Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Good the Bad and the Ugly

Good Essays
845 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Good the Bad and the Ugly
After the defacing of the walls of Patrick Berger’s East Park café, debate surfaced regarding the impact of graffiti on communities. The editorial, in the 16 July issue of The Daily Tribute, contends in an emotional and didactic tone that local governments and councils should be supporting prideful citizens and adjudge graffiti as vandalism. In contrast, the letter by Michaela Whitehouse, a representative of the East Park Council, controverts in a scathing yet conciliatory tone that certain places should be dedicated for graffiti and solidly defends the council’s position by addressing several inaccuracies in the editorial.

The title of the editorial catches our attention straight away. It establishes a sense of moral values and appeals to ethos. The “good” in the title refers to the ‘self-respecting’ citizens; the “bad” refers to the graffiti artists and the “ugly” refers to graffiti itself. This serves to separate the principled and upright members of society from the graffiti artists.

The demoralizing effects of graffiti are strengthened by the accompanying picture. The picture is dominated by disfigured tags and a suspicious looking man riding on a bicycle. This indicates a lack of consideration for the owners of the defaced wall. The ‘artistic’ elements of the graffiti are obscure and this suggests to the reader that the graffiti artists are not interested in how people perceive their work; hence they will continue to vandalize other properties at their own consent.

The opening paragraph utilizes emotive imagery and strong language to juxtapose between the irresponsible graffiti artists and the hardworking owners of the café. By labeling the graffiti artists as “thugs” who “desecrated the freshly painted walls” arouses feelings of anger and enmity towards the graffiti artists. This is further enhanced and supported by comments from the locals. In contrast, sympathy is expected for the Bergers through anecdotes, “…his heavily pregnant wife spent the majority of one day…restoring the wall”. The reader also realizes that the Bergers are very earnest, “…diligently kept up with their repayments”. This serves to appeal to pathos and conjures up a sense commiseration for the Bergers. The editorial then attacks the East Park Council. Through the use of hyperbole, “…dragging its heels”, the editorial diminishes the role of the council. This is effective in illustrating the council’s lack of concern regarding its responsibilities. The council is portrayed to be carefree as it “refused to offer any support”. The piece concludes by combining an attack on the graffiti artists and the council. This leaves the reader sharing the editorial’s solid and firm point of view.

Whitehouse responds on behave of the East Park Council in a cogent and rational letter to the editor. She directly opens up her letter by dismissing the editorial assessment of the issue and candidly says that she will address some of the editorial’s “less enlightened remarks.” This straight away lends Whitehouse a sense of authority and provides her following argument with strength. She then uses a pertinent and well-grounded argument by saying “… have no legal recourse to council assistance for maintenance” and “Our budget is only just able to cover the claims of hundreds of leaseholders.” This is a direct appeal to logos and it is an effective way of grabbing the attention of leaseholders and householders. Whitehouse then uses two very powerful rhetorical questions which allow the audience to critically analysis the issue. It also implies that the answer is obvious and anyone who disagrees would be foolish. The effect of this is also strengthened by the fact that Whitehouse uses these rhetorical questions immediately after her logical argument, hence we can expect that many people would have no choice but to share the same viewpoint as her.

Whitehouse then criticizes the editorial in a scathing yet scrupulous tone. She undervalues the editorial by completely discarding their remarks about the council “dragging their heels.” Again this lends her a sense of authority and it shows to the audience that she is well-informed and cognizant of her position. She then addresses the issue of graffiti in a benevolent and sapient fashion. She uses inclusive language so that the audience is not alienated and it creates a sense of solidarity. Also by saying that “… with the aim of providing public spaces dedicated to the expression of this skill” shows that she is not against graffiti in any way. It also illustrates that she is aware of both sides of the situation and instead of completely dismissing the other side; she tries to find a mutual solution. This is effective in encouraging most of the audience to share this legitimate and sensible stance.

The editorial mainly uses strong language, emotive imagery and appeals to communal values to consolidate its point of view. This would likely appeal to an audience which does not welcome graffiti. Whitehouse’s letter presents the audience with a logical and coherent argument. She also attempts to find a mutual solution for the issue of graffiti. As a result, she is likely to persuade and gain the support of forbearing readers and even some graffiti artists themselves.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Safety Graffiti on Hedges,” by Katya Sander, created with white spray paint and green hedges, depicts safety procedures on the hedges outside of suburban homes. Each image shows a different safety procedure; such as, the heimlich maneuver, mouth-to-mouth resuscitation, or evacuation routes. Sander sprayed the white paint on the hedges of a Denmark community; regardless, these maneuvers are universally known, making it easy for anyone to decipher her artistic message. Due to the simplicity of the maneuvers being depicted, it can be assumed that Sander was not trying to target doctors, or medical personnel; rather, she was targeting the community as a whole. The irony of this piece, however, is that she purposely put these drawings in a suburban…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is where Certeau enters the scene as Cintron spins a narrative of how graffiti used to “enact a degree of violence against another gang or to implicitly do so by celebrating the power of one’s own gang” (170). In addition, it is from the mainstreams cultural material that street gangs draw their meanings. Citron also admitted that he is no expert on gang activities. In my opinion, graffiti that are left behind in a public area and the monument that we see in our daily life its a work of art it has some meaning like any other kind of art. Each memorial consumes its own significance, just as the artwork of graffiti creator itself. I believe that the focal point of graffiti is more vague and the secret behind it are sacred to the member of the…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A local council plays a significant role in creating and repairing the order in Hounslow High Street. It has launched a program, which prime concern is to focus on the improvement of street furniture and crime prevention. In City Road in Cardiff uniformed officers attempt to restore social order, engaging the residents to call the helpline, whenever they notice, for instance, illegal waste disposal (‘Ordered Lives’, 2009, scene 2). Hounslow council also gets involved in targeting issues like graffiti, litter or fly - tipping. The place is a…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Glasgow 5th March 1971

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Edwin Morgan’s vivid visual poem “Glasgow 5 March 1971” deals with the themes of violence, crime, apathy and responsibility.This poem is all about street violence and how people don’t get involved. “Glasgow 5 March 1971” is a very dramatic visual poem about a “young man and his girl” who get pushed through a window by some thieves and are not helped by the passing drivers. The poet is commenting on the individualism of modern society and telling us not to stand by and watch others suffer and that we need to stop the violence in our society. It is about how society accepts violence without objecting, whilst pretending to object. In this poem, Morgan freezes a dramatic moment in time in a vivid manner. This essay will show how the poet uses an attention-grabbing opening, effective word choice and imagery to capture a moment in time which changes everything. It will then go on to show how realistic violence, everyday characters and an underlying message help to present the poet’s ideas and to add excitement and emotion to the incident he describes.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Artists in the urban graffiti movement carried out their work among the cities they lived in. It becomes relevant to document their work to enhance society’s perception regardless of the legal concerns. By documenting their work, Mr. Brainwash captures the artists’ insight and motivation behind his or her form of art expression. Nevertheless this form of art is imperative to seize as many aspects of the artists’ work.…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Banksy Vandalism

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Banksy is known around the world for his artwork creating conversations that people are too afraid to start. Although graffiti is seen as a vandalous crime, Banksy’s work is use to point out the crime that is really harming our environment and society. Politics, economics, homophobia, hypocrisy, and war are all themes used in his work to project his beliefs on the recent issues around the world. As there are many fans of this anonymous artist, there are also many people who disagree with him. Banksy’s work lies between rebellious vandalism and art that speaks for those who cannot. He stated in an interview that his work is harmless compared to others, as he says, “Twisted little people go out every day and deface this great city; leaving their…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Street Art Vandalism

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For centuries, street art has been perceived all around us in subways, schools, building and even in the bathroom. Graffiti however, is a form of street art that most people are aware of and seen before. Graffiti is used as a form of expression for many young children all around the world, but society has many misconceptions regarding graffiti. People interpret graffiti as a form of vandalism and breaking the law, but it’s diverse style of art can create a beautiful way for an individual to express their emotions and bring other perspectives together. This form of expression is not a simple task to accomplish and yet it does not get the positive attention that it should just because society doesn’t understand the conception of graffiti. With…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We All Fall Down

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Cormier is very successful in engaging the readers interest through the use of a wide range of literary techniques including features of the thriller genre, narrative perspective and setting.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Graffiti Vandalism

    • 2272 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Look around a certain community; do you see spray-painted gates? Walls covered with irritating drawings? Spray-painted walls? Damage posters due to unnecessary markings? Cars polished with markers? Or any obscene and violent language scrawled on brick walls?…

    • 2272 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Open University (2015a) ‘The life and times of the street, (Part 1)’ [Video], DD102 Introducing the Social Sciences. Available athttps://learn2.open.ac.uk/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=620287§ion=2 (17.02.15).…

    • 335 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    History of Graffiti

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Most people in society view graffiti pieces negatively. Low class neighborhoods and vandalism are often associated with this form of artwork. Just like all other forms of fine artwork, graffiti pieces by true graffiti artists need to be analyzed and appreciated for the deeper meaning that they hold. Graffiti artists risk their reputations and security writing publicly. An extremely influential writer, Jerry Moise Rosembert, does social graffiti and his drawings often have political or social messages.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Graffiti Research Papers

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The wall speaks” truly shows how “walkers”(De Certeau) try to express themselves in the street level by making graffities, when we as “voyeurs”(De Certeau) takes pleasure in looking at the incredible good looking paintings, while trying to think deep down what these “walkers” are trying to say in their drawings. Graffities are sometimes treated as challenges to the government, because the act itself strongly refuses to conform to the law, and shows loss of control to other citizens. Government feels threatened by it, because Graffities generally shows awareness of current issues that surrounds the whole community. Usually with very strong words or graphics, it brings people together to think beyond and react to it, therefore governments around the world fears this kind of propaganda.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Graffiti Research Paper

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages

    I basically search all possible articles that discussed graffiti in an artistic way, rather than vandalistic. I acquired this article, “The Writing on the Walls”, which discusses a new program in a Los Angeles area where they have created a legal way for graffitists to express their art. “However, graffiti — from grand, elaborate murals to smaller, less-planned "tags" — often has been an unwelcome guest in the tourist area, frequently drawing complaints from residents. (Hart 1)” This article states how the new program gives graffitist open space and limited regulations to express their art to reduce the spread of graffiti in residential. Having such a well-developed understanding on the issue of graffiti, the city decided to solve the problem rationally and positively. This definitely is a big “plus” on my postion on the topic. “ICU responded with a new idea to attract artists to paint the pavilion 's walls instead.” Cities and organizations are looking for deterrents to help better the community as whole rather than restricting or ignoring the graffiti. “The city council also has contributed $15,000 to help with the organization 's efforts. (Hart 1)” Not only is the city dealing with the matter of graffiti and graffitist, there are also putting funding into programs and organizations to create the best possible outcome in hopes…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moreover, these artists reflect on a set of principles underlying their graffiti works, reflecting on the social contexts in cites and the public spaces. In addition to this, they have been seized by legal authority, and accused of supporting refusals to social issues and ideas, by producing graffiti writings, tags and works, which reflects on the criminalization of a rule maintained by the authority. (Young 2012, 297)…

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Others

    • 1088 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Growing up in a particular neighborhood related with gang influences and doing graffiti is usually not accepted by many people. In Ruben Martinez’s essay “Going up in LA”, he shows the community of the graffiti artists and how they get discriminated for what they do. Graffiti artist Phoe describes writing as a community because it is a source of communication with other writers all over the city (Pg 104 ¶ 14 ). This community uses this form of art to express their feelings, thoughts, and messages in public. They compose their own culture together by having a passion for “bombing” around town with their meaningful pieces. Writers from the Eastside state that when they do graffiti they are being blame for vandalism but when whites do it is called art (Pg 106 ¶ 23 ). There is a distinction based on race and class which irritates most eastside writers. They do come from poor neighborhoods and low class families but that should not mean their way of art should be treated as a false conation. Though there many people that might not understand graffiti. In the eyes of the LAPD, they typically see graffiti as not art and illegal unlike approved city murals. Stuart Haines assumes there is only way to put an absolute stop on graffiti, “The real answer is to pass tougher laws to punish the graffiti artists who deface public property, along with the gang members who are identifying their turf” (Pg 109 ¶31, 34 ). Most officials and adults strongly disagree with the acts of graffiti. They are seeking for other…

    • 1088 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays