Computer World. 20 INDUSTRY REPORT: THE PROBLEM OF SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE IN PHILIPPINE CALL CENTERS Frost & Sullivan (2005, December 20). Assessment of the Asia Pacific contact center markets. Hookway, J. (2004, October 7). The services spin-off. Far Eastern Economic Review. IBON Databank Phil, Inc. (1990). The semiconductor industry. Institute for Developmental and Econometric Analysis, Inc. Call center industry and the Philippine economy. Lecture delivered at the UP School of Economics. March 2006. International Customer Management Institute. http://www.incoming.com IT Matters. http://itmatters.com.ph McDougall, P. (2004, January 26). Automation takes toll on offshore workers. Information Week. NOTES 1 Selection of the ten top call center companies is arbitrary and not based on an objective ranking of financial performance. The subset was intended to illustrate industry concentration: how a small minority of ten call centers have contributed significantly more revenues to the sector than the other 138.