top-rated free essay

Means and Ends: How Hamlet’s Supposed Insanity Justifies and Masks His True Goal of Revenge

By Jbooch Feb 09, 2009 990 Words
Means and Ends: How Hamlet’s supposed insanity justifies and masks his true goal of revenge

In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Hamlet uses “comedy” and insanity as a façade to mask his inner turmoil. By using humor and insanity, he can misdirect his own means of whether or not he wants to kill his father’s murderer, King Claudius. Hamlet believes that if he can keep people off balance regarding his physical state of mind, they will question only his sanity, not his ultimate plot of revenge. However, do these means justify the ultimate end of revenge? Do these means make Hamlet a noble person?

In Act II Scene ii, there is an exchange between Polonius and Hamlet. Polonius attempts to converse with Hamlet, who appears to be insane then he calls Polonius a “fishmonger” and answers his questions irrationally. One instance of this is when Polonius asks Hamlet what he is reading and Hamlet replies, “words, words, words” (II.ii.187). This is a very sarcastic and humorous reply to “what are you reading?” The whole exchange is rather humorous as Hamlet continues on with his quick-witted remarks that keep Polonius on edge. But many of Hamlet’s seemingly lunatic statements hide barbed observations about Polonius’s pomposity and his old age. Polonius comments that while Hamlet is clearly mad, his replies are often “pregnant” with meaning (II.ii.200).

In the first two scenes of Act III, Hamlet and Claudius both devise traps to catch one another’s secrets: Claudius spies on Hamlet to discover the true nature of his madness, and Hamlet attempts to “catch the conscience of the king” in the theater (III.i.582). The play-within-a-play tells the story of Gonzago, the duke of Vienna, and his wife, Baptista, who marries his murdering nephew, Lucianus. Hamlet believes that the play is an opportunity to establish a more reliable basis for Claudius’s guilt than the claims of the ghost. Since he has no way of knowing whether to believe a member of the spirit world, he tries to determine whether Claudius is guilty by reading his behavior for signs of a psychological state of guilt. When the murderer pours the poison into the king’s ear, Claudius rises and cries out for light. Chaos ensues as the play comes to a sudden halt, and the king flees from the room. Hamlet is now left with Horatio and they agree that the king’s behavior was telling. Extremely excited, Hamlet continues to act frantic and scatterbrained, speaking glibly and inventing little poems. This nonsense talk is another comic element. Shakespeare gives Hamlet these lines, which make people think he’s mad, but at the same time, they provide a little bit of comedy to lighten up the tragedy just a bit.

Along with providing the audience with a good laugh, Hamlet’s humorous lines are also there for another reason. All of Hamlet’s funny lines are in scenes were he is pretending to be insane. He uses comedy as a façade to mask her inner turmoil. Hamlet wanted people to believe that he was truly insane. In order to do this, he used some comedic and sarcastic lines the keep people off balance for his own purpose. When Polonius asked him what he was reading, he responded only by saying, “words, words, words” (II, ii, 187). This response was not was Polonius had expected. He was confused by Hamlet’s answer and the more he spoke with Hamlet, he realized that he kept getting these strange responses. It was then that Polonius really begins to think that Hamlet is mad, and this is exactly what Hamlet wants. He believes that if he can get people to think he’s insane, then they wont realize that he is really plotting the death of the king. According to Hamlet’s Obsession with Revenge, “ Hamlet feigns insanity because it allows him to do several things that he otherwise would be unable to do…This would help prevent others in the royal household from speculating that Hamlet was rationally planning hostile actions such as killing Claudius” (1).

Although Hamlet pretended to be insane around people, on his own he was very intelligent and was able to analyze things in depth and on a personal level. He produced beautiful soliloquies about life, contemplating death, debating whether his motives for killing Claudius are justified; however, this methodical person is only found by himself and is never shown to another character throughout the play. By hiding this side of himself, he is able to use his insanity to justify and mask his ultimate goal of revenge. He uses the time he has to himself to justify his motives for killing Claudius. He debates whether he has the right intentions or whether he is going to be committing an unnecessarily cruel murder. In order to hide these thoughts and to keep people from becoming suspicious, he uses his fake insanity to distract people and make them think that he isn’t capable of thinking such thoughts.

Even though Hamlet is able to justify his means for revenge, does killing your stepfather qualify Hamlet as a noble person? Hamlet’s actions show his allegiance lies to the duty of his family and not to the duty to his country. By using comedic lines to hide his inner confusion and by hiding the logical and systematic side of Hamlet, he was able to finally revenge his father’s death. Hamlet went to extreme lengths to keep his revenge a secret so it would be perfect when he executed his final plan, and that shows extreme nobility and dignity to his father

Works Cited
“Hamlet’s Obsession with Revenge.” 123HelpMe.com. 24 Oct 2007
.

Literature: An introduction to fiction, poetry, drama, and writing. Comp. X.J. Kennedy,
Dana Gioia. New York: Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data,
2007 1508-1509; 1528-1531

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Hamlet's Insanity

    ...Hamlet's "Insanity" Merriam-Webster's Dictionary defines insanity as "a deranged state of mind, commonly exhibiting behavior considered abnormal in society," and depression "a psychoneurotic or psychotic disorder marked especially by sadness, inactivity, difficulty in thinking and concentration, a significant increase in appetite and time sp...

    Read More
  • Hamlet's Revenge

    ...Seymon Lewis 1/17/13 2a Hamlet’s revenge Hamlet is a revenge tragedy based on a young prince whose father was murdered by the new king Claudius. After his father’s funeral he is confronted by his father’s ghost. Hamlet believes that he has to listen to the ghost, when who replied "So art thou to revenge, when thou shalt hear”(1.5.7);...

    Read More
  • The Ends Justify the Means?

    ...The idea that "the ends justify the means" is very dangerous because not only can it hurt others but it can also damage those who believe in that idea and take action to do it. Some people have a tendency to focus only on the outcomes since they seem much more victorious and glorious than the time they have to spend to reach them. This tendenc...

    Read More
  • The End Justifies the Means

    ...A philosopher once said in one of his more controversial essays that 'The End Justifies the Means.' Through the ages this quotation could be applied, especially in today's society. This statement does have its positives and negatives. However, it still has some values. Most people look at this statement and ponder why this individual believes in...

    Read More
  • Finding a Middle Ground: How the Ends Justify the Means

    ...Composition 1 11 February 2013 Finding a Middle Ground: How the Ends Justify the Means Everyone has goals. Some people believe in order to attain a certain goal that it is acceptable to do things that are immoral. This may cause one to wonder if the actions taken to reach such a goal will be worth it. I am going to discuss some differe...

    Read More
  • Hamlet's Revenge

    ...The Revenge of Hamlet Hamlet's sixth soliloquy is full of irony, philosophy, and with the familiar subject of revenge. It reflects themes of the entire play, and it helped further my understanding of Shakespeare's masterpiece, Hamlet. The main character, in his second-to-last monologue reflects Claudius' regret which is an obstacle to revenge....

    Read More
  • Does the End Justify the Means

    ...Lesley Rawlins The end justifies the means The end justifies the means is an expression that is often used in society to validate or excuse distasteful and objectionable actions undertaken by its people. In effect, the phrase is a justification for dispensing with all morality and principle in the passage towards a successful ...

    Read More
  • The End Justifies the Means

    ...Philosophy Assignment – The Last Days of Socrates Question/Answer Essay In Plato's apology: The trial of Socrates, Socrates is convicted by a great and many crimes. Through these blames Socrates comes up with different ways of countering the assumptions cast upon in his defense. In turn, through his defense Socrates makes some very strong...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.