Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Romanesque Architecture vs. Gothic Architecture

Better Essays
1120 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Romanesque Architecture vs. Gothic Architecture
Tabitha Crosby
Dr. Maineville
Hum1020
10/07 /2012

Romanesque Architecture and Gothic Architecture
Throughout history it’s simple to understand how so many were inspired to create masterpieces we see and love today. Many years ago beauty was shaped in almost every feature, sculpture, and building. One of the most memorable of these iconic creations can be seen in Romanesque and Gothic architecture; however even though they are both similar they also have many differences. These themes were carried out throughout many parts of Europe sending both fear and beauty through the hearts of every being to lay their eyes upon them. Whether it was in its distinctive windows, unique exterior and interior designs, or any of the other myriad architectural features, Romanesque and Gothic architecture are identifiable if one can distinguish the two types of styles.
It was the age of the development of Romanesque and Gothic Architecture where the battle began to reach greater and higher achievements. During this new development a new task was held that gave a new appreciation for light, during the medieval age many structures were built sheltered and isolated from the world outside. The inside of these buildings would seem dark and on some occasions moldy. With the development of new structures the idea for these new Gothic structures was to make a more pleasant place to be. By allowing higher and grander windows it allowed more light in these usual dark places, it removed many issues with mold and eliminated the use of open doors on raining days. It was a great achievement for the new structures and it was a feature that remained with them throughout time. However many were not so focused on the idea of an open and airy concept. The Romanesque buildings are known for their straight and boxy appearance. In Roman structures the walls were large and thick and had to create smaller windows as to not weaken to walls with large gaps. The Civic Hall in Massa Marittima, Italy has a very popular boxy appearance, and is limited on large or thick windows. By making these windows lean and tall it allowed for light while maintain a strong and sturdy fortress. It was a trait that allowed for simplicity and convenience for both styles of building and was in time considered the norm for both of their establishments.
To consider these fortresses and churches as the norm could be understatement for such ginormous master pieces. With gothic structures it is very easy to identify typical features for these unique buildings, everyone can say the vaulted ceilings and large towers, but it’s the small detail that makes it all flow together. Gargoyles have been apart Gothic structures since the beginning being both practical and intimidating. Originally their use was to sprout out water from the roof tops and to flow them to the street below, but for unreligious citizens it was to motivate them in to the safety of church. With a world filled with fear and superstitions it was the perfect way to lure people into the safety with the stone cold glares.(Morris) By allowing such a positive and protective presence in the center it draws your attention away from the demons above; allowing for an excellent way to attractive its citizens to the safety of insideAlthough in stocking fear was a tactful tool, the Romanesque style of detailed and religious art was also effective. Romanesque buildings wanted to tell stories, similar to Gothic structures, with their buildings to let all citizens see the religious stories chiseled in stone. Many of the buildings had carved in stories that were Biblical in subject and included scenes such as the Creation and the Fall of Man (Notre). The tympanum on Vézelay Abbey, Burgundy, France (Vézelay), is a perfect example to fully grasp the detail and message of Romanesque exterior art. It shows the depictions of people lining up to enter heaven all facing Christ who remains in the center. Both themes were inclined in showing stories about the religion, and both succeeded leaving behind hundreds of tales of a salvation and resurrection that will forever be marked in stone.
In Gothic buildings were built with an attachment of ribbed vaults. Ribbed vaults were the most common vaults used in Gothic structures, with high vaulted ceiling it’s one of its most popular traits in their buildings. An example of these remarkable ceilings can be seen in the Bourges Cathedral in Bourges, France; this memorable Cathedral shows the perfect use of ribbed vaults. These vaulted ceilings were constructed for weight to be distributed throughout the structure and toward the ground, however an almost identical trait followed through Romanesque architecture. It was in ingenious ideas that in time lead to giving both themes an extraordinary way to distribute the buildings weight. However vaulted ceilings were not the only tools that helped support these old buildings. In Gothic structures pointed arches had become a very popular and common trait amongst their buildings. With the Gothic’s pointed arch it allowed for more height development since most of the pressure would return to the ground. The reason in Gothic structures it was common to see such height in their towers, because a majority of the weight was resting on the surface. While in Romanesque arches were rounded, mostly commonly known as a semi-circle arch. A very popular place to see these arches is at the Pont du Gard in Roman Gual. The semi-circle arches allowed for many gallons of water to flow to Rome, with the support of these strong arches it has been able to remain standing even through all these year.
It is hard to imagine words to describe these structural themes. These architectural beauties have inspired and entertained millions throughout the world. Sending a message of power and wealth to all who look upon it, with so much alike Romanesque and Gothic will remain different from others and themselves. From the ribbed ceilings, unique window differences, majestic features, and innovative structural results. These great themes will live forever not just in physical form but in our imaginations, fully understanding the art like this cannot just be built over and over again.

Bibliography page
"Notre-Dame De Paris." Notre-Dame De Paris. N.p., n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. <http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/-English->.
Morris, E. "The Seven Key Characteristics of Gothic Architecture." : From the Gargoyle to the Flying Buttress. Castles Blog, n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. http://www.exploring-castles.com/characteristics_of_gothic_architecture.html
"Vézelay Abbey (Basilique Ste-Madeleine)  ." Vézelay Abbey (Basilique Ste-Madeleine). Sacred Destinations, n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. <http://www.sacred-destinations.com/france/vezelay-church>.

Bibliography: page "Notre-Dame De Paris." Notre-Dame De Paris. N.p., n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. &lt;http://www.notredamedeparis.fr/-English-&gt;. Morris, E. "The Seven Key Characteristics of Gothic Architecture." : From the Gargoyle to the Flying Buttress. Castles Blog, n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. http://www.exploring-castles.com/characteristics_of_gothic_architecture.html "Vézelay Abbey (Basilique Ste-Madeleine)  ." Vézelay Abbey (Basilique Ste-Madeleine). Sacred Destinations, n.d. Web. 04 Oct. 2012. &lt;http://www.sacred-destinations.com/france/vezelay-church&gt;.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Third, in Gothic architecture was had some animals on the walls. The animals are call Gargoyles. The Gargoyles were also one of the important characteristic of Gothic architecture. The Gargoyles usually on the top of the roof of buildings. The Gargoyles not only the decorative, but also deterrence evil not to come close this place. In fact the purpose of the Gargoyles were drain off the rainwater from the roof. This design on the roof not only the functional, but also had another meaning behind. Most of Gothic architecture buildings were no longer just decorate inside, the architects were decorated outside. The Notre Dame cathedral is the typical example of gothic style. The Notre Dame cathedral has all of the characteristic we mentioned before.…

    • 124 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sainte-Foy is one of the earliest surviving examples of a Romanesque style pilgrimage church. That is, a church designed specifically to accommodate visiting pilgrims. (Peterson). It is basically an expansion of the Early Christian basilica church, such as Old Saint Peters Basilica. The former aisles on either side of the nave were extended around the transept and apse to form an ambulatory aisle circling the perimeter of the church (Adams, 383). This permitted the pilgrim to circumambulate the entire church without entering the central vessel, leaving the monks undisturbed access to the main altar in the choir (Rice). The nave and two transept arms are capable of holding hundreds of faithful pilgrims who may all see the priest officiating on the main altar located underneath the crossing. (Bultez, D.) A very prominent feature in many Romanesque churches is the radiating chapel. In the Abbey Church of Sainte Foy, there are 3 small radiating chapels around the main apse and two chapels of unequal size added to the east side of both transept arms (Adams, 383). These smaller chapels were dedicated to saints and the Madonna (Zurakowski, D).…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Even though the Italians said the Gothic architecture is “barbaric” and should discontinue the style, surprisingly the style is still being constructed to this day. I chose the St. John the Divine because it has so much similarity to the Cathedral of Notre Dame, Paris. Even though the St. John the Divine is unfinished, it is a very big tourist attraction, just like the Cathedral of Notre Dame. They both have the whole gothic style look, such as the wheel windows, that you notice, almost always, first and stained glass windows. The only difference that is noticeably is how the Cathedral of Notre Dame has a different front look then St. John the Divine.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the Middle Ages in Europe, it was considered a light age through the Rise of Universities, the Gothic Cathedrals, the First Crusade, the Black Death and the Magna Carta. The Rise of Universities was part of the light age in Europe because it shows that there were many people being educated by the amount of universities built in that time period. According to The Rise of Universities passage, ”University of Bologna, University of Paris, University of Oxford, University of Cambridge and University of Salamonca,” were some universities constructed. Gothic Cathedrals showed that several new architectural ideas were being constructed. The Universities and Cathedrals document states, “Common features of Gothic Cathedrals included architectural…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Salisbury Cathedral

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In medieval England and all across Europe, Romanesque architecture was the most popular style when it came to building cathedrals. One classic characteristic of Romanesque architecture was rounded arches. This characteristic was visible in all Romanesque cathedrals. Thick walls were also a common characteristic. There were not many windows so it did not allow much light into the building. This old style of architecture slowly became less favored when Gothic style architecture was introduced to England in the late 12th century. Since the construction for the Salisbury Cathedral started in the early 13th century, it fully embraced the rise of Gothic architecture. A noticeable difference in this style of architecture is that instead of rounded arches, there were pointed Gothic arches. This new arch could support more weight and distribute the weight more effectively as buildings were getting higher and higher. Height was also a very important part of Gothic architecture. The Salisbury Cathedral with the spire is over 400 feet in height, and the spire that Jocelin visions of adding is also that tall. This was symbolic of reaching towards the heavens and would allow people to, quite literally, reach the heavens and connect with God. In order to build so high, a new design, flying buttresses, were added. They were buttresses that spread the additional weight away from building. This removed much of the pressure from the building and onto the ground. Additionally, large lancet windows were typical of Gothic architecture. These lancet windows allowed large quantities of light to enter, which is different from Romanesque in which minimal light entered the cathedrals. Light would be able to transform a church into a more majestic and desirable place of worship. It created a sense of power in God, which was why people worshipped…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gothic Vs Gothic Essay

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although to some level it is ultimately undeniable that The Yellow Wallpaper and The Strange Case of Dr.Jekyll and Mr.Hyde represent the gothic genre, it can be viewed as too simplistic because of the complexity within the Gothic genre; both showing clear distinct differences between each other. ‘Dr.J+Mr.H’ explores the Duality of man through the beast like character of Mr. Hyde, with clear conventions of the Classic Gothic. TYW on the other hand representing the modern Gothic, replacing the supernatural with the irrational, which is not seen as monstrous but preferable by the unnamed female protagonist which sees her insanity as a triumph for freedom.…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gothic Environment

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the same way it was placed in a Gothic environment due to the “neighboring hillside churchyard of St. John's” and the “Eighteenth Century gravestones” that can be seen in the churchyard. The elements of nature converge with this old house, in the same way it happened in Dracula, where the castle of the Count is placed. The yard of the house reflects the image of a dreadful forest, since the house is described as “vacant, with barren, gnarled and terrible old trees, long, queerly pale grass and nightmarishly misshapen weeds in the high terraced yard where birds never lingered.” (92) An important difference between the setting of the Gothic tradition and this story is that of the location of the house. It is located in an urban environment…

    • 171 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Gothic Period is regarded as a grand step forward towards personal choice and creativity, allowing the artist to transcend beyond the simplistic forms of day-to-day life. The Gothic vocabulary gradually permeated all forms of art throughout Europe—pointed arches, trefoils, flying buttresses and other architectural ornaments. The dominant theme of the period was, without a doubt, Christianity and Christian ideals. The most produced works of the time were those utilized in churches such as reliquaries, liturgical vessels, precious diptychs, illuminated manuscripts, as well as sculpture. During this period, France was a major contributor to the material culture of Western Europe and art in general. Echoes of its grandeur, especially in architecture,…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gothic Cathedrals Essay

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Architecture at this point in time was labeled Gothic for its advances in the way buildings were established with pointed arches, ribbed vaulting, and flying buttresses that gave way to taller and more stable buildings.(Spanswick) The Renaissance appreciated beauty, but the time period was focused more on the study of Roman art and history. Although the focus was mainly Roman history, the Renaissance still applauded the innovative ways that the new and dynamic design was being accomplished. Cathedrals are their own individual works of…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To support this vaults and domes the walls of Romanesque buildings and structures were made very thick and had projecting piers called buttress, which helped to bare the weight of the heavy stones. The massive size of the stones used in Romanesque buildings and structure is another characteristics of this style. Because of the massive stones vaults, walls and piers most of the Romanesque buildings and structures were composed of many small units called bays that together completed the whole design. When these bays when placed in a long row down the center of a Romanesque building or structure they were called a nave. The naves of the Romanesque period were much higher and narrower then of periods before it. This allowed for clerestory windows that were larger and higher then ones that came before it but they were still very small and many of them did not contain glass. Almost all of the doors and windows of the Romanesque style were capped with round arches. Towards the end of the Romanesque period decorative moldings and carvings and sculptures were used in many buildings and…

    • 2191 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gothic Architecture

    • 2691 Words
    • 11 Pages

    3. Beaumaris castle- unfinished masterpiece and the last and the largest of the Edwardian castles built by james of st. George; concentric castle; talus "inclination of the wall for…

    • 2691 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The invention of the Christian church was one of the brilliant solutions in architectural history. This was achieved by a process of assimilating and rejecting various precedents, such as the Greek temple, the Roman public building, the private Roman house, and the synagogue. The Early Christian period saw the growth of Christianity. It was established as the state religion of the Empire under the successors of Constantine. Early Christian Architecture consisted of the basilica church developed from the Roman secular basilica. The sixth century was a time of growth for the Byzantine Empire. Many of the churches built during this time were of the basic basilica style. At least two developments began during this century. One involved small buildings with domed or niched interiors and the other the use of domed vaulting in the basilica. While it is difficult to generalize any architectural developments during this time, one of the most striking changes that can be found in many churches of this time is the use of the domed nave. The domed nave was usually used with a rectangular or Latin cross plan. The Carolingian and Ottonian (merely a continuation of Carolingian period) periods consisted of mainly the basilica also. By the end of the pre-Romanesque period, Roman stylistic elements had fused with elements from Byzantium and the Middle East, and from the Germans, the Celts, and other northern tribes in Western Europe. These various combinations created a number of local styles, called Romanesque, meaning "in the manner of the Roman." An outstanding achievement of Romanesque architects was the development of stone vaulted buildings. To support the heavy stone vaults, architects used massive walls and piers, creating a typical building plan that treated the entire structure as a complex composed of smaller units, called bays. A distinguishing feature of Romanesque style, bays are square or rectangular spaces enclosed by groin vaults and used by architects as the basic…

    • 1582 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Notre Dame de Paris

    • 3784 Words
    • 16 Pages

    Gothic Architecture (n.d.). Introduction: Flowering of the Gothic in Vol.4 No.2 of Athena Review. Retrieved September 10th,2007 from http://www.athenapub.com/14gothic-architecture.htm…

    • 3784 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The building that has taken my interest is Notre Dame de Paris, which literally means “Our Lady of Paris” in French. When one thinks of Gothic architecture, majority will think of Notre Dame as it is one the most significant French catholic cathedral that is distinctively Gothic. Because Notre Dame has seen many reconstruction in its days, its early construction in the period 1160s is characterized as Early Gothic and adopt similar pointed arch that transcends from late Romanesque. Notre Dame’s early gothic style then slowly evolved in 13th century when High Gothic began to achieve further light, tall and yet majestic. Clerestory windows had changed from one window holed in a wall, into two windows united by elaborate window tracery and colourful rose window. 1…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Decadence

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Romanesque Architecture has developed and separated into first Romanesque architecture and Norman Architecture. Just like human as we grow up and become more mature, we retain our personality but gradually developed more distinction from the others. The First Romanesque architecture contained the characteristics of rubble walls, smaller windows and non-vaulted roof which in contrast Romanesque architecture had increased the use of vault and dressed stone. Building San Pietro in Agliate, 875 is one of the examples of first Romanesque architecture. As we can see the thick external wall is covered by rubbles, with small rounded arch windows. The other type of Romanesque architecture is in England which known as Norman architecture. The distinctive characteristics of Norman…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics