Top-Rated Free Essay

The Morality of Pornography

Good Essays
The Morality of Pornography

As the morality of pornography as a form of free speech is as questionable as it is popular, the question that I would like to raise is whether the correct response to the harm associated with pornography is censorship. MacKinnon argues that pornography represents everything that women have struggled to overcome through feminist suffrage including battery, sexual harassment, and prostitution. Nadine Strossen, although she does not deny MacKinnon’s claims, argues that pornography represents an opportunity for women to use a novel form of free speech to change how society views female sexuality. I argue that Strossen’s argument is more convincing than MacKinnon’s. MacKinnon misinterprets the problem with pornography as being men’s depiction of women’s sexuality, when the real issue is the lack of response by women to this depiction. Strossen is correct in saying that hate speech, or sexual discrimination, requires counter-speech over censorship. I believe that if women participated in the pornography industry, the perception of women’s sexual identity could be improved. MacKinnon states that we do not live in such a perfect world, that discrimination against women does occur without reason, and that realization is the basis of feminism. Feminism strives against the silent abuse that happens within families, work places, and on the streets and works to make it publicly known. However, the majority of society refuses to believe that the huge amount of unaccounted abuse occurs behind the scenes. MacKinnon attributes this denial to pornography. Pornography, to MacKinnon, represents everything that feminists have struggled against; harassment, prostitution, and sexual subjugation. However, to the general populous all these crimes fall under the blanket term of ‘sex’. People who consume pornography do not take an issue to the obvious abuse is because pornography constructs an image of woman that is desires and relishes all these different forms of abuse. Women are portrayed as objects that want and need to be subjugated and used rather than being independent individuals, sexually or otherwise. Subjugation of women, MacKinnon argues, is part of what makes pornography arousing, and therefore inequality between men and women is necessary. The effect of this industry however is more sinister than its purpose. Pornography constructs an image of the female nature, and those for those who consume it, pornography becomes their sexual reality. MacKinnon argues that is why the majority of the population accepts the social inequality between the sexes. The solution, according to MacKinnon, is to ban pornography and take away this formidable weapon that men use against women. Strossen does not dispute MacKinnon’s claims of how pornography depicts women. Strossen argues that it is a form of hate speech, or free speech used to discriminate. However, to her it is a huge opportunity for feminists and women in general to change the stereotypes concerning female sexuality. In order to explain her proposal, Strossen explains why the solution that most feminists including MacKinnon favor, censorship of pornography, would adversely affect women’s social standing instead of repairing it. Firstly, free speech is an important tool for people who suffer from discrimination to rebel against it. Just as protesters during the Civil Rights movement were protected by the right to free speech, Strossen states that women’s rights have also depended on free speech, and that it could continue to be a tool in repairing the damage by pornography to women’s status. Secondly, censorship has traditionally been used as a tool to prevent a minority from having equal rights. From the British Race Relations Act in 1965 to anti-hate speech laws in universities worldwide, enforced censorship of hate speech has almost always resulted in an increase of discrimination against the minority. The enforcement of anti-hate speech laws could be used to persecute women in and outside of the pornography industry. Finally, and concerning to sexual discrimination, laws against sexually explicit content have traditionally been used to suppress important information for women’s rights. From the beginning of the century until recently, anti-obscenity laws against degrading sexual content concerning women has resulted in the banning of information on everything from reproductive rights to feminist literature in general. In general, Strossen concludes that criminalizing free speech concerning a minority results in the infringement on the rights of that minority, which is exactly what feminists like MacKinnon do not want. Instead, free speech must be defended at all costs, and the only solution to discrimination through free speech is free speech itself. MacKinnon argues that pornography is the source of the social inequality that women suffer from. Strossen argues that although pornography is a form of discrimination, it must be protected as a form of free speech. Although these two arguments seem unrelated, they are connected through a solution that MacKinnon refuses to accept and Strossen fails to effectively describe. I argue that trying to destroy pornography altogether by censoring or banning it is the wrong method entirely. As Strossen says, banning pornography would not stop the pornography industry, and it would enforce the stereotype that women are not comfortable with their sexuality. Pornography is an accumulation of all the ways that MacKinnon describes in which men subjugate women because women have allowed men to take over the pornography industry. MacKinnon is wrong to attribute this solely to men’s propensity to subjugate women; women and feminists alike have fallen into the stereotype that they cannot independently express themselves sexually. Women permitted men to dominate pornography and pervert it into an exclusively male expression of sex. MacKinnon is correct in saying that men actually have sex with their image of what a woman is, as that image is a collective expression by men of a woman’s nature without any response from women themselves. The problem therefore is not that pornography is a male-dominated form of sexual expression, but rather that there is a lack of female expression of sexuality. The solution, therefore, is to do what Strossen suggests and fight fire with fire. Strossen states that the solution to hate speech is counter speech and not censorship. I agree with Strossen, and I would propose a solution to sexual discrimination through pornography. I argue that the counter-speech needed to equilibrate women’s sexual and social identities to men’s is female interest in the industry of pornography. If women challenge the male pornographic perspective with their own, the entire pornography industry as well as society’s perception of female sexuality would change for the better. MacKinnon argues that inequality is part of the nature of pornography. I argue that this problem is due to an inequality of purpose in pornography, as the industry is, for the most part, meant exclusively for men’s entertainment. By removing this exclusiveness, women would prove that the stereotype that women are not comfortable with their sexuality or are not sexually independent is wrong. Different generations of feminists have different opinions of the nature of pornography. Second wave feminists such as MacKinnon believe it to be the accumulation of everything that feminism stands against, and it is the source of social inequality between men and women in modern society. Third wave feminists such as Strossen believe pornography is an opportunity, a form of free speech that, if it is not censored, could counter sexual discrimination against women. I argue that Strossen’s argument is more convincing than MacKinnon’s; the problem with pornography lies in women’s lack of sexual expression, and censorship is would adversely affect women’s social status. Women’s participation in the industry of pornography could change society’s perception of female sexuality for the better, and bring women much closer to the complete social equality with men that they deserve.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Religion of Pornography

    • 2007 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Personal Relationships > Pornography “With pornographic material freely available on the internet and not covered by the laws of the country in which it may be viewed, ethics are needed to guide its usage”. The general meaning of ethics is the balance of morals and principles. Generally ethics has to do with particular groups, and in each group they are constantly changing. These changes happen due to factors in life, factors such as; age, religion and gender. Ethics is a very debatable topic…

    • 2007 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Immorality of Pornography

    • 2325 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Ken Stoye Ethics 2050 - 014 April 19, 2005 The Immorality of Pornography The argument over the morality of pornography can take shape in many different ways. In order to take a stance, it's important to identify what exactly is included in the definition of pornography. In this paper, pornography will be defined as sexually explicit materials in which the acts depicted degrade or subordinate women. The degradation and subordination can occur through various different acts, but in an attempt to…

    • 2325 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immorality of Pornography

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Immorality of Pornography Philosophy of Ethics The Immorality of Pornography Access to pornography has been steadily growing in recent years. You can find pornography everywhere – on the Internet, on DVD, and even in magazines at the corner store! The argument over the morality of pornography seems to be an ongoing argument. Porn’s publication, production, distribution and use are often…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethics on Pornography

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Türkay SARIKAYA 20701889 Section 02 Research paper 1ST draft ETHICS OF PORNOGRAPHY Everybody knows something about porn. But what is porn really? Why it is exist? People get pleasure from porn. Porn is just for an entertainment and it is like other genres of movies. It is just like action, just like horror… Porn is a genre and it has some sub-genres in it. In Turkish there is a word says; “nerede çokluk orada bokluk” means if there are so many things there must be bad things in…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Child Pornography

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Child Pornography Ronda Harris CJ 3318: Sex Crimes Professor Mike Cannon March 21, 2011 Abstract Child pornography is not solely a question of morality or artistic taste or political ideas. The primary concern is not how to protect the community from exposure to sexually explicit materials; rather the concern was how to protect innocent children from sexual abuse. A pedophile uses child pornography to convince him or her that their conduct or obsession is normal lower a child’s…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Effects of Pornography

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages

    to us. This is similar to what the government attempts to do with pornography and obscenity laws. Pornography is the portrayal of sexually explicit material with the intent to cause sexual arousal. Pornography is the display of women as sexual objects, enjoying pain, humiliation, rape or being physically harmed. It is also obscene material in the form of audio, video, pictures, paintings, and even in written words. Pornography is many things and can not be defined it to one single definition because…

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Media and Pornography

    • 3696 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Internet Pornography: Freedom of Press or Dangerous Influence? Sexual morality has declined in America today. The immoral life can be seen all around us. We see it in drugs, alcohol, movies, magazines, gangs, teenage pregnancy, pre-marital sex, and society as a whole. A person can walk into almost any convenience store and purchase a magazine depicting naked women. After considering the increase in rape and molestation, sexual harassment, and other sex crimes over the last few decades, and also…

    • 3696 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Child Pornography

    • 1966 Words
    • 8 Pages

    the nature, extent, and impact of pornography in the United States, and to find some recommendations concerning more effective ways in which the spread of pornography could be contained, consistent with constitutional guarantees. The dimension of pornography is very broad, since the evidence on the relationship between exposure to pornographic materials and antisocial behavior is narrow, unless we looked in a larger context at the entire phenomenon of pornography. I have tried to examine carefully…

    • 1966 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is Pornography Prostitution? In todays society we find pornography more socially acceptable than prostitution. There are many reasons why pornography has the upper hand in our society. It is legal, 42.7% of Internet users view porn (Pornography Statistics), and porn stars are seen as sex celebrities. When we hear the word prostitution we automatically think illegal, drugs, pimps, STDs, cheap women, and dirty men. If we take a step back and just erase whatever we were taught, heard, or seen and…

    • 1052 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Argument Pornography

    • 4229 Words
    • 17 Pages

    Mark Wicclair argues that we should be very wary about the censorship of pornography, even if pornography, as Helen Longino defines it, exists. In order to fully understand Wicclair 's reason for being wary of the censorship of pornography it is important that we use Helen Longino 's definition of pornography. Helen Longino defines pornography as "[the] verbal or pictoral explicit representations of sexual behavior that...have as a distinguishing characteristic ‘the degrading and demeaning…

    • 4229 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays