Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

To What Extent Does Medicine Act as a Social Control Mechanism

Good Essays
1232 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Does Medicine Act as a Social Control Mechanism
To What Extent Does Medicine Act As A Social Control Mechanism? Please Refer T o Social Class And Mental Illness In Your Response.
There are a number of theories about medicine as a social control mechanism.The medical profession is the recognised authority in the UK on illness and treatment and also has established a monopoly on the official identification of sickness and on the legitimate practise of healing. It also shapes ideas, expectations of how those who are pronounced sick may behave and believe the public have to be protected from unscrupulous practise. For example Functionalism sees doctors as gate-keepers to the sick role thereby limiting abuse because they have the skills and knowledge to maintain a healthy population. Marxists believe that it is a mechanism to get people back to work as quickly as possible so they can make more money for the capitalists. The Feminists argue that drugs ‘treatment’ of depression in women is based on gender stereotypes. Although these theories put forward strong arguments in favour of medicine as social control there are however criticisms that suggest that medicine is not always a form of social control.
Medically dealing with deviance justifies certain intrusive procedures to be performed on individuals not only in the name of "treatment" but also in the interests of the common good. When health professionals attempt to eradicate a disease or a bothersome social behaviour, we all supposedly benefit. Mental illness is ‘a state of mind which affects the persons thinking, perceiving, emotion or judgement to the extent that she or he requires care or medical treatment in her or his interest or in the interest of other persons’. Mental
Illness is common. 1% of the population develop schizophrenia. One in ten are admitted to a mental hospital and a much higher proportion receives psychoactive medication.

The biomedical approach sees mental illness as a medical problem and treatment involves the use of drugs or other medical or surgical treatments in clinical environments. In the past mentally ill were treated in long – stay psychiatric hospitals but now, accept for the most serious cases they are likely to be cared for in the community. Community care involves those who are mentally ill living as much as possible within a ‘normal’ community, alongside members of the public who are not mentally ill. The move to care in the community was prompted by the desire to reduce spending on large-scale hospital care and the desire to avoid negative effects that long-stay psychiatric hospitals had on the patients. The underfunding of community care led to a series of scandals arising from inadequate care and supervision by welfare agencies, and lack of liaison between local authorities and health authorities. On the other hand care in the community provides an important means for people with mental health problems to receive support and treatment in conditions as near normal as possible. The World Health Organisation estimates one in six people suffer from some form of mental illness. . The working class are diagnosed as suffering more mental illness than the middle class and working class mothers report more depression than middle class mothers. This may reflect higher levels of poverty and family stress. Class differences in the treatment given, such as admittance to NHS psychiatric hospitals (where they become a health statistic) rather than unrecorded private psychotherapy or psychiatric treatments at home or in private clinics may also explain this difference in the pattern shown in statistics on mental illness.

Scheff and Szasz argues that mental illness is not really an illness at all but a label used by powerful or influential people to control those who are seen as socially disruptive or who challenge existing society or the dominant ideas in some way. Scheff also argues that most people at some time go through stages of stress, anxiety or depression or show signs of odd or bizarre behaviour. In the majority of cases other people do not label this as evidence of mental illness and it is dealt with by the normal sick role. A few days off work, a change in social circumstances or a holiday is often enough to deal with these problems. It is only when people with power such as doctors, politicians, mass media etc label this behaviour as evidence of mental illness. Psychiatrists confirm the ‘insane’ label, psychiatric treatment begins and the deviant label of mentally ill is firmly established.

Goffman suggests that once the person is labelled as mentally ill and chooses or is forced to enter a psychiatric hospital as a patient the insanity role is confirmed and the career of the psychiatric patient begins. Goffman argues once a person attains ’Master Status’ and a ‘Self Fulfilling Prophecy’ then the insanity role is confirmed and this reduces the chance of release and makes it difficult for them to re-enter ‘normal’ society successfully. Entering a mental hospital involves what Goffman calls ‘Mortification’. The patient then withdraws, rebels, or accepts institutionalisation and accepts their new role and keeps their head down, don’t break rules so they can hang on to what’s left of their own identity. On being discharged Goffman also argues that the ‘mentally ill’ carry a stigma of ‘ex-mental’ patient. This may make it difficult to find work and develop completely normal relations with others hence the patient might relapse.

Rosenham’s research confirmed the views of Scheff, Szasz and Goffman that mental illness is basically a label placed on behaviour by others. Rosenham in 1972 with eight other people prepared themselves by not washing, shaving or cleaning their teeth for 5 days and faked symptoms of schizophrenia by claiming to hear a voice saying ’thud’. All were diagnosed as schizophrenics and admitted to the different hospitals. Once admitted they behaved normally and said the voice was not bothering them anymore but were still kept in hospital for many days and aspects of their normal lives befor being admitted to hospital were reinterpreted as signs of their apparent illness. Rosenham took many notes while in hospital, and this was also interpreted by staff as part of his illness, labelled as ‘writing behaviour’. Rosenhan then made an even more serious challenge to the bio-medical model and institutionalisation in particular when he reversed the experiment and told hospital staff to expect people trying to gain entrance by faking illness. The staff eventually thought they had identified forty-one patients, but all those they identified were actually genuine patients who wanted help and Rosenhan had in fact not sent any fake patients at all. Rosenhan’s work illustrated very clearly that the attachment of the label ‘mentally ill’ is fairly arbitrary and an inaccurate process.
The work of Scheff, Szasz,Goffman and Rosenhan have been criticised for the small scale of their studies which may therefore not be representative of all institutions involved with mental health. Further more mental illness is not just a social constraint but a very real condition that affects an increasing number of people.

In the olden days mentally ill used to be sectioned and put away and even forgotten about. Now a days because of the work of Scheff, Szasz, Goffman and Rosenhan institutional care of the mentally ill has become increasingly replaced by a focus on care in the community so patients are treated at home or in day centres so they can live a normal life as possible.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In u.s. new thoughts have been developed about the control and remedy of mental health in nineteenth-century. but later on this idea known as “moral treatment,”.(Patricia, ’Antonio, PhD, RN, FAAN).…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Biological treatments arise from the medical model of abnormal behaviour, which considers mental disorder to be an illness of disease resulting from underlying biological factors. Most people with schizophrenia receive some form of drug therapy.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    “One of the traditional methods of imposing statism or socialism on a people has been by way of medicine. It's very easy to disguise a medical program as a humanitarian project. Most people are a little reluctant to oppose anything that suggests medical care for people who possibly can't afford it.”…

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Biological therapies are constructed on the belief that mental illnesses are caused by abnormalities in the neural and bodily process, such as imbalances in certain neurotransmitters or malfunctions in certain areas of the brain. Biology treatment is used everywhere as medicine. There is proof that it has been successful for many mental disorders.…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The medical model utilizes an objective approach that is generally agreed upon by those within the field, illness is scientific and lacking a moral or political aspect. Finally, the medical model focuses the attention on a singular or unique etiology that can be targeted for treatment. Whereas, the sociological model approaches illness from a different view and perspective. Illness is labeled in a more subjective way leaving the educated world with multiple definitions or labels -which can lead to confusion, misdiagnosis, and delayed treatment. In the sociological model illness takes on a moral and political aspect because conditions and behaviors are now deemed as abnormal or deviant straying from the 'norm'. Since the 'norm' can very within a cultural group and groups with more power can guide the prevalence often illness label being applied to an undesirable group or the 'other'. Sociological illness models carry a political component that is not present in the medical model. Finally, the sociological model of illness attributes multiple sources as the cause of the illness: social, biological, psychological, etc (Wietz,…

    • 1430 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purpose of Freidson’s article was to analyze the social organization of the medical profession and its members. In his study, he explored how the medical profession has gained a monopoly in its field, which grants it complete jurisdiction over determining what illness is therefore how people must act in order to be treated as ill (Freidson 1970:205). Because medicine has the ability to label one person’s grievance an illness and another one not, Freidson believes that medicine creates the social role of illness. Illness is thought of as a deviance from a set of norms that represent normal or healthy behavior. “Human, and therefore social evaluation of what is normal, proper, or…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Within this assignment the intention is to discuss the biological, psychological and social models and perspectives of care. This will be achieved through examining the influences of each model and their effects upon the practice of mental health care. Some historical information will be provided to give explanation of the background into the evolution of social and moral perspectives that have shaped mental health care practice throughout the ages.…

    • 3319 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    * Education in the need to understand mental illness as a medical condition to promote the reversal of social exclusion, discrimination and social isolation which result in stigma.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the 1900s people viewed mental illness as a disease of individual weakness or a spiritual disease, in which the mentally ill were sent to asylums. This was a temporary solution in hope to remove “lunatics” from the community. This caused a severe overcrowding, which led to a decline in patient care and reviving the old procedures and medical treatments. Early treatments to cure mental illness were really forms of torture. Asylums used wrist and ankle restraints, ice water baths, shock machines, straightjackets, electro-convulsive therapy, even branding patients, and the notorious lobotomy and “bleeding practice”. These early treatments seen some improvement in patients, although today this eras method of handling the mentally ill is considered barbaric, the majority of people were content because the “lunatics” were no longer visible in society.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Healthcare Exam 2

    • 4590 Words
    • 19 Pages

    1. Most individuals assume that illness is an objective, biological category. Our textbook, on the other hand, argues that illness is a moral category and a social construction. Argue for or against this position. Be sure to address the issues likely to be raised by those holding the opposite view.…

    • 4590 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    While it is important to understand the differences in today’s institution compared to their predecessors; it is also critical to take heed of lessons learned. Throughout history mankind has been challenged by how to treat members of society who are different whether these differences are based on physical or mental attributes. As for mental illness, we have entered into an age of new beginnings where the negative aspects of these places are being forgotten and images of safety and happiness for these patients are being…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This essay further explains the different social philosophies and some examples of what some individuals believe in regards to the health care reform and the changes that have taken place in society. This essay briefly explains the characteristics of each philosophy/theory. Also, some human service professionals such as Katherine have been able to experience some of what children and families experience in another country across the world. She has seen the effects that people suffer from mentally and physically. She is learning how to develop better services and ways to communicate to the individuals in Berundi in order to help them enhance their lives. Most…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medicated American

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A study conducted by the New England Research Institute found that 43 percent of people who are prescribed drugs do not have a psychiatric diagnosis or any mental health care. There is increasing evidence of doctors prescribing medication without sufficient cause or care. Many of the doctors do not even discuss the side effects that go along with the drugs. The amount of psychiatric therapy has decreased over the years and the amount of prescription drugs taken have increased.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    NORMAL VS ABNORMAL

    • 7259 Words
    • 21 Pages

    This is not an idle question without real-world consequences. The "treatment" of every single "mental disorder" that mental health professionals "diagnose," from "depression" and "attention deficitdisorder" on through "schizophrenia," flows from how society construes "normal" and "abnormal." This matter affects tens of millions of people annually; and affects everyone, really, since a person's mental model of "what is normal?" is tremendously influenced by how society and its institutions define "normal."…

    • 7259 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Irving Zola, and Joseph Schneider (Overgaard, et al., 2014, p. 743). Published studies primarily focus on medical interventions of deviant behaviors, mental health, personality differences, aging, and the role that medical intervention has played in society. Additionally, studies also examine the increase of pharmaceutical advertising that robustly stimulates the invention of illness and targets consumers to self-diagnose through check-lists of symptoms (Maturo, 2012, p. 124). Ultimately, most theorists agree that by describing certain aspects of life and human differences as pathologies, the institution of medicine has metamorphosed into an institution of social control, therefore dictating what is normal and acceptable within society, and what should be classified as a medical condition in order to correct or control undesirable and deviant behaviors. (Conrad,…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays