Beethoven gives it to the listener up front: the four-note motive upon which the entire symphony is based (short-short-short-long). You can't help but get chills when a brief pause before the recapitulation …show more content…
The same melodies are almost the same in both scherzo sections, however, the variation comes from the dynamics and tone color. Section A starts very bold, B seems hasty to me, then A' comes in very dark. I found the transition returning to the scherzo very sneaky: sections of the orchestra fall away until only the flute is left descending from a high-pitched solo, which is handed off to the clarinet, then to the low strings. It is an excellent lead-in which continues through the remainder of the 3rd movement. Initially I felt as if this movement was just one large transition from the 2nd movement to the 4th because although the original four-note motive was stated by the horns around 0:19, it didn't seem to be developed any further here (Forney 185). However, upon further review I now believe that the lifting phrases of the “rocket theme” (Fillerup) in the scherzo section are actually a variation of the four-note