Selkie Girl and the Secret of Roan Inish: Similarities and Differences

Better Essays
Topics:
Legends, myths, and folklore have always captured my attention. Whether they are about made-up, mystical creatures or even creatures turning into humans, I always seem to thoroughly enjoy the stories behind them. After reading the novel Selkie Girl and watching the movie Secret of Roan Inish, I started to draw some similarities and differences between the two. Further research from other selkie folklore stories really began to show me that there are different elements to each myth that continuously relate back to Laurie Brooks’ Novel and the film we watched in class. Each one of these comparisons shows why there are so many believers today in these tales.
In the novel, Selkie Girl, Brooks’ explains that selkie's can only come ashore and transform into humans once a year on Midsummer’s Eve. From discussions in class and from my own interpretations, I was under the impression that selkie’s could emerge out of their skin whenever they wanted to. This was not the case throughout Selkie Girl. When the main character, Elin Jean, learns that her mother is a selkie, the black and the red selkies explain that “every year at Midsummer they return to be with her” mother (Brooks). The novel differs from the movie, Secret of Roan Inish, because in the movie there is a scene where a young man finds a selkie, captures her pelt, and then takes her captive to be his wife on land. It was not stated in the movie that it was Midsummer’s Eve when the fisherman discovered the selkie. In fact, the movie made it seem like selkies could shed their pelts and come on land whenever they wanted to.
Continuing my research online, I found that many folklore have differences as to how often the selkie-folk were able to carry out the transformation. Some tales say it was once a year, usually on Midsummer's Eve, while others state it could be “every ninth night” or “every seventh stream”. Another legend says if a mortal woman wishes to make contact with a selkie-man, there was a specific

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Roan Inish

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Conelly’s bond with Roan Inish. The film directed by John Sayles; The Secret of Roan Inish is a captivating story about an Irish family; The Coneelly’s. The family’s bond to the island of Roan Inish and the seals that reside nearby is exceptional and mystifying. Why are the Coneelly’s so drawn to the island? The family’s roots on Roan Inish start far back with Fiona’s great great great grandfather Sean Michael who arrives on the island on a prayer. Another Coneelly; Liam, solidifies the connection…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ripple of concern for him. For a Selkie, it was forever, for a human it wasn’t quite the same effect. Even for a Selkie, a lifemate was hard to find. Selkie’s enjoyed sex with others of their kind and humans alike. Selkies are known for their sexual talents and prowess in pleasing others. But, once a Selkie found it’s lifemate they did not wander from their mate, to remain faithful until death. He wondered if Adaira would want to share her life with a Selkie. His life without…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    relate Rozin to Selkie. Rozin, fell in love with Frank when she was married to her ex-husband, Richard. At some point I got the feeling that Rozin wanted to live alone, however she asserts, “even if (we) never get married (she considers this just living together)” (253). Rozin comprises her dream of marrying to Frank to just living with him, she even decides to create a party for his birthday so that he can remember the love and thoughtfulness she put into the planning (253). Selkie comprise with the…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Similarities and Differences of discriminatory treatment of African and Asian Americans Even though Asians came to America voluntarily and African Americas were brought involuntarily as slaves (a significant difference), both share similar discrimination experiences at the hands of White Americans fighting to maintain their dominance. Similarities: Unequal pay, limited job opportunities as agricultural labors and domestic servants, defended the United States in segregated military regiments, refused…

    • 364 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Similarities and Differences

    • 2419 Words
    • 10 Pages

    SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES ASPECTS | SIMILARITIES | DIFFERENCES | THEMES | For the short story, The Drover’s Wife the theme is life is precious and needs to be protected. Four innocent life would be lost if the drover’s wife fails in the duty as a protective mother.For the short story Looking for a Rain God, the theme is also life is precious. The moral issue on life in this story is; no one has the rights to take his or her life. Life is the gift of God and it is precious. | For the short…

    • 2419 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Running head: Similarity and Difference Similarities and Differences Comparisons between the iGAAP and U.S. GAAP There happens to be important resemblances and dissimilarities between International GAAP and the United States GAAP in the accounting for intangible assets. Resemblances as well as dissimilarities should not come at a surprise to the accounting profession. U.S. GAAP compared to any other entity has similarities and differences, so therefore the iGAAP is no different. It is estimated…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Writing Effective Comparison or Contrast Essays A Comparison or Contrast essay is an essay in which you either compare something or contrast something. A comparison essay is an essay in which you emphasize the similarities, and a contrast essay is an essay in which you emphasize the differences. We use comparison and contrast thinking when deciding which university to attend, which car to buy, or whether to drive a car or take a bus or an airplane to a vacation site. In this section, two classic…

    • 4768 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Similarities and Differences Nowadays, people depend more on technologies. Almost everyone has at least one hardware and software. How do people use those technologies and how do they think? Thoughts are different. I read the article “ Hell Is Other iPods” by Caspar Melville and “Someone to Watch Over Me” by Theodora Stites. I found some similarities and differences of those two articles and I would like to share my experience which relates to those two articles. First of all, both “ Hell Is…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Smith,William Bradford, and Mary Rowlandson encountered numerous dangerous and fatal events due to the new lives they wanted to start in this new world, because of this they have many similarities and differences in their writings. One big similarity was Death, they were surrounded by it. It was as if Death was playing a sick joke with them taking away friends and family, slowly eating at what little hope they had left. In John Smiths “The General History” fifty people had died from starvation…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    African American literature has been an important cultural canon of literature for the better part of the last century. Their contributions have provided a large work from which one may draw criticism. Many argue that the legacy of African American literature beginning with the genius of the Harlem Renaissance. One its key players, Zora Neale Hurston created a masterpiece with her 1937 magnus opus: Their Eyes Were Watching God. Hurston lays the groundwork, and provides an avenue for contemp…

    • 351 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays