top-rated free essay

New Criticism "When I Heard a Learn'D Astronomer"

By danyamarie Apr 18, 2013 1123 Words
Danya P.
Ms. Q
English 1302
April 2013
New Criticism and the Poem “When I Heard a Learn’d Astronomer”
During the early half of the 20th century, a new style of criticism emerged allowing literary texts to be examined as “independent and complete works of art” as defined by Linda Pavlovski (1). It is evident that literary works were and still are interpreted with aid from historical, biological, and even cultural perspectives but New Criticism advocates each work of literary can stand with its own importance unaided. Critic, poet, and author of the book titled The New Criticism, John Crow Ransom, established New Criticism as the term which is used today. The majority of critics who use New Criticism use it to analyze and defend poetry from its common interpretations. A poem that can be analyzed by New Criticism is “When I Heard a Learn’d Astronomer” by Walt Whitman. The eight-lined poem recounts a day in class and a revelatory encounter with nature. Sticking to Pavlovski’s definition of New Criticism and by focusing on a close reading of the technicalities such as structure, paradoxes, and word choice the message is clear to read.

Jason Wilson claims “the structure of a story can relate its author and the ideological system” of the story itself (33). Evaluating the structure of “When I Heard a Learn’d Astronomer” this is demonstrated. The poem can be broken down into two sections splitting directly down the middle; the first four lines and the last four lines. These sections can be categorized just as Linda Wagner-Martin labeled two sections of the poem “Laying the Dust.” She called the first section a “simple happening” while the latter is a result of the happening being called “from this experience, the poet concludes” (45). To begin the speaker of the poem describes the instruction he is receiving from the “learn’d astronomer” simply and with minimal interest. The word “When” introducing the first line of every line in the first section unifies the idea of boredom the speaker has throughout that entire section. Parallel structure is applied while describing the learn’d astronomer’s visual aids such as: the proofs, the figures, the charts, the diagrams and so on. This type of structure is used to lengthen the time of the lecture and quantify the amount of visual aids the learned astronomer has with him. Action words, as a result of the first half of the poem, are evident throughout the second section of the poem such as: the speaker rises, glides, wanders and so forth. The structure of the poem helps to present the message of knowledge comes by experience and initiative.

Constant contrast are unmistakable in the poem convince the reader of the difference between the lecture and the evening with nature. Richard S. Calhoun describes paradoxes as the “central argument in poetry” (pars. 15). Reflecting back on the beginning of the poem the speaker states that he is being lectured by a learn’d astronomer. Calhoun’s description is validated concerning the speaker who does not gain knowledge of astronomy from the learn’d astronomer. When describing the atmosphere of the speaker’s learning environment Whitman states the learn’d astronomer lectured in the lecture-room. Other words such as “instruct” or even “teach” indicate the same as lecture but repetition, prolonging the moment, suggests the lecture’s monotony. In the next line of the poem it states, “How soon unaccountable I became,” as a product of the lecture (line 5). The learning experience and how the speaker felt contrasts heavily with the atmosphere the speaker experienced being outdoors. Wagner-Martin states “silence can go beyond the effectiveness of sound” (56). Outdoors there was not a person talking let alone lecturing but there was “perfect silence” (8). Lastly, the speaker sharply contrasts the description of the lecture-room to the outdoors. With all of the items mentioned with the lecturer, the lecture-room may be imagined cluttered or busy by the reader but the speaker outside in the primitive world signifies room and space.

Throughout the poem, word choice is significant using denotation and connotation to fully understand the rationale behind why those words were chosen. Beginning with the title “When I Heard a Learn’d Astronomer,” the word “Heard” does not denote understanding or knowledge but merely as it is defined “to perceive by ear.” The next word in the title is “Learn’d.” A person who is learned indicates a highly educated person but the speaker uses slang or not the grammatically correct version of the word to describe someone as learned. Calhoun states “form and content are regarded as inseparable” by varying the word learned to “Learn’d” it changes the quality of knowledge from the “Learn’d Astronomer.” In the poem, during the lecture, the speaker becomes “tired and sick” (5). Although “tired” is commonly used to express someone who is over taken by boredom, the word “sick” illustrates the level of abhorrence the speaker was experiencing. After the speaker leaves the classroom, the tone of the poem shifts from dreadful to dreamy as he wanders off by himself in the “mystical” night air from “time to time” (7). Ending the poem,”Look’d up in perfect silence at the stars” implies the speaker is content and full of wisdom from just looking at the stars (8). Wagner-Martin suggests “silence surrounds the facts” and “it can permit people to truly know what they are seeing” (56). Once the speaker left the lecture-room and went outdoors, he became aware to all of the knowledge that was around him.

The advantage of New Criticism allows literary works to be analyzed separately without common influences so that readers can determine their own meaning of the literary work. A variety of view points catalyze new avenues that a literary work can advance into, showing this type of criticisms importance. In “When I Heard a Learn’d Astronomer,” the use of New Criticism truly permits the reader to get the true theme of the literary work, their own.

Works Cited

Calhoun, Richard S. "Formalistic Criticism." Critical Survey of Poetry. Ed. Frank N. Magill. Salem Press, 1992. 3973-3980. Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter and Deborah A. Schmitt. Vol. 110. Detroit: Gale Research, 1999. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Mar. 2013. Kirszner, Laurie G., and Stephen R. Mandell, eds. Compact Learning: Reading, Reacting, Writing. 8th ed. Boston: Wadsworth, 2013. Print. “The New Criticism.” Introduction. Twentieth-Century Literary Criticism. Ed. Linda Pavlovski. Vol. 146. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 1-2. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 29 Mar. 2013. Wagner, Linda Welshimer. Denise Levertov. New York: Twayne Publishers, 1967. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 29 Mar. 2013. Wilson, Jason. Claude Levi-Strauss. Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1987. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 31 Mar. 2013.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • When I heard the Learn'd Astronomer First by e.e. cummings and When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer by Walt Whitman are two poems whose main ideas contrast very much from each other. They both reflect the basic most form of human experiences, that being feeling and intellect since they often come hand in hand. When one is emotional, they often only consider emotion in a given ...

    Read More
  • IOP of Whitman's "When I Heard the Learn'd Astronomer"

    ...When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer Walt Whitman 1. Bio: Walt Whitman practically taught himself to read through the works of Homer, Shakespeare, Dante, and the Bible during his time as a printer’s apprentice in New York City. After a printing district fire in 1836, Whitman became a teacher, and then a journalist. In 1855, he publis...

    Read More
  • When I Heard the Learn'D Astronomer

    ...Upon rare occasion, my freshman brother actually decided to pull his nose out of his lousy video game, and join me upon reading this poem. Actually, I should say that I forced him to do this, because he needed to analyze a poem for his own English class, and the music coming from the television was beyond annoying. Anyway, my brother's reaction ...

    Read More
  • When I Heard the Learn'd Astronomer

    ...Walt Whitman's poem "When I Heard the Learn'd Astronomer" describes the feelings of knowing too much about the workings of nature. The speaker in the poem is a student who has attended a lecture on astronomy. As he learns more and more, he becomes more and more depressed until he leaves the lecture room. Whitman uses interesting elements of f...

    Read More
  • metapoetic in the poem "when i heard the learn'd astronomer

    ...Walt Whitman's poem "When I heard the learn’d astronomer" is composed of two quatrains that stand as one stanza. The poem has a sense of separation between the first quatrain, that presents a passive view of the poem, and the second quatrain, that presents the active view of the poem. The active view of the poem are the verbs that appear in...

    Read More
  • What Is the Effect of the First Four Lines of Walt Whitman's “When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer” Beginning with the Word “When”?

    ...“When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer” begins by repeating the title. This phrase also stands out because of it’s a rhyme within the same line, of “heard” with “learn’d.” This poem talks about an astronomer lecturing the narrator's class. The narrator becomes tired and sick implying he is bored by the class and dazes off to his ...

    Read More
  • New Criticism

    ...English 441 New Criticism Explained Beginning in the 1920's and coalescing in the 1940's, an interpretative approach emerged that did not define literature as essentially the self-expressive product of the artist nor as an evaluative reflection or illumination of cultural history. These "New Critics" opposed the traditional critical practice of ...

    Read More
  • New Criticism

    ...Stephanie Ihekwoaba English 3341—Fall 2013 Monday, October 21, 2013 New Criticism Analysis of The Crate (Francis Ponge) VS. A Dog After Love (Yehuda Amichai) As defined by the editors of the Bedford Glossary of Critical and Literary Terms, mentioned in a handout given by Professor Tomás Q. Morin, New Critics have the ability to...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.