You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Thus, it is quite likely that schools may not have established official policies regarding online social media, and, even if pertinent policies do exist, the students may not be cognizant of these policies until after the fact. To this end, the current issue presents two opposing perspectives with respect to public schools’ authority over students’ online social media activity executed off-campus. On one side, in Layshock v. Hermitage School District, Chief Judge Theodore A. McKee, acting on behalf of the United States Third Circuit Court of Appeals, upheld Hermitage School District’s decision to discipline a student for his derogatory online speech regarding the principal that was originated outside of the school premises on the MySpace social media platform. In contrast, on the other side, in J.S. v. Blue Mountain School District, Chief Judge Theodore A. McKee, again acting on behalf of the United States Third Circuit Court of Appeals, overruled Blue Mountain School District’s decision to punish a student for a very similar offense. After carefully examining the aforementioned perspectives regarding this contemporary educational issue, I have concluded that public schools lack sufficient justification to…
- 1194 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Josh Renville, an 18 year old student attending Fargo North High School has petitioned against the school in question for violating his first amendment right to freedom of speech. The school prohibited Renville from using a photograph in which he his holding his favorite rifle for his senior portrait in the yearbook. Renville claims that by prohibiting the photograph, the school is infringing on his rights to freedom of symbolic speech. Despite Renville’s claims, the actions taken by the administrators at Fargo North High were completely constitutional. Fargo North was acting well within their constitutional limits to promote the ideals of public education, to properly monitor any media that would have been associated with the school, and to limit any action that inherently interfered with the school’s disciplinary…
- 815 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In my ruling, the illegal glorification of the drug culture “Bong hits for Jesus”. I feel the school had made a bad judgment call about having the banner. I feel it is not an attack on the saying “Bong hits for Jesus”. I feel that this is an attack on the student’s first amendment rights, just because the sign had something to do with marijuana. The school has an anti- drug program. I believe a non- disruptive pin, shirt, banner, etc. should not be taking from a student, for the shear fact that they oppose the anti-drug programs that the school offers. It is an attack on their first amendments rights. It was a 15-foot joke. The school dose has the right to not tolerate an interruption of a school sponsored anti-drug event. But this was not this kind of an event and the banner was not placed on school grounds. The banner was placed across the street from the school in a public open forum. One cannot be punished for holding of a banner not on school property. I feel that the principal was wrong to hastily take the banner down in the heat of the moment, but feel she should not pay punitive damages, for the banner was not worth much. Though the pride of the student’s who put the banner up was hurt a little I feel they should not be punished for expressing their first amendment rights, which they demonstrated non-violently, very conformed manner, and not on school property.…
- 279 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
BOSTON-MA, The 2009 Boston University scandal reveals itself earlier this week. The report contains players who drank a lot and had sex in the penalty box at Agganis Arena. From the reports given, it is clear that the BU hockey team feel like they are superior to the rules presented by their institution. Sara Al Hashemi, a 20-year-old junior at American University gives her input in regards to this situation. Al Hashemi was asked if college athletes get special treatment and she agreed that they most certainly do. “It happens a lot here at American University. The school pushes an athlete through school with less academic efforts in his part in order to ensure that he is still qualified and meets the requirements of the athletic board”. The same question was asked to Lama Ghannam, a 19-yearold junior at the University of Massachusetts and she also agreed with Al Hashemi.…
- 492 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
As long as college students, legal and underage, drink with responsibility on or off campus without any means of causing disturbance, destruction, or injury to themselves or others, then the schools should not be held responsible nor care, for that matter, of what students can do when it comes to any type of alcohol consumption. Even if to say a college student was to die from alcohol abuse, no matter the age, on campus, the university should still not be liable for the poor choices that student made for it wasn’t the school that made that student drink themselves to death. Each student has a conscious mind and knows how to utilize it, and if a university were to control it just because one immature student chose not to is inadmissible. However, some students may seem irresponsible with drinking habits due to the fact that they are new to…
- 724 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One cannot continue to coddle them any longer, college is the time and place to begin to show how one may act in the adult world. They must learn to deal with the consequences of their actions. Never blame the effect for the cause is the culprit. Take for example, Henry Wechsler, author of “Binge Drinking Must Be Stopped” argues for the banning of alcohol on campus grounds with this statement. “The root of the problem is seldom touched. The focus is on the students, and not on the suppliers and marketers of the alcohol” (31). This argument is invalid, the root of the problem is the students not the business. They are the ones who buy the alcohol and give business to the local bars, pubs and breweries. That would be the same as blaming the tobacco company for teen smoking. Instead colleges should implement harsher plenaties for students caught breaking the rules. That is to expel any students who are caught driving under the influence or buying drinks for anyone under the legal age who are currently enrolled in college. There must be consequences for these actions, this way students are also less likely to binge drink if it means getting kicked out of their school and potentially ruining their career. This in turn will promote more students to drink on campus as opposed to going out to parties and which could result in accidents or lives…
- 1317 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
It had three goals: prevent athlete drug use, protect student health and safety, and provide drug assistance programs. It imposed strict eligibility requirements: parents of student athletes had to submit a consent form for drug testing of their children, and the student athletes had to submit to tests. Once weekly the school randomly tested 10 percent of all student athletes by taking urine samples that were analyzed for illegal drug usage procedure known as urinalysis.…
- 658 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The student activities drug testing policy by Tecumseh, Ok school district requires all middle school and high school students to consent to urinalysis testing for drugs in order to participate in any extracurricular activity. Two Tecumseh high school students brought suit alleging that the policy violates the fourth amendment. Court appeals held that policy did violate the fourth amendment. The appellate court concluded that before imposing a suspicion less drug testing program, a school must demonstrate some identifiable drug abuse problem among a sufficient number of those tested, such that testing that group will actually redress its drug problem, which the school district failed to demonstrate.…
- 710 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Not only is it a violation of student rights, but it is also a waste of time and a feeble and tedious way of checking whether the students are under the influence of alcohol. In this day and age, alcohol isn’t the only substance impairing students, so rather than treating all the students as offenders and forcing them to blow into breathalyzers, schools should use other methods to further educate the students on how to have a great time without alcohol/substance. In the case of Northern SS, I believe that although the principal had pure intentions of helping the students, he did not approach this situation in an effective manner. Not only did he waste a lot of time and effort to dealing with this situation, but he may have caused the relationship between him and his students to become hostile. Nonetheless, if all schools were to implement such breathalyzer policy to prevent alcohol consumption at school events, why stop there? They might as well also enforce a policy that requires students to participate in a blood test or a pat down before entering any school-related event then. With that being said, prom should be remembered as a night of unforgettable memories, not as a night where you used a…
- 729 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Hazing is a concept that has been seeing increasing prevalence in America, especially within the past few decades. Indeed, hazing can be done for any number of reasons, yet the increasing prominence of technology such as social media means that the message that is sent through hazing is more salient now than ever. Although these traditions are a way to help promulgate the violence and reduce it, it is nevertheless as inhumane as causing direct harm, yet despite this, current laws do little to stem the tide of hazing incidents, nor to protect those who are vulnerable to them. This is especially disgusting when one considers the psychological, mental, and, in many cases, physical harm that can ultimately arise as a result of hazing. For this…
- 1698 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Cyberbullying is not a disruptive factor to school systems as the public school systems are making it out to be. In the J.S v. blue mountain school district case, J.S created a Myspace profile about her middle school principle, the profile did not include the name of the principle or the school name just a picture of him. Students of course at the school talked about it but they have that right according to the 1st amendment it is the right to free speech. I feel that what she did didn’t cause harm to the principle or physical dangers of other students merely a simple joke. I feel that for her being suspended was an unreasonable action. The facts simply do not support the outcome that the school district could assume it disrupted any school ordinary day functions.…
- 501 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
But what is not obvious is that in recent rulings electronic image (photographs) of people in some circumstances can also be classed as personal data. So class or course activity photos need to be considered and individual approval sought before using on social media, websites, and promotional materials…
- 1078 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Schools are now starting drug testing students because of the rate of drug use that’s under the influence. Drug testing in schools will put the students’ rights and the schools’ money at risk. The article ¨Presumed Guilty¨ by Emily C. Mckenna explains that drug testing is against people's constitutional rights. One reason why drug tests put students rights at risk is because that it´s invading the students privacy. Emily C. Mckenna introduces us with the price for drug tests for each student and about constitutional rights. According to Emily C. Mckenna, she states, “ But I do have something to protect my constitutional rights.” (Emily C. Mckenna 77) . The constitutional rights show that drug tests do not have the right to invade people's…
- 258 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Campus gossip websites were ideally intended to be used as a way to communicate with students and engage with peers in useful ways. I feel that campus gossip websites are being used unethically. Currently, Campus gossip websites are just now being utilized to start rumors and anonymously publicly bash fellow students without ramifications from school and related officials. In turn, the students have gone to new extremes with malicious comments towards fellow peers and in some cases, causing physical and emotional damage with no clarity on who all should be held liable. A waste of time and energy is spent by students anonymously involving themselves in these gossip websites who knowingly hold such power to destroy a fellow peer and yet people still use them in all the wrong ways.…
- 1595 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Colleges should use monitoring purposes for social media pages. One good example is to monitor the social page for drug use or suicidal post. According to Michael Martinez publisher of CNN: he said,( “California school district hires firm to monitor students' social media” . If somebody had been posting that they were doing drugs and was depressed and could have been on the verge of committing suicide, the people monitoring would have been able to see to notify someone to help. Monitoring somebody’s post if they are cursing all the time. Say you were going to a religious college and one of their rules was to not curse on social media sites. If somebody was the monitoring business would see it and would be able to notify and dean and student. This is why college should use monitoring purposes.…
- 460 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays