Civil Procedure notes- Joinder of Claims

Topics: Plaintiff, Pleading, Complaint Pages: 3 (696 words) Published: November 1, 2013
Civil Procedure
Joinder of Claims
Scope of dispute may expand, but most of the time we’re talking about the same parties and circumstances- relating back By Defendant- Counter claims Rule 13, compulsory v. permissive counterclaims, both parties believe they are the plaintiff- determined by who gets to court first Leave behind process of joining claims between exact same parties Plaintiff sues one or more defendants, someone realizes that missing or not having the right party members Rule 20(a)- Persons who may join or be joined

Mosley v. General Motors Corp.
Mosley and 9 other employees raise race discrimination and gender discrimination claims Federal questions in play- Federal Statutes 42 U.S.C. 2000e and 1981 Procedural Question- May all 10 Plaintiffs sue in same lawsuit? District court says no, must file 10 separate complaints. Court of Appeals reverses and remands the decision. The factor that unites all of the plaintiffs is that they were all under the same non-discriminatory contract The Union is not paying attention to race as it should- becomes a policy issue Question of law or fact common to all P’s

Point of case- not just a free for all, but same transaction or occurrence can be flexible Plaintiff could be biting off more than it can chew
Same transaction or occurrence can be very flexible- district and appeals courts in Mosley case had opposing rulings with different opinions Class action suits- example: drug commercials (suit includes everyone who has taken Zoloft); what makes it a class action versus a multiple plaintiff case is that we can’t reasonably identify everyone in the class with substantial certainty. Must have 1) numerosity and 2) so hard to identify. Class Action v. Mass Action

Permissive Joinder (of Multiple Defendants)- example: Speedway walkway collapse; Must be some kind of commonality 12(b)(7) defense: failure to join a necessary party
Rule 19: some people have to be parties in lawsuits:
Court can’t
Accord...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay about civil procedure:
  • Eeoc Claims Process and Civil Litigation Procedures Essay
  • Civil Procedure V. Criminal Procedure Essay
  • Civil Procedure Essay
  • Civil Procedure Reviewer Essay
  • Civil Procedure Case Digest Essay
  • Essay about Civil Procedure Outline
  • 16884062 Ateneo 2007 Civil Procedure Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free