 # Nike Case Finance

Better Essays
866 Words Grammar Plagiarism  Writing  Score Nike Case Finance 1)
We do not agree with Joanna Cohen’s WACC calculation because she mistakenly used historical data to estimate the future cost of debt. Joanna calculated the cost of debt by taking the interest expense for 2001 and dividing it by the average debt balance. The cost of debt for Nike is the effective rate that it pays on its current debt, meaning the yield to maturity of bonds should be used to make an estimate instead of the average debt balance.
Through the use of past data, the average balance of debt, the 4.3% before-tax cost of debt does not accurately reflect Nike’s current or future cost of debt, and therefore a new WACC should be calculated to discount future cash flows.
Additionally, Joanna’s cost of equity calculation should also be revised to recalculate a more accurate WACC. Rather than using the average beta from 1996 to 2001, the most recent beta estimate should be used because it is more relevant to the current cost of equity.
Furthermore, the market values, not the book values, of debt and equity, should be used to correctly weight the capital components.

2) Using CAPM: a. The market free rate is 5.74%, which is the longest US Treasury Yield forecast. We used this rate because WACC is used for long-term projects and therefore, the longest treasury rate should also be used. b. The market risk premium is the geometric mean of 5.9%. The geometric mean was used, as it is a common measure for measuring the results of a portfolio. The geometric mean uses percentages and it is therefore much more accurate than the standard arithmetic mean. c. The Beta that was used to gain a return on equity equivalent to 10.5% was 0.8, the average of all the Betas from 1996 to the present. Although this is a good measure to use, in actuality the Beta of 0.69 for the recent year of 2001 is a much better indicator of the return on equity given the present situation

Joanna’s CAPM Re= 10.5% = 5.74 + (.8)(5.9) Re= 10.5% Rf= 5.74 Rm-Rf= 5.9 B= 0.8
New CAPM

## You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

• Satisfactory Essays

Cost of equity = Rf + (Rm-Rf) beta = 3.5% + 7.5% X 1.3 = 13.25%…

• 420 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Powerful Essays

20-year current yields should be used as market risk free rate since it has the longest period, which is equal to 5.74%…

• 776 Words
• 4 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Powerful Essays

Book value are better for calculating the firm's weighted average cost of capital. Firstly, book value numbers are showed on the financial statement. Secondly, the bond rating agencies like to pay attention on book value. Thirdly, book value are more stable than market value, the book value weight can produce more stable inputs for using in capital budgeting.…

• 1589 Words
• 7 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Good Essays

In January 2013, Sterling Household Products Company (Sterling), a highly successful manufacturer and marketer of household goods, was experiencing low growth rates for unit volume, sales, and profits which led management to seek expansion into higher growth industries. Between 2010 and 2012, sales had a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of only 2.2%, sales volumes in units were less than 1% per year, operating expenses rising faster than inflation, and retailers with high buying power (The 10 largest customers accounted for 55% of sales). Sterling identified the health care infection-control market as an attractive sector with high growth opportunities, and the product lines were a natural extension of Sterling’s current production. Sterling found its ideal investment opportunity through Montagne Medical Instruments Company’s (Montagne) germicidal, sanitation, and antiseptic products unit (GS&A Unit). The unit was profitable with an operating margin of 18.9% in 2012 and sales grew over 5% annually the past two years. However it was not a core focus for Montagne and required scarce resources and time, so Montagne was eager to sell the unit.…

• 1809 Words
• 5 Pages
Good Essays
• Powerful Essays

Blackmores LTD (BKL) which started in the 1930s is a major player in developing and marketing products and services that deliver a more natural approach to health, based on their expertise in vitamins, minerals, herbs and nutrients.…

• 7597 Words
• 31 Pages
Powerful Essays
• Good Essays

The cost of debt is the yield to maturity (YTM) of the bonds. The YTM is the discount rate that will make the present value of interest and principal equal to the price today. The interest amount per year is \$93 and the principal amount is \$1,000. Using trial and error method of substituting different rates or by using the RATE function in excel, we derive the YTM as 10.65%. This is the before tax cost of debt. Since the interest amount is tax deductible, we use the after tax cost of debt in the WACC calculations. The tax rate is given as 35%. The after tax cost of debt is 10.65% X (1-0.35) = 6.92%…

• 746 Words
• 3 Pages
Good Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

Question 3 [5 points]: Suppose the market risk premium is 6% and the risk-free interest rate is 2.7%. What is the expected annual return of investing in Microsoft’s stock according to the CAPM if its beta is 1.24?…

• 576 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

1. What is the WACC and why is it important to estimate a firm’s cost of capital? Is the WACC set by investors or by managers?…

• 278 Words
• 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

As long-term valuation is assumed, risk free rate is set as 30-year treasury rate, 5.73%. Cost of debt is 6.72% reflecting Amoco’s credit level. Cost of equity is calculated as 10.63%, leading to final WACC at 8.85% (Chart 1).…

• 636 Words
• 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Good Essays

1.a) To value Spyder Active Sports Inc., we decided to use the WACC method since we can easily value its cost of assets with the data immediately available to us in the case. We first unlevered the beta’s of 7 comparable companies and took the average to get a comparable unlevered beta for Spyder (Exhibit 1). Since we are assuming Spyder is entirely equity financed, its unlevered asset beta is equal to the beta of its assets. We now have a rough estimate of Spyder’s asset beta, we can use CAPM to calculate the cost of assets of the firm (Exhibit 2). With an appropriate discount rate, we can use the WACC method to discount the company’s projected cash flows. Again, since the company is entirely comprised of equity, the cost of assets is the cost of the entire firm, so we will use it in place of WACC. Using Spyder’s pro-forma income statement, we then calculate the FCF’s for the next 4 years and discount those using our cost of assets (Exhibit 3).…

• 1038 Words
• 5 Pages
Good Essays
• Good Essays

Chandler knew that the maximum value of the firm was achieved when the weighted average cost of capital was minimized. Thus she intended to estimate what the cost of equity and the wacc might be if wrigley pursued this capital structure change. The projected cost of debt would depend on her assessement of wrigley’s debt rating after recapitalization and on current capital market rates.…

• 1638 Words
• 7 Pages
Good Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

We found Joanna’s estimates to be wrong because of a few reasons. The first mistake she made was using the average beta instead of the most recent beta provided. She was using average of Nike’s beta from 1996 to the present, which was .80 (Case 13, pg. 59). We used the beta of .69, which was the most recent beta provided to us. The second mistake we found was that she used the book value of debt instead of the market value of debt. The book value was \$441.30 and the market value was \$421.88 so she overstated debt by \$19.42 (Exhibit 6).…

• 393 Words
• 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Good Essays

O’Grandy Apparel Company can calculate the after tax debt cost using YTM (CP + (FV-Nd /n) / FV +Nd /2) *2. Cp is (0.12/2) * 1000= 60 Semi-annually Fv is 1000 Nd is 995 – (0.025* 1000) = 970…

• 3365 Words
• 14 Pages
Good Essays
• Satisfactory Essays

WACC = rD (1- Tc )*( D / V )+ rE *( E / V ) Cost of Debt Tax Rate Total Debt Cost of Equity Total Equity Total Market Value Risk Free Rate Historical Market Return Beta WACC rD Tc D rE E V rF rM B Interest Expense / (Total Debt) Avg tax rate for 2008 per Exhibit 9B Short Term + Long Term Debt Total Equity per from Exhibit 7 Total Market Value from Exhibit 7 Source : ustreasury.gov Avg Annualized market Return S&P 500 From Yahoo Finance…

• 538 Words
• 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays
• Better Essays

Weight of Equity = Market value of equity / (Total firm Value = (Equity + Net Debt))…

• 826 Words
• 4 Pages
Better Essays