Preview

Myth of Model Family

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
715 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Myth of Model Family
Myth of the Model Family The image of the model family is breathtaking, a housewife-mother, a breadwinner father, a couple of kids and a pet or two. This is the dream of most Americans but at the same time is a cliché. “The “traditional” family… has existed for little more than two hundred years” (18). This idea has been so widely accepted due to the attention that it has received in the media. Like Gary Soto in “Looking for Work” the perfect family misleads people into thinking what is truth and what is fiction. Of course the truth is that there is no such thing as the “perfect” family. One family cannot represent all the variation of families all around the world. The universal nuclear family is the same with the stay-at-home mother, the breadwinner father, a couple of children and maybe a pet or two. Preferably, people would like to see what a family should be or act like, but not everyone is the same. Each and every culture is different, with each of them having there own definition or idea of what the model family is like. In Soto’s “Looking for Work” the story is about a child's expectance of a family life filled with love and comforts, which is contrast with his real working class family life. In the story Soto, back at the age of nine, dreams to live is a life where his family is straightforward in there routine. Soto lived in a working class family that had only a breadwinner mother and three children. There was no mention of a father. Over the years there has been the question of who has the authority in an American family. It used to be the male of the family who had the most authority. Over the years, that has slowly changed. As in Soto’s story he lives with his mom and no mention of a dad. Today there are families that have two fathers or two mothers or only one of each and not the other. The idea of the “perfect” model family is so widely accepted, due to the attention that it receives in the media. So the idea of two fathers, or two

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Since there are not many books that focus on the Latino, or the Chicano, culture, he tries to write stories so children, who are from that background, could see their selves and could actually relate to the stories that they were reading. After he made this discovery, Soto wrote children books such as “Too Many Tamales” where the protagonist, Maria, is helping her family make tamales for her mother’s wedding. While they were cooking they let Maria see her mother’s wedding ring and Maria loses the ring in one of the many tamales that they were making (Too Many Tamales, Putnam). In another one of his books “Novio Boy” His main character, Rudy, is taking a girl, Patricia, out on a date and he goes to one of his friends to seek dating advice. Later on he realizes that he does not have enough money to take her out on the date that he would want to (Novio Boy, Putnam). By writing books of the genre, Soto is trying to help connect his writing with a day in a typical Childs life, and even though this book was written in the 1990’s it still applies to today’s teenagers. He is letting children and teenagers know that mistakes happen and we will encounter problems, however, we will get through them. While in an interview Soto once stated how he “believed that the connection Latino teens feel to his work is mainly one of pride” (Gary Soto, Ted Fabiano,). Although Mexican Americans do not have an extensive…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    He was surprised and accustomed to the norm that children in Morelia could work at a young age. For example, his father made him work at construction sites at the age of 10. Once my father settled in his new home with his brother, Mariano Soto and his sister in law, Rosa Santander, they stressed the importance of an education to become competitive in the work force in America. His parents, however, disregarded the importance of an education, but rather stressed the importance of possessing a strong work ethic. He attended University High School, at Santa Monica, where he was placed in his favorite class, English as a Second Language (E.S.L). The most of the ethnicities he saw were Asians, Armenians, and lacked in African Americans and Latinos. He was surprised with the amount of diversity in America compared to Morelia. In his favorite class, he met some people who were, too, international students and were struggling to learn English. They hanged out frequently and he established a relationship with them in which improved the rate of learning the language. They would spend time during lunch, at the beach, or watching movies at the local theater. Also, they would hang out with other Americans at the beach and would all play sports, such as volleyball. Their constant interactions made him more confident in speaking out and helped him break the…

    • 2274 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gary Soto’s reflections on his childhood efforts of improving his working-class family are humorous and entertaining, yet show the flaws in the era of the family. Fueled by TV shows such as Leave it to Beaver, young Gary wanted to make his Mexican-American household more like the idealistic “nuclear families” that he seen on television. However, achieving that appealing lifestyle of the white middle-class families proved to be very difficult; especially for families like Soto’s, who didn’t fit that idealist image. His mother was a single parent who worked hard to put food on the table. She did not have the time, energy, or money to engage in activities shown in the 1950’s sitcoms. The author points out the little differences between the “comfortable lives of white kids” who “hopped into bed with kisses and woke to glasses of fresh orange juice…” (29) and his own family. Instead of loud dinners consisting of “belly laughs” and “pointing fingers at one another” (29), Gary envied the proper ceremonial dinner where everyone dressed up and the table included steak, mashed potatoes, and starch napkins.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Killing / Fiesta, 1980

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Today, family is one of the most sacred values we share in the individualist society we live in. Every family is different and has different rules and values; but in most of them, fathers are supposed to be leaders of the family, and role models for their children. They are also considerate like the one who transmits the traditions of their ancestors in order to carry them on. “Fiesta, 1980” is a short story written by Junot Dìaz taken from his short story collection, Drown, (1996). “Killings” is also a short story taken from, Finding a Girl in America (1980), written by Andre Dubus. Both of these stories are dealing with the family’s subject and provide us different perspectives of it. In Dìaz’s story we can see the relationship among a foreigner family, while in Andre Dubus’s story we see an American average family. In both stories, fathers play an important role; they figure prominently and have a considerable impact on their family but on the story also. The father in Dubus’s story is more family oriented that the one in Dìaz’; moreover the family is more closely–knit in Dubus’s story than in Dìaz’s story. The difference between the behaviors of the two fathers can be explained by their cultural backgrounds, which are not the same. These stories also provide us another perspective of the father’s role in the family, through their strength and their weakness without compromise.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe psychiatrist John Watson and sociologist Amitai Etzioni were wrong in their predictions that true families would be nonexistent by now. Their opinion implies families could only be "true" if the parents were married. Based upon the definition of a traditional family this may be true, but times have changed. We should focus on how we define family today, before we decide if it is or isn't existent.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Steinberg Analysis

    • 2346 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The model family is only a myth, nothing more. There is no such thing as a perfect family where there is no problem, no disputes and fights. As I read through “The Accordion Family”, I actually feel as if the model family can only break family down and cause more disappointment in reality. In the accordion family, the kids come back to live, usually temporarily, with their parents because of financial problems or they are trying to pursue an interest that requires the help of their family. Well then, society might view the kid who is trying to pursue his own interest with the help of his family as a slob and that he/she is ruining his family by staying around doing nothing. But the only reason society would even be thinking that is because they are comparing it to a model set forth 5 decades ago. They are still basing that today’s “perfect” family will still be exactly the same as it was back then. I think that as the social, political, and economic situation of a culture and society change, the standard for a “perfect” family also change. I also put the word perfect in quotation mark, as I want to show that the word perfect has high amount of flexibility. There is no one defining perfection. The model family was a model that was set forth in the 1950 where economy was booming; optimism is high in the air. This is not the case for the 21st century, we have only recover from the great recession and maybe due to the circumstances that is provided, a family where everyone stick together, pit their effort and wealth together is actually the best solution right now. Also the model family is created for the American Culture, but what about the Chinese culture, the Indian Culture, and the Middle Eastern Culture. Some of these cultures have the parents and the children and the children’s spouse and the children’s children all living together. This is…

    • 2346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gary Soto Swot Analysis

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Unlike Gary Soto in “Looking for work.” I didn’t look to the television to imitate what my idea of a family was. My family included my mother, my brother and my sister and that was enough for me. I never really focused on not having a dad around; it wasn’t as important as having our mom, who was always there for us. Many people believe that to be a productive family there needs to be two parents in the household. However, I know different. My mother was both parents and did just fine as a single mother raising and supporting three kids all by herself. Mom was the nurse that made me feel better whenever I got sick. She was teacher, because she taught me to read and to write. She cared and loved me but also punished…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Gary Soto

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    ¨ Looking For My Brother At The Computer Factory ¨ has relationships which leads the reader to wonder why was his brother even going to the computer factory? ¨ He had disappeared. Ricky, I called under my breath. His name hung only inches from my face ¨ ( “ Saturday At The Canal “ Line 38-40 ) The use of relationships in this quote has an affect on the audience of how did his brother disappear? and why was his brother at the factory in the first place? Soto not only used relationships in ¨Looking For My Brother At The Computer Factory ¨ but also in ¨ Inheritance ¨ in order to find the good memories he had with his grandmother before she died and how his grandfather lives alone now. ¨ Dry up in the time you turned your back¨ ( “ Inheritance “ Line 40 ) . The use of relationships in this quote explains the good memories that his grandfather had before his wife had passed away and his grandkid is seeing him do the things grandma did and now the grandpa has to do it. In Conclusion the importance of using relationships connects the audience to the piece and feel like it's their…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Living only with his older brother Miguel, he seemed like the typical straight-A student. He participated in band, the debate team, spelling bees, sports, and theatrical plays; he received many academic awards, and he was the Valedictorian of his class. However, growing up without parents made him the subject of curiousity among his friends. “They would always ask me, ‘Hey, where are your parents at? Why are you not living with them?’ It would always be difficult telling them how my mom stayed in Mexico to care for my family and how my father lost his job in the U.S. and was forced to move back to Mexico. I just thought it was normal up until that point in time” (Castellanos). Despite not having parents around, Francisco still did well in school. He used these extra-curricular activities to occupy his time and stay off the streets. “I found my escape through academics and school activities,” he said. “It was great, but at the same time, it was tough because no one was there to watch me win all those awards. At these events, I was taking pictures with my friends and their families, instead of my own” (Castellanos). It would seem he would have promising future after…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child Abuse

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages

    family was thought to be, or shown to the general public to be, the "perfect family".…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is suggested that the Nuclear family is universal as it is promoted as the ‘right’ family type through mass media…

    • 675 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    English Case Study

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A “family” is mom, dad, sister, brother, right? We are taught to believe that this is the family structure, and this is “normal”. The majority of American’s strive to have the white picket fence, two children and Fido. What about when mom is no longer in the picture? Todd, like so many other fathers today, is faced with the stereotype that they cannot parent on their own as well as a woman. When I say “single dad” the most of us conjure up images of a klutz in an apron, spooning scorched macaroni-and-cheese into a bowl for a poorly-dressed tot with a bad haircut while the school bus beeps at the curb.…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Perfectly Imperfect

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In my opinion, a ‘perfect’ family is nonexistent. That perfect families are more than just a myth, I do not believe. Every family has their ups and downs, their fights and makeup’s, and their moments of wanting nothing to do with each other. Families are like best…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Perfect Family

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages

    At present, the perfect family is idealized because it offers a utopian alternative in which people can live better, although there is evidence that even in the best case in the pursuit of the perfect family are presented important collateral effects in other topics.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Communication Speech

    • 1680 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Some, including President Barack Obama, contend that fathers, whether resident or nonresident, are critical to the foundation of the family (Bosnian 2008). Others argue that children develop optimally in famihes that include both a primary caregiver (usually a mother) and another supporter (often a father) of the primary caregiver (see, e.g., Broufen- Sodal Service Review (December 2010). © 2010 by The University of Chicago.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays