top-rated free essay

Who Is Ultimately Responsible for the Tragedy of Macbeth

By noirevilla Jul 11, 2013 1540 Words
Vishavjit
Mr. Dietrich
ENG3U1
November, 17, 2012

Who is Ultimately Responsible for the Tragedy of Macbeth?

Macbeth was always a loyal man to his King, but when he knew he had the chance to get the kingdom he always wanted, he knew that he had to do everything he could to get it. In this play, Macbeth shows how he was weak, and let people control his actions. His actions and his led to his death, which left the people who changed him ultimately held responsible for his death. The three people that were held responsible for the death of Macbeth were the witches, Lady Macbeth, and Macbeth himself. The witches were the characters that started off the twisted events in the story, which led Macbeth to become vulnerable. Macbeth allowed them to get into his head, which caused himself problems throughout the story. The witches gave Macbeth mixed signals which led him to go crazy and do whatever it took to be fearless. Lady Macbeth pushed Macbeth too hard to become more ambitious for the throne, which brainwashed him to turn into a murderer. Lady Macbeth was even scared for Macbeth at a later point of the play, because she knew that he had played too rough to get what he wanted by killing everyone in his way. The most obvious person who was held responsible for Macbeth’s death was himself. Not only was he brainwashed, but he allowed everyone to take advantage of him. He never listened to himself, and never took responsibility for his actions. At the end of the play, he finally understood that he should do what his instinct told him, but at that point of the play, he ended up killing families which led people to be furious with him and want him dead.

They are ultimately three reasons held responsible of the death of Macbeth. Firstly it the tree witches. The three witches took advantage of Macbeth’s ambition for being King, and brainwashed him into changing him for the worst. They gave him prophecies that made him feel unstoppable, but ironically made him fall into his death. The witches started to brainwash Macbeth by getting him excited to be soon to be King. They knew that he had lust and ambition to keep the throne, so they had fun playing games with him. “All hail, Macbeth, thou shalt be king hereafter!” (1.3.50). This was the first prophecy that Macbeth was interested in. He got the thought of how his life would be of being King, which turned his life around for the worse. An apparition prophecy that the witches gave Macbeth was the apparition of a bloody child that told Macbeth that no man born of a woman can do him harm. That apparition gave Macbeth confidence: “Then live Macduff: what need I fear of thee?” (4.1.78-80). This was ultimately the prophecy that killed Macbeth, because he assumed that no man could kill him. Macbeth was soon surprised to know that Macduff was not born of woman, but born of a C-section, and later killed him in battle. The witches had suckered Macbeth into thinking that the apparitions and prophecies were not as they seemed. Another apparition that the witches gave Macbeth was a crowned child. “Macbeth shall never vanquished be until Great Birnam wood to high Dunsinane hill shall come against him” (4.1. 92-94). This apparition was a trick played by the witches on Macbeth. When they gave this apparition, Macbeth got a different idea of what it meant. Macbeth thought that he would never be vanquished until Great Birnam Wood literally came across the castle. This gave Macbeth confidence which made him think that he was unstoppable. They made him into a fearless character which resulted into him being killed, which was a cause that the witches were ultimately responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth.

Secondly. Macbeth chose to go down a path where he could have what he always wanted, which was to be King. What he didn’t realize was how far he had to go to get the throne, and what he had to do to keep it. Macbeth himself is held responsible for his death, because of his actions towards others, and the downfall he caused on himself. Macbeth became a murderous tyrant soon after he became King, which was the main source of why he was a reason for his death. The first sign of him becoming a murderer was the assassination of King Duncan. “Stars, hide your fires, Let not light see my black and deep desires;” (1.4. 50-51). This quote explained how he was loyal to Duncan, but was questioning whether to kill him or not. This was the first sign of the changing of Macbeth. At the beginning of the play, he was portrayed as a loyal man towards his King and his fellow people, but this event of the killing of Duncan changed him into a monster. “That I require a clearness: and with him to leave no rubs nor botches in the work Fleance his son, that keeps him company, whose absence is no less material to me than is his father's, must embrace the fate Of that dark hour” (3.1. 146-151). Banquo was the only person who knew of Macbeth’s prophecy, so he needed to make sure that Banquo couldn’t expose his plans. He decided that he could kill Banquo’s son so he wouldn’t become King in the future. He started to become a monster because he tasted the power of the throne. He wanted to make sure nobody stood in his way, and started becoming. “The very firstlings of my heart shall be the firstlings of my hand” (4.1. 147-148). When Macbeth had said this, he was determined to kill Macduff’s family as a message that he is ready for anything, and that he doesn’t find him as a threat. He wanted to show himself that he needed to follow his instincts, and if he had done that from the beginning, he could have had everything solved. This brought Macbeth one step closer into becoming a crazed monster. He wanted all his problems to be solved by killing anyone in his way.

Lastly is Lady Macbeth. One of the most famous quotes told by the witches was “fair is foul, and foul is fair.” This quote explains how nothing is what it seems. A prime example of that is Lady Macbeth’s attitude throughout the play. Throughout the beginning of the story, Lady Macbeth acted as the “man” in family and was dominant over Macbeth. She wanted him to work for the throne instead of sitting back and doing nothing about it. “Yet do I fear thy nature; It is too full o; the milk of human kindness to catch the nearest way.” (1.5. 16-18). This quote explained how she felt that she didn’t think he had it in him to become a King. She said this quote after hearing the Macbeth had got the prophecy of becoming King. She wanted to make sure that she could man him up. “But screw your courage to the sticking-place, and we'll not fail” (1.7. 60-61). After Lady Macbeth failed to kill Duncan, she wanted to try and convince Macbeth that he is incapable to kill Duncan, which made Macbeth more eager to become King. She encouraged him to become more of a murderous tyrant, which is an example of how she corrupted him to his death. “She should have died hereafter; there would have been a time for such a word” (5.5. 17-18). This is what Macbeth had said after observing his wife’s body at the castles grounds. After he found out that his wife was dead, he knew that he didn’t have anything to lose. This brought him one step closer into losing control of himself, and not letting anything else get in his way. He still had the assumption that no man born of woman could harm him, so he decided to just take on whoever wanted to challenge him, which left him to die from Macduff. Lady Macbeth showed to be a dominant character over Macbeth, which led her to be a cause of the corruption and downfall of Macbeth. At the end all three personas led to Macbeth’s death. The three witches gave Macbeth a total of 9 prophesies witch where totally misinterpreted by himself. Lady Macbeth is the one who triggered Macbeth’s madness witch then led to Macbeth killing many people including his own cousin Banquo. The last person that was responsible is Macbeth himself, he let greed take over and so he started to misinterpreted everything that as going on. Ultimately, the three witches, Lady Macbeth, and Macbeth himself were all responsible for the death of Macbeth. Not only did the physical body of Macbeth die, but the loyal caring man inside that was transformed into a monster. Macbeth transformed from a noble shoulder to a murderous unreliable king which ends up dead because of his actions.

Works Cited Shakespeare, W., and R. Gill. Macbeth. 6. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977. Print. . (Shakespeare and Gill)

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Who Is Ultimately Responsible for the Tragedy of Mackbeth

    ...Who is ultimately responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth? It could be said that Macbeth´s strive for power affects every aspect of his life, and this motivation eventually leads to his demise. Many different factors play a pivotal role in deciding his ill-fated future. With his wife´s cajoling, and the three witches´ foretelling of his fut...

    Read More
  • Macbeth Tragedy

    ...The Cause of Tragedy Through Mischief From the perspective of A.C Bradley, a valueless central feeling is demonstrated in the great tragedy achieved by Macbeth`s mischief, thus leading to the catastrophe of Macbeth. In the play, after achieving the title as Thane of Glamis, Macbeth realizes that he can become much more by murdering the king. B...

    Read More
  • Macbeth Is Not a Tragedy

    ...Macbeth has been defined as a tragedy, however, the definition of “tragedy” is questionable and doesn’t have a definite definition. The dictionary definition of a tragedy is a “serious drama with unhappy events or a sad ending” however, according to the famous Greek philosopher Aristotle, a tragedy should have six parts which consists ...

    Read More
  • Macbeth as a tragedy

    ...Macbeth as a Tragedy According to Aristotle's Definition Literature provides us the various sensation; for examples; love, hate, sorrow, melancholy, pity, fear and joyfulness. Melancholy is the origination of many great literature works; for instances; the works written by the greatest writer in English literature, William Shakespeare. He w...

    Read More
  • Who is Responsible for Macbeths Downfall?

    ...Macbeth, Lady Macbeth and the three witches are all to blame for the tragedy that is “Macbeth”, Lady Macbeth through convincing Macbeth, Macbeth for following his ambition more than his conscience and the three witches for putting the idea of being king in Macbeth’s head. But i think Macbeth is more responsibe because he had a choice to ki...

    Read More
  • Macbeth Is a Tragedy

    ...William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth qualifies as a tragedy. A tragedy is a dramatic or narrative writing in which the main character suffers disaster after a serious or significant struggle but faces his or downfall in such a way as to attain heroic stature. The play Macbeth qualifies as a tragedy because there is dramatic writing, a main chara...

    Read More
  • Macbeth in Relation to Greek Tragedy

    ...MACBETH ESSAY Macbeth by William Shakespeare is a tragedy, and the character of Macbeth is its tragic hero. Like every tragic hero, Macbeth has a tragic flaw. His flaw that leads to his downfall is hubris, or pride. His pride causes him to think himself in control of prophecies concerning Banquo, those told by the three apparitions, and h...

    Read More
  • Macbeth- Who is responsible for the tragedy?

    ...  Macbeth​ : The Blame of the Tragedy  Shakespeare blurs the line between protagonist and antagonist in ​ The Tragedy of  Macbeth​ . He makes the audience care about Macbeth yet the blame for the tragedy falls on him.  Lady Macbeth encourages him, convincing him to live up to his word, but M...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.