Preview

A Man Without Words

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
822 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Man Without Words
Cholaki, Cassandra
ENGL 98R
11/29/12
A Man Without Words
In her book, “A Man Without Words,” Susan Schaller describes how the eighteenth century French philosophers continually exercised speculation as to how much of human nature was "given" and native, and how much was dependent on language and culture. She encountered Ildefonso, a Mexican Indian who lived in the most unique form of isolation, who was born deaf, and had never been taught even the most basic language. She set herself the challenge to make contact with this man, and introduce him to language. Ildefonso not only lacked any language but lacked any idea of language: he had no conception, at first, of what Schaller was trying to do, yet Ildefonso had a yearning to communicate and to be more than just himself in isolation. Inclusively, this book vividly conveys the challenges, frustrations, and the exhilaration of opening the mind of a congenitally deaf person to the concept of language.
I believe the topic that stuck out to me the most was mentorship—the mentoring of a language-less mind, while bringing forth the qualities of patience, persistence, and, eventually, growth in both Schaller and Ildefonso. The entirety of the text reflected Schaller’s predominant efforts of constant and continuous care for Ildefonso’s success, no matter how difficult their communication had been between each other. Additionally, through her mentorship, she not only talked about ASL but she also exemplified the hand forms and gestures in which she was teaching Ildefonso; therefore, the reader has an opportunity to learn from Schaller at the same time. This novel was easy and fun to read probably being because I was interested in the topic. Sign language has always been fascinating to me; I even took a class at Grossmont when I was in high school. Being interested in the topic made reading strategies easier to engage in while reading. Some of these strategies I used were asking questions, annotating in the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    I think that so far, the book is pretty good. It makes you want to keep reading, because it is about interesting things, but I find it very easy to read. This book…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis: In Ambrose Bierce’s “Chickamauga,” the deaf child depicts today’s society as individuals are ignorant during dark times because they are unaware of their surroundings until it affects them directly.…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this book, Deaf in America, by Carol Padden and Tom Humphries, the two authors wrote stories, jokes, performances, and experiences of Deaf people. They also wrote Deaf culture and Deaf people’s lives from various angles. This book is great navigator of Deaf world for hearing people and even Deaf people as me. There are several factors attracting reader. To begin with, I could learn about backgrounds of deaf people and hearing people. Authors wrote about a Deaf boy who was born into a deaf family. Until he discovered that a girl playmate in neighborhood was “hearing”, he didn’t notice about “Others”. Authors explained, “She was HEARING and because of this did not know how to SIGN; instead she and her mother TALK” (Chapter 1). This story strongly impressed me. I was born into a Deaf family too, but I grew up with hearing grandparents. In my childhood, I did intensive oral training with my grandparents. So, I can sign JSL and talk Japanese smoothly. Therefore I never felt emotion like this occasion, “Others” to hearing people. The next factor is difference of “Deaf” and “deaf”. For example, the capitalized “Deaf” people are not only “deaf” but also user of Sign Language. I haven’t known the meaning of “Deaf” and “deaf” exactly before, thanks to this book, now I can understand. When I analyzed myself, I identified as “Deaf” because I truly cherish Sign Language. In addition, Sign Language is explained as a primary mode of communication for Deaf people including me. It has full access to communication for us. Unfortunately, some hearing people misunderstand that Sign Language is a kind of gestural communication. Authors wrote about it, “ASL are often thought to be direct representations of spoken words” (Chapter 3). In my country, Japan, there are some misconceptions about JSL too. Sign Language has both iconic and abstract concept.…

    • 620 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Message To Garcia

    • 387 Words
    • 1 Page

    The book's short length makes it easy to read, but you have to read it slowly to understand…

    • 387 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Redefining D.E.A.F

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Being honest, from the very beginning of the movie my notions were challenged when I noticed that this video was going to be silent. It only happened to me for a couple seconds and then it became obvious to me that there was no other way to make a video about this matter than soundless. The video itself tries to make a statement to all the viewers so we can reflect on the previous perceptions and preconceptions that we have about the meaning of the word “deaf”. Moreover, it successfully proves that sing languages such as ASL are as valuable and eloquent as any other spoken or written language. In that nature, the video also intends that the movie becomes the grand opening of a series of other artistic production where sign language can be deeply explore and fully understand.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The deaf-mute John Singer could not communicate with most of the world because he couldn’t speak. He strove to break out of his isolated existence because he desperately needed to communicate his feelings with somebody who understood him. The isolation from which John Singer suffered was a combination of a personal individual control and environmental factors. John Singer, a tall man with gray eyes, and his friend Spiros Antonapoulos was an obese man of Greek descent. Both men were deaf and dumb and always together.…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Deaf Culture Book Report

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Thomas K. Holcomb’s book, Introduction to American Deaf Culture, shines a light on the deaf community and the culture they experience. The intended audience, however, is the hearing. It gives the reader insight on deaf experiences and how the atmosphere is different, even though the environment is the same. All aspects of culture are covered. The book starts off with how the culture is formed through the 5 hallmarks (p. 17). Next, the book focuses on the identity of a deaf person. This is not only limited to, labeling from the rest of the world, but also by how the person sees himself. After, the book discusses the core values the deaf community has. These values are much different when compared to the hearing community. They focus on the person engaging as a full member of society. This is done through communication, interacting, and having a sense of self-worth in the community (104-107). Eventually, literature and art are mentioned. The classifications are difficult to place. There are American works, but with the growing awareness in the recent year they have earned their own Deaf category. This is important to the deaf community because it allows “Deaf people’s lives to be better…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Inupiaq Culture

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page

    Language is the heart and the foundation of each culture, which means that if someone does not know it, they will not be able to thoroughly acknowledge their culture. To exemplify this, long ago the Inupiaq were Americanized and forced to have an education where they could not speak their native dialect. To this day, their generation of language is gradually diminishing with each passing second, minute, and hour. Accordingly, the Inupiaq people want to be able to speak their rightful tongue, but they could not connect with others. Despite the fact that this affects new generations, an idea formed that without language, it indicates that their interactions among people, nature, animals, and the universe is conflicted over time.…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    through deaf eyes

    • 311 Words
    • 1 Page

    Trough Deaf Eyes is a documentary outlining the history of the early deaf communities. The movie illustrates and touches the numerous achievements the deaf community has accomplished over the past years. It is startling to see and know the many obstacles that deaf citizens had to go through here in America to reach “acceptance”; this can almost be compared to years when African Americans were segregated. People these days might think that deaf citizens have it hard, but I’m pretty sure it is nothing compared to those years when it was punishable or looked down upon to use sign language to communicate with your family and friends. It is frustrating to know that deaf people were once forced to assimilate instead of just letting them sign. One of the movies speakers hints a good point when she shares that because she spent so much time learning how to assimilate words like “dog, cat, milk, and ext.” deaf people usually fell behind in their other topics. I can really relate to this and how frustrating it is because when I moved from Mexico to the U.S. I didn’t know any English at all. It was almost like being deaf because whenever I wanted to communicate to my teachers or fellow classmates most of my communication came from my hands since they all spoke mostly English and could not understand what I was saying or asking. Twice a week I was pulled out from my home classroom to go to another “special classroom” where another teacher would teach me English little by little along with another 5 other students. Thanks to that I also fell behind in my other school subjects in class; when it came down to grammar, reading, science, and cursive I sucked. Because of this small relation I found the movie to be really interesting.…

    • 311 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Amy Tan - Mother Tongue

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Amy Tan makes a valid point about the use of different Englishes that are spoken in different places and to certain people. What one says may sometimes vary based on the person, situation, or event as well. How one speaks and what they pick up on happens in the home and other people see them differently based on the way they speak. Different languages become difficult to translate as well because there isn’t always a similar word in the translating language. Many people can relate to this story in the aspect that everyone has their own way of speaking and others’ make them feel inferior with their speech. Some people may have difficulty saying certain words and those who speak well may downsize the verbally handicapped. This is a great essay that relates well to this day and time.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Man Without A Face

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Man without a Face is just another movie in the countless that illustrate the four major themes from the exodus story, slavery, exodus, covenant and Promised Land. In the beginning of the movie, the main character, Charles Norstadt. or Chuck feels a lack of freedom. He has a dysfunctional family with two annoying half-sisters from different fathers, and a mother who is on the brink of a fifth marriage. His mother tells him that marrying his father was a mistake, and he fails the exam to the boarding school he wanted to go to, and doesn't know who can help him study for the makeup exam.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He understood. He had forded the same river Helen Keller did at the water pump when she suddenly connected the water rushing over her hand with the word spelled into it. Yes, w-a-t-e-r and c-a-t mean something. And the cat-meaning in one head can join the cat-meaning in another's head just by tossing out a cat. . . . But a suddenly as he had asked for names, he turned pale, collapsed, and wept. . . . He had entered the universe of humanity, discovered the communion of minds. He now knew that he and a cat and a table all had names, and the fruit of his knowledge had opened his eyes to evil. He could see the prison where he had existed alone, shut out of the human race for twenty-seven years” (Schaller, 1991, pgs. 44-5). For me, this quote showed me that Ildefonso was able to learn. Proving that learning language after puberty could be possible and that not all who are languageless will stay that way.When I read this quote, my heart filled with joy knowing that Ildefonso, a 27 year old man, was learning about language and was understanding that words actually have a meaning. I think that many people do not understand how amazing it is to learn that language exists and that words can be connected to other words and that communication is…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discovering Language

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Discovering language Language is an essential part of human existence; we use language to express ourselves by labeling our thoughts with words, and symbols; in addition, language can also be a powerful tool to understand concepts, and ideas. In this essay will talk about the power of language how it breaks social barriers, and how it empowers people. Two influential people in the world relied on language to enlighten themselves with knowledge. Malcolm X the Black Muslim leader discovered how he can turn his life around, by learning language in his own term, second, a seven year old girl name Helen Keller conceived to learn language, despite of her disability. Language is an evolutionary marvel that became an essential tool to human survival. We use it to communicate and express our thoughts. However, it is a privilege to learn a language; like how it is a privilege to read and write, without either one, we struggle to get our ideas across to others. A person that is deprived of a proper education can feel lost, and confused. According to, Eschholz, Paul, Alfred Rosa, and Virginia Clark, Language Awareness. 10th ed. St. Martin: Bedford, 2009. Print. Malcolm X story reveals how he struggled to understand words and complex concept; without having a proper education he felt frustrated, not being able to express what he wanted to convey in letters, drove him to pick up a dictionary to educate himself. This shows the importance of language and its use. Therfore, without language, we strain in conveying our ideas making it hard for others to understand us. Malcolm X was born in a period where racial segregation was in a mist of change. As a child he was intelligent and a bright student, but a comment from one of his teachers about his future to be a lawyer was impossible, because he was black, led to him dropping out of junior high school. As he grew up Malcolm got involved in petty crimes that landed him in jail and one of those crime was a robbery that sentenced him…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mother Tongue

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is no doubt that language would be very useful to connect individuals into a community. However language is a double-edged sword, it also has a power that comes with a people alienated from the community. Obviously, Tan’s mother and I belong to the latter. I have the similar experience with this essay very much, because I can not control English skills very well, neither.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book was an easy read but rather uninteresting. I picked it because we were required to read in groups and someone else in the class was the only person who wanted to read it, but later I kind of regretted my choice.…

    • 1709 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays