Accountant's Liability to Third Parties

Topics: Supreme Court of the United States, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Enron Pages: 19 (7118 words) Published: March 2, 2008
Table of Contents


Accountants' Liability to the Client and Third-Party
A)Breach of Contract
B)Ordinary Negligence (Accountant Malpractice)
a.Constructive Fraud (Gross Negligence)
b.Actual Fraud

Accountants' Liability under Common Law for Third-Party
A)The Near-Privity Doctrine
B)The Restatement Doctrine
C)The Foreseeability Doctrine
D)The Balancing-Factors Doctrine

Accountants' Liability under Statutory Law – Third-Party
A)Securities Act of 1933
B)Securities Exchange Act of 1934
C)The Sarbanes Oxley Act
D)The RICO Act

Accountants' Deep Pockets


Works Cited

This research paper analyzes the degree of an auditor's liability to clients and third parties under applicable law. Specifically, it focuses on accountants in their professional role engaged by contract to express an opinion about a company's financial statements and the professional commitment to exercise due care in providing those services. An accountant's failure to comply with the promised obligations can result in the accountant being held liable to clients for fraud, negligence, and breach of contract. In some cases, accountants may have a potential legal obligation to third parties as a result of not following established professional standards. Accountant liability for the most part is based on contract, common and statutory law. Section 2 discusses the degree of liability accountant's face under a negligence standard. When an accountant performs work for a client a contract of employment is created, usually called an "engagement letter." The engagement letter specifies the work to be performed and the compensation to be paid. Because an accountant is an agent of his/her client, agency law also applies to the relationship. Under agency law, the accountant owes his/her client important duties, including competence in performing the work. The standard of competence used by the court is that of a reasonably competent accountant, which is a negligence standard. Most courts agree that a reasonably competent accountant will follow the principles of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) and Generally Accepted Accounting Standards (GAAS). Accountants also are subject to common law liability, particularly claims of negligence and fraud. If an accountant fails to exercise the degree of care of a reasonably competent accountant, and as a result he/she issues incorrect financial information, he or she faces claims of negligence. Fraud occurs when an accountant issues false financial information with the knowledge that it is false and with intent to deceive someone. The degree of liability the law imposes on accountants varies by the nature of the negligent act. For example, an accountant's error may constitute breach of contract, ordinary negligence, or Fraud which include constructive fraud and Actual Fraud. Section 3 of the paper addresses the four main doctrines of accountant liability under the common law: (1) The Ultramares Doctrine; (2) The Restatement of Torts Section 552; (3) the Foreseeability doctrine and (4) the balancing-factors doctrine. The tort of negligence against an accountant is a dangerous legal theory of liability, because there can be more than one or two plaintiffs. Under contract liability, only the client or an intended third party can claim contract liability, and the amount of the loss and the accountant's liability are limited. However, under the theory of negligence, an entire class of claimants, potentially numbering in the hundreds, may be able to assert liability. This concern for imposing mass liability on an accountant and its potential to destroy the accountant and the firm, led to the Supreme Court decision in Ultramares v. Touch in 1931. The Ultramares doctrine stems from the rule created by this case, stating that mass liability should not apply to accountants and only the client and an intended third party could hold an...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Third Party Liability in Audit Essay
  • 12 Accountant's : Iability to Third Party Essay
  • Auditor's and Director's Liability to Third Party Essay
  • Essay on Auditors Third Party Liability
  • Third Partys Essay
  • Essay about Assignment 2.4
  • “Advise the parties as to their criminal liability, if any”. Essay
  • Essay about Liability

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free