Preview

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
579 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
Should Australians Apologize to the
Stolen Generation?

A difficult issue that is facing society is whether or not Australians should apologize to the Stolen Generation. The Stolen Generation is the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children who were forcibly taken away from their families. This took place in 1909 until 1969. Governments, churches, and welfare bodies all took part in the event (Reconciliaction, 2012). They were then placed into institutional care with non-Indigenous families and were expected to work as labourers and servants. While many records have been lost, it has been that 100,000 children were taken during this period (Reconciliaction, 2012). Although some people think Aboriginal people are better off because they were removed from dysfunctional families, I believe Australians should apologize for three main reasons.

The first and most important reason why Australians should apologize to the Aboriginal people is that apologizing will restore their dignity and identity back. An apology can serve as an expression of regret for pain and suffering of the children who had been physically and sexually abused. A mere example of abusing of the Stolen Generation is the case of Valerie Linow, a domestic servant for a white family. Valerie (2012) informed, “He yelled out to me, ‘Get inside!’ And the next minute, he just belted me. He yelled and had this fence wire and just belted me across my legs and I doubled up. Today, I still wear marks here on the top of my legs ‘cause I was doubling up trying to protect myself.” By apologizing, victims of the Stolen Generation can know the government and the people acknowledge their pain. The Stolen Generation can realize that their well-being are recognized to the community. Clearly, having their dignity and identity restored is an important matter to the Stolen Generation.

The second reason to apologize is that an apology can have a positive impact on the relationship between

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    When the stolen generation was occurring only half-cast children were taken. Half-cast meaning one parent was white and the other was Aboriginal. Only half-cast children were taken because they believed that they could soon eradicate the culture and colour out of the young children. The children that were stolen were brought up in white communities and taught not to follow the aboriginal culture. Most were put into foster homes and used as servant and others were put into missions. Many we exposed to abuse. Acquiring this topic will teach us so much about how the government had a faux pas.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the period of approximately from 1910 to 1970 the abduction of aboriginal children was a commonality. With the goal of bettering the lives of the aboriginal savages, up to 100.000 aboriginal children were abducted and put in either foster families or special aboriginal orphanages. But at the start of the 70’ies the program was abandoned was it because of the increased public awareness or because of the utter failure of the program I cannot say. But fact is that the practice has been abolished. Now 40 years later the debate is still raging as to the morality of this program. And while the government made a formal apology back in 2008, is it something that is actually pardonable? Is it possible to forgive the people behind the abduction of a so called Stole Generation (or two to be exact)? Can…

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    They placed children under the care of Europeans because they thought this would mean “advancing” the aboriginal children. However, many Aborigines are still searching for their children, mothers and other family members. Through this forced separation many aboriginal people have struggled in life, experienced low-self esteem, feeling of worthlessness, social dysfunction, high rates of unemployment and ongoing health issues. This loss if identity can result in depression and other mental illness (Creative Spirit…

    • 1625 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Noel Pearson

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Noel Pearson’s speech, ‘An Australian History for us All,’ explores the divides between our community and the issues that prevent us as a nation from achieving reconciliation. Ultimately, throughout his exordium Pearson is excessively humble, ‘it is my honour to have been invited… Alas, I cannot promise my teacher’s rigour ,’ this diminution of his prominent political position equalises Pearson with his audience. He successfully characterises himself as being selflessly modest, a successful tool in capturing our attention, his choice to do this in the exordium is also an example of kairos, his appealing attitude is naturally attractive, guaranteeing our fixated attention throughout the duration of his speech. Pearson additionally employs a variety of quotes to both enforce his credibility and portray society’s ignorant attitude towards reconciliation. We see this when he quotes Professor Bill Stanner, the ‘Great Australian Silence,’ becomes a metaphor of our refusal to address the Aboriginal struggle on a national level, objectifying the Australian nation as absent minded. Furthermore, Pearson makes noticeable appeals to pathos and logos, encouraging an emotional and logical response identifiable by all of us. Pearson in his battle for reconciliation, provides syllogistic reasoning and structure on solving the inherent ‘guilt’ issue, ‘it is not about guilt. It is about opening our hearts a little bit… and to have an open and generous heart…means that when you acknowledge the wrongs of the past, you might try to do so ungrudgingly… there must be some respect for that.’ Additionally, the inclusive pronouns that Pearson employs in this statement make his proposed solution exclusive, applying to both indigenous and non indigenous peoples as such he unites his audience, generating logos through the universal nature and structural flow of his statement. Additionally, Pearson goes on to compare the reasoning he provides to the internationally notorious issue of Jewish…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism In The Sapphires

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page

    The strong presence of racism among Australian communities as depicted in the film caused such events, namely the Stolen Generation, to occur. This significant event was a period in late 1800s-1960s where children from both Indigenous, and non-Indigenous (i.e. ‘white’) origins were forcefully taken away from their families as a result of official Australian Government policy. In relation to the film, Gail’s recall of a bitter memory associated with Kay particularly sheds light upon this key historical event.…

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    the Stolen Generation refers to the generations of Aboriginals being forcefully taken from their families and put in camps or European homes. Europeans believed they needed to educate aboriginals in the western culture thus causing a ripple effect for millions of aboriginal and/ or Torres Strait Islanders to come. Aboriginals were ripped of their independence, culture, land and freedom. Due to this the ‘Stolen Generations’ has impacted current health and wellbeing of Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander communities, families and individuals. The spirituality, emotional, physical, and mental part of wellness was crushed in the Stolen Generation. Many of the stolen generation agonize now over the trauma that became their childhoods. The wellness…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Stolen Generation describes the period of time in which the many Aboriginal children were forcibly removed from their families in order to discontinue the passing down of their culture, language and identity. These young children were sent to institutions or adopted by non-Indigenous families and received little to no form of education in comparison to the level of schooling offered to the white Australian children. Life was immeasurably harsh for the Aboriginal children as they were growing up within a society which taught them to believe their culture was nothing more than rubbish and were encouraged to deny their own heritage. This disabled their ability to flourish and explore their potential in the world due to their racial discrimination which vastly limited their future pathways as they…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Module B Speeches

    • 1177 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In his speech, Noel Pearson addresses the need to acknowledge the past mistreatment of Australian Aboriginals. As an Indigenous Australian politician, Pearson gave his speech at the Chancellor’s Club Dinner in the University of Western Sydney to advance equality of Aborigines. Pearson quickly introduces his purpose, “our popular understanding of the colonial past is central to the moral and political turbulence we are still grappling with as Australians”. The illustrative use of turbulence is used to highlight the prevalence of past disharmonies and he uses the inclusive pronoun “we” as a synecdoche for all Australians to unify the audience. By directly quoting authorities such as John Howard and Bill Stanner, Pearson supplements his ethos and strengthens his case by evaluating both sides of the situation. The metaphor, “cult of forgetfulness” has negative connotations in order to challenge the common social mindset regarding the recognition of the past and induce a desire for change. Pearson effectively uses a cumulative list, “You have taken from us not just our land and not just all of the icons of Indigenous Australia…” to illustrate past injustices. The diction is divisive between Indigenous and European Australians, but deliberate emphasis is placed on the past tense to suggest hope for the future. Thus Pearson…

    • 1177 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indigenous Australians are a prominently disadvantaged group that are subject to extreme discrimination impacting on their life’s. The Stolen generation had severe negative impacts on the victims of the stolen generation and has continued to negatively affect future generations. Further negative implications have stemmed from this extreme action. And it is the cause of many issues of inequality today among Indigenous Australians. This essay will define the stolen generation, outline and discuss the negative impacts that have stemmed from it and then link the impacts of assimilation to theories such as functionalist theory, structural, etc.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Module a Speeches Essay

    • 988 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Noel Pearson’s address rivets the need to recognize discrimination and seize responsibility for the mistreatment of Indigenous Australians in the name of justice and morality. In the promotion of these imperative values, he argues that the pathway to reconciliation requires an acknowledgement of the Aboriginal abuse that has created lasting effects, including the 1996 Wik Decision which inverted the previous success of the Mabo Case. Pearson reiterates the need to acknowledge the past, present and future by alluding to several figures such as then-Prime Minister, John Howard. He promotes justice though the misconception of guilt, repeated throughout the speech, by condemning the Prime Minister through his own words, ‘of course we treated Aboriginals very, very badly in the past –…

    • 988 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sitting in the lecture theatre and taking in all the information that was put forward, really opened my mind up to a lot of the horrific issues surrounding the Indigenous people of Australia. When first being exposed to the Stolen Generation, I didn’t know how to feel toward innocent children being taken away from their homes. This was done by social workers and police officers that would invade the homes of the Indigenous people for the removal of their children (Gerrett 2013). It was concluded in 1989 the national Indigenous survey on health found almost half (47%) of Aboriginal children had been forcibly removed from both their parents (Gerrett 2013). This left me in distress, that something like this could happen to innocent children and their families. When saying this, I’m not implying that there are no children in the Indigenous community that weren’t mistreated, but this too happens in other racial communities. It is seen that incidence of sexual abuse of minors is far more worrying in other communities other than the…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many Australians associate and put emphasis on the idea of reconciliation between indigenous Australians and non indigenous Australians with the federal governments formal reconciliation policy in 1991. However the events of symbolic reconciliation play an equal part if not more significant part of this reconciliation process by bridging the 'gap' between indigenous people and non indigenous people of Australia both in past and present times. Without these fundamental symbolic events of reconciliation it can be argued that the federal governments formal reconciliation policy and other practical reconciliation efforts may have never eventuated. This concept is elucidated in the text which not only highlights the value of these symbolic reconciliation…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beginning in 1910 and ending in the 1970s, Australians Federal and State government agencies and church missions made a policy to forcibly take many aboriginal and Torres Strait children away from their families in an attempt to destroy the Aboriginal race and culture. There was an impact on the aboriginals with a particular policy the Australian Government had introduced, which was the policy of ‘Assimilation’. This policy was to encourage many Aboriginal people to give up their culture, language, tradition, knowledge and spirituality to basically become white Australians. Unfortunately this policy didn’t give the Aboriginals the same rights as white Australians, as a result of discrimination, aboriginals were moved to live in special housing…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Aboriginal Issues

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Research Paper: Aboriginal issues Elisse Ostrovsky Multicultural countries such as Canada are designed with good intentions; uniting people of different cultures and giving refugees a safe place to live. Unfortunately this system creates inequality, often resulting with acts of discrimination within a society. The First Nations in particular have suffered from this and Aboriginal living has been made difficult by the Canadian society since the establishment of the state. At the present time, acts of discrimination toward Aboriginals have grown milder.…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Australian Aborigines

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Anthropology is the study of humanity. In Chapters 3 and 4 of the text we are learning about kinship system. In these selections I will focus on the Australian Aborigines culture. I will also concentrate on the Australian Aborigines and the three specific examples of how the kinship system of the chosen culture impacts the way the culture evolves. This paper will also show how the cultures compare to each other.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics