Summary of "Value/Evaluation" by Barbara Hernstein Smith

Powerful Essays
Topics: Jane Eyre, Sociology
Summary of "Value/Evaluation"
In her essay "Value/Evaluation," Barbara Herrnstein Smith reflects upon the shifting nature of the evaluation process, and what exactly the meaning of "value" is. She begins by pointing out that the dispute on the value of something occurs whenever any social activity becomes the focal point of a discussion. However, Smith points out, the perspective on value and evaluation has changed dramatically, and is still a topic of debate. These new perspectives indicate that value judgments are made by entire societies, not necessarily individuals; they also give rise to skepticism and question traditional ideas about how evaluations are made.
Pointing out the importance of attempting to define a term before truly being able to discuss it, Smith identifies "value" as two separate but related meanings. The first and most obvious relates to the worth of an object, or "the material… equivalence-in-exchange of something" (178). The other, more intangible definition refers to a multitude of attributes: its practicality, its ability to expand upon some function, how gratifying it is to its owner, and its class in some sense. The related concept here, Smith stresses, is that "both senses of the term involve two key ideas, namely comparison and amount" (179). It is no wonder, then, Smith says, that the term "value" refers to something so elementary to our nature. There is, however, an even more complex and intangible aspect to the etymology of "value". In its historical sense, there has been a sense of the object itself having an inherent value of its own, above and beyond and monetary or cultural value. Therefore, while everything would then have some value of its own, Smith argues that it is also exactly what makes it distinct and incomparable, apart from any outside force.
This concept of inherent value is further complicated, Smith asserts, when applied to literature. This elusive idea of there being something else once any

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Reviewing the Case of Barbara Terry L. Bailey PS 531 Co-Occurring Disorders and Treatments Amanda Graham August 11, 2015 Kaplan University Abstract This paper will examine the case study of Barbara, a 29-year old single Hispanic female who presents with nervous episode, appearing to have an anxiety disorder. Additionally, she is also a mental health counselor which raises various legal and ethical concern regarding herself and her client. Discussion will include a completed assessment…

    • 2074 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It is my belief that the author, Barbara Ehrenreich does put forward an objective plan. Although she is a journalist, she acts as if her true profession is a scientist. She does this by having only one goal set, putting rules and boundaries in place for herself, and recording and analyzing the data she has collected. She decided to completely change her lifestyle and learn how many Americans live their lives. Ehrenreich tries her hardest to enter this experiment with neutral, unbiased ideologies…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Barbara Ehrenreich and Lewis Lapham asked themselves how anyone lives on the wages available to the unskilled. (Introduction: Getting Ready) Roughly four million women were about to taken off welfare reform programs to get jobs that paid $6 to $7 an hour; how will they survive? Barbara wanted to see how the 5 division of Dennis Gilbert and Joseph A. Kahl’s (1993) 6 part class structure handled everyday life without government assistance that she left her regular job and sat out on the journey. Although…

    • 2635 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Summary And Evaluation

    • 1254 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Part B: Summary In his article ‘Fossils Fuels Improve The Planet’, Mr Alex Epstein’s main claim was that fossil fuels are not dirty energy as they have created clean, healthy and liveable human environment. He also concluded that unlike fossil fuels, solar and wind energy - dubbed as cleaner energy - are expensive, unreliable and not abundant. He began by arguing that fossil-fuels-powered technologies and facilities have enabled humans to live in the most clean, healthy and liveable condition in…

    • 1254 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Chapter 2 Mini Case 1 -Smith, Smith, Smith, and Smith Elimination of errors during transmission is controlled by hardware and software. There are two categories of network errors when it comes to data; Corrupt data, data that has been changed during the transmission and Lost data, data that does not reach its final destination. When you design a network it should be constructed to prevent, detect and correct both the corrupt as well as the lost data errors. Network errors are inherent part of data…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Networking Concept and Application Assignment : Mini Case, Chapter 4 Smith, Smith, Smith, and Smith Smith, Smith, Smith, and Smith is a regional accounting firm that is putting up a new headquarters building. The building will have a backbone network that connects eight LANs (two on each floor). The company is very concerned with network errors. What advice would you give regarding the design of the building and network cable planning that would help reduce network errors? To best addressing…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    pixels but each pixel alone does not have any meaning. Only when you put these pixels together that is when you start to notice the small details that makes the bigger picture. After we took the pictures outside, I had to reread “on Compassion” by Barbara Ascher and began to understand what she was trying to say this time. She just wanted to notice what is going around her and when she did, she had noticed different scenes that made her questions if they are done because of care and love or feeling…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Barbara Ehrenreich’s book, Nickel-and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, she investigates whether welfare reform programs are appropriate in aiding women in poverty and that these institutions will affect their economic and social mobility in the future. Ehrenreich initiated her research in June 1998, in the form of participant observation. Her experiment was design allowed her to personally experience the hardships of a worker with minimal skills living on minimum wage. Barbara’s poses as…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this essay I will analyze James Rachel’s Smith and Jones case for active and passive euthanasia. Furthermore, I will give an ethical reasoning for why I either agreed or disagreed with his opinion. Additionally, I will show how he lures our attention to the dissimilarities amongst his view of killing and allowing someone to die. I will do so by refining my propositions and reaction of this case, of the dispute of active and passive euthanasia. By defending Rachel’s case I will discuss why…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the utility of wealth inspired people then they would admire the happiness that the rich, the noble or the ‘superior in society’, as Smith calls them, derive from their wealth and not the seemingly beauty that comes with wealth. Smith asserts that sympathy drives us to act the way we do. As observers, we put ourselves in the position of a sufferer. We imagine what it is to be in their shoes and what they may be feeling. We form an imagination of how they are affected and conceive what we ourselves…

    • 2479 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays