Preview

Underground to Canada

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
380 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Underground to Canada
CRITICAL EVALUATION
Introduction
‘Underground to Canada’ by Barbara Smucker is a captivating novel which tells the story of Julilly and Liza and their journey to Canada.
The following essay will show how Smucker uses themes such as courage and determination to make the novel’s two central characters (Julilly and Liza) show remarkable feats of courage to escape from slavery and make a new life for themselves in Canada.
Plot Summary
At the beginning of the novel Julilly and Mammy Sally are slaves in the Henson plantation alongside Adam, Ben, Lester and James. They worked very hard as slaves. They were slaves in the Deep South. Sims usually chained the slaves and they worked night and day.
In the middle section the story develops when the riley plantation is a harsh place. Julilly worked in the cotton fields in the blazing heat if they go to slow Sims will whip them. Mr Ross plans to escape plan for Julilly. They have to dress in boys clothes. The woman cut there head with scissors. Julilly is on the run to Canada.
The story develops near the end when Julilly and Liza move from ‘Safe House’ to ‘Safe House’ before finally escaping to Canada. They are helped along the way by some kind Quaker people

Body
The main themes highlighted in this novel are slavery, cruelty and courage. Barbara Smucker brings the story to life when she addresses these themes. Examples of these are addressed throughout the novel e.g. when Sims bullies the slaves. For example, he shouts:
“You field-hand niggers. Line yourselves up along this path and don’t you loiter.”
Then the sound of a zinging whip cut the air and Sims screamed:
“Some of you ain’t gonna chop no cotton today.”
That shows a good example of Sims cruelty and how he views slavery. Julilly is very brave to escape from the Riley Plantation.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is easy to see that in her novel ‘Underground to Canada’; Barbara Smucker has used a number of themes to highlight the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    One day a girl named Hanna came back from with her friends and does not want to go to passover because she does not want to remember. She pleaded not to go but they made her and she went. When she got there she sat at the table to celebrate and she loved the wine. Aunt Eva told her to open the door. When she opened the door she was at a farm and she had an aunt and a cousin named Rivka they told her that her parents died. She went to a guy named Shmuel's wedding and they got captured on a train and they were took to a camp. They have a hard time in the camp being told that if they are sick or can't work they will die. Later in the book Shmuel and others try to escape and they get caught when they do they get hanged. They are working and the guard starts picking people and when Rivka is picked because she was sick Hanna takes her spot. They get rushed into a chamber and they get gassed. When she came back to normal time she knew that her Aunt Eva was Rivka and they talked about a lot of things that happened and they were…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Writer's Responsibility

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Atwood describes Canadians as an audience that wants to be entertained by writers, giving readers a distraction from reality and the truth. How an author is appraised is not based on their message but on their ability to entertain. Atwood describes a writer as someone who writes what is being seen and experienced in the world. Atwood then focuses the attention on Canada compared to other countries where writers are suppressed in means of what they can say and how they can say it, opposed to Canada, which is more accepting to people’s opinions and styles as long as the message does not focus us too much on the world around us. Atwood reminds readers that Canada has not always been the Canada it is today known for its civil rights. She then continues with describing how Canadian writers are currently being constrained and how it is not seen as of any importance.…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Where the World Began

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Laurence uses the microcosm of her small town to show Canada's growth as a country through her childhood memories, the seasons of her small town, and where a person is raised, affects their point of view on the world.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary – Chapter 1 starts with a young boy named Ralph, searching the area around him to find other life after their plane crash landed on a deserted island. Ralph eventually finds another boy with the nickname "Piggy" and they realize that are no adults and that they can't find their plane. Then they decide to go to the shore to swim and Ralph tells Piggy that his dad will save them since he is in the navy but Piggy tells him that the pilot had told them that an atom bomb had gone off and everyone was dead which kind of foreshadows what is going on back home and why they were leaving. Once they finish swimming they decide to find other people by blowing into a shell that makes a loud noise and as they hoped boys started to come towards them. Along with all the boys, came another group of boys all dressed black robes and we find out that their leaders name…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the Great Depression crashing Canadian economic system overwhelmingly, numerous of unemployed Canadians lost their jobs and turn to live in the hobo lifestyle. They traveled from town to town on trains for seeking a new work and food. William Jefferson, a young man who just graduated from the university had to face the unemployment depressingly. He became as a hobo and involved into the current of riding of rail. With the imagination of the figure of Zarathustra, William was also looking forward to receiving a romantic adventure in the ride. By the collision with the real world, William recorded what he saw and heard in this journey. This is a collection of William’s journals and the reminiscence when he was eighty which describes the…

    • 134 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No great Mischief review

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One of the greatest qualities of this novel is the ease in which the author transports us to Cape Breton and the different places where the story takes place.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Her adventure starts when she steals. Molly has a passion for reading and it is one of the only things she can enjoy anymore but it stabs her in the back when she steals her favorite book and gets caught for it. For doing this she has to do 50 hours of community service. Her boyfriend at the time, Jack had a connection with a 91 year old woman named Vivian. Jack thought it would be a good idea to do her community service hours cleaning out the Attic of the old woman's house.This creates the connection which is the main focus of the novel.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The setting is Arthur Shelby's Kentucky plantation during the antebellum period. Although Shelby is not characterized as a harsh or unforgiving master, he has nevertheless suffered serious debts- forcing him sell some slaves to avoid financial ruin. Mr. Haley, the slave trader, purchases Uncle Tom, Shelby's loyal servant since childhood, and five-year-old Harry, a handsome and talented child who sings and dances. Shelby regrets betraying Uncle Tom's faithfulness, as much as he regrets taking the child away from his mother, Eliza. Eliza overhears Mrs. Shelby protesting her husband's decision, and decides to flee the plantation with her son. George, her husband from a neighboring plantation, has already left for Canada via the “underground railroad.” Eliza plans to do the same, and tries to convince Uncle Tom to save himself and come with her. Uncle Tom, however, sees his duty to remain loyal to his master, despite his betrayal, and does not accompany Eliza and Harry on their journey to the Ohio River.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Hanging of Angelique, Afua Cooper investigates the secret of slavery in Canada. She points out that this “lurid” image is ingrained in the national psyche and is a part or their national identity (page). For her, this idealistic image of Canada as a land of refuge takes its origins between 1830 and 1860, the period known as the Underground Railroad when “thousands of American runaway slaves escaped to and found refuge in the British territories to the north” (Cooper, 69). As a consequence, this part of Canadian history is written out of books. Afua Cooper states that it is difficult to find scholarly or popular accounts and depiction of slave life at the time…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gabrielle Roy’s The Tin Flute (originally titled Bonheur d’occasion) is a quintessential novel of Canadian social history. While Gabriel Roy’s first novel is a work of fiction, it very carefully and accurately depicts the times, circumstances, experiences, and feelings of Canadian society before World War II. Set in 1939 and 1940, during the first year of Canada 's contribution to World War II, The Tin Flute is a harsh depiction of the all so common life in poverty found throughout Canada. The Tin Flute is a dark, tragic story in a world where women search for well-to-do men to help them escape the burdens of lower class and men sign up for military service and put their lives at risk on the warfront just to escape from their poverty. Throughout the novel we see through Florentine and other main characters the trials and tribulations of what appears to be an impossible process by which to ascend the socioeconomic ladder of class. Roy’s novel depicts the futility of upward social mobility found throughout Canada and the world in the first half of the Twentieth Century, especially for women. By examining the struggles of the characters in The Tin Flute with support from other literature pertaining to pre-war Canadian society the causes and desires for upward social mobility, available options to obtain upward movement and, most importantly, the limitations of social mobility for women can be defined and proven as fruitless.…

    • 1928 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This enigmatic quote; a part of ‘A Wilderness Station’ one of the stories in the anthology-‘Carried Away’ by Alice Munroe, not only justifies the title but also sets us onward through the journey into the unique sensations of Post-colonial feminist sensibilities that Munroe lends so easelessly to her work. The term, ‘wilderness’ and the desperate sense of solitude honed by the inner turmoil indicates that the real wilderness stays intact and never leaves a person by a mere change of geography and situation. This sense of being alone in company, being without an association as in the sense of “otherness” opens up and introduces the title of this article Post-colonial feminist reading of Alice Munro’s Man Booker Award winning collection of short stories- ‘Carried Away’. Born Alice Laidlaw in 1931, in Wingham Southwestern Ontario, Munro began writing and publishing stories at the university itself and slowly rose to fame. Her gradual rise to success is a story in itself, how even after many of her short stories appearing regularly in Canadian Forum, Chateline and the Tamarack review, and winning the Governor General’s Award for her first collection, Dance of The Happy Shades in 1968, she was such an obscure figure in Canadian literary circles that when in 1971, Lives of Girls and Women came out, she was called a ‘new talent’! This second book which is the only novel she has written also received Canadian Book Sellers Award. In 1974 she wrote her second collection of short stories Who Do You Think You Are? Which brought Munro her second Governor General’s Award. In 1980 Munro held the position of Writer- in- residence at both the University of British Columbia and the University of Queensland. Through the 1980s and 1990s, Munro published a short story collection about once every four years to increasing…

    • 4543 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Several main characters throughout the novel epitomize typical slave owners and their attitudes toward the bondage of another human being. They are racists who portray the worst of what society has to offer.…

    • 2186 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    <br>Harriet Jacobs' narrative is a powerful statement unveiling the impossibility and undesirability of achieving the ideal put forth by men and maintained by women. Jacobs directs her account of the afflictions a woman is subjected to in the chain of slavery to women of the north to gain sympathy for their sisters that were enslaved in the south. In showing this, Jacobs reveals the danger of such self disapprobation women maintained by accepting the idealized role that men have set a goal for which to strive. She suggests that slave women be judged by different standards than those applied to other women. Jacobs develops a moral code that apprises the specific social and historical position of captive black women. Jacobs' will power and strength shown in her narrative are characteristics of womanly behavior being developed by the emerging feminist movement.…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Body” has strong recurring themes throughout the story. One of the strongest relates to the subtitle of the novella, “Fall from Innocence”. The boys journey shows their fall from innocence as they encounter new experiences over the two days. Each boy shows their own emotions and ideas during the duration of their journey to discover Ray’s dead body. Over time, chris, Teddy, and Gordie lose their innocence by having hostile home environments, escaping death by a train, and having to point a gun at people they grew up with.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The book of Beatrice Culleton Mosioner titled In Search of April Raintree, is about the trials and sufferings of two sisters growing up in the foster home. Beatrice writes about the two young Métis sisters and the struggles about their lives. She tells us about the social system, stereotypes, drug, alcohol abuse and the girl’s on-going battle to fit in with society to become “normal”. As they grew up through many hardships trying to uncover their unique identity in society, the Métis sisters discovered the world in two entirely different perspectives. Though they planned to stay together as they grew up, the changing personalities in addition to the distinct beliefs about their Métis heritage separated them not only from society but from each other as well.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays