Men as Women Article #1 Outline
Hermaphrodite vs. Transsexual
* 19th century
* Genitals were ambiguous: a one-and-a half inch long penis, partly descended testicles, and a urethral opening. Has vulva, labia majora, and a feminine uretha. Never menstruated, no womb. Whole outer part of her body is that of a man. * Never felt socially accepted because he did not think a women would ever marry him. * No social status for a man-women at this time
* Committed suicide at 30
* What could have happened 100 years later?
* Gender reassignment surgery? With no gender reassignment surgery what sex might she be labeled as on her birth certificate? Emma
* Penis-like clitoris as well as a vagina.
* Raised as girl
* Had numerous relationships with women, married a man.
* Refused to have vaginal closure and live as a man because it would mean having to work and divorce. * Why was she so content with her lifestyle?
* Possibly because her gender identity was clearly that of a women Gender ambiguity and its acceptance in other cultures
* Dominican Republic- female at birth have gender masculinized * Adopt men’s identities and social roles despite being raised as girls * Culturally, the community recognized a third sex catagory * Name for this third gender: Guevedoces (Penis at 12), Machihembra (first women, then man), Guevotes (penis and eggs) Switching Genders
* Surgically altering their genitalia to fit their gender identity * Chromosomes remain the same
* Some indicate sense from an early age of being in the wrong body * “Strategies and rituals” to create a feminized self * Gender identity vs. Gender status in western culture vs. other cultures * Western culture= preoccupation with genitalia
* Cross Dressing- Since cross dressers can put on and take off gender by changing clothes, do they disrupt the conventional conflation of sex more than...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document