Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Revisionist History of Roman Legions

Better Essays
1048 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Revisionist History of Roman Legions
Revisionist History History today can be either greatly exaggerated or underrated by movies and other presentations of major events in history. Movies give an account of the historical past a “Hollywoodized” look to make the viewer more fascinated and entertained by the story. Movies such as Centurion, Last Legion, and The Eagle are in fault “Hollywoodizing” the historical factors and truth. The theme behind the given movies is the mysterious Ninth Legion, and how this legion seemed to vanish from record (historical and archaeological) in AD 108. “Modern scholars can be credited with developing the story that this legion was destroyed and then ignominiously forgotten, likely sometime during either the reign of Trajan or Hadrian.” Whether defeated, disappeared, or complete annihilation of Rome’s Ninth Legion stationed in Britain the military would not leave it to ruin.
A station that has been defeated would gather up their skirts and retaliate; they would not let a legion’s destruction go unpunished, Romans were not known to back down from a fight. They were most commonly instigators and would definitely not try to hide or run away from a defeat. Multiple situations and battles during Roman history prove their military’s persistence and their ability to overcome a defeat and retaliate. Historical sources relate that in 390 BC, several Gallic tribes from Transalpine Gaul region invaded Italy from the north. Rome was then attacked and destroyed. In the event of an ambush or a major defeat of the Roman army, news of the account would be immediately sent to surrounding campaigns, to Rome, as well as other cities. In turn the camps and the cities would send aid to the fallen legion, and attack the enemy. In this case the citizens who left for protection manage to raise an army under Camillus. The military waited until the Gauls divided their army in order to obtain food while the other half was left to keep the city secure. The Gaulish army collecting food was destroyed making the left standing army in Rome easy to kill. In other words Camillus used the placement of the Gauls strategically to defeat them and take back their city.
During the greater part of Roman’s history was their attention on expanding their empire. Legions were set in place to protect the barrier/boundary of Roman Empire, and they controlled the boarders. If one was to be defeated, the enemies creating a threat of invasion in the empire would be put in their place. The military would advance to the area in question and plan an attack. This idea was behind the first of the Punic Wars. Carthage, Syracuse and Rome all sought to control Massena, Sicily for trade and material goods. Rome was looking to expand its boarders as well as using Sicily to export its wealth and trade, placing Massena under Roman protection. This action caused the leading to the Punic Wars. With the empire expanding and provinces are being created and wealth is being sifted into the Roman treasury. Rome begins to receive more money as a way to pay tribute from other provinces and people start ‘donating’ (so to speak) able bodied men to join the legions, which in made it easy to raise armies and campaign.1 Rome’s refusal to run away from a fight and hid was their advantage in military reforms, which practice new tactics and strategies to become better than their opponent. After the sack of Rome by the Gauls, Rome engaged in military campaign of a yearly basis and created the main military unit of group of legions. Fallowing this war military tactics changed, and moved away from the Greek Phalanx style of fighting, instead adopted weaponry closer resemblance to the Gauls, as well as their ability to cross vast distances with speed. The legions were tough; they trained to march for long distances while carrying not only enough food for two weeks, but also their heavy armor, a shield, helmet, two javelins, a dagger, and a short sword.2 The difficulty between the military advantaged of Carthage and Rome was Carthage’s strong navy and Rome’s strong infantry. With Carthage’s upper hand to reach the shores of Italy faster the Roman military had to adapt and change tactics. Rome began building warships and developed a boarding advice corvus, turning the naval battle into an infantry battle. Roman’s legions were organized, strong and disciplined. They were well trained to come up against any conditions they had to face. They were able to adapt strategies and tactics, the adopted styles of fighting from opponents who were lucky enough to overcome them and perfected it. A strong military is nothing without its commanders or generals to lead. Emperors would ensure the legions fierce training by personal inspecting and staying with the camp, such as Trajan and Hadrian. Hadrian visited camps to ensure discipline, but also continued military reforms, and created a distinction between the legions and auxiliary.
The mystery behind a disappearing legion can be labeled as ridiculous in the sense of the Roman army’s nature to be fierce and at times honorable. Throughout history, sources inform that Romans where never seen to be cowards but used influence of others (Greeks and Carthaginians) to aid in their already strong and over powering military. They were able to adapt strategically and tactically to better themselves to overcome enemies while keeping their boarders and home safe from threatening invaders. From reforms, the legions were able to come as aid for fellow foreign allies, or take revenge on those who were in the wrong. From expansion the empire Romans military grew dramatically in numbers. Rome’s military defeated many in its history and can be considered one of the best. Men were not only protecting their brothers in arms, but also their empire, they were warriors who never backed down from a threat or a fight.
Bibliography

Crookham, Alan. The Power of the Roman Army, Yahoo Contributor Network, Nov 27, 2007 http://voices.yahoo.com/the-power-roman-army-664193.html Gray, David E., Why was the Roman Army so Dominate in the Ancient World? Yahoo Contributor Network Oct 16, 2008
Http://voices.yahoo.com/why-was-roman-army-so-dominate-ancient-1907600.html?cat=41

Valdivielso, Michael. Fall of Rome, Visitor Contributions Articles written by Visitors to the Site. http://www.roman-empire.net/articles/article-003.html

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this essay I will argue that the Principate is a history of military dictatorships insofar as certain emperors seize power via some form of military coup. I shall cover emperors via the themes of: bread and circuses, reliance on the army and Praetorian Guard as depicted on imperial coinage and the times when the accession of an emperor is instigated by either defeat in battle or the assassination of one’s predecessor.…

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The long decline of the Western Roman Empire was caused by the accumulation of the many obstacles that stood in their way over time. At first the Roman Empire was thriving. It was the biggest empire at the time and it expanded at an incredible speed. Their military and leadership capabilities were magnificent. When confronted by the Roman military their enemies were better off giving up and not even trying; it wasn’t worth it. In time, however, the Roman Empire’s golden age expired, they stopped conquering and internal drawbacks began to appear. The once flourishing Roman Empire began to face many problems, like military incapacity, the growth of Christianity, and unemployment, all of which contributed in a different way to the decline of the Empire.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Spartacus Film Analysis

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the movie Spartacus the deployment of the Roman army is very interesting. In the battle scene you see a deployment of a legion in a quincunx formation (checker board pattern) this shows the discipline and organization of the Roman army. As the Roman army comes closer to Spartacus' slave army the front legion starts to form a solid front line and they would continue moving forward. As the front group is lining up you can see the back legionaries coming together into one group. As an opponent seeing this it can be quiet intimating.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tiberius Army Influence

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Army held an increasing amount of influential power over each of the Julio-Claudian Emperors’; the army was the base of the Julio-Claudian dynasty. The Principate was founded on the practice of maius imperium, supreme military potestas (power). Soldiers swore an…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1000 BCE, a group of Latins, later known as Romans, founded the city of Rome. After almost 500 years of it being founded, the Romans set up a republic. They gained territory by force, beginning with the Italian peninsula and then easily moving to the Mediterranean region. The Romans launched a series of three wars, known as the Punic Wars. During this time, the were able to conquer Carthage and in return gained access into Sicily, Sardinia, and Corsica. Even after the Punic Wars ended, Rome still managed to gain the territory of Macedonia, Greece and even some parts of Anatolia. Even through troubling times of the empire, it still managed to spread through Gaul,…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In eighth to sixth century BCE Celtic Gaul’s culture began to emerge. Its surrounding neighbors, especially the Romans, saw their culture as barbaric. Gaul was separated into tribes led by chiefs. Life had been uncomfortable, agitating, and very divided between the tribes and its people. The Romans saw this division as an opportunity to take Gaul, and conquered it in the turning battle of Alesia in 52 BCE. The victory in this battle resulted in new Roman cities like Lugdunum (which is now Lyon) and Arles being established in Roman Gaul, and with these new cities came the influence of Roman politics and religion.…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Romans were great diplomats. They were firm when necessary and smart about granting citizenship. They also let citizens participate in domestic affairs. Their military was made up of strong, persistent soldiers. If a substantial amount of men were lost in battle they wouldn’t just surrender, but instead recruit new soldiers. They would build up new armies so that they could keep fighting. The Romans were also good strategists. By the year 264 BCE Rome had established colonies in strategic spots throughout Italy. By connecting these settlements with roads, they built a military and communication network that helped them rule more effectively. By getting military help from allies, they mobilized Italy’s military…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rome, Constantinople, and the Barbarians begins by reaffirming that barbarians fit the epitomization of the external dimension because they were foreigners. Barbarians were the name the Grecko-Romans used when referring to non-Greek speakers. It was up to historians to ask whether the barbarians of the Christian era, the Goths, Vandals, Huns, other tribes, fit into this idea of unforeseeable “ruin from the outside.” Despite this idea of unforeseeable “ruin from the outside”, the barbarian invasions did not happen to an unsuspecting Roman empire. Rome was custom to having warlike tribesmen at its gates and could deal with them (Goffart 275). Barbarian tribes were portrayed under anachronistic names. The Goths…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The traditional dates for the Roman Republic are 509 to 27 B.C. The latter part of this period from 133 to 27 B.C. is known as the late Republic. It is also known as the Roman Revolution. The result of this revolution was the emergence of the Roman Empire and the catalyst has traditionally been linked to a single Roman citizen called Tiberius Gracchus. The wake of his brief political career left Rome much different than it had been. Like a crack in the wall of a dam, Tiberius revealed a weakness in the Roman system of government that would soon spider out of control until it could no longer hold back the deluge of the building political tension. What was this weakness?…

    • 2567 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In spring of 72 BC, the slaves left their winter encampments and began to move northwards. At the same time, the Roman Senate, alarmed by the defeat of the praetorian forces, dispatched a pair of consular legions under the command of Lucius Gellius Publicola and Gnaeus Cornelius Lentulus Clodianus. The two legions were initially successful—defeating a group of 30,000 slaves commanded by Crixus near Mount Garganus but then were defeated by Spartacus. These defeats are depicted in divergent ways by the two most comprehensive (extant) histories of the war by Appian and…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Roman Successor Empires

    • 3500 Words
    • 14 Pages

    The barbarian forces were able to effectively invade the roman empire and the military fighting was used to show the power of the ruler. Traditionally the Roman forces were paid in fee regularly whilst the Barbarians were not due to the lack of a tax system. The men enlisted to fight were often men from the aristocrats’ army and the king’s men (a small proportion of the total population). If a war leader was successful they are able to set up a post- roman regime like Clovis. In this period there…

    • 3500 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since the third century C.E., Rome faced many problems and was weakened by barbaric invasions from 100-500 C.E. Around 476 C.E, most of the Eastern Roman Empire was still intact, but the Western Roman Empire was covered by barbarians. External enemies, such as the Saxons, Vandals, and Ostrogoths engaged with Rome, which enabled the empire to wear out slowly. On the other hand, this powerful empire was not only weakened by external rivals but by internal decay as well. The increase of enemies contributed to the problematic issue of recruiting soldiers. Rome had difficulty recruiting male boys from Rome into their military, which resulted in the government to promptly pay German foreigners to join the army. Low funding from citizens did not give the military supplies or resources they needed to protect Rome. Consequently, citizens rarely paid for the army, even though Rome kept on paying German foreigners for their army. This caused a major conflict. Lastly, many foolish decisions made by the emperors and government caused the aspects of the military to slowly…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Spartacus was a leader under the old Roman Republic. He is known for starting a rebellion against the Roman Empire in the Third Servile War. There are thoughts that have not been confirmed to this very day but one thing is for sure, Spartacus was able to share a vision with the slaves during the ancient times. There are arguments when it comes to the origins of him. Ancient historians believed that he was Thracian. A lot of authors have closed him in on so many origins that it became hard to keep track of them. Although, he is known to the world as a Thracian who later received training from the Roman army and was then sold to slavery.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The decline and fall of Roman Empire was an attractive topic. This paper will focus on the economic field. There will be three parts in this paper to analyze the reason of the economic recession happened in later Roman Empire. After the back background introduction, the first part will focus on how the Empire 's military affected the economy. The legions of Empire used to be the reason for the prosperity of the Empire but in the later period they couldn 't protect the Empire any more. The second part will focus on how the political chaos affected the economy. The turbulence in administration system brought the disorder to the Empire and interrupt increase of economy. In the third part, to analysis what kinds of changes happened in the economic field is the purpose. The people lived in Roman Empire, including the Emperor, officers and citizens, didn 't know the importance of industry and commerce. To sum up, the economic recession was resulted by the cause from these three fields.…

    • 2451 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    tried to build a more solid senate but failed to take power away from the…

    • 2425 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics